PROPERTY APPRAISAL DISCREPANCY DETECTION AND ASSESSMENT

• US 20150154663A1
• Filed: 12/03/2013
• Published: 06/04/2015
• Est. Priority Date: 12/03/2013
• Status: Abandoned Application

• Current Assignee: Fannie Mae
• Original Assignee: Fannie Mae
• Inventors: Carroll, Franklin, Rosenblatt, Eric, Willard, Kent R., Chung, Kevin, Dawson, Zachary, Saraf, Sampat
• Application Number:
  US14/095,112
• Publication Number:
  US 20150154663A1
• Time in Patent Office: Days
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0278 Product appraisal
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 50/16 Real estate

Abstract

An appraisal error detection method includes accessing a database of appraisal-data-field entries of property appraisals. Because sales transactions are cited repetitively as comparables on multiple appraisals, it is possible to inspect appraisal-data-field entries for consistency. An error detection operation is performed for each of the corresponding appraisal-data-field entries by detecting any discrepancies, both between appraisers, and between different appraisals by the same appraisers, where corresponding appraisal-data-field entries are for a same property characteristic of a same property. Appraisal-data-field entries determined by the error detection operation to be erroneous are flagged, and a discrepancy score may be assigned to flagged erroneous entries that indicates an amount of risk posed by the entry. Appraisals in the database may be assigned a score based upon the sum of their entries'"'"' discrepancy scores.

Claims

1. A method comprising, causing a processor to:

access appraisal-data-field entries from a plurality of property appraisals, each of the appraisal-data-field entries indicating a value assigned to a property characteristic of a property included in the respective property appraisal;

perform an error detection operation for each of the accessed appraisal-data-field entries as a target entry, the error detection operation comprising detecting a discrepancy between the target entry and an appraisal-data-field entry corresponding to the target entry; and

flag as erroneous appraisal-data-field entries determined by the error detection operation to be erroneous,

wherein appraisal-data-field entries that correspond to one another indicate respective values assigned to a same property characteristic of a same property.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising causing the processor to:

assign respective numerical discrepancy values to flagged appraisal-data-field entries,

wherein a magnitude of the discrepancy value assigned to at least one of the flagged appraisal-data-field entries is different than a magnitude of the discrepancy value assigned to at least one other of the flagged appraisal-data-field entries.

3. The method of claim 2, further comprising causing the processor to:

assign a total discrepancy score to at least one of the plurality of property appraisals that depends upon a sum of any numerical discrepancy values assigned to those appraisal-data-field entries that are included in the property appraisal being assigned the total discrepancy score.

4. The method of claim 3, further comprising causing the processor to:

display data corresponding to at least some of the plurality of property appraisals, the displayed data including the respective total discrepancy scores assigned thereto,

receive input specifying one of the displayed property appraisals, and

display in response to the received input at least any flagged appraisal-data-field entries of the specified property appraisal in association with respective deemed-correct values for the displayed flagged appraisal-data-field entries.

5. The method of claim 2,

wherein respective magnitudes of the assigned discrepancy values depend at least in part upon how much the flagged appraisal-data-field being assigned the discrepancy value affects valuation of a subject property in the property appraisal that includes the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value.

6. The method of claim 2,

wherein respective magnitudes of the assigned discrepancy values depend on a type of property characteristic indicated by the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned a discrepancy value.

7. The method of claim 2,

wherein respective magnitudes of the assigned discrepancy values depend on at least one of:

a type of property characteristic indicated by the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value, a discrepancy type of the discrepancy detected for the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value, and a magnitude of the discrepancy detected for the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value.

8. The method of claim 7, further comprising causing the processor to:

assign a total discrepancy score to at least one of the plurality of property appraisals that depends upon a sum of any numerical discrepancy values assigned to those appraisal-data-field entries that are included in the property appraisal total discrepancy score.

