-
Ronald A Katz Technology Licensing L P v. Citizens Financial Group Inc et al NPE DC
- 2:07-cv-04964
- C.D. Cal.
- Judge: Robert Gary Klausner
+1
- Filed: 07/31/2007
- Closed: 07/30/2014
- Latest Docket Entry: 05/22/2014
- PACER
1
Plaintiff
12
Defendants
29
Accused
Products
17
Patents-in-Suit
2,610
Days in
Litigation
-
Ronald A Katz Technology Licensing L P v. Citizens Financial Group Inc et al NPE DC
- 2:07-cv-04964
- C.D. Cal.
- Judge: Robert Gary Klausner
+1
- Filed: 07/31/2007
- Closed: 07/30/2014
- Latest Docket Entry: 05/22/2014
- PACER
Transferred From
Causes of Action
Infringement
Willful Patent Infringement
Market Sector
Financial Services
Referred Judge
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
56 |
A process for interfacing, through a telephone-communication facility, (1) callers who are at a multitude of remote terminals for voice-digital communication with (2) a system for prompting the callers with caller cues, said process comprising
view more
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 775 |
62 |
A process according to claim 56, further comprising the step of: processing, to isolate a subset of callers, caller-response signals responsive to certain of the plurality of caller cues.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 775 |
63 |
A process according to claim 62, wherein during the processing step, the response signals are processed on-line.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 775 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
69 |
A process for controlling operations of an interface with a telephone communication system, said process including the steps of: providing products carrying participation numbers specifying limits on use to entitle individual callers to access
view more
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 775 |
85 |
A process for controlling operations of an interface with a telephone communication system according to claim 69, wherein the step of providing products includes providing said products for purchase.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 775 |
-
Infringement
Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania
- 6 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 4,930,150 A |
11
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank’s check imaging applicationRBS | US 5,255,309 A |
46, 51
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 5,351,285 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank systemRBS systems | US 5,561,707 A |
69, 75, 83
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 5,684,863 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank system | US 5,787,156 A |
11, 26
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
Citizens Financial Group Incorporated
- 6 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 4,930,150 A |
11
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank’s check imaging applicationRBS | US 5,255,309 A |
46, 51
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 5,351,285 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank systemRBS systems | US 5,561,707 A |
69, 75, 83
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|
1-2-3 rewards mastercard servicesBankcard servicesCard activation servicesCCO mortgageCCO mortgage lines of credit customer serviceCCO new mortgage loansCharter one bank customer serviceCharter one bank megarewards redemptionand customer serviceCharter one bank online bankingCharter one business phone bankCharter one customer direct salesCharter one insurance agencyCharter one investment servicesCharter one investment services corpCitizen card activation servicesCitizens bank customer serviceCitizens bank education finance departmentCitizens bank gold debit card activationCitizens bank master card activation lineCitizens bank MBNA credit cardCitizens bank rewardsCitizens bank telephone bill paymentCitizens business phone bankCitizens credit card servicesCitizens direct mortgageCitizens financial headquartersCitizens gift card service centerCitizens investment servicesCitizens online banking servicesMegarewards automated information line | US 5,684,863 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 841
|
PhoneBank system | US 5,787,156 A |
11, 26
|
No infringement
Entry 841
|