Method and apparatus for normalization and deconvolution of assay data

• US 20030139886A1
• Filed: 09/05/2002
• Published: 07/24/2003
• Est. Priority Date: 09/05/2001
• Status: Abandoned Application

• Current Assignee: Life Technologies Corporation (Thermo Fisher Scientific Incorporated)
• Original Assignee: Life Technologies Corporation (Thermo Fisher Scientific Incorporated)
• Inventors: Warden, Laurence, Anderson, Richard R., Yguerabide, Juan, Rhodes, Kate, Bodzin, Leon J.
• Application Number:
  US10/236,169
• Publication Number:
  US 20030139886A1
• Time in Patent Office: Days
• US Class Current: 702/28
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 15/0205 by optical means
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 15/1433 using image recognition
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 15/1475 using image analysis for extracting features of the particle
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2015/1472 with colour
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2021/4764 Special kinds of physical applications
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2021/6421 Measuring at two or more wavelengths
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2021/6441 with two or more labels
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 21/47 Scattering, i.e. diffuse reflection G01N21/25, G01N21/41 take precedence G01N21/55 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 21/49 within a body or fluid
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 21/554 detecting the surface plasmon resonance of nanostructured metals, e.g. localised surface plasmon resonance
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/54346 Nanoparticles
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/58 involving labelled substances G01N33/53 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/6803 General methods of protein analysis not limited to specific proteins or families of proteins

Abstract

The present invention is directed to deconvolution and normalization of assay data. The present invention includes a control and analysis system, used in conjunction with a signal generation and detection apparatus, for capturing, processing and analyzing images of samples having resonance light scattering (RLS) particle labels. The control and analysis system processes instructions and algorithms for performing multiplexed assays of two or more colors, for example, to allow separation and analysis of detected light that contains information from two or more different types or sizes of RLS particles. The multiplexing analysis software is preferably incorporated within the system of the present invention, and the multiplexing analysis is preferably performed in real-time during a scanning or assay procedure. The invention provides for a computer readable medium containing instructions for carrying out the same.

Claims

1. An assay system, comprising:

at least one type of light scattering particles configured to be bound to an analyte of interest in a sample; and

a scattered light detector configured to analyze analytes in the sample based on detected scattered light of at least first and second colors from the sample.

2. The assay system of claim 1, wherein the scattered light detector comprises:

a sample holder configured to hold and position a sample containing the sample;

an illumination system providing light to the sample;

a light detector positioned with respect to the sample holder to detect scattered light in response to light provided by the illumination system; and

an analyzer communicating with the light detector to analyze the analytes in the sample based on the detected light of the at least first and second colors.

3. The assay system of claim 2, wherein said analyzer comprises at least one processor and a memory, wherein said processor is configured to:

accept spectral intensity data from a sample, wherein said spectral intensity data comprises signals from at least two types of light scattering particles, and wherein a first particle binds to a first analyte and a second particle binds to a second analyte;

convert said spectral intensity data, using multi-spectral deconvolution, into a first intensity that corresponds to an abundance of said first particle, and a second intensity that corresponds to an abundance of said second particle; and

quantify said first analyte from said first intensity and quantify said second analyte from said second intensity.

4. The assay system of claim 3, wherein said multi-spectral deconvolution comprises using a first reference spectrum of a pure sample of said first particle, and a second reference spectrum of a pure sample of said second particle.

5. The assay system of claim 3, wherein said spectral intensity data is unmixed into amounts of said first reference spectrum and said second reference spectrum that are in proportion to, respectively, the abundance of said first particle, and the abundance of said second particle.

6. The assay system of claim 3 wherein said sample is in an array.

7. The assay system of claim 3, wherein said spectral values are corrected for spectral properties of the illumination and detection system.

8. The assay system of claim 6, wherein a spectral value for said sample comprises a linear sum of spectral values from said first and second particle types.

9. The assay system of claim 2 wherein said illumination system is a tunable light source.

10. The assay system of claim 9 wherein said tunable light source comprises one or more LED'"'"'s that together emit light of at least two different colors.

11. The assay system of claim 2 wherein said illumination system comprises a broad-band light source in conjunction with at least two individually selectable spectrally discriminative light filters.

12. The assay system of claim 11 further comprising an illumination path between said illumination system and said sample holder, and a detection path between said sample holder and said detector, wherein said at least two individually selectable spectrally discriminative light filters are placed in one or more of the illumination path and the detection path.

13. The assay system of claim 2 wherein said illumination system comprises a broad-band light source in conjunction with a tunable LCD spectrally discriminative light filter.

14. The assay system of claim 13 further comprising an illumination path between said illumination system and said sample holder, and a detection path between said sample holder and said detector, wherein said tunable LCD spectrally discriminative light filter is placed in one or more of the illumination path and the detection path.

15. The assay system of claim 6 wherein said array is a microarray.

16. The assay system of claim 2, wherein said light detector is selected from the group consisting of:

an objective lens microscope with a magnification from 0.5 to 500 times, confocal lens, and a photodetector.

