Techniques for business process driven service oriented architecture (SOA) governance

• US 10,354,212 B2
• Filed: 02/07/2013
• Issued: 07/16/2019
• Est. Priority Date: 02/07/2013
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Software AG
• Original Assignee: Software AG
• Inventors: Vairavan, Shanmugam, Shanmugasundaram, Karthik, Woods, Gary
• Primary Examiner(s): Behncke, Christine M
• Assistant Examiner(s): Divelbiss, Matthew H
• Application Number:
  US13/762,128
• Publication Number:
  US 20140222523A1
• Time in Patent Office: 2,350 Days
• Field of Search: 717104, 707802, 707E17017, 705 711
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/0637 Strategic management or analysis, e.g. setting a goal or target of an organisation; Planning actions based on goals; Analysis or evaluation of effectiveness of goals

Abstract

Certain example embodiments tie the business process governance and Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) governance processes together through the use of Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) and Event Driven Architecture (EDA) based messaging. That is, in certain example embodiments, a BPMN agent integrated into a SOA registry and publish/subscribe agents deployed to the SOA registry and a business process engine are used to bring the business and SOA governances together through an EDA that helps generate relevant messages from a BPMN model representing the various governance mechanisms. Advantageously, a Complex Event Processing (CEP) engine and business analytics modules may provide monitoring and feedback to both parts of the overall architecture.

Claims

1. A joint service oriented architecture (SOA) and business process governance computer system, comprising:

a computer readable storage medium configured to;

store a predefined computer-modeled business process, and

store metadata for a plurality of SOA entities that are separate from, but associated with, the predefined computer-modeled business process;

a processing system that includes at least one hardware processor coupled to the computer readable storage medium, the processing system configured to;

execute business process engine (BPE) computer instructions that coordinate execution of the predefined computer-modeled business process;

manage a SOA registry that is configured to run a governance process to enforce governance on at least the SOA entities that are associated with the predefined computer-modeled business process, wherein (1) execution of the BPE and the predefined computer-modeled business process is outside and separate from management of the SOA registry and the governance process run therein and (2) the SOA registry and the governance process run therein are outside execution of the BPE and the predefined computer-modeled business process;

execute a computer process that is configured to;

(a) receive a document that includes the predefined computer-modeled business process,

(b) extract, from the document, at least one process element of the predefined computer-modeled business process, and

(c) responsive to extraction of the process element from the document, create at least one governance object and publish the at least one governance object to the SOA registry to be included as at least part of the governance process that is executed within the SOA registry;

publish, by using an SOA event emitter that is part of the SOA registry, SOA messages that are based on execution of the governance process within the SOA registry;

subscribe to and receive, within the BPE, at least one of the published SOA messages;

publish, by using a process event emitter that is part of the BPE, process messages that are based on execution of the predefined computer-modeled business process by the BPE;

subscribe to and receive, within the SOA registry, at least one of the published process messages;

automatically execute an action or step that is part of the governance process being executed within the SOA registry based on reception of the at least one of the published process messages; and

execute an analytics application module that is configured to receive and analyze published SOA messages and published process messages.

2. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 1, wherein the processing system is further configured to:

execute a complex event processing (CEP) engine that is configured to receive and analyze SOA events published by the SOA event emitter, as well as process events published by the process event emitter.

3. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 2, wherein the analytics application module and/or the CEP engine is/are configured to generate, and publish, further events based on received events, the generated events including further SOA events or further business process events and the received events including SOA events published by the SOA event emitter or process events published by the process event emitter.

4. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 1, wherein the computer process is included in the SOA registry.

5. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 1, wherein the predefined computer-modeled business process is a Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model.

6. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 5, wherein the BPMN model includes policy, lifecycle management, and/or approval management type governance process elements.

7. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 1, wherein the at least one process element includes at least one policy type governance process element, at least one lifecycle management type governance process element, and at least one approval management type governance process element,

wherein the at least one governance object that is created in response to extraction of the policy type governance process element is a policy entity,

wherein the at least one governance object that is created in response to extraction of the lifecycle management type governance process element is a lifecycle management entity, and

wherein the at least one governance object that is created in response to extraction of the approval management type governance process element is an approval management entity.

8. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 7, wherein:

lifecycle management entities are generatable in the SOA registry as lifecycle object, lifecycle state, and/or lifecycle stage type entities, and

approval management entities are generatable in the SOA registry as approval work flow and/or policy type entities.

9. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 5, wherein the computer process is further configured to convert the extracted governance-related entities to WL-based representations and provide the converted representations to the SOA registry.

10. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 9, wherein the XML-based representations include XPDL elements.

11. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 9, wherein the computer process is further configured to validate at least some of the BPMN model using the XML-based representations.

25. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 1, wherein the processing system is further configured to:

in accordance with execution of the governance process within the SOA registry that includes the triggered action, publish a first SOA message of the SOA messages; and

receive, in the BPE, the first SOA message and continue execution of the predefined computer-modeled business process by the BPE based on contents of the first SOA message.

26. The joint SOA and business process governance computer system of claim 25, wherein the contents of the published first SOA message are based on the execution of the governance process within the SOA registry.

12. A computer system configured to help provide combined service oriented architecture (SOA) and business process governance, the system comprising:

a computer readable electronic storage medium configured to store a predefined modeled business process definition;

hardware processing resources that include at least one hardware processor coupled to the computer readable electronic storage medium, the hardware processing resources configured to;

execute business process engine (BPE) computer instructions that coordinate execution of a business process within the BPE that corresponds to the predefined modeled business process definition,

receiving a document specifying the predefined modeled business process definition that includes at least one governance process element that is used to enforce governance on SOA entities stored in a SOA registry or the business process that leverages the SOA entities, the at least one governance process element object being a policy, lifecycle management, or approval management type governance process element,

extract, from the document, the at least one governance process element,

based on extraction of the at least one governance process element from the document, create at least one SOA governance object,

deploy the at least one SOA governance object to the SOA registry to be included as at least part of a governance process that is executed within the SOA registry, wherein (1) execution of the BPE and the business process within the BPE is outside and separate from management of the SOA registry and the governance process executed within the SOA registry and (2) the SOA registry and the governance process executed therein are outside execution of the BPE and the business process within the BPE,

publish, by using a process event emitter that is part of the BPE, process messages that are based on how the business process is run within the BPE,

subscribe to and receive, within the SOA registry, at least one of the published process messages, and

trigger an action or step that is part of the governance process being executed within the SOA registry based on reception of the at least one of the published process messages.

13. The system of claim 12, wherein the hardware processing resources are further configured to execute a web service that is configured to at least receive the document and extract the at least one governance process element.

14. The system of claim 12,

wherein the at least one process governance element includes at least one policy type governance process element, at least one lifecycle management type governance process element, and at least one approval management type governance process element,

wherein the at least one SOA governance object that is created based on extraction of the policy type governance process element is a policy entity,

wherein the at least one SOA governance object that is created based on extraction of the lifecycle management type governance process element is a lifecycle management entity, and

wherein the at least one SOA governance object that is created based on extraction of the approval management type governance process element is an approval management.

15. The system of claim 14, wherein:

lifecycle management entities are generated as lifecycle object, lifecycle state, and/or lifecycle stage type entities, and

approval management entities are generated as approval work flow and/or policy type entities.

16. The system of claim 12, wherein the document includes a Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model that represents at least some of the business process run within the BPE.

17. The system of claim 16, wherein the hardware processing resources are further configured to convert the document to an XML-based representation of the BPMN model.

18. The system of claim 17, wherein the hardware processing resources are further configured to validate at least some of the BPMN model using the XML-based representation.

19. A service oriented architecture (SOA) system, comprising:

computer readable electronic storage configured to store;

a predefined modeled business process definition;

store metadata for a plurality of SOA entities that are separate from, but associated with, the predefined computer-modeled business process definition;

at least one hardware processor coupled to the computer readable electronic storage, the at least one hardware processor configured to;

execute business process engine (BPE) computer instructions that coordinate execution of the predefined modeled business process definition;

manage a SOA registry that is configured to run a governance process to enforce governance on at least the SOA entities that are associated with the predefined computer-modeled business process executable by a business process engine (BPE), wherein (1) execution of the BPE and the predefined modeled business process is outside and separate from management of the SOA registry and the governance process run therein and (2) the SOA registry and the governance process run therein are outside execution of the BPE and the predefined modeled business process;

execute a computer process that is configured to;

(a) receive a document that includes the predefined computer-modeled business process definition,

b) extract, from the document, at least one process element of the predefined computer-modeled business process definition, and

(c) responsive to extraction of the process element from the document, create at least one governance object and publish the at least one governance object to the SOA registry to be included as at least part of the governance process that is run within the SOA registry;

publish, by using an event-driven architecture (EDA) based SOA event emitter, SOA messages that are based on how the SOA registry has run the governance process within the SOA registry;

receive, via a process event subscriber, at least one process message that has been published by a process event emitter that is part of the BPE; and

trigger an action or step that is part of the governance process being run within the SOA registry based on reception of the at least one of the process messages, the action or step enforcing governance by using enabled ones of the at least one governance object.

