Machine for the finding of an optimum passage

• US 3,974,481 A
• Filed: 05/14/1974
• Issued: 08/10/1976
• Est. Priority Date: 05/14/1973
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Societe Cybco
• Original Assignee: Societe Cybco
• Inventors: Ledieu, Jean, Eschenbrenner, Philippe
• Primary Examiner(s): Morrison, Malcolm A.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Smith, Jerry
• Application Number:
  US05/469,881
• Time in Patent Office: 819 Days
• Field of Search: 340/172.5, 235/150.1, 444/1
• US Class Current: 700/33
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/06 Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling

Abstract

The optimiser includes P cells for the computation and memorization of a content, the P contents simulating the deformation of a backward wave front which explores a plane representative of a concrete situation submitted to constraints.

The set of elementary optimum actions which define the optimum path between an initial state and a final state are found by iteration.

Claims

1. A digital problem solving machine of optimizer type, for the seeking of an optimum path between an initial state and a final state for a system with a plurality of quantified variables, m in number, each of which can take on N values, comprising:

a. means for setting in the sets of coordinate values of the variables corresponding to the initial and final states of the said system and for setting in the coordinate value sets corresponding to the values of the variables defining the system forbidden states, referred to as constraints;

b. a plurality of computation-and-memorization cells for handling digital contents, arranged to have their initial contents set by said setting-in means;

c. means providing for variation of the said contents in said cells by quantities appropriately defined as a function of the said constraints imposed on the system, starting from the set of initial values, the evolution of the values of the said contents by said variation being capable of consideration as simulating the propagation of a backward dummy wave which propagates step by step in a representative space receiving the said wave of the preceding adjacent points, with the exception of the points representative of constraints which do not propagate the wave, such variation for each constraint being termed processing the constraint;

d. means for reading the finally obtained cell contents after processing each constraint, and

e. decision means using the results of the reading performed by said reading means and comparing them for selecting at least one of m+1 possible alternative succeeding states, as being the state corresponding to the first optimum elementary action, which transfers the system from the initial state to the said selected succeeding state, and which includes means for producing at least one reiteration comprising;

f. means for setting as the new initial state of the system the said succeeding state selected by said decision means,

g. means for reinitializing the cells contents,

h. means for commanding anew the operation of the means defined in foregoing subparagraphs c) to g), inclusive, for reprocessing of the cell contents, and

i. means for memorizing the set of optimum elementary actions found at each processing, which set gives by successive approximation, the said optimum route going from the initial state to the final state,

the said digital machine comprising the improvements constituted by the following characteristics;

the said computation-and-memorization cells are P in number, where P<

mN, and constitute an operator;

3. Optimizer according to claim 1 in which the number of coordinate values in each of said sets of coordinate values is 2, so that the coordinate sets are pairs of values and the representative space is a representative plane of N² points equidistantly located on intersecting straight lines defined by said points and in which:

the number of cells P is equal to 2N,

each of the 2N cells is referenced by an address, called the diagonal address, the 2N diagonal addresses being numbered from 0 to 2N - 1, so that the cells can then be considered as being allocated to each one of the 2N diagonals of the representative plane,

the means for setting in an initial content in the said cells include means for initially setting in a content equal to 0 for the cells of which the addresses go from 0 to N-1 inclusive and contents equal to 1, 2, 3....N respectively for the N cells of which the addresses go from N to 2N - 1,

means are provided for setting in each constraint by two numbers, an upper diagonal address denoted H corresponding in the representative plane to the constraint point situated on the highest diagonal and a lower diagonal address denoted B, corresponding to the constraint point situated on the lowest diagonal of the plane, the said means for incrementing the contents of each cell as a function of the addresses B and H and of the constraint processed include means for;

a. maintaining unchanged the contents of the cells of which the addresses are included between 0 and B, inclusive,

b. changing the contents of a cell of address B +1 to (B) + 1, the expression;

(B) esignating the content of the cells of address B before processing, changing to (B) + 2 the contents of the cells of address B + 2 and so on,

c. comparing the contents of each cell with the content (H) of the cell of address H,

d. determining which cell is the intermediate cell for which the new content becomes equal to (H),

e. maintaining at the value (H) the contents of the cells with addresses higher than the said intermediate cell up to the cell with address H,

f. maintaining unchanged the contents of the cells of which the addresses go from H + 1 to F - 1.

