-
Harris Corporation v. Federal Express Corporation DC CAFC
- 6:07-cv-01819
- M.D. Fla.
- Judge: John Antoon, II +1
- Filed: 11/16/2007
- Closed: 08/13/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 03/18/2015
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
1
Plaintiff
1
Defendant
1
Accused
Product
8
Patents-in-Suit
2,098
Days in
Litigation
-
Harris Corporation v. Federal Express Corporation DC CAFC
- 6:07-cv-01819
- M.D. Fla.
- Judge: John Antoon, II +1
- Filed: 11/16/2007
- Closed: 08/13/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 03/18/2015
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
Cause of Action
Willful Patent Infringement
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
- Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during an entire flight of the aircraft from at least take-off to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
3 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data over a direct sequence spread spectrum communications signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
4 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data automatically after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
5 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of uploading data to the ground data link unit over a wideband spread spectrum communications signal after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
6 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of selecting a frequency channel for transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data from a plurality of available frequency channels.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
8 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data from the ground based spread spectrum transceiver to a flight operations center for further processing.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
9 |
A method according to claim 1, and further comprising the step of storing the generated aircraft data within a memory of the ground data link unit.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
11 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during the entire flight of the aircraft from at least take-off to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
13 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data over a direct sequence spread spectrum communications signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
14 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data automatically after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
15 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of uploading data to the ground data link unit over a wideband spread spectrum communications signal after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
16 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of selecting a frequency channel for transmitting the generated aircraft data from a plurality of available frequency channels.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
18 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data from the ground based spread spectrum transceiver to a flight operations center for further processing.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
19 |
A method according to claim 11, and further comprising the step of storing the generated aircraft data within a memory of the ground data link unit.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
21 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during at least two entire flights of the aircraft from at least takeoff to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
23 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data over a direct sequence spread spectrum communications signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
24 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data automatically after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
25 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of uploading data to the ground data link unit over a wideband spread spectrum communications signal after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
26 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of selecting a frequency channel for transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data from a plurality of available frequency channels.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
28 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data from the ground based spread spectrum transceiver to a flight operations center for further processing.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
29 |
A method according to claim 21, and further comprising the step of storing the generated aircraft data within a memory of the ground data link unit.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising: an airborne data acquisition unit coupled to the aircraft flight data recorder that continuously obtains flight performance data representative of
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
2 |
The system according to claim 1, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a spread spectrum wireless RF communication signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
4 |
The system according to claim 1, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a wireless RF communication signal operating in a channel of a frequency spectrum band which has been sub-divided into
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
5 |
The system according to claim 1, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a wireless RF communication signal operating in an unlicensed frequency band.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
6 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising: an airborne data acquisition unit coupled to the aircraft flight data recorder that continuously obtains flight performance data representative of
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
7 |
The system according to claim 6, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a spread spectrum wireless RF communication signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
9 |
The system according to claim 6, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a wireless RF communication signal operating in a channel of a frequency spectrum band which has been sub-divided into
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
10 |
The system according to claim 6, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically downloads the flight performance data over a wireless RF communication signal operating in an unlicensed frequency band.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during an entire flight of the aircraft from at least take-off to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
2 |
The method according to claim 1, wherein the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data comprises automatically transmitting the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
8 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during at least two entire flights of the aircraft from at least takeoff to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
9 |
The method according to claim 8, wherein the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data comprises automatically transmitting the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed after the second flight.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
12 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising: a ground data link unit that continuously obtains flight performance data representative of aircraft flight performance during an entire flight of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
13 |
The system according to claim 12, wherein the wireless RE transceiver automatically transmits the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
14 |