20. The system of claim 19, further comprising:

a first connection to an analytics application over which subscribed to first events are receivable, the first events including at least one of SOA events and process events; and

a second connection to a complex event processing (CEP) engine over which subscribed to second events are receivable, the second events including at least one of SOA events and process events.

21. A method of providing combined service oriented architecture (SOA) and business process governance on a computer system that includes at least one hardware processor and electronic storage that is electronically accessible by the one hardware processor, the electronic storage storing a Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model file, the method comprising:

providing, by using the at least one hardware processor, a SOA registry that is configured to run a governance process to enforce governance on SOA entities that are associated with the BPMN model in the file;

receiving, via a computer service that is being executed by at least one hardware processor, the Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model file that specifies at least one governance-related process element to be enforced on (a) Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) entities stored in a SOA registry and/or (b) a business process leveraging the SOA entities that is run within a business process engine (BPE), wherein (1) execution of the BPE and the business process of the BPMN model file by the BPE is outside and separate from the SOA registry and the governance process run therein and (2) the SOA registry and the governance process run therein are outside execution of the BPE and the business process run within the BPE;

automatically extracting the at least one governance-related process element from the BPMN model file;

responsive to extraction of the at least one governance-related process element, creating at least one governance object based on the extracted at least one governance-related process element;

responsive to the creation of the at least one governance object, validating each said created at least one governance object;

publishing, in connection with at least one hardware processor, each said validated governance object to the SOA registry;

activating, within the SOA registry, the at least one published governance object;

publishing, by using an SOA event emitter that is part of the provided SOA registry, SOA messages that are based on running of the governance process by the SOA registry;

receiving, within the SOA registry, process messages that have been published based on execution of the business process by the BPE;

triggering an action or step that is part of the governance process being run within the SOA registry based on reception of the at least one of the published process messages, wherein the action or step is related to policy, lifecycle management, and/or approval management type governance tasks of the governance process.

22. The method of claim 21, wherein the SOA event emitter is an event-driven architecture (EDA) based SOA event emitter.

24. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 22, wherein the SOA event emitter is an event-driven architecture (EDA) based SOA event emitter.

23. A non-transitory computer readable storage medium tangibly storing instructions for use with a computer system that includes at least one hardware processor and electronic storage that is accessible by the at least one hardware processor, the electronic storage storing a Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model and metadata for a plurality of Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) entities that are separate from, but associated with, a business process of the BPMN model, the computer system managing a SOA registry that is configured to run a governance process to enforce governance on the SOA entities that are associated with the Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model, the instructions comprising instructions that cause the computer system to:

receive, via a computer service that is being executed by at least one hardware processor, a model file that includes the Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN) model that specifies at least one governance-related process element to be enforced on (a) the (SOA) entities and/or (b) the business process leveraging the SOA entities that is run within a business process engine (BPE), wherein (1) execution of the BPE and the business process run within the BPE is outside and separate from the computer systems management of SOA registry and the governance process run therein and (2) the SOA registry and the governance process run therein are outside execution of the BPE and the business process run within the BPE;

automatically extract the at least one governance-related process element from the BPMN model file;

responsive to extraction of the at least one governance-related process element, create at least one governance object based on the extracted at least one governance-related process element;

validate each said created at least one governance object;

publish, in connection with at least one hardware processor, each said validated governance object to the SOA registry;

activate, within the SOA registry, the at least one published governance object;

publish, by using an SOA event emitter that is part of the provided SOA registry, SOA messages that are based on running of the governance process by the SOA registry;

receive, within the SOA registry, process messages that have been published based on execution of the business process by the BPE;

trigger an action or step that is part of the governance process being run within the SOA registry based on reception of the at least one of the published process messages, wherein the action or step is related to policy, lifecycle management, and/or approval management type governance tasks of the governance process.