5. Optimizer according to claim 3 including:

A. interface means for interconnecting said operator connecting said operator constituted by said cells, and a computer;

B. a control means for providing a sequence of orders to the operator,

C. addressing means for interpreting said orders for the operator, said addressing means including means for reading the contents of the cell the address of which is that of the upper address H of a constraint being processed, means for transmitting the result over a comparator-bus and means for subtracting, from the lower address B of the said constraint being processed, the contents of the cell of the same address and means for transmitting the result over an operator bus,

the said optimizer being further characterized in that each diagonal address of n bits is split into a base-address part composed of a first set of n'"'"' bits and a displacement part composed of a wired-in word composed of a second set of n - n'"'"' bits and that in each cell the operator includes;

a. first multiplexer means having two inputs, and n'"'"' bits, said inputs connected to receive respectively the words of n'"'"' bits of the base address and of the address which exceeds the base address by 1 and therefore may be referred to as the base + 1 address or address part,

b. random access memory means of p = 2^n'"'"' bits, for memorizing the successive contents of the cell after each constraint is processed, said memory means being controlled by an enabling line and being addressable by a word of n'"'"' bits coming from said multiplexer, the output of the said memory being orgaized in a bus, hereinafter referred to as the RAM-output-bus,

c. adder-subtractor means receiving a cell address composed of one of said wired-in words of (n - n'"'"') bits and one of said word of n'"'"' bits coming from said multiplexer and also receiving words of n bits transmitted by the said operator-bus,

d. comparator means for comparing each word of n bits coming from said adder-subtractor means respectively with each word of n bits transmitted by the said comparator-bus,

e. second multiplexer means with two inputs and n bits, connected to receive the word coming from said adder-subtractor means and the word transmitted by said comparator-bus, the said second multiplexer means being controlled by the output of said comparator means, the output of said second multiplexer means being constituted so as to transmit words of n bits towards said memory means.

10. Optimizer according to claim 1, characterized in that the operator is composed of p layers of M cells, with p . M = 2N, and wherein the number M can be less than the dimensions of certain constraints, the said operator in such case operating several times in succession to process the constraints last mentioned.

11. Optimizer according to claim 1 characterized in that each cell of the operator includes means for computation and memorization of an increment which represents, for a specified cell, the increase of the content of this cell with respect to the content of the cell of the preceding address.

12. Optimizer according to claim 10 in which m=2 so that the coordinate sets are pairs of values, the representative space is a representative plane of N² points arranged equidistantly on intersecting straight lines defined by said points, the number of cells is P≦

2N, and in which further;

each of the P cells is referenced by an address, called the diagonal address, the P diagonal addresses being numbered from 0 to P - 1, the cells can then be considered as being allocated to P diagonals of the representative plane,

the means for setting in an initial content in the said cells include means for initially setting in a content equal to 0 for the cells of which the addresses go from 0 to N inclusive and a progessive of increment as contents for the cells of which the addresses go from N + 1 to P - 1,

in the setting in means, each constraint is set in by two numbers, the one called "upper diagonal address" denoted H and corresponding in the representative plane to the constraint point situated on the highest diagonal of the plane and the other called "lower diagonal address" denoted B, corresponding to the constraint point situated on the lowest diagonal of the plane,

the said means for computing the increment of each cell as a function of the addresses B and H of the constraint processed include means for;

a. maintaining at zero the increment of the cells of which the addresses are included between 0 and B, inclusive,

b. computing the number S of increments that it counts before the processing of the constraint under consideration in the cells of which the addresses go from B exclusive to H inclusive,

c. resetting to zero the contents of the cells of which the addresses go from B + 1 to H,

d. setting in a progressive increment of "1" in the cells of addresses B + 1, B + 2 . . . .B + S,

e. setting in a zero increment in the cells of which the addresses go from B + S + 1 up to H inclusive, and

f. mantaining unchanged the increments of the cells of which the addresses go from H + 1 to P - 1.

