Flight control system with low-frequency instrument landing system localizer anomaly detection and method of use

• US 10,089,892 B2
• Filed: 11/01/2016
• Issued: 10/02/2018
• Est. Priority Date: 11/01/2016
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: The Boeing Co.
• Original Assignee: The Boeing Co.
• Inventors: McLees, Robert E., Hooks, Andrew R., Panyakeow, Prachya
• Primary Examiner(s): Bendidi, Rachid
• Application Number:
  US15/340,371
• Publication Number:
  US 20180122248A1
• Time in Patent Office: 700 Days
• CPC Class Codes: B64D 45/04 Landing aids; Safety measures to prevent collision with earth's surface
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/882 for altimeters measuring height using barometric means G01C5/06
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 19/15 Aircraft landing systems
• CPC Class Codes: G05D 1/0202 specially adapted to aircraft
• CPC Class Codes: G05D 1/0676 specially adapted for landing
• CPC Class Codes: G08G 5/02 Automatic approach or landing aids, i.e. systems in which flight data of incoming planes are processed to provide landing data landing aids fitted in or to aircraft B64D45/04; visual or acoustic landing aids B64F1/18
• CPC Class Codes: G08G 5/025 Navigation or guidance aids radar or analogous systems specially adapted for landing purposes G01S13/913

Abstract

A flight control module for detecting anomalies in ILS localizer signals during landing of an aircraft is provided. The flight control module includes a communication interface and a processor coupled thereto. The communication interface is configured to receive inertial data, GPS data, and an ILS localizer deviation for the aircraft. The processor is configured to compute an inertial localizer deviation based on the inertial data and a GPS localizer deviation based on the GPS data. The processor is configured to compare the ILS localizer deviation to an average of the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation to detect a low-frequency anomaly in the ILS localizer deviation. The processor is configured to initiate a transition from controlling the aircraft based on the ILS localizer deviation to controlling the aircraft based on the inertial localizer deviation when the low-frequency anomaly is detected.

Claims

1. A flight control module for detecting anomalies in instrument landing system (ILS) localizer signals during landing of an aircraft, comprising:

a communication interface configured to receive inertial data for said aircraft, global positioning system (GPS) data for said aircraft, and an ILS localizer deviation; and

a processor coupled to said communication interface and configured to;

compute an inertial localizer deviation based on the inertial data,

compute a GPS localizer deviation based on the GPS data,

compare the ILS localizer deviation to an average of the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation to detect a low-frequency anomaly in the ILS localizer deviation, and

initiate a transition from controlling said aircraft based on the ILS localizer deviation to controlling said aircraft based on the inertial localizer deviation when the low-frequency anomaly is detected.

2. The flight control module of claim 1, wherein said communication interface is further coupled to a radar altimeter configured to measure altitude of said aircraft above ground level, and wherein said processor is further configured to initialize computation of the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation to the ILS localizer deviation when said aircraft descends beneath a low approach altitude threshold.

3. The flight control module of claim 2, wherein said processor is further configured to:

initialize a second computation of the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation when said aircraft descends beneath a high approach altitude threshold;

compare the second computations to the ILS localizer deviation to detect an earlier low-frequency anomaly when said aircraft is located between the high approach altitude threshold and the low approach altitude threshold; and

disable detection of the low-frequency anomaly below the low approach altitude threshold when the earlier low-frequency anomaly is detected between the high approach altitude threshold and the low approach altitude threshold.

4. The flight control module of claim 3, wherein the low approach altitude threshold is 200 feet and the high approach altitude threshold is 600 feet.

5. The flight control module of claim 1, wherein said processor is further configured to:

compare the inertial localizer deviation to the GPS localizer deviation; and

disable detection of the low-frequency anomaly when a difference between the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation exceeds a threshold.

6. The flight control module of claim 1, wherein the processor is further configured to:

compute the average of the inertial localizer deviation and the GPS localizer deviation;

compute an absolute value difference between the average and the ILS localizer deviation; and

latch an anomaly indicator when the absolute value difference exceeds a trip threshold.

7. The flight control module of claim 6, wherein the processor is further configured to reset said anomaly indicator after the absolute value difference falls below a healing threshold for a healing duration.

8. The flight control module of claim 1, wherein the processor is further configured to initiate an indication to a pilot of said aircraft that the low-frequency anomaly has been detected.