17. The assay system of claim 16 wherein said photodetector is at least one detector selected from the group consisting of:

photodiode, photomultiplier tube, photodiode array, charge coupled device, complementary metal oxide semiconductor, and a charge induction device.

18. The assay system of claim 1, wherein said light scattering particles comprises particles of a first type and particles of a second type producing said first and second colors, respectively.

19. The assay system of claim 18, wherein said two types of particles are configured to be bound to different analytes of interest.

20. The system of claim 1, wherein:

said at least one type of particles produce scattered light of at least the first color; and

said scattered light of at least the second color is produced by light scattering background sources.

21. The assay system of claim 20 wherein a first spectral profile of scattered light from said particles differs from a second spectral profile of scattered light from said background sources.

22. The assay system of claim 21 wherein the difference between said first and second spectral profiles is used to reduce background signal contribution.

23. The assay system of claim 18 wherein said particles of a first type are gold particles.

24. The assay system of claim 23 wherein said gold particles are about 80 nm in diameter.

25. The assay system of claim 18 wherein said particles of a second type are silver particles.

26. The assay system of claim 25 wherein said silver particles are about 60 nm in diameter.

27. The assay system of claim 18 wherein a first spectral profile of scattered light from said particles of a first type differs from a second spectral profile of scattered light from said particles of a second type.

28. The assay system of claim 27 wherein said first spectral profile has a first peak wavelength, and said second spectral profile has a second peak wavelength at a different wavelength from said first peak wavelength.

29. The assay system of claim 28 wherein said first peak wavelength differs from said second peak wavelength by at least 100 nm.

30. The assay system of claim 2, wherein said analyzer is configured to quantify at least one analyte through particle counting.

31. The assay system of claim 2, wherein said analyzer is configured to quantify at least one analyte through integrated light intensity measurement.

32. The assay system of claim 2, wherein said analyzer is configured to quantify at least one analyte through particle counting and at least one analyte through integrated intensity measurement.

33. An apparatus for quantifying at least two types of analytes in an assay, said apparatus comprising at least one processor and a memory, wherein said processor is configured to:

accept spectral intensity data from a sample, wherein said spectral intensity data comprises signals from at least two types of light scattering particle, and wherein a first particle binds to a first analyte and a second particle binds to a second analyte;

convert said spectral intensity data, using multi-spectral deconvolution, into a first intensity that corresponds to an abundance of said first label, and a second intensity that corresponds to an abundance of said second label; and

quantify said first analyte from said first intensity and a concentration of said second analyte from said second intensity.

34. An apparatus of claim 33 wherein said processor is additionally configured to use multi-spectral deconvolution to remove a background signal that is not due to a light scattering particle, from a signal due to an light scattering particle.

35. An apparatus of claim 33 wherein said spectral intensity data is obtained using the defined isosbestic filter to improve the abundance to intensity conversion.

36. An apparatus of claim 33 wherein spectral differences are a function of properties of the illumination and detection system.

37. An apparatus of claim 33 wherein the multi-spectral deconvolution comprises using a first reference spectrum of a pure sample of said first particle, and a second reference spectrum of a pure sample of said second particle.

38. An analyzer for quantifying at least two types of analytes in multiplexed assays, comprising at least one processor and a memory, wherein said processor is configured to:

accept spectral image data from a sample that includes two or more spectrally selective images, wherein said spectral image data is comprised of signals from two labels and wherein a first label binds to a first analyte and a second label binds to a second analyte;

convert said two or more spectrally selective images into individual images that either contain only said first label or contain only said second label, using multispectral deconvolution; and

quantify said first analyte by means of particle counting from said individual images that contain only said first label, and said second analyte by means of particle counting from said individual images that contain only said second label.

39. A method for normalizing assay data, comprising:

selecting a first population of assay data and a second population of assay data, wherein said first population comprises a dependent set of controls and said second population comprises an independent set of controls;

obtaining a linear relationship between said independent set of controls and said dependent set of controls; and

applying said linear relationship to said first population, thereby producing normalized assay data.

40. The method of claim 39 wherein said first set of controls and said second set of controls comprise spots in an array.

41. The method of claim 39 wherein said first set of controls and said second set of controls are treated as equivalent.

42. The method of claim 39 wherein said linear relationship has a slope, m, and an intercept, b.

43. The method of claim 39 wherein said obtaining comprises applying linear regression to said controls, wherein assay data for said first set of controls is treated as a dependent variable and assay data for said second set of controls is treated as an independent variable.

44. The method of claim 43, further comprising applying the linear relationship with slope m, and intercept b, to said dependent set of controls, thereby producing a transformed set of controls that, when plotted against the independent control set, results in a straight line that has a slope equal to one and an intercept equal to zero.

45. The method of claim 43 wherein said applying comprises producing a normalized set of assay data from said assay data for said first population, wherein a value, y′

in said normalized set is obtained from a value, y, in said first population of assay data by the formula y′

=(y−

b)/m.

46. The method of claim 39 wherein said assay data comprises microarray data.

47. The method of claim 46 wherein said first set of controls is disposed on a first microarray and said second set of controls is disposed on a second microarray.