13. Optimizer according to claim 11, characterized in that the operator includes:

a memory (M) having as many 1 bit locations as cells, each bit representing one increment for one cell, each location having input and output means;

circuit means (V) for enabling all of the memory location output means relating to cells of addresses included in the interval going from B exclusive to H inclusive, an interval hereinafter denoted ]B, H],

an adder (ADD

     1) connected to the output means of memory (M) via the intermediary of the said circuit means (V) and which makes the sum S of all of the 1 s included in the interval ]B, H],

means for resetting to zero the memory M locations in the interval ]B, H],

means for writing a number of 1 s equal to the sum S starting from the address B + 1 up to the address X = B + S then 0 s from X + 1 up to H, and

sequencer means connected to a computer and comprising;

a. means for controlling the write and read operations in said memory (M), said circuit means (V), and said adder (ADD

     1), for each processing of one constraint,

b. means for transferring the processing operations in the cells, from the processing of one constraint to the processing of the following constraint to be processed, and

c. means for extracting, after the last processing, the sum of the 1 s written up the for respective addresses of the cells corresponding to said three possible succeeding states of the initial state.

14. Optimizer according to claim 12, characterized in that the memory (M) is organized in 2^q lines of 2^r bits, with P = 2^{q +r}, the line to which an address belongs being defined by the q most significant bits of the said address which form a word noted by B₁ for a lower address and H₁ for an upper address and in that the circuit means (V) for enabling include:

a lower address decoder means (DECOD B) the inputs of which are connected to the portion of the setting in means provided for the lower addresses and to the outputs of the enabling circuits of said circuit means for the outputs of the memory corresponding to the interval ]B, H] of the said lower address decoder means, including in particular a decoder (DECOD B₁) with q bits, of which the q inputs transmit B₁,having 2^q outputs,

an upper address decoder means (DECOD H) the inputs of which are connected to the portion of the setting in means provided for the upper addresses and to the outputs to the said logic circuits of said circuit means (V), the said upper address decoder means including in particular a decoder (DECOD H₁) with q bits of which the q inputs transmit H₁, having 2q outputs.

15. Optimizer according to claim 13, characterized in that each of the lines of 2^r bits is organized in 2^s words of 2^t bits each with s + t = r and in that:

A. the said lower address decoder includes, in addition to said decoder (DECOD B₁) of said lower address decoder means;

a. a second decoder (DECOD B₂) of s bits, the said s bits corresponding to the s intermediate bits of the lower address which form a word denoted B₂,

a third decoder (DECOD B₃) with t bits, the said t bits being the t least significant bits of the lower address which forms a word denoted B₃, and

B. the said upper address decoder includes, in addition to decoder (DECOD H₁);

a. a second decoder (DECOD H₂) with s bits, the said s bits corresponding to the s intermediate bits of the upper address which forms a word denoted H₂,

b. a third decoder, (DECOD B₃) with t bits, the said t bits being the t least significant bits of the upper address which form a word denoted H₃.

16. Optimizer according to claim 14, characterized in that said memory M has 2¹¹ = 2048 bits organized in 2⁴ = 16 lines of 2⁷ = 128 bits divided into 16 bytes numbered from i = 1 to 16, the bits of one byte being numbered from j = 8, one of the 128 bits of one line being thus referenced by the notation with two indices Mⁱ,j and in that each address is defined by a word of 11 bits composed of three words denoted B₁, B₂ and B₃, respectively for the lower address and H₁, H₂ and H₃ respectively for the upper address, respectively formed in each case by the 4 most significant bits of the address, by the 3 intermediate bits and by the 3 least significant bits.

17. Optimizer according to claim 15, characterized in that:

A. the second decoder (DECOD B₂) of the lower address decoder means has four inputs and sixteen outputs denoted B₂ⁱ, i varying from 1 to 16, and is arranged to select among all of the bytes situated to the left of that at which the lower address is found, including that byte,

B. the third decoder (DECOD B₃) of the lower address decoder means has three inputs and eight outputs denoted B₃^j, varying from 1 to 8, and is arranged to select in each byte all of the locations situated to the left of that represented by the value in binary coded decimal of B₃, including that location,

C. the second decoder (DECOD H₂) of the upper address decoder means has four inputs and sixteen outputs denoted by H₂ i, i varying from 1 to 16, and is arranged to select among all of the bytes situated to the right of that at which the upper address is found, with the exclusion of this byte,

d. the third decoder (DECOD H₃) of the upper address decoder means has three inputs and eight outputs denoted by H₃^j, j varying from 1 to 8, and is arranged to select in each byte the locations to the right of the location represented by the binary coded decimal value of H₃ with the exclusion of the said position,

E. the said logic circuits (VAL) of said circuit means (V) include;

a logic gate pⁱ,j of NOR type, connected to the output of each memory location Mⁱ,j, the output of the said gate being connected to the adder (ADD