9. The method of claim 7,

wherein respective magnitudes of the assigned discrepancy values further depend upon how much the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value affects a valuation of a subject property of the appraisal that includes the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value.

10. The method of claim 7,

wherein the magnitude of the numerical discrepancy value further depends upon whether the target entry corresponds to a subject property of the respective property appraisal that includes the target entry.

11. The method of claim 2,

wherein respective magnitudes of the assigned discrepancy values depend on a discrepancy type of the discrepancy detected for the flagged appraisal-data-field entry being assigned the discrepancy value, and

said discrepancy types include self-discrepancies and peer-discrepancies.

12. The method of claim 11,

wherein a target entry for which a self-discrepancy is detected is flagged as erroneous when at least one of the following is true:

a value different from the value of the target entry is agreed upon by at least a predetermined number of appraisal-data-field entries that correspond to the target entry, and

the target entry inflates a valuation of a subject property of the appraisal that includes the target entry.

13. The method of claim 11,

wherein a target entry for which a peer-discrepancy is detected is flagged as erroneous when a value different from the value of the target entry is agreed upon by at least a predetermined number of appraisal-data-field entries that correspond to the target entry.

14. The method of claim 11,

wherein the discrepancy types include outlier discrepancies, and a flagged appraisal-data-field entry has an outlier discrepancy when:

a magnitude of the discrepancy detected for the target entry exceeds a predetermined threshold, and

the target entry inflates a valuation of a subject property of the appraisal that includes the target entry.

15. The method of claim 11,

wherein, for at least one type of property characteristic, a higher discrepancy value is assigned when a detected discrepancy is both a self-discrepancy and a peer-discrepancy than when an otherwise identical detected discrepancy is only one of a peer-discrepancy and a self-discrepancy.

16. The method of claim 11,

wherein for at least one type of property characteristic, a higher discrepancy value is assigned when a self-discrepancy is detected than when an otherwise identical peer-discrepancy is detected.

17. A computer program product comprising a non-transitory computer readable medium having program code stored thereon, the program code being executable by a processor to perform the method of claim 1.

19. A computing device comprising:

at least one processor, and

a memory unit, having stored thereon program code executable by the at least one processor to perform the method of claim 1.

18. A method comprising causing a processor to:

access appraisal-data-field entries from a plurality of property appraisals, each of the appraisal-data-field entries indicating a value assigned to a property characteristic in the respective property appraisal;

associate with one another those appraisal-data-field entries that correspond to a same property as one another, correspond to a same property characteristic as one another, and have transaction dates separated by less than a predetermined time from of one another;

perform an error detection operation for each of the accessed appraisal-data-field entries as a target entry, the error detection operation comprising detecting a discrepancy between the target entry and an appraisal-data-field entry associated therewith;

flag as erroneous appraisal-data-field entries determined by the error detection operation to be erroneous, said flag indicating a type and magnitude of the detected discrepancy; and

identify at least one property appraisal of the plurality of property appraisals as suspect based upon flagged appraisal-data-field entries.

20. A system comprising:

at least one processor;

a database including a plurality of appraisal-data-field entries from a plurality of property appraisals, each of the appraisal-data-field entries indicating a value assigned to a property characteristic in the respective property appraisal; and

a non-transitory computer readable medium having program code stored thereon, the program code being executable by the at least one processor to perform the following operations;

access the appraisal-data-field entries from the database,

perform an error detection operation for each of the accessed appraisal-data-field entries as a target entry, the error detection operation comprising detecting a discrepancy between the target entry and an appraisal-data-field entry corresponding to the target entry,

flag as erroneous appraisal-data-field entries determined by the error detection operation to be erroneous, said flag indicating a type and magnitude of the discrepancy, and

identify at least one property appraisal of the plurality of property appraisals as suspect based upon flagged appraisal-data-field entries,

wherein appraisal-data-field entries that correspond to one another indicate respective values assigned to a same property characteristic of a same property.