The system according to claim 12, and further comprising uploading data to the ground data link unit over a wireless RE communication signal operating in a channel of a frequency spectrum band which has been sub-divided into adjacent sub-band
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during an entire flight of the aircraft from at least take-off to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
2 |
The method according to claim 1, wherein the step of transmitting the generated aircraft data comprises automatically transmitting the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
8 |
A method of providing data from an aircraft comprising: continuously monitoring the flight performance of the aircraft during at least two entire flights of the aircraft from at least takeoff to landing; generating aircraft data representative of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
9 |
The method according to claim 8, wherein the step of transmitting the accumulated generated aircraft data comprises automatically transmitting the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
10 |
The method according to claim 8, and further comprising the step of uploading data to the ground data link unit over a RF communications signal operating in an unlicensed frequency band after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
15 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising: a ground data link unit that continuously obtains flight performance data representative of aircraft flight performance during an entire flight of the
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
16 |
The system according to claim 15, wherein the wireless RF transceiver automatically transmits the generated aircraft data after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
17 |
The system according to claim 15, and further comprising uploading data to the ground data link unit over a RF communications signal operating in an unlicensed frequency band after the aircraft has landed.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
4 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising:</claim-text> a ground data link unit that obtains flight performance data representative of aircraft flight performance during flight of the aircraft,
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
14 |
A method of providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising the steps of:</claim-text> acquiring flight performance data of an aircraft during flight of the aircraft; accumulating and storing within an archival
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
16 |
A method of providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising the steps of:</claim-text> acquiring flight performance data of an aircraft during flight of the aircraft; accumulating and storing within a memory of a
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A system for providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising: a ground data link unit that obtains flight performance data representative of aircraft flight performance during flight of the aircraft, said ground
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 214 |
2 |
A system according to claim 1, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a direct sequence spread spectrum communication signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
3 |
A system according to claim 1, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal within an S band.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
4 |
A system according to claim 1, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal in the range of about 2.4 to about 2.5 GHZ.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
17 |
A method of providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising the steps of: acquiring flight performance data of an aircraft during flight of the aircraft; accumulating and storing within an archival memory of a
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
18 |
A method according to claim 17, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a direct sequence spread spectrum signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
19 |
A method according to claim 17, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal within an S band.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
20 |
A method according to claim 17, wherein the wideband spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal within a range of about 2.4 to about 2.5 GHz.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
Claim | Outcome |
---|---|
All challenged claims |
Valid (112)
Entry 242 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
31 |
A method of providing a retrievable record of the flight performance of an aircraft comprising the steps of: collecting data within a ground data link unit on the flight performance of the aircraft during flight of the aircraft; accumulating and
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
35 |
A method according to claim 31, and further comprising the step of selecting desired sub-band frequency channels and dynamically assigning sub-band frequency channels based upon the quality of available channel links between the spread spectrum
view more
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
36 |
A method according to claim 31, and further comprising the step of storing the demodulated flight performance data within an airport based archival data store.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
37 |
A method according to claim 31, and further comprising the step of retrieving the flight performance data via an airport based server for further processing.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
38 |
A method according to claim 31, wherein the spread spectrum communication signal comprises a direct sequence spread spectrum signal.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
39 |
A method according to claim 31, wherein the spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal within the S band.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
40 |
A method according to claim 31, wherein the spread spectrum communication signal comprises a signal within the range of about 2.4 to about 2.5 Ghz.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 257 |
-
Infringement
Federal Express Corporation
- 7 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Wireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 6,047,165 A |
1, 2, 3, 4, 17, 18, 19, 20
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 |
Flight performance data systemWireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 6,154,637 A |
31, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 Entry 218 |
Wireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 6,308,045 B1 |
4, 14, 16
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 |
Flight performance data systemFrequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication SystemWirelessWireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 6,990,319 B2 |
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 28, 29
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 Entry 298 Entry 218 |
Flight performance data systemFrequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication SystemWirelessWireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 7,426,387 B2 |
1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 Entry 298 Entry 218 |
Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication SystemWirelessWireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 7,428,412 B2 |
1, 2, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 Entry 298 |
Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication SystemWirelessWireless, Frequency-Agile Spread Spectrum Ground Link-Based Aircraft Data Communication System | US 7,444,146 B1 |
1, 2, 8, 9, 10, 15, 16, 17
|
Willful infringement
Entry 319Entry 257 Entry 298 |
-
Damages