     1), one of the two entries being connected to the output of the memory location Mⁱ,j and the other input being connected to the output of a logic subcircuit Kⁱ,j with six inputs, three of the said six inputs being connected respectively to the two outputs B₂ⁱ and B₂^{i +} 1 of the said second decoder (DECOD B₃) of said lower address decoder means, the said logic subcircuit constituting the logic operation b₂^{i +} 1 + b₂ⁱ . b₃^j for these three inputs, the three others of the six inputs of said logic subcircuit Kⁱ,j being connectd respectively to the two outputs H₂ⁱ and H₂^{i -} 1 of the said second decoder (DECOD H₂) of said upper address decoder means and the output H₃^j of the said third decoder (DECOD H₃) of said upper address decoder means, the said logic subcircuit thereby also performing the logic operation h₂^{i -} 1 + h₂ⁱ . h₃^j for these three inputs, where the lower case letters b and h designate the logic state of the corresponding outputs.

18. Optimizer according to claim 16, charactrized in that each logic subcircuit Kⁱ,j includes:

a second logic gate (PH) of NAND type, with one of the two inputs connected to the output H 3^j and the other to the output H₂ⁱ,

a third logic gate (PB) of NAND type, with two inputs connected to the output B₂ⁱ and the other to the output B₃^j,

a fourth gate (PBH) of NAND type, with four inputs, the first connected to the output of said second gate (PH), the second connected to the third gate (PB), the third connected to the output H₂^{i -} 1 complemented, denoted H₂^{i -} 1, and the fourth to the output B₂^{i +} 1 complemented, being B₂^{i +} 1, the output of the said fourth gate (PBH) being connected to one of the two inputs of said first-mentioned gate pⁱ,j of said logic circuit of said circuit means (V).

19. Optimizer according to claim 17, characterized in that said memory (M) comprises a plurality of integrated circuits and a buffer register is inserted between each integrated circuit of said memory and the gates pⁱ,j of said logic circuit for output enabling.

20. Optimizer according to claim 16, characterized in that the memory inputs are controlled by a switching system controlled by the outputs of the Kⁱ,j logic gates of said logic subcircuits and means are provided fow resetting to zero of the memory elements over the interval ]B, H] after forming the sum S.

21. Optimizer according to claim 15, characterized in that the memory of 16 lines of 16 bytes is composed of 16 memory cards in series, each card being made by the series connection of two 16 ×

4 bit integrated circuits.

22. Optimizer according to claim 11 characterized in that it includes an adder and a computation circuit means (Σ

) for computation of the sum S + B, connected to the output of said adder (ADD

     1), the output of said computation circuit means providing the address X up to which it is necessary to write in the 1s, the address X also being noted by X₁ X₂ X₃, where X₁ is the word formed by the four most significant address bits, X₂ the word formed by the four intermediate bits and X₃ the word formed by the three least significant bits.

23. Optimizer acccording to claim 21, characterized in that the said decision means are composed of second comparator means for comparing the address X delivered by the said compuation circuit means with the address of the cell representing the arrival point.

24. Optimizer according to claim 21, characterized in that the operator includes a memory (M) having as many 1 bit locations as cells, each bit representing one increment for one cell, each location having input and output means;

and in that the adder (ADD

     1) includes;

four adder circuits each receiving 31 1-bit words and each delivery one 5 bit word representing the sum of the bits of the 31 1-bit words that it has received; and

a fifth adder circuit with seven outputs receiving the said four 5-bit words and the 125, 126, and 127th bits of the same line of said memory (M) and delivering the sum S in the form of a 7-bit word.

25. Optimizer according to claim 1 for the searching of an optimum path between an initial state and a final state for a system with p variables T_i, where i is an index 1≦

i ≦

p, characterized in that it includes;

A. a plurality of suboptimizers each constituted as an optimizer according to claim 1 limited to a system of two variables, m being equal to 2, so that the coordinate sets are pairs of values and the representative space is a representative plane of N² points arranged equidistantly on intersecting straight lines defined by said points, each of said suboptimizers being organized as means for respectively finding and memorizing optimum elementary actions for the p(p₂ -

     1) systems of two variables T_i = m and T_{1 =} n with m ≈

n and

B. means for performing the recombination of these p(p₂ -

     1) optimum elementary actions, in such a manner

that the recombination gives the optimum elementary action for the system with p variables.

