-
3Form v. Lumicor DC CAFC
- 2:12-cv-00293
- D. Utah
- Filed: 03/26/2012
- Closed: 01/29/2016
- Latest Docket Entry: 10/22/2018
- Judge: Clark Waddoups
- PACER
1
Plaintiff
1
Defendant
12
Accused
Products
2
Patents-in-Suit
1,405
Days in
Litigation
-
3Form v. Lumicor DC CAFC
- 2:12-cv-00293
- D. Utah
- Filed: 03/26/2012
- Closed: 01/29/2016
- Latest Docket Entry: 10/22/2018
- Judge: Clark Waddoups
- PACER
Cause of Action
Willful Patent Infringement
Market Sector
Industrial
Court
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim | Outcome |
---|---|
All challenged claims |
Invalid (102 and 103)
Entry 73 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A decorative architectural panel comprising: one or more compressible objects suspended between two extruded resin sheets formed together about the one or more compressible objects using a plurality of pressures in a thermosetting process, at least
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
2 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the first and second extruded sheets are at least partially translucent.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
3 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the decorative laminate panel has a thickness of between 0.25 and 2 inches.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
4 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein at least one of the first and second extruded sheets comprise extruded PETG having a thickness of between 0.1 inches and 0.50 inches.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 73 |
5 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein at least one of the first and second extruded sheets comprise extruded polycarbonate having a thickness of between 0.1 inches and 0.50 inches.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
6 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein at least one of the first and second extruded sheets has a width and length dimensions of approximately 3′×5′ approximately 4′×8°, or approximately 5′×10′.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
7 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein at least one of the first and second extruded sheets comprises a copolyester that has a melting point between 180° F. and 230° F. in a pressure range of up to 40 psi.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 73 |
8 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the one or more compressible objects comprise any one or more of bamboo, beans, straw, a tree branch, a tree twig, a bush branch, a bush twig, or any other object having a natural diameter that is
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
9 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein a viewable surface of the decorative laminate panel is substantially uniform from one end to the next such that no lakes or air bubbles are exposed.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
10 |
The panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the one critical pressure is less than about 92 psi for the one or more compressible objects.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
11 |
The panel as recited in claim 10, wherein the critical pressure is greater than about 10 psi, such that the one or more compressible three-dimensional objects ordinarily appear to have an unnatural conformation when subjected to the critical pressure
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
12 |
The panel as recited in claim 10, wherein the unnatural appearance comprises a substantially flattened appearance for the one or more compressible three-dimensional objects when viewed through the first or second extruded sheet.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
13 |
A laminate sheet assembly configured to create the decorative architectural panel recited in claim 1 when the laminate assembly is subjected to the plurality of pressures in the thermosetting process comprising: the first extruded sheet; the one or
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
14 |
The laminate sheet assembly as recited in claim 13, further comprising a pressure pad positioned about one of the first and second extruded sheets.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
15 |
The laminate sheet assembly as recited in claim 13, wherein the first and second extruded sheets comprise PETG.
|
Invalid (103)
Entry 73 |
16 |
The laminate sheet assembly as recited in claim 13, wherein the first and second extruded sheets comprise polycarbonate.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
17 |
The decorative architectural panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the one or more compressible objects comprise thatch or willow reed.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
18 |
The decorative architectural panel as recited in claim 1, wherein the one or more compressible objects comprise bamboo.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
19 |
A decorative architectural resin panel comprising: first and second extruded resin sheets formed together with a plurality of pressures, at least one of the one plurality of pressures being greater than a critical pressure at which one or more
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 73 |
-
Damages