-
Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc et al v. First Quality Baby Products LLC et al DC CAFC
- 1:09-cv-00916
- E.D. Wis.
- Filed: 09/21/2009
- Closed: 05/31/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 11/02/2017
- Judge: William C. Griesbach
- PACER
2
Plaintiffs
2
Defendants
3
Accused
Products
10
Patents-in-Suit
1,349
Days in
Litigation
-
Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc et al v. First Quality Baby Products LLC et al DC CAFC
- 1:09-cv-00916
- E.D. Wis.
- Filed: 09/21/2009
- Closed: 05/31/2013
- Latest Docket Entry: 11/02/2017
- Judge: William C. Griesbach
- PACER
Causes of Action
Breach of Contract
Infringement
Other
Willful Patent Infringement
Market Sector
Consumer Products
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
1 |
A packaged garment defining a waist opening and a leg opening, the garment comprising, a front region comprising a front panel and defining a front waist edge, a back region comprising a back panel and defining a back waist edge, and a crotch region
view more
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
2 |
The garment of claim 1 wherein the refastenable seam is formed between a body-facing surface of the front side panel and a clothing-facing surface of the back side panel.
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
8 |
The garment of claim 1 wherein the fastening component is engaged with a mating fastening component, wherein the mating fastening component is integral with a side panel.
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
9 |
The garment of claim 1 wherein the front and back side panels are bonded to the front and back panels, respectively.
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
10 |
The garment of claim 1 wherein the fastening component extends transversely outward from a side panel.
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
18 |
A packaged garment having a waist opening and a leg opening, the garment comprising, a front region comprising a front panel and defining a front waist edge, a back region comprising a back panel and defining a back waist edge, and a crotch region
view more
|
Valid (112)
Entry 812 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
8 |
A disposable absorbent article, comprising an absorbent chassis and a fastening system for releasably attaching a front waist region of the absorbent chassis to a back waist region of the absorbent chassis to define a refastenable pant having a waist
view more
|
Invalid
Entry 861 |
9 |
The disposable absorbent article of claim 8, wherein the refastenable pant further comprises: an elastomeric front waistband disposed in the front waist region and positioned between the pair of elastomeric front side panels; and an elastomeric back
view more
|
Invalid
Entry 861 |
10 |
The disposable absorbent article of claim 8, wherein the absorbent article has an overall length dimension, the front side panels are longitudinally spaced from the back side panels, and the front and back side panels have an average length dimension
view more
|
Invalid
Entry 861 |
Claim | Outcome |
---|---|
All challenged claims |
Valid (102)
Entry 813 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
4 |
A disposable absorbent pant defining a longitudinal axis, front and back longitudinally spaced waist regions, and a crotch region which extends between and interconnects the front and back waist regions, the absorbent pant comprising:</claim-text> a
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 803 Entry 861 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
18 |
An absorbent article comprising:</claim-text> an outer cover having an interior surface and an opposite exterior surface; an absorbent assembly disposed on the interior surface; a permanent character graphic disposed on the outer cover; an active
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 805 Entry 861 |
19 |
An absorbent article comprising:</claim-text> an outer cover having an interior surface and an opposite exterior surface; an absorbent assembly disposed on the interior surface; a permanent character graphic disposed on the outer cover; an active
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 805 Entry 861 |
20 |
An absorbent article comprising:</claim-text> an outer cover having an interior surface and an opposite exterior surface; an absorbent assembly disposed on the interior surface; a permanent character graphic disposed on the outer cover; an active
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 805 Entry 861 |
29 |
An absorbent article comprising:</claim-text> an outer cover having an interior surface and an opposite exterior surface; an absorbent assembly disposed on the interior surface; a permanent character graphic disposed on the outer cover; an active
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 805 Entry 861 |
31 |
An absorbent article comprising:</claim-text> an outer cover having an interior surface and an opposite exterior surface; an absorbent assembly disposed on the interior surface; a permanent character graphic disposed on the outer cover; an active
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 805 Entry 861 |
-
Infringement
First Quality Baby Products LLC
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
NAtraining pant product | US 6,513,221 B2 |
4, 5, 7, 10, 15, 16
|
No infringement
Entry 814Entry 861 |
SuperValu | US 6,514,187 B2 |
1, 3, 4, 5
|
Infringement
Entry 811
|
NASuperValu training pant Training pant White Cloud training pant | US 6,846,374 B2 | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 861Entry 364 |
First Quality Consumer Products LLC
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
NAtraining pant product | US 6,513,221 B2 |
4, 5, 7, 10, 15, 16
|
No infringement
Entry 814Entry 861 |
SuperValu | US 6,514,187 B2 |
1, 3, 4, 5
|
Infringement
Entry 811
|
NA | US 6,846,374 B2 | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 861
|
First Quality Retail Services LLC
- 3 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
NAtraining pant product | US 6,513,221 B2 |
4, 5, 7, 10, 15, 16
|
No infringement
Entry 814Entry 861 |
SuperValu | US 6,514,187 B2 |
1, 3, 4, 5
|
Infringement
Entry 811
|
NASuperValu training pant Training pant White Cloud training pant | US 6,846,374 B2 | All Asserted Claims |
No infringement
Entry 861Entry 364 |