26. Optimizer for the search of an optimum path between an initial state and a final state for a system with p variables T_i, where i is an indice 1≦

i≦

p, characterized in that it includes;

A. a plurality of suboptimizers each constituted as an optimizer according to claim 1 limited to a system of two variables, m being equal to 2, so that the coordinate sets are pairs of values and the representative space is a representative plane of N² points arranged equidistantly on intersecting straight lines defined by said points, each of said suboptimizers being organized as means for respectively finding and memorizing, for each of the p(p₂ -

     1) systems considered as a function of two variables T_{i =} m and T_{i =} n with m ≈

n, the lengths of the three paths ending up on the three possible alternative succeeding states of the initial state, and

B. means for memorizing the 3 p(p₂ -

     1) lengths thus obtained; and

further characterized in that;

C. the decision means of said suboptimizers are combined into a common decision means for comparing the said 3 p(p₂ -

     1) lengths and selecting one of the 2^{p -} 1 possible successive states for the system with p variables, which defines the first optimum elementary action, and

D. means are provided for checking in each of the p(p₂ -

     1) planes that the said first optimum elementary action is compatible with the constraints set in for that plane by the setting in means of the corresponding suboptimizer.

2. each cell includes means for incrementation of its contents controlled by the aforesaid means for the setting in of coordinate values defining each constraint and includes means for sequentially delivering the said coordinate values of the constraints to the said incrementation means, the processing performed by the said operator thus being performed from constraint to constraint, and

the contents of each cell after processing of a constraint represents the difference between the number of steps performed on any one of the variables to pass the said constraint and the dummy number of steps which would lead to the same situation if the said constraint did not exist, so that the set of P contents can then be considered as representative of the difference expressed as the number of steps between the front of the said backward dummy wave and the front of the reference wave propagating in the same way as the dummy wave but not being disturbed by the said constraints.

4. Optimizer according to the claim 2, characterized in that the said decision means include means for comparing the respective contents of the three cells corresponding to the three possible succeeding states for the initial state, and selecting one of the three contents having the smallest value.

6. Optimizer according to claim 4, characterized in that said memory means comprises a plurality of random access memories arranged for being enabled in parallel.

7. Optimizer according to claim 4, characterized in that said addressing means includes first and second decoders and:

A. first register means for storing the base part of the upper address, having its output directed towards second comparator means for ensuring the operation of said first decoder and the provision of a stop order;

B. second register means for storing the displacement part of the upper address, having its output oriented both towards said second decoder and towards third comparator means for a part of the provision of said stop order;

C. a first counter and third register means for receiving the base part of the lower address, the output of said first counter being connected, via an adder to a second counter which contains the base + 1 part of the lower address and has its output directed both towards said second comparator means and towards fourth comparator means for the reinitialization of said memory means;

D. fourth register means for receiving the displacement part of the lower address having its output directed towards;

a. demultiplexer means for decoding an enabling signal for said memory means, the output of said demultiplexer means being oriented towards gate means for single or parallel enabling of said memory means;

b. a third decoder DECOD 11 having an output which serves, for the selection of a base address of said memory means and for activating a fourth decoder DECOD 12 having an output controlled by second gate means and constituting a write clock for said memory means;

c. subtractor means for computing the contents of the operator bus and receiving on its two inputs;

the output of third multiplexer means and the output of a fifth register, the output of said subtractor means constituting the said operator bus;

d. said third comparator means responsible for one part of the detection of said stop order,

E. a sixth register arranged to supply the contents of the upper address over the operator bus, and

F. a seventh register used in a write procedure.

8. Optimizer according to claim 4, characterized in that said control means is constituted by a microprocessor which includes, a clock (H) arranged for synchronizing and sequencing its operation, a read only memory in which a microprogram is stored and arranged for sequential addressing of its instructions, said read only memory having control output lines serving as outputs of said control means and test output lines for evaluating inputs to said control means from other portions of the optimizer at the various stages of the microprogram, a test decoder interconnected with said inputs and said test output lines through logic circuit means and with an operation code output of said read only memory so as to determine whether the next microprogram instruction should be addressed, and an ordinal counter (CO) interconnected with said read only memory, said clock and said test decoder so as to address the next instruction of said microprogram in response to a determination of said test decoder (FIG. 19).

9. Optimizer according to claim 4, characterized in that the interface means includes:

a simulator comprising a generalized interface,

a coupler having the form of a card installed in said computer with which said interface means connects,

and a maintenance console.