Method for inspection process development or improvement and parts inspection process

• US 20070260342A1
• Filed: 05/08/2006
• Published: 11/08/2007
• Est. Priority Date: 05/08/2006
• Status: Abandoned Application

• Current Assignee: Standard Aero Limited (StandardAero Business Aviation Services LLC)
• Original Assignee: Standard Aero Limited (StandardAero Business Aviation Services LLC)
• Inventors: Fields, Michael, Rooney, John, Atamanchuk, Kathryn, McCormick, Michael, Blanchette, Gilbert, Moura, Antonio
• Application Number:
  US11/429,229
• Publication Number:
  US 20070260342A1
• Time in Patent Office: Days
• US Class Current: 700/95
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/06 Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling

Abstract

A method of developing or improving a parts inspection process, the method comprising: selecting at least one target part for inspection; convening a panel to review samples of the target part, and to define conditions and determine a disposition of the target part samples; conducting initial inspections of the target part samples to obtain sample inspection results; comparing the sample inspection results with the conditions and disposition of the target part samples set by the panel; determining a cause of variability between the sample inspection results and the conditions and disposition of the target part samples set by the panel and generating one or more solutions for the cause of variability; creating an inspection standard based on the one or more solutions; conducting training of inspectors using the inspection standard, with inspectors which qualify on the training proceeding with routine inspections; and conducting reviews of the routine inspections to determine an inspection error rate; wherein the routine inspections are allowed to continue if an acceptable inspection error rate is achieved, and wherein an inspection standard review is performed if an unacceptable inspection error rate is achieved.

Claims

1. A method of developing or improving a parts inspection process, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) selecting at least one target part for inspection;

(b) convening a panel to review samples of said target part, and to define conditions and determine a disposition of said target part samples;

(c) conducting initial inspections of said target part samples to obtain sample inspection results;

(d) comparing said sample inspection results with the conditions and disposition of said target part samples set by the panel;

(e) determining a cause of variability between the sample inspection results and the conditions and disposition of said target part samples set by the panel and generating one or more solutions for said cause of variability;

(f) creating an inspection standard based on the one or more solutions;

(g) conducting training of inspectors using said inspection standard, with inspectors which qualify on said training proceeding with routine inspections; and

(h) conducting reviews of said routine inspections to determine an inspection error rate;

wherein the routine inspections are allowed to continue if an acceptable inspection error rate is achieved, and wherein an inspection standard review is performed if an unacceptable inspection error rate is achieved.

2. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein the panel is a panel of one or more experts in the field of the target part.

3. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein the initial inspections are conducted by a sample group of inspectors.

4. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said inspection standard comprises documentation, training packages, and/or samples that clarify and supplement existing technical data for the target part.

5. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said inspection standard is based on a selection of the best solutions generated in step (e).

6. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein a pass rate is established for the qualification of said inspectors in step (g), and said inspectors do not qualify to proceed with said routine inspections until they meet or exceed said pass rate.

7. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said reviews of the routine inspections are conducted by said panel.

8. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said inspection error rate is compared with statistical measures to determine whether said inspection error rate is acceptable or unacceptable.

9. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 8, wherein said statistical measures comprise a p-attribute control chart.

10. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said inspection standard review comprises a determination of whether the inspection standard requires revision.

11. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 10, wherein steps (g) and (h) are repeated if said inspection standard is determined to be satisfactory without revision.

12. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 10, wherein said inspection standard is revised and steps (g) and (h) are repeated if said inspection standard is determined to require revision.

13. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein if said acceptable inspection error rate is achieved the routine inspections are allowed to continue with step (h) repeated to ensure that said acceptable inspection error rate is maintained.

14. The method of developing or improving a parts inspection process according to claim 1, wherein said part is a service-exposed gas turbine engine part.

15. A parts inspection process for determining for determining whether a service-exposed part can be returned to service, said process comprising the steps of:

(a) selecting at least one target part for inspection;

(b) convening a panel to review samples of said target part, and to define conditions and determine a disposition of said target part samples;

(c) conducting initial inspections of said target part samples to obtain sample inspection results;

(d) comparing said sample inspection results with the conditions and disposition of said target part samples set by the panel;

(e) determining a cause of variability between the sample inspection results and the conditions and disposition of said target part samples set by the panel and generating one or more solutions for said cause of variability;

(f) creating an inspection standard based on the one or more solutions;

(g) conducting training of inspectors using said inspection standard, with inspectors which qualify on said training proceeding with routine inspections; and

(h) conducting reviews of said routine inspections to determine an inspection error rate;

wherein the routine inspections are allowed to continue if an acceptable inspection error rate is achieved, and wherein an inspection standard review is performed if an unacceptable inspection error rate is achieved.

16. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein the panel is a panel of one or more experts in the field of the target part.

17. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein the initial inspections are conducted by a sample group of inspectors.

18. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein said inspection standard comprises documentation, training packages, and/or samples that clarify and supplement existing technical data for the target part.

19. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein said inspection standard is based on a selection of the best solutions generated in step (e).

20. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein a pass rate is established for the qualification of said inspectors in step (g), and said inspectors do not qualify to proceed with said routine inspections until they meet or exceed said pass rate.

21. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein said reviews of the routine inspections are conducted by said panel.

22. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein said inspection error rate is compared with statistical measures to determine whether said inspection error rate is acceptable or unacceptable.

23. The parts inspection process according to claim 22, wherein said statistical measures comprise a p-attribute control chart.

24. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein said inspection standard review comprises a determination of whether the inspection standard requires revision.

25. The parts inspection process according to claim 24, wherein steps (g) and (h) are repeated if said inspection standard is determined to be satisfactory without revision.

26. The parts inspection process according to claim 24, wherein said inspection standard is revised and steps (g) and (h) are repeated if said inspection standard is determined to require revision.

27. The parts inspection process according to claim 15, wherein if said acceptable inspection error rate is achieved the routine inspections are allowed to continue with step (h) repeated to ensure that said acceptable inspection error rate is maintained.