Method and apparatus for radio system cochannel interference suppression

• US 4,025,853 A
• Filed: 02/12/1976
• Issued: 05/24/1977
• Est. Priority Date: 02/12/1976
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Bell Telephone Laboratories, Inc. (Nokia Corporation)
• Original Assignee: Bell Telephone Laboratories, Inc. (Nokia Corporation)
• Inventors: Addeo, Eric John
• Primary Examiner(s): Griffin, Robert L.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Bookbinder, Marc E.
• Application Number:
  US05/657,564
• Time in Patent Office: 467 Days
• Field of Search: 325/51-53, 325/55, 325/64, 325/54, 325/466, 325/478, 343/177, 343/200, 343/205, 179/41 A, 340/311-313
• US Class Current: 455/422.1
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/2621 using frequency division multiple access [FDMA] H04B7/2615 takes precedence

Abstract

In a radio communication system of the cellular type wherein sets of communication channels are reused in different adjacent sets of cell areas within a common mobile communication service area, each cell base station utilizing a given set of channels in common with other base stations is assigned a different supervisory tone to be modulated on all of its channels. Any mobile unit receiving such channel transponds the modulated supervisory tone and sends it back to the base station. At each base station the transmitted and received supervisory tones for any given channel are compared to produce an indication of whether or not the sending mobile unit is actually communicating on the transmitted channel of the same base station. At each mobile unit, reference tones are generated which are spectrally located between adjacent ones of the possible supervisory tones for the mobile communication area, and the spectral position of a received tone with respect to the reference tones is determined. Signals representing that determination are translated into a digital character corresponding to the name of the received tone, and that name is compared with the name of the tone for the mobile unit'"'"'s assigned channel. A name mismatch is utilized to quiet the mobile unit receiver for the duration of the mismatch. In addition, if that duration exceeds a predetermined interval, the mobile unit controller is actuated to initiate the dropping of communication on the assigned channel.

Claims

1. In a radio communication system in which significant signal reception and demodulation is possible at one station from plural signal sources having the same nominal frequency, but only one of such sources is assigned for communication with such station and each source signal has modulated thereon a unique tone for that source as well as other frequencies, the system being characterized in that there are provided,

a filter in the station for separating a band of frequencies, including the tones, from substantially all other frequencies in a received and demodulated source signal,

a circuit for producing at least one reference frequency tone,

a circuit for producing a digital signal to indicate the relative frequency spectrum positions of the separated tone signal from the filter and of the reference tone, and

a circuit, responsive to the digital signal, for indicating whether or not the separated tone signal is the correct tone.

2. In a radio communication system,

means for receiving a plurality of signals having the same nominal frequency and having different tones modulated thereon, only one of said signals being desired for communication with said receiving means, said receiving means providing at an output thereof one of said plurality of signals,

means coupled to said receiving means output for selecting a sufficient band of signal frequencies to include all of said tones of the tone signal modulation to produce thereby a selected tone which is the one of said tones modulated on said one of said plurality of signals,

means for generating at least one reference tone, and

means, responsive to said selected tone signal in the output of said selecting means and to said reference tone, for producing a digital signal indicating the relative frequency spectral position of the selected tone signal with respect to said reference tone.

3. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 2 in which

said tones of said signals in said receiving means are spectrally adjacent to one another and spaced apart from each nearest one of said tones by a frequency which is much smaller than the tone frequency, and

said tone selecting means comprises

means for limiting the output of said receiving means to improve the signal-to-noise ratio thereof, and

phase-locked loop means for coupling the output of said limiting means to said digital signal producing means.

4. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 2 in which

said generating means includes means for fixing each of said at least one reference tone at a frequency which is not harmonically related to said nominal frequency, and

said digital signal producing means comprises

means for generating a signal having a magnitude that is a function of the frequency difference between said tone signal from said selecting means and said reference tone, and

means for producing a first or a second digital signal state in response to said magnitude being greater or less than a predetermined threshold magnitude, respectively.

5. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 2 which comprises

means responsive to an output of said receiving means for producing human-perceptible signals corresponding to other information modulated on said plurality of signals and

means are provided for determining whether or not said selected tone is the tone of said desired communication signal, said determining means comprising

each of said different tones having a predetermined frequency spectral position in relation to at least one reference tone,

means for storing a digital signal naming the tone modulated on said signal which is desired for communication with said receiving means,

means for translating said relative position digital signal into a digital signal naming the one of said different tones having approximately the same spectral position,

means for comparing said relative position digital signal and said storing means digital signal, and

means responsive to a mismatch indication from said comparing means for inhibiting said receiving means output to said human-perceptible signal producing means.

6. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 5 which further comprises

means for timing the duration of said mismatch indication, and

means for indicating when said mismatch indication persists for an interval in excess of a predetermined time.

7. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 2 in which said digital signal producing means comprises at least one set of

a cophasing circuit responsive to said selected tone signal and to one of said reference tones for generating respective pulse trains at approximately the frequencies of such tones and without coincident pulses,

means for reversibly counting pulses, said counting means having an input responsive to said pulse train at the frequency of said selected tone signal from said cophasing circuit for causing said counting means to count in a first direction and having an input responsive to said pulse train at the frequency of said reference tone from said cophasing circuit for causing said counting means to count in a second direction, and

means for coupling the most significant bit output of said counting means to an output of said producing means as said digital signal.

8. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 7 in which said cophasing circuit comprises

first and second multibit shift registers clocked at a shift rate which is much higher than any of said tones,

means for coupling said reference tone and said selected tone signal to data inputs of different ones of said shift registers,

means for coupling plural outputs of one of said shift registers to said counter first direction input,

means for coupling plural outputs of the other of said shift registers to the second direction input of said counting means, and

means responsive to all of said shift register outputs for inhibiting both of said coupling means in response to operation of said shift registers so as to indicate the occurrence of a simultaneous signal state transition in the tones applied to such shift registers.

9. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 7 in which there are at least three different ones of said modulated tones selectable by said selecting means, there are at least two of said reference tones each spectrally located between different adjacent pairs of the three modulated tones, and in which said digital signal producing means comprises

a further set of said cophasing circuit, said reversible counting means, and said most significant bit coupling means.

10. The radio communication system in accordance with claim 9 which comprises in addition

means for translating the digital signal represented by the most significant bit outputs of said counting means of all of said sets into a binary coded digital character which is the binary coded name of the selected tone.

11. A radio communication system of the cellular type wherein plural cell sets are assigned the same set of communication frequency channels and the cell-channel assignment pattern in each set is such that cells with the same channel assignments are at least a predetermined minimum distance apart so that interference-limited radio communication can be effected between a base station of any one of said cells and mobile radio stations in such cell, each of said cells which is within a potential interference range of another cell, and utilizing the same channel assignment, is assigned a tone which is different from a correspondingly assigned tone of said another cell and which is provided for modulation on its channel carrier frequencies by its base station, and said system comprises

in each base station and each mobile station,

means for selecting said assigned tones received at such station on a predetermined channel, and

means for evaluating the correctness of the selected tone with respect to the tone assigned for the station by comparing the selected tone to at least one reference tone,

said evaluating means comprises in a base station, means for comparing the assigned tone provided in the base station for modulation, as the reference, to the selected tone, and means for indicating whether or not there is a frequency difference in excess of a predetermined threshold between such tones, and

said evaluating means comprises in a mobile unit means for generating at least one reference tone which is different from any of said assigned tones, and means for indicating the relative frequency spectrum positions of the last-mentioned reference and selected tones.

12. In a radio communication system in which signal reception is possible at one station from plural signal sources having the same nominal frequency but only one of such sources is assigned for communication with such station and each such source signal has modulated thereon a unique tone for that source as well as other frequencies, a method for verifying reception of said one source signal comprising the steps of

separating a band of frequencies, including the tones, from substantially all other frequencies in a received source signal,

producing at least one reference frequency tone,

producing a digital signal to indicate the relative frequency spectrum positions of a dominant one of the separated tones and of the reference tone, and

determining in response to said digital signal whether or not the dominant tone is the correct tone.