-
Accentra, Inc. et al v. Staples, Inc. DC CAFC
- 2:07-cv-05862
- C.D. Cal.
- Judge: Audrey B. Collins +1
- Filed: 09/10/2007
- Closed: 12/09/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 12/09/2013
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
2
Plaintiffs
2
Defendants
4
Accused
Products
4
Patents-in-Suit
2,283
Days in
Litigation
-
Accentra, Inc. et al v. Staples, Inc. DC CAFC
- 2:07-cv-05862
- C.D. Cal.
- Judge: Audrey B. Collins +1
- Filed: 09/10/2007
- Closed: 12/09/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 12/09/2013
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
Causes of Action
Other
Trademark
Unfair Competition
Willful Patent Infringement
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
- Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
24 |
A desktop stapler, comprising: a body with a handle pivotably attached to the body, the handle including a pressing area near a front end of the handle; a base pivotably attached to the body toward a rear end of the stapler, wherein the body extends
view more
|
Enforceable and Invalid (112)
Entry 569 |
25 |
The desktop stapler of claim 24, wherein the striker includes a pre-release position above the staple loading chamber, a lowest striker position in front of the staple loading chamber, wherein the striker moves toward the base about one half inch
view more
|
Enforceable and Invalid (112)
Entry 569 |
27 |
A desktop stapler, comprising: a body with a handle pivotably attached to the body, the handle including a pressing area near a front end of the handle; a base pivotably attached to the body toward a rear end of the stapler, the stapler having a
view more
|
Enforceable and Invalid (112)
Entry 569 |
28 |
The desktop staple of claim 27, wherein the handle at the pressing area moves about 0.9 to 1 inch inclusive toward the base as the handle moves from the rest position to the pre-release position.
|
Enforceable and Invalid (112)
Entry 569 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
6 |
A safety mechanism for a self-powered tool that ejects and drives fasteners into a working surface, comprising: a body having a front end, a rear end, and a bottom; a striker disposed at the front end of the body, wherein the striker slides along a
view more
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 472 |
7 |
A safety mechanism for a self-powered tool that ejects and drives fasteners into a working surface, comprising: a body containing a striker at a front end thereof, wherein the striker slides along a path therein; a power spring disposed in the body,
view more
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 472 |
9 |
The safety mechanism for a self-powered tool according to claim 7, wherein the striker starts at a rest position in front of the fasteners.
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 472 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
20 |
A desktop stapler comprising: an elongated base including sidewalls; a body pivotably attached to the base toward a rear end of the stapler, the stapler having a closed stapler position wherein the body extends forward from the pivotal attachment in
view more
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 472 |
21 |
The stapler of claim 20, wherein a track chamber is at least partially exposed when the track assembly is moved rearward.
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 472 |
-
Infringement
Staples, Inc.
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
CX1D-X1EX-5Executive one-touch staplerHigh Capacity staplerOne-touch 60-sheet high capacity staplerOne-touch staplers DX-1, CX-1Staples One-Touch CX-1Staples One-Touch DX-1Staples One-Touch EX-5Staples One-Touch High Capacity | US 7,080,768 B2 |
20, 21
|
Willful infringement
Entry 569Entry 472 Entry 557 |
CX1D-X1EX-5High Capacity staplerStaples One-Touch CX-1Staples ONE-TOUCH CX-1, DX-1 and EX-5 staplersStaples One-Touch DX-1Staples One-Touch EX-5 | US 7,178,709 B2 |
24, 25, 27, 28
|
Willful infringement
Entry 569Entry 472 Entry 619 |
CX1CX-1, DX-1, EX-5D-X1EX-5Executive one-touch staplerHigh Capacity staplerHigh Capacity stapler productsOne-touch 60-sheet high capacity staplerOne-touch staplers DX-1, CX-1Staples One-Touch CX-1Staples One-Touch DX-1Staples One-Touch EX-5Staples One-Touch High Capacity | US 7,290,692 B2 |
6, 7, 9
|
Willful infringement
Entry 569Entry 643 Entry 472 Entry 557 |
Staples The Office Superstore LLC
- 2 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
CX1D-X1EX-5High Capacity stapler | US 7,080,768 B2 |
20, 21
|
Infringement
Entry 569
|
CX1CX-1, DX-1, EX-5D-X1EX-5High Capacity staplerHigh Capacity stapler products | US 7,290,692 B2 |
6, 7, 9
|
Infringement
Entry 569Entry 643 |
-
Damages