Apparatus for controlling vibrational chatter in a machine-tool utilizing an updated synthesis circuit

• US 3,967,515 A
• Filed: 06/13/1975
• Issued: 07/06/1976
• Est. Priority Date: 05/13/1974
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Voith-Morden Incorporated (Voith GmbH & Co. KGaA)
• Original Assignee: Purdue Research Foundation (The Trustees of Purdue University (d/b/a Purdue University))
• Inventors: Klein, Richard G., Nachtigal, Chester L., Maddux, Kenneth C.
• Primary Examiner(s): Vlachos, Leonidas
• Application Number:
  US05/586,572
• Time in Patent Office: 389 Days
• Field of Search: 82/2 B, 82/DIG. 9, 318/561, 318/571, 51/165.77, 51/165.92, 51/103 R, 235/151.11, 90/11 R
• US Class Current: 82/118
• CPC Class Codes: B23Q 15/12 Adaptive control, i.e. adjusting itself to have a performance which is optimum according to a preassigned criterion
• CPC Class Codes: B23Q 17/0976 Detection or control of chatter B23Q15/12 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/37351 Detect vibration, ultrasound
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/41256 Chattering control
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 82/904 Vibrating method or tool
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 409/300896 with sensing of numerical information and regulation without mechanical connection between sensing means and regulated means [i.e., numerical control]
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 409/304312 with means to dampen vibration
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 82/2502 with program control

Abstract

A method and apparatus for controlling vibrational chatter in a machine tool operation wherein a workpiece and a tool are mounted in a manner to permit controlled and forced engagement of the tool and workpiece to remove material from said workpiece. A first transducer is spatially disposed from the tool-workpiece interface and generates an electrical signal representative of the applied cutting forces on the workpiece. This force signal is applied to a workpiece movement synthesis circuit for continuous calculation of the workpiece displacement in response to cutting forces and in accordance with continuously updated static and dynamic characteristics of the machine structure and the workpiece. Simultaneously, another transducer on the machine structure continuously provides a tool acceleration signal for use in deriving an electrical signal representing the actual displacement of the tool.

The synthesis circuit output signal representing the calculated workpiece displacement is electronically compared with the signal representing the actual tool displacement, with vibrational chatter occurring whenever the two signals are not equal and offsetting. When the two signals are not equal, the differential therebetween is used to generate an error signal for controlling a compensatory force actuator mounted on the machine structure. The compensatory actuator provides forces of controlled magnitude and frequency to the machine structure to offset and eliminate the vibrational chatter.

Claims

1. An apparatus for controlling a machining operation wherein a workpiece and a machining tool are mounted in a machine structure and one of said workpiece and tool is moved with respect to the other to cause said tool to exert a machining force on said workpiece and to remove material therefrom, comprising first transducer means connected to the machine structure at a position spaced from said tool and workpiece for detecting a force representative of the machining force and for generating a first electrical signal corresponding thereto;

second transducer means connected to the machine structure for detecting the actual motion of one of said tool and workpiece in response to the machining force and for generating a second electrical signal corresponding thereto;

a synthesis circuit electrically coupled to said first and second transducer means for generating a synthesized electrical signal representative of the motion in response to the maching force of the one of said tool and workpiece not connected to said second transducer means, said synthesis circuit having updating circuit means responsive to said first and second electrical signals for continuously altering parameters of said synthesis circuit in accordance with changes in the machine static and dynamic characteristics;

comparison means for comparing said second electrical signal with said synthesis signal and for generating an error signal in accordance therewith; and

compensatory force means electrically coupled to said comparison means and having mechanical means for delivering compensatory forces to the machine structure in response to said error signal for maintaining said tool and workpiece in predetermined spatial relationships during the machining process irrespective of vibratory movements of said workpiece, tool, or machine structure.

2. Apparatus as set forth in claim 1 with the addition of third transducer means connected to said compensatory force means for detecting the compensatory forces delivered thereby to the machine structure and for generating a third electrical signal representative thereof;

said third electrical signal being coupled to said synthesis circuit for offsetting any compensatory force effects unrelated to cutting force supplementation upon the output of said first transducer means.

3. Apparatus as set forth in claim 1 with the addition of third transducer means connected to said compensatory force means for detecting the compensatory forces delivered thereby to the machine structure and for generating a third electrical signal representative thereof;

and a second synthesis circuit having said third electrical signal coupled thereto for generating a second synthesized electrical signal representative of the motion in response to the compensatory force effects unrelated to cutting force supplementation of the one of said tool aand workpiece not connected to said second transducer means, said second synthesized electrical signal being coupled to the output of said first synthesis circuit for producing a motion signal representative of the total motion of the one of said tool and workpiece not connected to said second transducer means.

4. Apparatus as set forth in claim 1 wherein said second transducer means comprises an accelerometer mounted on the machine structure adjacent one of said tool and workpiece for measuring the acceleration thereof and for generating a signal corresponding thereto, said accelerometer being coupled to circuit means for converting said acceleration representative signal to said second electrical signal representative of displacement of said one of said tool and workpiece.

5. Apparatus as set forth in claim 1 wherein said updating circuit means comprises phase discriminating means for monitoring the actual difference in electrical phase angle between first and second electrical signals, for comparing said actual phase angle difference to a predetermined phase angle difference, and for generating an updating signal corresponding to any inequality between said actual phase angle difference and said predetermined phase angle difference for continuously altering parameters of said synthesis circuit.

6. Apparatus as set forth in claim 5 wherein said updating circuit means further comprises frequency and amplitude discriminating means for determining when said first electrical signal exceeds a predetermined frequency and amplitude and for enabling alteration of synthesis circuit parameters in accordance with said updating signal whenever said predetermined frequency and amplitude are exceeded.

7. Apparatus as set forth in claim 1 wherein said machining tool is moved with respect to the workpiece to traverse the length of the workpiece, said updating circuit means comprising first generating means mechanically coupled to said tool for generating a linearly variable signal indicative of the position of said tool along the length of said workpiece, and second generating means coupled between said first generating means and said synthesis circuit for generating a non-linearly variable signal in response to the position signal, said non-linearly variable signal varying predeterminably and being coupled to said synthesis circuit for continuously altering parameters thereof.

8. Apparatus as set forth in claim 7 wherein said non-linearly variable signal is representative of the mechanical compliance of the workpiece in accordance with the position of the tool with respect thereto.

9. An apparatus for controlling a machining operation wherein a workpiece and a machining tool are mounted in a machine structure and one of said workpiece and machining tool is moved with respect to the other to cause said tool to exert a machining force on said workpiece and to remove material therefrom, comprising first transducer means connected to one of said tool and said workpiece for detecting the actual motion thereof and for generating an electrical signal representative of said actual motion;

a force signal generation circuit coupled to said first transducer means for acting on said motion signal to generate a force signal representative of the machining force;

a synthesis circuit electrically coupled to said force signal generation circuit and to said first transducer means for generating a synthesized electrical signal representative of the motion in response to the machine force of the one of said tool and workpiece not connected to said first transducer means, said synthesis circuit having updating circuit means responsive to the signals generated by said force signal generation circuit and said first transducer means for continuously altering parameters of said synthesis circuit in accordance with changes in the static and dynamic characteristics of the workpiece;

comparison means for comparing said motion signal generated by said first transducer means and said synthesized signal to generate an error signal in accordance with the compared signals; and

a compensatory force actuator electrically coupled to said comparison means and mechanically coupled to said machine structure for delivering compensatory forces to the machine structure in response to said error signal to maintain said tool said workpiece in a predetermined spatial relationship during the machining process irrespective of any vibratory movements of said workpiece with respect to said tool.