Refining of applicability rules of management activities according to missing fulfilments thereof

• US 10,389,593 B2
• Filed: 02/06/2017
• Issued: 08/20/2019
• Est. Priority Date: 02/06/2017
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Original Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Inventors: Crudele, Michele, Gangemi, Rosario, Perrone, Antonio
• Primary Examiner(s): Coby, Frantz
• Application Number:
  US15/425,497
• Publication Number:
  US 20180227183A1
• Time in Patent Office: 925 Days
• Field of Search: 709223, 709225, 709224
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0661 by reconfiguring faulty entities
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0816 the condition being an adaptation, e.g. in response to network events
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0823 characterised by the purposes of a change of settings, e.g. optimising configuration for enhancing reliability for optimising operational conditions of wireless networks H04W24/02
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0893 Assignment of logical groups to network elements
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0894 Policy-based network configuration management

Abstract

A mechanism is provided for managing a plurality of computing machines. An indication of a management activity having an applicability rule is deployed to a plurality of computing machines to cause each of the plurality of computing machines having corresponding values of one or more characteristics fulfilling the applicability rule to apply the management activity. Results are received indicating that the management activity has been applied successfully on corresponding success computing machines and that the management activity has not been applied on corresponding excluded computing machines. One or more candidate computing machines of the excluded computing machines is selected according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the further characteristics of the excluded computing machines with a success fingerprint. An indication of rule transformations and corresponding frequencies for use in transforming the applicability rule accordingly to a number of the candidate computing machines is then provided.

Claims

1. A method for managing a plurality of computing machines, the method comprising:

deploying an indication of a management activity having an applicability rule to the plurality of computing machines to cause each of the computing machines having corresponding values of one or more characteristics fulfilling the applicability rule to apply the management activity on the computing machine;

receiving corresponding results of the deploying of the management activity to each computing machine of the plurality of computing machines, the results indicating that the management activity has been applied successfully on corresponding success computing machines of the plurality of computing machines and that the management activity has not been applied on corresponding excluded computing machines of the plurality of computing machines;

determining a success fingerprint according to corresponding values of one or more further characteristics of at least part of the success computing machines;

selecting one or more candidate computing machines of the excluded computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machines with the success fingerprint;

determining one or more rule transformations and frequencies of the rule transformations for the candidate computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the characteristics of the candidate computing machines with the applicability rule, each of the one or more rule transformations being adapted to make the applicability rule fulfilled by a number of the one or more candidate computing machines defining the corresponding frequency; and

providing an indication of the rule transformations and of the corresponding frequencies for use in transforming the applicability rule accordingly.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein selecting the one or more candidate computing machines comprises:

calculating corresponding similarity indexes of the excluded computing machines, the similarity index of each of the excluded computing machines being calculated according to a comparison of the values of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machine with the success fingerprint; and

selecting the candidate computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding similarity indexes with a similarity threshold.

3. The method according to claim 2, wherein calculating the corresponding similarity indexes comprises:

calculating the similarity index of each of the excluded computing machines by combining one or more similarity components each for a matching further characteristic of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machine comprised in the success fingerprint and having the corresponding value in the excluded computing machine matching the corresponding value in the success fingerprint.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein calculating the similarity index comprises:

calculating the similarity index by combining the similarity components to contribute to the similarity index each with a weight decreasing with a cardinality of the value of the corresponding matching further characteristic in the success fingerprint.

5. The method according to claim 4, wherein calculating the similarity index comprises:

calculating the similarity index by combining the similarity components to contribute to the similarity index each with the corresponding weight decreasing exponentially with the cardinality of the value of the corresponding matching further characteristic in the success fingerprint.

6. The method according to claim 2, wherein selecting the one or more candidate computing machines comprises:

calculating the similarity threshold according to a maximum value of the similarity indexes corresponding to the success computing machines.

7. The method according to claim 1, wherein determining the success fingerprint comprises:

determining the success fingerprint by assigning each common further characteristic of the one or more further characteristics of the at least part of the success computing machines to the success fingerprint in association with a union of the values of the common further characteristic of the at least part of the success computing machines.

8. The method according to claim 1, wherein determining the success fingerprint comprises:

determining the success fingerprint according to the corresponding values of the one or more further characteristics of a subset of the success computing machines.

9. The method according to claim 1, wherein the applicability rule comprises one or more applicability conditions contributing to define the applicability rule and wherein determining the one or more rule transformations comprises:

for each of the applicability conditions based on at least one of the characteristics that is not available in at least one of the candidate computing machines, determining one of the rule transformations by removing the applicability condition from the applicability rule.

