Method and apparatus for reducing inter-cell interference

• US 10,116,406 B2
• Filed: 08/30/2016
• Issued: 10/30/2018
• Est. Priority Date: 10/25/2012
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Intucell Ltd. (Cisco Systems, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Intucell Ltd. (Cisco Systems, Inc.)
• Inventors: Nuss, Ziv, Apelewicz, Tuvia
• Primary Examiner(s): Nguyen, Phuongchau Ba
• Application Number:
  US15/251,471
• Publication Number:
  US 20160373202A1
• Time in Patent Office: 791 Days
• Field of Search: 370252, 370311, 370315, 370277, 370329
• CPC Class Codes: H04J 11/005 of intercell interference
• CPC Class Codes: H04J 11/0053 using co-ordinated multipoint transmission/reception co-ordinated antenna or beam-forming aspects H04B7/022
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 1/1812 Hybrid protocols; Hybrid automatic repeat request [HARQ]
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 16/10 Dynamic resource partitioning
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 36/0061 of neighbour cell information
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 72/541 using the level of interference
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 84/042 Public Land Mobile systems, e.g. cellular systems
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 84/045 using private Base Stations, e.g. femto Base Stations, home Node B

Abstract

A method is described for reducing interferences in a wireless network, by: identifying cells which experience more interference than others; identifying a group of PRBs that their transmissions are subjected to more interference than other concurrent transmissions; identifying UEs associated with the group of PRBs, and determining whether the location of the UEs is at the cells'"'"' edges; selecting a pair of UEs where one member is located at a first cell'"'"'s edge and the other is located either (i) at a second cell, not included within a neighbors'"'"' list of the first cell, or (ii) at the core or remote edge of a second cell. In case (i), the second cell is introduced to the first cell neighbors'"'"' list, and in case (ii) the other UE is falsely defined as a UE located at the near second cell'"'"'s edge. Then, ICIC procedure is invoked for that pair of UEs.

Claims

1. A method comprising:

identifying, for a cluster of wireless cells comprising a plurality of wireless cells, a first wireless cell that is a most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells by comparing a hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate to a threshold value;

identifying, for a plurality of radio resources available to the first wireless cell, one or more most interfered radio resources of the plurality of radio resources;

identifying one or more user equipment (UE) associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources for the first wireless cell;

identifying at least one UE associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources for the first wireless cell as a cell edge UE based, at least in part, on at least one of a time adjustment (TA) value and a received signal strength power (RSSP) value associated with the at least one UE;

identifying at least one other UE associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources;

determining whether the at least one other UE is one of;

a cell edge UE served by a second wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells, wherein the second wireless cell is not identified in a neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

or

a cell core UE served by a second wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells, wherein the second wireless cell is identified in a neighbor list of the first wireless cell but no inter-cell interference coordination is provided for the cell core UE,

wherein the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell edge UE or a cell core UE based, at least in part, on at least one of TA value and a RSSP value associated with the at least one other UE;

including the second wireless cell in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell if the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell edge UE for the second wireless cell that is not identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

falsely identifying the at least one other UE as a cell edge UE if the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell core UE for the second wireless cell that is identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

determining if the first wireless cell remains the most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells by comparing the hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate of the first wireless cell to the predetermined threshold; and

issuing an error message based on the determination that the first wireless cell remains the most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

calculating the hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate for each wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells;

calculating an average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells; and

determining a standard deviation of the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells.

3. The method of claim 2, further comprising:

comparing a first HARQ success rate calculated for the first wireless cell to the threshold value, wherein the threshold value comprises the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells minus the standard deviation of the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells; and

triggering the identifying of the first wireless cell based, at least in part, on the first HARQ success rate associated with the first wireless cell being less than the threshold value.

4. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

receiving Radio Resource Control (RRC) Connection Setup information associated with the first wireless cell; and

determining whether the second wireless cell is identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell based on the RRC Connection Setup information.

5. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

monitoring high interference indicator messages transmitted by each wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells; and

recording radio resource allocation information associated with each wireless cell, wherein a radio resource allocation information record for a given high interference indicator message sent from a given wireless cell comprises an identity of the wireless cell, a timestamp associated with the given high interference indicator message, and a list of one or more radio resources allocated to one or more cell edge UE served by the wireless cell,

wherein the identifying one or more UE associated with the one or most interfered radio resources is further based on the high interference indicator messages.

