-
Research Corp v. Microsoft Corp DC
- 4:01-cv-00658
- D. Ariz.
- Filed: 12/21/2001
- Closed: 09/03/2009
- Latest Docket Entry: 01/20/2011
- Judge: Robert Clive Jones
- PACER
1
Plaintiff
1
Defendant
0
Accused
Products
6
Patents-in-Suit
2,814
Days in
Litigation
-
Research Corp v. Microsoft Corp DC
- 4:01-cv-00658
- D. Ariz.
- Filed: 12/21/2001
- Closed: 09/03/2009
- Latest Docket Entry: 01/20/2011
- Judge: Robert Clive Jones
- PACER

Complaint Unavailable
Cause of Action
Infringement
Market Sector
E-commerce and Software
Court
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
2 |
A method for halftoning image information which comprises the step of comparing such information against at least one array, wherein said at least one array is comprised of multibit threshold values, and said at least one array, when thresholded,
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 770 |
6 |
A method for the halftoning of an image which comprises the step of comparing information derived from said image against at least one array, wherein said at least one array, when thresholded, produces a pattern that exhibits a power spectrum
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 770 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
42 |
An apparatus for halftoning image information, comprising a comparator for comparing such information against at least one array, wherein said at least one array is comprised of multibit threshold values, and said at least one array, when
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103) and Unenforceable
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
72 |
An apparatus for halftoning a color image, comprising a comparator for comparing information derived from at least one component color of such image against at least one array, wherein said at least one array, when thresholded, exhibits a power
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103) and Unenforceable
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A method for the halftoning of color images which comprises the step of utilizing, in turn, a pixel-by-pixel comparison of each of a plurality of color planes of said color image against a mask in which the mask comprises a non-determinate,
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
11 |
A method for the halftoning of color images which comprises the step of utilizing, in turn, a pixel-by-pixel comparison of each of a plurality of color planes of said color image against a respective one of a plurality of masks in which each
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A machine comprising a computer readable storage device which stores a dither matrix for use in halftoning image information and a comparator responsive to said computer readable storage device, said dither matrix comprising at least one array,
view more
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
4 |
The machine of claim 1, wherein substantially all of said number of dot profiles have a power spectrum substantially characteristic of a blue noise power spectrum for the level at which such dot profile is produced.
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
63 |
The computer readable memory device of claim 57, wherein said halftoning mask is designed to produce substantially all visually pleasing dot profiles when thresholded at a number of levels.
|
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 770 Entry 729 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A method for the halftoning of gray scale images by utilizing a pixel-by-pixel comparison of the image against a blue noise mask in which the blue noise mask is comprised of a random non-deterministic, non-white noise single valued function which
view more
|
Invalid (101)
Entry 1124 |
2 |
The method of claim 1, wherein said blue noise mask is used to halftone a color image.
|
Invalid (101)
Entry 1124 |
11 |
The method of claim 10, wherein said optical blue noise mask and said image are separately photographed onto said high contrast film such that a repeated exposure of said film occurs.
|
Invalid (101)
Entry 1124 |
-
Infringement
Microsoft Corporation
- 6 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,111,310 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 729 Entry 995 |
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,341,228 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 729 Entry 995 |
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,477,305 A |
42, 72
|
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 729 Entry 995 |
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,543,941 A |
1, 11
|
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 729 Entry 995 |
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,708,518 A |
2, 6
|
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 995 |
GreenMonoMethod and Apparatus for HalftoneRendering of a Gray Scale Image Using a Blue Noise MaskRGB555Pat arraysSuperCell 216SuperCell PackeducOrderedStochastic | US 5,726,772 A |
1, 4, 63
|
No infringement
Entry 770Entry 729 Entry 995 |
-
Damages