-
freal Foods LLC et al v. Hamilton Beach Brands, Inc. et al DC CAFC
- 1:16-cv-00041
- D. Del.
- Judge: Colm F. Connolly
- Filed: 01/26/2016
- Closed: 08/14/2020
- Latest Docket Entry: 02/06/2024
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
2
Plaintiffs
3
Defendants
6
Accused
Products
4
Patents-in-Suit
1,663
Days in
Litigation
-
freal Foods LLC et al v. Hamilton Beach Brands, Inc. et al DC CAFC
- 1:16-cv-00041
- D. Del.
- Judge: Colm F. Connolly
- Filed: 01/26/2016
- Closed: 08/14/2020
- Latest Docket Entry: 02/06/2024
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
Market Sector
Consumer Products
Court
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
- Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A mixing machine for mixing a liquid contained in a vessel having an opening, the mixing machine comprising: a holder coupled to the mixing machine, the holder proportioned to receive a vessel; a rotatable mixing element extendable through the
view more
|
Valid
Entry 286 |
5 |
The mixing machine of claim 1, wherein the splash shield has a mass of approximately 5 lbs.
|
Valid
Entry 286 |
6 |
A method for retaining a vessel in a holder while mixing contents of the vessel, the method comprising the steps of: providing a vessel containing contents to be mixed, the vessel including an opening; further providing a mixing machine having a
view more
|
Valid
Entry 286 |
10 |
The method of claim 6, wherein the contents of the vessel are at least partially frozen.
|
Valid
Entry 286 |
11 |
The method of claim 6, wherein the contents comprise frozen milkshake ingredients.
|
Valid
Entry 286 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
15 |
On a mixing machine for mixing a liquid contained in a vessel having an opening, the mixing machine of a type including a rotatable mixing element extendable into the vessel for mixing the contents of the vessel, the improvement comprising: a rinse
view more
|
Valid
Entry 286 Entry 264 |
20 |
The improvement of claim 15, wherein the at least one nozzle is oriented to direct rinse fluid onto the mixing element.
|
Valid
Entry 264 |
22 |
The improvement of claim 15, wherein the splash shield is of sufficient mass to retain the vessel within the holder during relative movement of the mixing element and vessel in opposite directions.
|
Valid
Entry 264 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
An apparatus for making frozen drinks from a frozen substance frozen into a cup, comprising: a housing; a cup support mounted to the housing; a liquid dispenser having an outlet positioned to direct liquid into a cup positioned in the cup support;
view more
|
Valid
Entry 264 |
11 |
An apparatus for making frozen drinks from a frozen substance frozen into a cup, comprising: a housing; a cup support mounted to the housing; a rotatable blade assembly mounted within the housing, the blade assembly including shaving elements and
view more
|
Valid
Entry 264 |
-
Infringement
Hamilton Beach Brands Incorporated
- 4 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 5,803,377 A |
1, 11
|
No infringement
Entry 264
|
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQBIC 3000DQ milkshake blenderFrozen milkshakesHamilton Beach BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersHamilton Beach MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blendersHershey Creamery frozen milkshakesMIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,144,150 B2 |
15, 20, 22
|
Infringement
Entry 286Entry 249 Entry 242 Entry 264 |
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQIMI2000MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,520,658 B2 |
1, 5, 6, 10, 11
|
Infringement
Entry 264
|
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQFrozen milkshakesHamilton Beach BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersHamilton Beach MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blendersHershey Creamery frozen milkshakesIMI2000MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,520,662 B2 |
21
|
Infringement
Entry 286Entry 249 Entry 241 Entry 355 Entry 264 |
Hershey Creamery Company
- 4 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 5,803,377 A |
1, 11
|
No infringement
Entry 264
|
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQBIC 3000DQ milkshake blenderFrozen milkshakesHamilton Beach BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersHamilton Beach MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blendersHershey Creamery frozen milkshakesMIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,144,150 B2 |
15, 20, 22
|
Infringement
Entry 286Entry 249 Entry 242 Entry 264 |
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQIMI2000MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,520,658 B2 |
1, 5, 6, 10, 11
|
Infringement
Entry 264
|
BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersBIC3000-DQFrozen milkshakesHamilton Beach BIC2000 blend-in-cup blendersHamilton Beach MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blendersHershey Creamery frozen milkshakesIMI2000MIC2000 mix-in-cup milkshake blenders | US 7,520,662 B2 |
21
|
Infringement
Entry 286Entry 249 Entry 241 Entry 355 Entry 264 |
-
Damages