6. The method of claim 5, wherein the defining is based, at least in part, on radio resource allocation information recorded for the second wireless cell.

7. The method of claim 6, further comprising:

sending the first wireless cell a high interference indicator message including one or more radio resources associated with the at least one other UE set to indicate that the one or more radio resources are associated with a cell edge UE.

8. The method of claim 1, further comprising inducing a change in a tilt of an antenna associated with at least one of the first wireless cell and the second wireless cell.

9. The method of claim 1, wherein identifying one or more most interfered radio resources further comprises:

determining the one or more most interfered radio resource associated with the most interfered wireless cell based on radio resource noise measurements of a base station in the most interfered wireless cell.

10. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

receiving a Radio Resource Control (RRC) Connection Setup information from the first wireless cell; and

determining which UEs are associated with the most interfered wireless cell and which UEs are associated with the most interfered radio resource.

11. A controller comprising:

a memory element for storing data; and

a processor to execute instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is configured to;

identify, for a cluster of wireless cells comprising a plurality of wireless cells, a first wireless cell that is a most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells by comparing a hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate to a threshold value;

identify, for a plurality of radio resources available to the first wireless cell, one or more most interfered radio resources of the plurality of radio resources;

identify one or more user equipment (UE) associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources for the first wireless cell;

identify at least one UE associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources for the first wireless cell as a cell edge UE based, at least in part, on at least one of a time adjustment (TA) value and a received signal strength power (RSSP) value associated with the at least one UE;

identify at least one other UE associated with the one or more most interfered radio resources;

determine whether the at least one other UE is one of;

a cell edge UE served by a second wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells, wherein the second wireless cell is not identified in a neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

or

a cell core UE served by a second wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells, wherein the second wireless cell is identified in a neighbor list of the first wireless cell but no inter-cell interference coordination is provided for the cell core UE,

wherein the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell edge UE or a cell core UE based, at least in part, on at least one of a TA value and a RSSP value associated with the at least one other UE;

include the second wireless cell in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell if the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell edge UE for the second wireless cell that is not identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

falsely identify the at least one other UE as a cell edge UE if the at least one other UE is determined to be a cell core UE for the second wireless cell that is identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell;

determine if the first wireless cell remains the most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells by comparing the hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate of the first wireless cell to the threshold value; and

issue an error message based on the determination that the first wireless cell remains the most interfered wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells.

12. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

calculate the hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) success rate for each wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells;

calculate an average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells; and

determine a standard deviation of the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells.

13. The controller of claim 12, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

compare a first HARQ success rate calculated for the first wireless cell to the threshold value, wherein the threshold value comprises the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells minus the standard deviation of the average HARQ success rate for the cluster of wireless cells; and

trigger identification of the first wireless cell based, at least in part, on the first HARQ success rate associated with the first wireless cell being less than the threshold value.

14. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

receive Radio Resource Control (RRC) Connection Setup information associated with the first wireless cell; and

determine whether the second wireless cell is identified in the neighbor list of the first wireless cell based on the RRC Connection Setup information.

15. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

monitor high interference indicator messages transmitted by each wireless cell of the cluster of wireless cells;

record resource allocation information associated with each wireless cell, wherein a radio resource allocation record for a given high interference indicator from a given wireless cell comprises an identity of cell, a timestamp associated with the given high indicator message, and a list of one or more radio resources allocated to one or more cell edge UE served by the wireless cell; and

identify one or more UE associated with the one or most interfered radio resources based further on the high interference indicator messages.

16. The controller of claim 15, wherein the at least one other UE is defined as a cell edge UE based, at least in part, on radio resource allocation information recorded for the second wireless cell.

17. The controller of claim 16, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

send the first wireless cell a high interference indicator message including one or more radio resources associated with the at least one other UE set to indicate that the one or more radio resources are associated with a cell edge UE.

18. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

induce a change in a tilt of an antenna associated with at least one of the first wireless cell and the second wireless cell.

19. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

determine the one or more most interfered radio resource associated with the most interfered wireless cell based on radio resource noise measurements of a base station in the most interfered wireless cell.

20. The controller of claim 11, the processor to execute further instructions associated with the data that, when executed, the controller is further configured to:

receive a Radio Resource Control (RRC) Connection Setup information from the first wireless cell; and

determine which UEs are associated with the most interfered wireless cell and which UEs are associated with the most interfered radio resource.