-
Acco Brands Inc v. ABA Locks Mfg Co, et al DC CAFC
- 2:02-cv-00112
- E.D. Tex.
- Judge: T. John Ward
- Filed: 05/31/2002
- Closed: 03/28/2006
- Latest Docket Entry: 09/23/2008
- PACER
1
Plaintiff
2
Defendants
2
Accused
Products
3
Patents-in-Suit
1,398
Days in
Litigation
-
Acco Brands Inc v. ABA Locks Mfg Co, et al DC CAFC
- 2:02-cv-00112
- E.D. Tex.
- Judge: T. John Ward
- Filed: 05/31/2002
- Closed: 03/28/2006
- Latest Docket Entry: 09/23/2008
- PACER
Cause of Action
Willful Patent Infringement
Market Sector
Consumer Products
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
- Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A security lock system, comprising: a portable electronic device having an external wall defining a security slot; locking means for attaching to a first object other than to the portable electronic device; a locking member having a peripheral
view more
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
3 |
A security lock system, comprising: a portable electronic device having an external wall defining a security slot; a locking member having a peripheral profile complementary to preselected dimensions of said security slot, said locking member
view more
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
4 |
The security lock of claim 3 further comprising: a cable attachment mechanism for associating a cable with the engagement member.
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
5 |
The security lock of claim 1 wherein said security slot is rectangular having a length dimension greater than a width dimension.
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
8 |
The security lock of claim 3 wherein said security slot is rectangular having a length dimension greater than a width dimension.
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
All Claims |
NA
|
Invalid (101) and Unenforceable
Entry 267 Entry 268 Entry 151 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A locking apparatus, comprising: a housing including a slot engagement member having a slot engaging portion provided with a locking member having a peripheral profile complementary to preselected dimensions of a security slot provided in an
view more
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
3 |
The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said pin extends a distance into the security slot greater than a wall thickness of the external wall.
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
10 |
A removable, lockable, portable electronic device attachment system, comprising: a cable for attaching to a first object other than a portable electronic device; a housing, proximate to said electronic device and including a slot engagement
view more
|
Valid
Entry 244 |
-
Infringement
ABA Locks Manufacturer Company Limited
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Combo LockKey Lock | US 5,493,878 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 151
|
Combo LockKey LockNotebook Security C100 combination lockNotebook Security K100 key lock | US 5,502,989 A |
1, 3, 10
|
Willful infringement
Entry 360Entry 244 Entry 336 Entry 151 Entry 177 |
Notebook Security C100 combination lockNotebook Security K100 key lock | US 6,006,557 A |
1, 3, 4, 5, 8
|
Willful infringement
Entry 244
|
Belkin Components
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Combo LockKey Lock | US 5,493,878 A | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 151
|
Combo LockKey LockNotebook Security C100 combination lockNotebook Security K100 key lock | US 5,502,989 A |
1, 3, 10
|
Willful infringement
Entry 360Entry 244 Entry 336 Entry 151 |
Notebook Security C100 combination lockNotebook Security K100 key lock | US 6,006,557 A |
1, 3, 4, 5, 8
|
Willful infringement
Entry 244
|
-
Damages
Total Damages:
$12,237,511.00Other Costs:
$78,509.14Dockets:
- Reasonable Royalty: $2,075,000.00
- Compensatory Damages: $10,162,511.00
- Pre Judgment Interest: $78,509.14