48. The method of claim 46 wherein said first set of controls and said second set of controls are both disposed on the same microarray.

49. The method of claim 46 wherein said first set of controls comprises a first plurality of features, and said second set of controls comprises a second plurality of features such that each feature in said first plurality of features is subject to equivalent experimental conditions to a replicate feature in said second plurality of features.

50. The method of claim 39, wherein said assay data comprises measurements of intensity of light scattered from light scattering particles.

51. The method of claim 39, wherein said assay data comprises measurements of intensity of light emitted by fluorescent labels.

63. The method of claim 39, further comprising displaying said normalized microarray data in a visual format.

52. A method of ratiometric analysis, performed on assay data that comprises an array of features, said method comprising:

selecting a first population of assay data and a second population of assay data, wherein said first population comprises a dependent set of controls and said second population comprises an independent set of controls;

obtaining a linear relationship between said independent set of controls and said dependent set of controls; and

applying said linear relationship to said first population of assay data, thereby producing a first normalized assay data;

obtaining a second linear relationship between said second set of controls and said first set of controls, wherein said first set of controls is treated as an independent variable, and said second set of controls is treated as a dependent variable in said linear relationship.

applying said second linear relationship to said second population of assay data, thereby producing a second normalized assay data;

calculating a ratio of a value of said feature in said normalized assay data to a value of said feature in said second normalized assay data; and

identifying said feature as regulated if said ratio exceeds a threshold value.

53. The method of claim 52 additionally comprising repeating said calculating for one or more other features.

54. The method of claim 52 wherein said threshold value is 2:

1.

55. A method of identifying at least one anomalous feature in assay data, wherein said assay data comprises an array of features, said method comprising:

dividing the assay data into a first population and a second population, wherein said first population comprises a first set of controls and said second population comprises a second set of controls;

obtaining a first linear relationship between said first set of controls and said second set of controls, including setting one set of controls as a dependent variable and the other set of controls as an independent variable;

obtaining a second linear relationship between said second set of controls and said first set of controls, wherein the control set that is treated as the dependent variable in obtaining said first linear relationship is treated as an independent variable in obtaining said second linear relationship;

applying said first linear relationship to said first population, thereby producing a first normalized assay data;

applying said second linear relationship to said second population, thereby producing a second normalized assay data; and

calculating a first ratio of a value of said feature in said first normalized assay data to a value of said feature in said second normalized assay data; and

calculating a second ratio of a value of said feature in said second normalized assay data to a value of said feature in said first normalized assay data; and

multiplying said first ratio by a reciprocal of said second ratio to produce a product;

identifying said feature as anomalous if said product exceeds a threshold value.

56. The method of claim 55 additionally comprising repeating said calculating and said multiplying for one or more other features.

57. The method of claim 55 wherein said threshold is 3.0.

58. The method of claim 55 wherein said assay data comprises gene expression data and said anomalous feature indicates a difference in level of gene expression between first and second data.

59. The method of claim 55 wherein said assay data comes from a microarray, and said anomalous feature derives from a defect or artifact in said microarray.

60. A method for comparing a first set of assay data to a second set of assay data, comprising:

identifying a first set of controls in said first set of assay data and a second set of controls in said second set of data, wherein said first set of controls and said second set of controls are treated a equivalent;

obtaining a linear relationship between said first set of controls and said second set of controls;

applying said linear relationship to said first set of assay data, thereby transforming said first set of assay data into a third frame of reference;

applying said linear relationship to said second set of assay data, thereby transforming said second set of assay data into said third frame of reference; and

within said third frame of reference, comparing a feature from said first set of assay data that is not in said first set of controls, to a feature from said second set of assay data that is not in said second set of controls.

61. A method for performing an analyte assay, comprising:

detecting signals from a plurality of sites from an array format thereby producing assay data;

dividing the assay data into a first population and a second population, wherein said first population comprises a first set of controls and said second population comprises a second set of controls;

obtaining a linear relationship between said first set of controls and said second set of controls;

applying said linear relationship to said assay data, thereby producing normalized assay data; and

correlating said signals to an amount of analyte in each of said sites.

62. A system for normalizing assay data, comprising:

a detector that detects signals from discrete areas of said microarray and produces microarray data; and

a computing device having embedded therein a set of instructions to transform said microarray data by;

selecting a first population of assay data and a second population of assay data, wherein said first population comprises a dependent set of controls and said second population comprises an independent set of controls;

obtaining a linear relationship between said independent set of controls and said dependent set of controls; and

applying said linear relationship to said first population, thereby producing normalized assay data.

64. A computer readable medium having recorded therein a set of instructions for providing normalized microarray data, comprising instructions for:

selecting a first population of assay data and a second population of assay data, wherein said first population comprises a dependent set of controls and said second population comprises an independent set of controls;

obtaining a linear relationship between said independent set of controls and said dependent set of controls; and

applying said linear relationship to said first population, thereby producing normalized assay data.

65. The computer readable medium of claim 64, wherein said medium is selected from the group consisting of random access memory, read only memory, magnetic disk, magnetic tape, and optical disk.