PATENT MAPPING

• US 20110072014A1
• Filed: 12/01/2010
• Published: 03/24/2011
• Est. Priority Date: 08/10/2004
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Lucid Patent, LLC, Steven W. Lundberg
• Original Assignee: FoundationIP LLC (Clarivate Plc)
• Inventors: Sinha, Pradeep, Lundberg, Steven W., Kalis, Janal M.
• Granted Patent: US 9,697,577 B2
• Time in Patent Office: Days
• US Class Current: 707/736
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/86 Mapping to a database
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 40/143 Markup, e.g. Standard Generalized Markup Language [SGML] or Document Type Definition [DTD]
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 40/30 Semantic analysis
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 50/184 Intellectual property management
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 99/00 Subject matter not provided for in other groups of this subclass

Abstract

The present inventive subject matter provides systems, methods, software, and data structures for patent mapping, storage, and searching. Some such embodiments include mapping patent documents, claims, and claim limitations. Some further embodiments provide for searching a universe of patent documents by patent document, claim, limitation, class, element, or concept.

Claims

1. A information management system comprising:

at least one computer system including;

at least one central processing unit adapted to execute computer instructions;

a memory;

a database management system operative on the computer system to manage data; and

wherein the at least one central processing unit and memory operatively coupled;

machine-readable data managed at least in part by the database management system and stored at least in part in the memory, the machine-readable data including;

machine-readable patent pool data stored in the memory, the pool data including machine readable data identifying a plurality of patent documents and at least some of the patent claims included in each patent document, wherein the patent document is published by a government entity;

machine-readable user-defined limitation data representing the text of one or more user-defined limitations mapped to one or more of the patent claims, at least one of the user-defined limitations specifying a limit on the scope of one or more of the patent claims;

machine-readable patent claim mapping data defining an association of user-defined limitation data to the data identifying the patent claims in order to represent a mapping of at least one of the user-defined limitations to at least one of the patent claims; and

machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory, the computer instructions executable in the central processing unit to cause the computer system to;

a) generate patent claim mapping data that associates at least one user-defined limitation to at least one patent claim, wherein the patent claim mapping data is generated in response to a selection by a user of the system of at least one of the user-defined limitations;

b) generate claim screening data and record the claim screening data in the memory, the claim screening data specifying an indication of the applicability of one or more of the user-defined limitations to a target technology, the indication provided by a user of the system when using the system to screen the claims of the pool of patents;

c) automatically determine if one or more of the patent claims represented by the patent claim data is not applicable to the target technology based at least in part on the claim screening data and the patent claim mapping data stored at least in part in the memory; and

d) generate claim applicability data that specifies the applicability of one or more of the patent claims to the target technology based at least in part on the screening data, the claim applicability data stored at least in part in the memory.

2. An information management system according to claim 1 further including a data structure stored at least in part in the memory, the data structure including data defining a hierarchy of the user-defined limitations, wherein at least some user-defined limitations are parents to other user-defined limitations that are children of the parent.

3. An information management system according to claim 1 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the screening mode of operation to identify user-defined limitations that are applicable only to patent claims that have been determined inapplicable to the target, the identifying of the user-defined limitations determined at least in part based on the claim screening data and the claim mapping data.

4. An information management system according to claim 1 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to automatically determine if one or more user-defined limitations are applicable to a patent claim other than the claim or claims the user-defined limitation is already mapped to.

5. An information management system according to claim 1 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to enable a user of the system to either choose an existing user-defined limitation to map to a claim or to map a new user-defined limitation to a claim on-the-fly.

6. An information management system according to claim 1 further wherein the user-defined limitations are organized in a catalog represented by the limitation data.

7. An information management system according to claim 6 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate to enable a user to merge user-defined limitations in the catalog.

8. An information management system according to claim 1 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the scope of a claim element of one of the claims.

9. An information management system according to claim 1 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the overall scope of one of the claims.

10. An information management system according to claim 1 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the scope of a claim element of one of the claims, and the claim element narrows the scope of the claim relatively more than another one of the claim elements for the one of the claims.

