-
Graphic Packaging International, Inc. v. C.W. Zumbiel Co. DC CAFC
- 3:10-cv-00891
- M.D. Fla.
- Filed: 09/29/2010
- Closed: 02/02/2012
- Latest Docket Entry: 09/04/2013
- Judge: Roy B. Dalton, Jr
+2
- PACER
1
Plaintiff
1
Defendant
2
Accused
Products
2
Patents-in-Suit
492
Days in
Litigation
-
Graphic Packaging International, Inc. v. C.W. Zumbiel Co. DC CAFC
- 3:10-cv-00891
- M.D. Fla.
- Filed: 09/29/2010
- Closed: 02/02/2012
- Latest Docket Entry: 09/04/2013
- Judge: Roy B. Dalton, Jr
+2
- PACER
Assigned Judge
Previously Presiding
Roy B. Dalton, Jr (until 03/11/2012)
Outcome Summary
Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A package comprising: a carton enclosing a plurality of containers; the carton comprising: two ends including an exiting end; four panels connected to the two ends, the four panels including a first panel connected to a second panel the first panel
view more
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
5 |
The package of claim 1 wherein the third tear line does not extend along the first fold line; and wherein the fourth tear line does not extend along the first fold line.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
8 |
The package of claim 1 wherein the containers are cans.
|
Valid (103 and 112)
Entry 151 Entry 128 |
9 |
The package of claim 1 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being hinged along the second section.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
10 |
The package of claim 9 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being detached from the carton.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
11 |
The package of claim 1 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being detached from the carton.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
12 |
The package of claim 1 wherein the second tear line extends at least partially along and collinear with a third fold line.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
14 |
A package comprising: a carton and a plurality of containers; the carton comprising: four panels connected to two ends, the two ends including an exiting end; the four panels including a first panel connected to a second panel, a third panel
view more
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
21 |
The package of claim 14 wherein the third tear line extends from the first corner to a means for facilitating separation of the dispensing flap.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
23 |
A carton comprising: four panels connected to two ends; the two ends including an exiting end; the four panels including a first panel connected to a second panel, a third panel connected to the first panel, and a fourth panel opposite the first
view more
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
29 |
The carton of claim 23 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being hinged along the second section.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
30 |
The carton of claim 29 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being detached from the carton.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
31 |
The carton of claim 23 wherein the dispensing flap is capable of being detached from the carton.
|
Valid (102 and 112)
Entry 175 Entry 151 Entry 128 |
33 |
The carton of claim 32 wherein the second tear line extends from the second corner along the third fold line; and wherein the second section of the dispensing flap is detachable along the second tear line.
|
Valid
Entry 176 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
23 |
A carton enclosing a plurality of cylindrical articles arranged on their sides in rows and columns, a first column being adjacent a first end of the carton, a top row cylindrical article being in a top row, being in the first column, and having a
view more
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 179 Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 |
33 |
A package comprising a plurality of cylindrical articles disposed on their sides in rows and columns, a first column being adjacent a first end of the package, a top row cylindrical article being in a top row, being in the first column, and having a
view more
|
Valid (102 and 103)
Entry 179 Entry 176 Entry 175 Entry 151 |
52 |
A carton blank comprising: a first panel; a second panel; a third panel; a second panel end flap; a third panel end flap; at least one tear line in the first panel; wherein the at least one tear line extends from an intermediate portion of the first
view more
|
Valid (103)
Entry 175 Entry 151 |
54 |
The blank of claim 52 wherein the second panel is foldably connected to the first panel at a first fold line.
|
Valid (103)
Entry 175 Entry 151 |
55 |
The blank of claim 54 wherein the third panel is foldably connected to the first panel at a second fold line.
|
Valid (103)
Entry 175 Entry 151 |
58 |
A carton formed from the blank of claim 52.
|
Valid (103)
Entry 175 Entry 151 |
60 |
In combination, a parallelepiped carton formed from the blank of claim 52, and a plurality of containers within the carton.
|
Valid (103)
Entry 175 Entry 151 |
-
Infringement
CW Zumbiel Company
- 2 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Dispensing system for double stack cartonZipper Pack BlanksZipper Pack Cartons | US 7,134,551 B2 |
23, 33, 52, 54, 55, 58, 60
|
Infringement
Entry 176Entry 175 Entry 219 |
Dispensing system for double stack cartonZipper Pack BlanksZipper Pack Cartons | US 7,780,003 B2 |
1, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 21, 23, 29, 30, 31
|
Infringement
Entry 176Entry 175 Entry 219 |
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Diet 7-Up CartonKroger® CartonZipper Pack BlanksZipper Pack Cartons | US 7,134,551 B2 |
23, 33, 52, 54, 55, 58, 60
|
Infringement
Entry 179Entry 151 |
-
Damages