10. The method according to claim 1, wherein the applicability rule comprises one or more applicability conditions contributing to define the applicability rule and wherein determining the one or more rule transformations comprises:

for each of the applicability conditions based on at least one of the characteristics that is not fulfilled by the corresponding values in at least one of the candidate computing machines, determining one of the rule transformations by relaxing the applicability condition to become fulfilled by the corresponding values in the at least one candidate computing machine.

11. The method according to claim 1, wherein providing the indication of the rule transformations and of the corresponding frequencies comprises:

outputting the indication of the rule transformations and of the corresponding frequencies.

12. The method according to claim 1, wherein deploying the indication of a management activity comprises:

deploying a management policy comprising the applicability rule and instructions for executing the management activity to cause each of the computing machines to enforce the management policy thereon.

13. A computer program product comprising a computer readable storage medium having a computer readable program for managing a plurality of computing machines stored therein, wherein the computer readable program, when executed on a computing device, causes the computing device to:

deploy an indication of a management activity having an applicability rule to the plurality of computing machines to cause each of the computing machines having corresponding values of one or more characteristics fulfilling the applicability rule to apply the management activity on the computing machine;

receive corresponding results of the deploying of the management activity to each computing machine of the plurality of computing machines, the results indicating that the management activity has been applied successfully on corresponding success computing machines of the plurality of computing machines and that the management activity has not been applied on corresponding excluded computing machines of the plurality of computing machines;

determine a success fingerprint according to corresponding values of one or more further characteristics of at least part of the success computing machines;

select one or more candidate computing machines of the excluded computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machines with the success fingerprint;

determine one or more rule transformations and frequencies of the rule transformations for the candidate computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the characteristics of the candidate computing machines with the applicability rule, each of the one or more rule transformations being adapted to make the applicability rule fulfilled by a number of the one or more candidate computing machines defining the corresponding frequency; and

provide an indication of the rule transformations and of the corresponding frequencies for use in transforming the applicability rule accordingly.

14. The computer program product according to claim 13, wherein the computer readable program to select the one or more candidate computing machines further causes the computing device to:

calculate corresponding similarity indexes of the excluded computing machines, the similarity index of each of the excluded computing machines being calculated according to a comparison of the values of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machine with the success fingerprint; and

select the candidate computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding similarity indexes with a similarity threshold.

15. The computer program product according to claim 14, wherein the computer readable program to calculate the corresponding similarity indexes further causes the computing device to:

calculate the similarity index of each of the excluded computing machines by combining one or more similarity components each for a matching further characteristic of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machine comprised in the success fingerprint and having the corresponding value in the excluded computing machine matching the corresponding value in the success fingerprint.

16. The computer program product according to claim 15, wherein the computer readable program to calculate the similarity index further causes the computing device to:

calculate the similarity index by combining the similarity components to contribute to the similarity index each with a weight decreasing with a cardinality of the value of the corresponding matching further characteristic in the success fingerprint.

17. The computer program product according to claim 16, wherein the computer readable program to calculate the similarity index further causes the computing device to:

calculate the similarity index by combining the similarity components to contribute to the similarity index each with the corresponding weight decreasing exponentially with the cardinality of the value of the corresponding matching further characteristic in the success fingerprint.

18. The computer program product according to claim 14, wherein the computer readable program to select the one or more candidate computing machines further causes the computing device to:

calculate the similarity threshold according to a maximum value of the similarity indexes corresponding to the success computing machines.

19. The computer program product according to claim 13, wherein the computer readable program to determine the success fingerprint further causes the computing device to:

determine the success fingerprint by assigning each common further characteristic of the one or more further characteristics of the at least part of the success computing machines to the success fingerprint in association with a union of the values of the common further characteristic of the at least part of the success computing machines.

20. An apparatus comprising:

a processor, and

a memory coupled to the processor, wherein the memory comprises instructions which, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to;

deploy an indication of a management activity having an applicability rule to the plurality of computing machines to cause each of the computing machines having corresponding values of one or more characteristics fulfilling the applicability rule to apply the management activity on the computing machine;

receive corresponding results of the deploying of the management activity to each computing machine of the plurality of computing machines, the results indicating that the management activity has been applied successfully on corresponding success computing machines of the plurality of computing machines and that the management activity has not been applied on corresponding excluded computing machines of the plurality of computing machines;

determine a success fingerprint according to corresponding values of one or more further characteristics of at least part of the success computing machines;

select one or more candidate computing machines of the excluded computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the one or more further characteristics of the excluded computing machines with the success fingerprint;

determine one or more rule transformations and frequencies of the rule transformations for the candidate computing machines according to a comparison of the corresponding values of the characteristics of the candidate computing machines with the applicability rule, each of the one or more rule transformations being adapted to make the applicability rule fulfilled by a number of the one or more candidate computing machines defining the corresponding frequency; and

provide an indication of the rule transformations and of the corresponding frequencies for use in transforming the applicability rule accordingly.