11. A information management system comprising:

at least one computer system including;

at least one central processing unit adapted to execute computer instructions;

a memory;

a database management system operative on the computer system to manage data;

wherein the at least one central processing unit and memory are operatively coupled;

machine-readable data managed at least in part by the database management system and stored at least in part in the memory, the machine-readable data including;

machine-readable patent pool data stored at least in part in the memory, the pool data including machine readable data identifying a plurality of patent documents and at least some of the patent claims included in each patent document, wherein the patent document is published by a government entity;

machine-readable user-defined limitation data representing the text of one or more user-defined limitations mapped to one or more of the patent claims, at least one of the user-defined limitations specifying a limit on the scope of one or more of the patent claims; and

machine-readable patent claim mapping data defining an association of user-defined limitation data to the data identifying the patent claims in order to represent a mapping of at least one of the user-defined limitations to at least one of the patent claims; and

machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory, the computer instructions executable in the central processing unit to cause the computer system to perform in a mapping mode of operation to generate patent claim mapping data that associates at least one selected user-defined limitation to at least one displayed patent claim, wherein the patent claim mapping data is generated in response to a selection by the user of the system of at least one of the user-defined limitations.

12. An information management system according to claim 11 further including a data structure stored at least in part in the memory, the data structure including data defining a hierarchy of the user-defined limitations, wherein at least some user-defined limitations are parents to other user-defined limitations that are children of the parent.

13. An information management system according to claim 11 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the screening mode of operation to identify user-defined limitations that are applicable only to patent claims that have been determined inapplicable to the target, the identifying of the user-defined limitations determined at least in part based on the claim screening data and the claim mapping data.

14. An information management system according to claim 11 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to automatically determine if one or more user-defined limitations are applicable to a patent claim other than the claim or claims the user-defined limitation is already mapped to.

15. An information management system according to claim 11 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to enable a user of the system to either choose an existing user-defined limitation to map to a claim or to map a new user-defined limitation to a claim on-the-fly.

16. An information management system according to claim 11 further wherein the user-defined limitations are organized in a catalog represented by the limitation data.

17. An information management system according to claim 16 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate to enable a user to merge user-defined limitations in the catalog.

18. An information management system according to claim 11 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the scope of a claim element of one of the claims.

19. An information management system according to claim 11 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the overall scope of one of the claims.

20. A information management system comprising:

at least one computer system including;

at least one central processing unit adapted to execute computer instructions;

a memory;

a data organization system operative on the computer system to organize data; and

wherein the at least one central processing unit and the memory are operatively coupled;

machine-readable data managed at least in part by the data organization system and stored at least in part in the memory, the machine-readable data including;

machine-readable patent pool data stored at least in part in the memory, the pool data including machine readable data identifying a plurality of patent documents and at least some of the patent claims included in each patent document, wherein the patent document is published by a government entity;

machine-readable user-defined limitation data representing the text of one or more user-defined limitations mapped to one or more of the patent claims, at least one of the user-defined limitations specifying a limit on the scope of one or more of the patent claims; and

machine-readable patent claim mapping data defining an association of user-defined limitation data to the data identifying the patent claims in order to represent a mapping of at least one of the user-defined limitations to at least one of the patent claims; and

machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in a screening mode of operation to;

a) generate claim screening data and record the claim screening data in the memory, the claim screening data specifying an indication of the applicability of the user-defined limitations to a target technology, the indication provided by a user of the system when using the system to screen the claims of the pool of patents;

b) automatically determine if one or more of the patent claims represented by the patent claim data is not applicable to the target technology based at least in part on the claim screening data and the patent claim mapping data stored at least in part in the memory; and

c) generate claim applicability data that specifies the applicability of one or more of the patent claims to the target technology based at least in part on the screening data, the claim applicability data stored at least in part in the memory.

21. An information management system according to claim 20 further including a data structure stored at least in part in the memory, the data structure including data defining a hierarchy of the user-defined limitations, wherein at least some user-defined limitations are parents to other user-defined limitations that are children of the parent.

22. An information management system according to claim 20 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the screening mode of operation to identify user-defined limitations that are applicable only to patent claims that have been determined inapplicable to the target, the identifying of the user-defined limitations determined at least in part based on the claim screening data and the claim mapping data.

23. An information management system according to claim 20 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to automatically determine if one or more user-defined limitations are applicable to a patent claim other than the claim or claims the user-defined limitation is already mapped to.

24. An information management system according to claim 20 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate in the mapping mode of operation to enable a user of the system to either choose an existing user-defined limitation to map to a claim or to map a new user-defined limitation to a claim on-the-fly.

25. An information management system according to claim 20 further wherein the user-defined limitations are organized in a catalog represented by the limitation data.

26. An information management system according to claim 25 further wherein the machine-readable computer instructions stored at least in part in the memory are operable when executed by the central processing unit to cause the computer system to operate to enable a user to merge user-defined limitations in the catalog.

27. An information management system according to claim 20 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the scope of a claim element of one of the claims.

28. An information management system according to claim 20 wherein the limitation data specifies a limit on the overall scope of one of the claims.