9. A flight control system for landing an aircraft, said flight control system comprising:

a communication bus;

a global positioning system (GPS) coupled to said communication bus and configured to transmit a GPS position of said aircraft onto said communication bus;

a multi-mode receiver (MMR) coupled to said communication bus and configured to transmit an instrument landing system (ILS) localizer deviation onto said communication bus, the ILS localizer deviation generated according to received ILS localizer signals;

a flight control module comprising a processor coupled to said communication bus and configured to;

receive inertial data for said aircraft, the GPS position, and the ILS localizer deviation on said communication bus,

compute a GPS localizer deviation and an inertial localizer deviation, and

detect a low-frequency anomaly in the received ILS localizer signals based on variances in the ILS localizer deviation relative to an average localizer deviation computed for the GPS localizer deviation and the inertial localizer deviation; and

an automated landing system configured to transition from controlling said aircraft based on the ILS localizer deviation to controlling said aircraft based on the inertial localizer deviation when the low-frequency anomaly is detected.

10. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to transmit an indicator to a pilot interface system, the indicator indicative of detection of the low-frequency anomaly.

11. The flight control system of claim 10, wherein said pilot interface system is configured to present a visual indicator to a pilot in response to the indicator received from said flight control module.

12. The flight control system of claim 10, wherein said pilot interface system is configured to present an aural indicator to a pilot in response to the indicator received from said flight control module.

13. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to:

enable detection of the low-frequency anomaly when said aircraft descends below a low approach altitude threshold; and

disable detection of the low-frequency anomaly below the low approach altitude threshold when the low-frequency anomaly is otherwise detected above the low approach altitude threshold.

14. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to disable detection of the low-frequency anomaly when a difference between the GPS localizer deviation and the inertial localizer deviation exceeds a threshold.

15. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to disable detection of the low-frequency anomaly after a rollout duration beginning when said aircraft touches down.

16. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to:

initiate computation of the GPS localizer deviation and the inertial localizer deviation based on a complementary-filtered ILS localizer deviation; and

compare the average localizer deviation to a lag-filtered ILS localizer deviation to detect the low-frequency anomaly.

17. The flight control system of claim 9, wherein said flight control module is further configured to receive inertial data including ground speed, track angle, cross-runway acceleration, and aircraft heading on said communication bus.

18. A method of detecting a low-frequency anomaly in an instrument landing system (ILS) localizer signal received by an aircraft during landing, said method comprising:

receiving, at a multi-mode receiver (MMR), an instrument landing system (ILS) localizer signal;

computing, by the MMR, a ILS localizer deviation based on the ILS localizer signal;

controlling, by an automated landing system, the aircraft according to the ILS localizer deviation;

computing, by a flight control module, a global position system (GPS) localizer deviation;

computing, by the flight control module, an inertial localizer deviation;

computing, by the flight control module, an average localizer deviation of the GPS localizer deviation and the inertial localizer deviation;

detecting, by the flight control module, the low-frequency anomaly when a difference between the average localizer deviation and the ILS localizer deviation exceeds a threshold; and

controlling, by the automated landing system, the aircraft according to the inertial localizer deviation after detecting the low-frequency anomaly.

19. The method of claim 18, wherein computing the inertial localizer deviation comprises:

initializing the inertial localizer deviation to the ILS localizer deviation when the aircraft descends below a low approach altitude threshold; and

integrating inertial data for the aircraft to continuously update the inertial localizer deviation below the low approach altitude threshold and through rollout.

20. The method of claim 19 further comprising:

initializing, by the flight control module, a second inertial localizer deviation to the ILS localizer deviation when the aircraft descends below a high approach altitude threshold;

initializing, by the flight control module, a second GPS localizer deviation to the ILS localizer deviation when the aircraft descends below the high approach altitude threshold;

detecting, by the flight control module, an earlier low-frequency anomaly based on variances between the ILS localizer deviation and a second average localizer deviation of the second inertial localizer deviation and the second GPS localizer deviation; and

disabling, by the flight control module, detection of the low-frequency anomaly before the aircraft descends beneath the low approach altitude threshold.

21. The method of claim 18 further comprising complementary-filtering the ILS localizer deviation for initializing the inertial localizer deviation and for controlling the aircraft.

22. The method of claim 18 further comprising:

computing, by the flight control module, a difference between the GPS localizer deviation and the inertial localizer deviation; and

disabling, by the flight control module, detection of the low-frequency anomaly when the difference exceeds a threshold.

23. The method of claim 18 further comprising:

lag-filtering, by the flight control module, the ILS localizer deviation; and

computing, by the flight control module, a difference between the average localizer deviation and the lag-filtered ILS localizer deviation for detection of the low-frequency anomaly.

24. The method of claim 18 further comprising transmitting, by the flight control module, an indicator to a pilot interface system, the indicator indicative of detection of the low-frequency anomaly.