Method for allocating radio resources in a communication system using non-GSO satellites with interference level constraint to a geostationary system

• US 10,390,351 B2
• Filed: 12/13/2016
• Issued: 08/20/2019
• Est. Priority Date: 12/18/2015
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Thales SA
• Original Assignee: Thales SA
• Inventors: Faraj, Zakariya, Chuberre, Nicolas
• Primary Examiner(s): Renner, Brandon M
• Application Number:
  US15/377,872
• Publication Number:
  US 20170181173A1
• Time in Patent Office: 980 Days
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/18513 Transmission in a satellite or space-based system
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/19 Earth-synchronous stations
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/195 Non-synchronous stations
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 52/243 taking into account interferences
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 72/541 using the level of interference
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 84/06 Airborne or Satellite Networks space-based or airborne stations H04B7/185

Abstract

A method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications in a first communication system comprising a constellation of non-GSO satellites and a first set of terminals, the method comprises the following steps, for each terminal of the first set: determining a distinct separation angle threshold to be observed with respect to a constellation of geostationary satellites, a separation angle being defined as the smallest topocentric angle by which a given non-GSO satellite and any geostationary satellite of the geostationary arc are seen from a given terminal of the first set, authorizing the terminal to set up a communication link with a non-GSO satellite if the separation angle associated with the link is greater than or equal to the separation angle threshold.

Claims

1. A method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications in a first communication system comprising a constellation of non-geostationary (non-GSO) satellites and a first set of terminals, the method comprising the following steps, for each terminal of the first set of terminals:

determining a distinct separation angle threshold to be observed with respect to a constellation of geostationary satellites, a separation angle being defined as the smallest topocentric angle by which a given non-GSO satellite and any geostationary satellite of the geostationary arc are seen from a given terminal of the first set of terminals,

authorising the terminal to set up a communication link with a non-GSO satellite if the separation angle associated with said link is greater than or equal to the separation angle threshold,

wherein determining a distinct separation angle threshold for each terminal comprises;

computing at least one interfering power level generated by the set of communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites towards a geostationary satellite communication system, the interfering power level being a function of all distinct separation angle thresholds of all terminals of the first set, and

iteratively selecting, independently for each terminal of the first set of terminals, a minimum value of the distinct separation angle threshold to be observed by the terminal such that said at least one computed interfering power level remains in accordance with a regulatory limit.

2. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 1, wherein the distinct separation angle threshold to be observed for each terminal of the first set of terminals is determined in such a way that all authorised communication links generate together, on a geostationary satellite communication system, an interfering power level conforming to a regulatory limit.

3. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 1, wherein the determination of a separation angle threshold comprises an initialisation phase comprising assigning an initial value to the separation angle threshold, for each terminal, and declaring each terminal a candidate for the lowering of its separation angle threshold.

4. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 3, wherein said iterative search comprises, for each terminal and on each iteration, the association of said terminal with a non-GSO satellite observing the separation angle threshold determined on the current iteration and wherein the separation angle is closest to said threshold, the iterations being continued as long as at least one terminal is a candidate for the lowering of its separation angle threshold.

5. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 4, wherein the communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites are two-way or one-way uplinks and said iterative search comprises the computation of a first interfering power level generated by the set of communication uplinks to the geostationary arc for a set of assumed positions of geostationary satellites.

6. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 5, wherein the computation of said first interfering power level is determined by choosing, for each geostationary satellite, a pointing direction which makes it possible to maximize the value of said first interfering power level.

7. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 5, wherein said iterative search comprises the search for at least one geostationary satellite for which the first computed interfering power level is not in accordance with said regulatory limit.

8. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 4, wherein the communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites are one-way down links and said iterative search comprises the computation of a second interfering power level generated by the set of downlink communication to a set of assumed positions of terminals belonging to a geostationary satellite communication system.

9. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 5, wherein the communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites are two-way and said iterative search comprises the computation of a second interfering power level generated by the set of downlink communication to a set of assumed positions of terminals belonging to a geostationary satellite communication system.

10. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 8, wherein the computation of said second interfering power level is determined by choosing, for each terminal belonging to a geostationary satellite communication system, a pointing direction which makes it possible to maximize the value of said second interfering power level.

11. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 8, wherein said iterative search comprises the search for at least one terminal belonging to a geostationary satellite communication system for which the second computed interfering power level is not in accordance with said regulatory threshold.

12. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 8, wherein said iterative search comprises, for each first or second computed interfering power level not in accordance with said regulatory threshold, the search for at least one pair (terminal of the first set of terminals, non-GSO satellite) whose contribution, in the value of the first or the second interfering power level, is highest.

13. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 12, wherein said iterative search comprises, for each terminal of the pair (terminal of the first set of terminals, non-GSO satellite) retained, the re-establishment of the separation angle threshold determined on the preceding iteration and the removal of said terminal from the list of the candidates for the lowering of the separation angle threshold.

14. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 12, wherein said iterative search comprises, for at least one terminal of the pair (terminal of the first set of terminals, non-GSO satellite) retained, the adaptation of the RF characteristics of at least one link involving said terminal and a non-GSO satellite, so as to reduce the interfering power level of the set of authorised communication links on a geostationary satellite communication system.

15. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 5, wherein the iterative search comprises a check of the conformity of the first interfering power level and/or of the second interfering power level and, if the conformity is checked, the lowering of the separation angle threshold by a predetermined value, for each terminal that is a candidate for the lowering of its separation angle threshold.

16. The method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications of claim 3, wherein the iterative search is stopped when there is no longer any terminal that is a candidate for the lowering of its separation angle threshold.

17. A device for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications comprising means, including at least one processor and one memory, configured to implement a method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications in a first communication system comprising a constellation of non-geostationary (non-GSO) satellites and a first set of terminals, the method comprising the following steps, for each terminal of the first set of terminals:

determining a distinct separation angle threshold to be observed with respect to a constellation of geostationary satellites, a separation angle being defined as the smallest topocentric angle by which a given non-GSO satellite and any geostationary satellite of the geostationary arc are seen from a given terminal of the first set of terminals,

authorising the terminal to set up a communication link with a non-GSO satellite if the separation angle associated with said link is greater than or equal to the separation angle threshold,

wherein determining the distinct separation angle threshold for each terminal comprises;

computing at least one interfering power level generated by the set of communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites towards a geostationary satellite communication system, the interfering power level being a function of all distinct separation angle thresholds of all terminals of the first set, and

iteratively selecting, independently for each terminal of the first set of terminals, a minimum value of the distinct separation angle threshold to be observed by the terminal such that said at least one computed interfering power level remains in accordance with a regulatory limit.

18. A computer program comprising instructions stored on a tangible non-transitory storage medium for executing on a processor a method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications in a first communication system comprising a constellation of non-geostationary (non-GSO) satellites and a first set of terminals, the method comprising the following steps, for each terminal of the first set of terminals:

determining a distinct separation angle threshold to be observed with respect to a constellation of geostationary satellites, a separation angle being defined as the smallest topocentric angle by which a given non-GSO satellite and any geostationary satellite of the geostationary arc are seen from a given terminal of the first set of terminals,

authorising the terminal to set up a communication link with a non-GSO satellite if the separation angle associated with said link is greater than or equal to the separation angle threshold,

wherein determining the distinct separation angle threshold for each terminal comprises;

computing at least one interfering power level generated by the set of communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites towards a geostationary satellite communication system, the interfering power level being a function of all distinct separation angle thresholds of all terminals of the first set, and

iteratively selecting, independently for each terminal of the first set of terminals, a minimum value of the distinct separation angle threshold to be observed by the terminal such that said at least one computed interfering power level remains in accordance with a regulatory limit.

19. A tangible non-transitory processor-readable recording medium on which is recorded a program comprising instructions for executing a method for allocating radio resources for setting up satellite communications in a first communication system comprising a constellation of non-GSO satellites and a first set of terminals, the method comprising the following steps, for each terminal of the first set of terminals:

determining a distinct separation angle threshold to be observed with respect to a constellation of geostationary satellites, a separation angle being defined as the smallest topocentric angle by which a given non-geostationary (non-GSO) satellite and any geostationary satellite of the geostationary arc are seen from a given terminal of the first set of terminals,

authorising the terminal to set up a communication link with a non-GSO satellite if the separation angle associated with said link is greater than or equal to the separation angle threshold,

wherein determining the distinct separation angle threshold for each terminal comprises;

computing at least one interfering power level generated by the set of communication links between the terminals of the first set of terminals and the non-GSO satellites towards a geostationary satellite communication system, the interfering power level being a function of all distinct separation angle thresholds of all terminals of the first set, and

iteratively selecting, independently for each terminal of the first set of terminals, a minimum value of the distinct separation angle threshold to be observed by the terminal such that said at least one computed interfering power level remains in accordance with a regulatory limit.