Method for Generating Software Variants

• US 20090099855A1
• Filed: 10/11/2007
• Published: 04/16/2009
• Est. Priority Date: 10/11/2007
• Status: Abandoned Application

• Current Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Original Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Inventors: Narendra, Nanjangud C., Banavar, Guruduth S., Srivastava, Biplav, Ponnalagu, Karthikeyan
• Application Number:
  US11/870,636
• Publication Number:
  US 20090099855A1
• Time in Patent Office: Days
• US Class Current: 705/301
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/103 Workflow collaboration or project management
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/08 Insurance

Abstract

A method generates, based on an original business process comprising at least one component, a variant business process comprising at least one variation compared to the original business process. The method comprises the steps of developing a variant meta-model, representing the at least one variation, instantiating and verifying the developed variant meta-model portion to obtain a variant model, and implementing the variant model to generate the variant. The method also comprises developing a formalism for defining the at least one variation.

Claims

1. A method for generating, based on an original business process model and implementation comprising at least one component, a variant business process model and implementation comprising at least one variation compared to the original business process model and implementation, and which generates the same outputs for the same inputs as of the original business process model and implementation, the method comprising the steps of:

developing a meta-model of the business process model, comprising a static meta-model portion and a variant meta-model portion, representing the at least one variation;

instantiating and verifying the developed variant meta-model portion to obtain a variant model; and

implementing the variant model to generate the variant business process implementation.

2. The method of claim 1, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein developing the variant meta-model portion further comprises:

identifying at least one variation point, the at least one variation point indicating a location in the original business process model where variation can be introduced;

identifying at least one variation feature specifying the nature and the specific applicability of variation to be introduced; and

obtaining a variation instance by applying a variation feature to a corresponding variation point.

3. The method of claim 2, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the at least one variation point is:

an implementation variation point, identifying a location in a respective component, in which the implementation of at least one method can be modified;

or a specification variation point, identifying a location in a respective interface that can be modified.

4. The method of claim 3, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein:

variations are applied at a business process level and a component level comprising semantic rules defined for each variation.

5. The method of claim 4, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the variation instances of a business process are categorised as;

component-level variations, which do not require a variation in the process flow; and

business process-level variations that relate to the application flow of the business process, each external variation being realized via a combination of component-level variations.

6. The method of claim 5, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein an internal variation is defined by:

a change only to the internal implementations of the components, without requiring changes to their interfaces or a change in the interfaces of the components thereby requiring implementation changes.

7. The method of claim 5, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein an internal variation effects at least one of:

adding component sequentially;

adding component in parallel;

deleting component;

adding dependency between two components; and

deleting dependency between two components.

8. The method of claim 1, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein step b) comprises enhancing the model by performing the steps of:

modeling variations at the component and business process levels; and

representing formally the variations by using a constraint based formulation in order to verify that the variant business process model and implementation generate the same outputs for the same inputs as of the original business process model and implementation.

9. The method of claim 8, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the constraint-based formulation comprises:

variation variables, representing the basic change constructs;

variable domains, representing values that apply to each variation variable; and

constraints, representing the constraints against any subset of the variation variables.

10. The method of claim 8, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the constraint-based formulation comprises equality or inequality constraints.

11. The method of claim 1, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the step c) comprises:

composing variation models for each variation into a business process model of the variant; and

integrating un-automated and external components into the model.

12. The method of claim 11, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the external components comprise legacy components.

13. The method of claim 1, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the variant business process is generated semi-automatically.

14. An electronic system that is programmable for generating, based on an original business process model and implementation comprising at least one component, a variant business process model and implementation comprising at least one variation compared to the original business process model and implementation, the electronic system comprising computational means programmable for;

developing a meta-model comprising a static meta-model portion and a variant meta-model portion, representing the at least one variation;

instantiating and verifying the developed variant meta-model portion to obtain a variant model;

implementing the variant model to generate the variant; and

using a developed formalism to define the at least one variation.

15. The electronic system of claim 14, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the system is also programmable for;

identifying at least one variation point, the at least one variation point indicating a location in the original business process model where variation can be introduced;

identifying at least one variation feature specifying the nature and the specific applicability of variation to be introduced; and

obtaining a variation instance by applying a variation feature to a corresponding variation point.

16. The electronic system of claim 15, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the at least one variation point is:

an implementation variation point, identifying a location in a respective component, in which the implementation of at least one method can be modified;

or a specification variation point, identifying a location in a respective interface that can be modified.

17. The electronic system of claim 16, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the system is so programmed that;

variations are applied at a business process level and a component level comprising semantic rules defined for each variation.

18. The electronic system of claim 17, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the system is so programmed that the variation instances of a business process are categorised as;

component-level variations, which do not require a variation in the process flow; and

business process-level variations that relate to the application flow of the business process, each external variation being realized via a combination of component-level variations.

19. The electronic system of claim 18, all the limitations of which are incorporated herein, wherein the system is so programmed that an internal variation is defined by:

a change only to the internal implementations of the components, without requiring changes to their interfaces or a change in the interfaces of the components thereby requiring implementation changes.

20. A computer program product having a computer readable medium having an executable computer program recorded therein for automatically generating, based on an original business process comprising at least one component, a variant business process comprising at least one variation compared to the original business process, said computer program comprising;

developing a meta-model of the business process, the meta model comprising a static meta-model portion and a variant meta-model portion, representing the at least one variation;

instantiating and verifying the developed variant meta-model portion to obtain a variant model;

implementing the variant model to generate the variant; and

using the developed formalism to define the at least one variation.