1:07-mc-00493 | In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC
- 1:07-mc-00493
- D.D.C.
- Judge: Randolph D. Moss
- Filed: 11/16/2007
- Closed: 03/08/2021
- Latest Docket Entry: 03/05/2021
- PACER
- Docket updated daily

Plaintiffs

Defendants

Accused Products

Patents-in-Suit

4,862

Days in Litigation

Overview

Docket (1,018 Entries)

Campaign

Outcome

News (8 Articles)

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC
- 1:07-mc-00493
- D.D.C.
- Judge: Randolph D. Moss
- Filed: 11/16/2007
- Closed: 03/08/2021
- Latest Docket Entry: 03/05/2021
- PACER
- Docket updated daily

Overview

Docket (1,018 Entries)

Campaign

Outcome

News (8 Articles)

View Complaint

Appeal

14-1110

Cause of Action

Declaratory Judgment

Patent Invalidity
Patent Non-Infringement
Patent Unenforceability

Market Sector

Consumer Products

Court

District of D.C.

Assigned Judge

Randolph D. Moss

Outcome Summary

View Outcome Details

Overview

Validity and Enforceability Details

Infringement Details

Patent Information

Patents-in-Suit

Petitions

Infringement

Canon Inc.

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Canon USA, Inc.

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Eastman Kodak Company

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Fujifilm Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Fujifilm Japan

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 560

Fujifilm USA Incorporated

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Hewlett-Packard Company

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
59 point-and-shoot digital camerasCanon productsCompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP USB still image capturing deviceSamsung productsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 547 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 560
59 point-and-shoot digital camerasCanon productsCompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSamsung productsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 547 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 560

JVC Americas Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Konica Minolta Business Solutions USA Incorporated

1 Detail

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Digital still camerasDSC	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 283

Matsushita Electric Industrial Company Limited

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 546 Entry 529 Entry 560

Nikon Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Nikon Incorporated

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Olympus Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Olympus Imaging America Incorporated

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Panasonic Corporation Of North America

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 529 Entry 560

Ricoh Americas Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Ricoh Company Limited

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Ricoh Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Samsung Opto-Electronics America Incorporated

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
AQ100CL65CL80CompactFlash devicesDigimaxA4DigimaxA40DigimaxA403DigimaxD85Eye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceHX30WHZ10WHZ15WHZ25WHZ35WHZ50Wi80L83TNX10Ordinary memory cardsPL200PL90PTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceS1030S830SDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSL102SL105SL202SL30SL35SL40SL420SL50SL502SL605SL620SL630SL720SL820SLK600SmartMedia devicesTL100TL105TL110TL205TL210TL225TL229TL240TL320TL350TL500TL90XD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 520 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 521 Entry 529 Entry 560
AQ100CL65CL80CompactFlash devicesDigimaxA4DigimaxA40DigimaxA403DigimaxD85Eye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceHX30WHZ10WHZ15WHZ25WHZ35WHZ50Wi80L83TMass Storage ClassNX10Ordinary memory cardsPL200PL90S1030S830SDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSL102SL105SL202SL30SL35SL40SL420SL50SL502SL605SL620SL630SL720SL820SLK600SmartMedia devicesTL100TL105TL110TL205TL210TL225TL229TL240TL320TL350TL500TL90XD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 520 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 521 Entry 529 Entry 560

Samsung Techwin Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
AQ100CL65CL80CompactFlash devicesDigimaxA4DigimaxA40DigimaxA403DigimaxD85Eye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceHX30WHZ10WHZ15WHZ25WHZ35WHZ50Wi80L83TNX10Ordinary memory cardsPL200PL90PTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceS1030S830SDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSL102SL105SL202SL30SL35SL40SL420SL50SL502SL605SL620SL630SL720SL820SLK600SmartMedia devicesTL100TL105TL110TL205TL210TL225TL229TL240TL320TL350TL500TL90XD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 520 Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 521 Entry 529 Entry 560
AQ100CL65CL80CompactFlash devicesDigimaxA4DigimaxA40DigimaxA403DigimaxD85Eye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceHX30WHZ10WHZ15WHZ25WHZ35WHZ50Wi80L83TMass Storage ClassNX10Ordinary memory cardsPL200PL90S1030S830SDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSL102SL105SL202SL30SL35SL40SL420SL50SL502SL605SL620SL630SL720SL820SLK600SmartMedia devicesTL100TL105TL110TL205TL210TL225TL229TL240TL320TL350TL500TL90XD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528 Entry 520 Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 521 Entry 529 Entry 560

Sanyo Electric Company Limited

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Sanyo North America Corporation

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528
Flexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O device	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 528

Victor Company of Japan Limited

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceOrdinary memory cardsPTP Accused DevicesPTP USB still image capturing deviceSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 534 Entry 524 Entry 535 Entry 529 Entry 560
CompactFlash devicesEye-Fi cardsFlexible interface for Communication between a host and an analog I/O device connected to the interface regardless the type of the I/O deviceMass Storage ClassOrdinary memory cardsSDIO cardsSecure digital devicesSmartMedia devicesXD devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 545 Entry 524 Entry 546 Entry 529 Entry 560

2 Details

Accused Product	Patent #	Claim #	Outcome
HP Accused Cameras, infringement as a seller of Samsung productsmemory cards including ordinary memory cards, SD (Secure Digital) devices, CF (CompactFlash) devices, XD devices, SmartMedia devices, SDIO cards, Eye-Fi cards, and other similar cardsTable 15 devices	US 6,470,399 B1	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 548 Entry 537 Entry 525
HP Accused Cameras, infringement as a seller of Samsung productsmemory cards including ordinary memory cards, SD (Secure Digital) devices, CF (CompactFlash) devices, XD devices, SmartMedia devices, SDIO cards, Eye-Fi cards, and other similar cardsTable 15 devices	US 6,895,449 B2	All Asserted Claims	No infringement Entry 548 Entry 537 Entry 525

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC

Outcome Summary

Infringement

Solutions

Use Cases

Quick Links

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC

In re: Papst Licensing GmbH & Company Kg Patent Litigation DC CAFC

Outcome Summary

Subscription Required

Subscription Required

Subscription Required

Subscription Required

Subscription Required

Infringement

Solutions

Use Cases

Quick Links