Adaptive control system for numerically controlled machine tools

• US 4,078,195 A
• Filed: 01/13/1976
• Issued: 03/07/1978
• Est. Priority Date: 01/13/1976
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Macotech Corporation
• Original Assignee: Macotech Corporation
• Inventors: Mathias, Richard A., Miller, Edward N., Adams, Lyle C.
• Primary Examiner(s): Schaefer, Robert K.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Feldhaus, John J.
• Application Number:
  US05/648,640
• Time in Patent Office: 784 Days
• Field of Search: 318/561, 318/571, 318/590, 318/591, 318/39, 235/150.1, 235/151.1, 235/151.11
• US Class Current: 318/561
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 19/4163 Adaptive control of feed or cutting velocity without NC B23Q15/12

Abstract

Prior art adaptive control systems for numerically-controlled milling machines are first discussed in which N/C instructions and adaptive control system data are obtained and stored in a storage medium utilizing a software routine which takes into consideration parameters of the milling process and parameters of a specific milling machine. The instructions and data command, for sequential steps in the milling process, such items as spindle position, feedrate and reference milling forces and are supplied to an N/C unit and to the adaptive control system at the milling machine to automatically control the milling process. The adaptive control system includes a milling force sensor and functions to override the commanded feedrate on comparison of the actual milling forces during the process with the reference milling forces. An improvement is then discussed which modifies the adaptive control system data so that the data can be used on any milling machine having an N/C unit capable of responding to the N/C storage medium in which the N/C instructions and adaptive control system data are stored. A set of universal adaptive control variables are included in the adaptive control data. The adaptive control system at the milling machine is modified to respond to these universal adaptive control variables and further to internally store machine constants for the specific milling machine with which the adaptive control system is utilized. The improved adaptive control system then recomputes the adaptive control data including reference milling forces in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and the machine constants and utilizes the recomputed adaptive control system data to override where necessary the commanded feedrate. In addition, provision is made in the improved adaptive control system for further modifying the adaptive control system data by operator-entered manual process control inputs. Applications of such improved adaptive control systems to numerically-controlled machine tools other than milling machines are also discussed.

Claims

1. An improved adaptive control system for use in combination with a numerically-controlled machine tool including an N/C unit capable of controlling the machine tool in a sequence of desired operational steps to provide a desired machining process in response to a set of N/C instructions contained in an N/C storage medium, the N/C unit further including input means responsive to an override signal to modify at least one selected operation of the machine tool;

an N/C storage medium containing a set of N/C instructions for a desired machining process which have been computed for a hypothetical machine tool having a predetermined operational capability, and further containing adaptive control system data including a reference value of at least one selected machining process variable which has been computed for operation of the hypothetical machine tool, the adaptive control system data further including a plurality of universal adaptive control variables containing information sufficient to allow the reference value of the selected machining process variable to be recomputed in accordance with the operational capability of the specific machine tool; and

data reading means coupled with the N/C storage medium for supplying the set of N/C instructions to the N/C unit and the adaptive control system data to the improved adaptive control system, the improved adaptive control system comprising;

a. storage means including machine constant data representing the operational capability of the specific machine tool with which the improved adaptive control system is utilized,

b. a machining process sensor coupled with the machine tool for providing an output signal representing the actual value of the selected machining process variable,

c. set-up means recomputing the reference value in the adaptive control system data in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data to obtain a new reference value,

d. control means comparing said new reference value with said output signal from said machining process sensor to obtain an override signal, and

e. means coupling said override signal to the input means of the N/C unit to allow modification of the selected operation of the machine tool.

2. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 1, wherein the adaptive control system data contained in N/C storage medium further includes a plurality of reference values for selected operational steps in the desired machining process, and sequence data relating each of said plurality of reference values to the specific operational steps for which said reference value is to be used;

wherein said set-up means further recomputes each of said reference values in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data to obtain a plurality of new reference values; and

further comprising means supplying said plurality of new reference values to said control means one at a time in response to the sequence data.

3. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 1, further comprising manual process control input means for providing a first signal representing an operator-selected reference value of the selected machining process variable;

second storage means having said first signal coupled thereto for storing said operator-selected reference value; and

means supplying said operator-selected reference value to said control means in place of said new reference value.

4. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 3, wherein the adaptive control system data contained in the N/C storage medium further includes a plurality of reference values for selected operational steps in the desired machining process, and sequence data relating each of said plurality of reference values to the specific operational steps for which said each reference value is to be used;

wherein said set-up means further recomputes each of said reference values in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data to obtain a plurality of new reference values; and

further comprising means supplying said plurality of new reference values to said control means one at a time in response to the sequence data;

wherein said manual process control input means provides a plurality of said first signals representing a plurality of operator-selected reference values of the selected machining process variable and a plurality of second signals representing operator-selected sequence data relating each of said plurality of first signals to the specific operational steps in the machining process for which the operator-selected reference value is to be utilized;

wherein said second storage means is operative to store said plurality of operator-selected reference values and said operator-selected sequence data; and

wherein said supplying means comprises means comparing said sequence data includes in the adaptive control system data with said operator-selected sequence data and supplying the corresponding operator-selected reference value to said control means in place of said new reference value upon correspondence between the sequence data and said operator-selected sequence data.

5. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 1, wherein the machine tool is a milling machine having at least one rotatable spindle for holding a cutter which engages a workpiece during a milling process;

wherein the selected operation of the machine tool which is modified in response to said override signal is feedrate of the cutter with respect to the workpiece;

wherein the selected machine process variable is milling force exerted on the machine'"'"'s spindle during the milling process; and

wherein said machining process sensor comprises a milling force sensor responsive to deflection of the cutter.

6. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 5, further comprising manual process control input means for providing an input signal representing an operator-selected reference value of milling force;

second storage means coupled to said manual process control input means for storing said operator-selected reference value; and

means supplying said operator-selected reference value to said control means in place of said new reference value.

7. An improved adaptive control system for use in combination with a numerically-controlled milling machine including an N/C unit capable of controlling the milling machine in a sequence of desired operational steps to provide a desired milling process in response to a set of N/C instructions contained in an N/C storage medium, the N/C unit further including input means responsive to a feedrate override signal to proportionally modify a feedrate of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle with respect to a workpiece as commanded by a set of N/C instructions;

an N/C storage medium containing a set of N/C instructions for a desired milling process which have been computed for a hypothetical milling machine which is stiffer and more powerful than any milling machine with which the N/C storage medium will be used, the set of N/C instructions including a feedrate command designating a predetermined feedrate of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle with respect to a workpiece during the milling process, the N/C storage medium further containing adaptive control system data including a reference value of milling force exerted on a cutter held in the milling machine'"'"'s spindle during the milling process, the reference value having been computed for operation of the hypothetical machine tool, the adaptive control system data further including a plurality of universal adaptive control variables containing information sufficient to allow the reference value of milling force to be recomputed in accordance with the operational capability of a specific milling machine; and

data reading means coupled with the N/C storage medium for supplying the set of N/C instructions to the N/C unit and the adaptive control system data to the improved adaptive control system, the improved adaptive control system comprising;

a. storage means including machine constant data representing the operational capability, including stiffness, of the specific milling machine with which the improved adaptive control system is utilized,

b. a milling force sensor coupled with the milling machine for providing an output signal representing the actual value of milling force during the milling process,

c. set-up means recomputing the reference value of milling force in the adaptive control system data in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data to obtain a new reference value,

d. control means comparing said new reference value with said output signal from said milling process sensor to obtain a first feedrate override signal, and

e. means coupling said first feedrate override signal to the input means of the N/C unit to allow modification of the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions during operation of the milling machine.

8. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 7, wherein the adaptive control system data contained in the N/C storage medium further includes a plurality of reference values for selected operational steps in the desired milling process, and sequence data relating each of said plurality of reference values to the specific operation steps in the milling process for which said each reference value is to be used;

wherein said set-up means further recomputes each of said reference values in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data to obtain a plurality of new reference values; and

further comprising means supplying said plurality of new reference values to said control means one at a time in response to the sequence data.

9. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 8, wherein said set-up means computes a plurality of feedrate scaling factors in accordance with the universal adaptive control variables and said machine constant data, one such feedrate scaling factor being provided for each operational step of the milling process identified by said sequence data;

and further comprising multiplying means modifying said first feedrate override signal by said plurality of feedrate scaling factors, one at a time in response to said sequence data.

10. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 9 further comprising:

manual process control input means for providing a plurality of first signals representing a plurality of operator-selected reference values of milling force, a plurality of second signals representing a plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors, and a plurality of third signals representing operator-selected sequence data relating each of said plurality of first and second signals to the specific operational steps in the milling process for which the operator-selected reference values of milling force and operator-selected feedrate scaling factors are to be used;

a second storage means operative to store said plurality of operator-selected reference values, said plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors, and said operator-selected sequence data; and

means comparing said sequence data included in the adaptive control system data with said operator-selected sequence data and supplying said plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors to said control means and to said multiplying means in place of said new reference values and said feedrate scaling factors upon correspondence between the sequence data and said operator-selected sequence data.

11. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 7, further comprising:

a spindle motor horsepower sensor providing a second output signal representing actual horsepower output of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle motor;

a source of a reference horsepower signal;

second control means comparing said reference horsepower signal with said second output signal to provide a second feedrate override signal; and

means coupling the smaller of said first and said second feedrate override signals to the N/C unit as a feedrate override signal.

12. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 11, wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include predicted spindle horsepower of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle motor at the feedrate designated by the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions;

wherein said machine constant data includes the available horsepower of such specific milling machine'"'"'s spindle motor;

wherein said set-up means further computes a horsepower-related feedrate scaling factor from said predicted spindle horsepower and said available horsepower; and

further comprising multiplyng means modifying said first and second feedrate override signals by said horsepower-related feedrate scaling factor.

13. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 7, wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include predicted milling force at the feedrate designated by the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions;

wherein said set-up means further computes a reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor from said predicted milling force and said new reference force; and

further comprising multiplying means modifying said first feedrate override signal by said reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor.

14. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 7, wherein said machine constant data includes a spindle force rating of said specific milling machine;

and wherein said set-up means further computes as said new reference value, the smaller of said spindle force rating and the reference value of milling force in the adaptive control system data.

15. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 7, wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include an allowable deflection DMAX of the cutter, a length CHL of the cutter and a tool holder, a combined rigidity RCW of the cutter, holder and workpiece, and an axial length AD of the cut;

wherein said machine constant data includes a plurality of spindle stiffness values for said specific milling machine, and a distance Z from the plane of zero-bearing deflection to the face of the spindle;

wherein said set-up means further computes;

a. a distance L from the plane of zero-bearing deflection to the end of the cutter using said length CHL and said distance Z,

b. a net rigidity RA of cutter, holder and spindle at the plane of the load centroid using said spindle stiffness coefficients, said new reference value, and said distance L,

c. a net rigidity RB of cutter, holder and spindle at the end of the cutter using said net rigidity RA, said distance L and said axial length AD,

d. a net rigidity RT of cutter, holder, spindle and workpiece using said net rigidity RB and said combined rigidity RCW,

e. a deflection DFL of the cutter, holder and spindle at the end of the cutter using said net rigidity RT and said new reference value, and

f. a force FMN required to deflect the cutter to the allowable deflection DMAX using said allowable deflection DMAX, said deflection DFL, and said new reference value; and

wherein said set-up means further compares said force FNM with said new reference value and, if said force FNM is less than said new reference value, sets said new reference value equal to said force FNM and recomputes said net rigidity RA, said net rigidity RB, said net rigidity RT, said deflection DFL and said force FNM until said new reference value is equal to or less than said force FNM.

16. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 15, wherein the universal adaptive control variables and the adaptive control system data include predicted milling force at the feedrate designated by the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions;

wherein said set-up means further computes a reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor from said predicted milling force and said new reference force; and

further comprising multiplying means modifying said first feedrate override signal by said reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor.

17. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 15, wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include a ratio of chip load for optimum cutting efficiency and programmed chip load for the milling process, wherein said set-up means further computes a cutting-efficiency-related feedrate scaling factor from said chip load ratio, said net rigidity RT and said combined rigidity RCW;

and further comprising multiplying means modifying said first feedrate override signal by said cutting-efficiency-related feedrate scaling factor.

18. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 17, wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include predicted milling force at the feedrate designated by the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions;

wherein said set-up means further computes a reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor from said predicted milling force and multiplies said reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor by a first predetermined number greater than unity to obtain a resultant reference-force-related feedrate scaling factor; and

wherein said multiplying means modifies said first feedrate override signal by the smaller of said resultant reference-force-related and said cutting-efficiency-related feedrate scaling factors.

19. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 18, further comprising a spindle motor horsepower sensor providing a second output signal representing actual horsepower output of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle motor;

a source of a reference horsepower signal;

a second control means comparing said reference horsepower signal with said second output signal to provide a second feedrate override signal;

wherein the universal adaptive control variables in the adaptive control system data include predicted spindle horsepower of the milling machine'"'"'s spindle motor at the feedrate designated by the feedrate command in the set of N/C instructions;

wherein said machine constant data includes the available horsepower of said specific milling machine spindle motor;

wherein said set-up means further computes a horsepower-related feedrate scaling factor from said predicted spindle horsepower and said available horsepower;

wherein said set-up means multiplies said horsepower-related feedrate scaling factor by a second predetermined number greater than unity to obtain a resultant horsepower-related feedrate scaling factor;

wherein said multiplying means modifies said first and second feedrate override signals by the smallest of said resultant reference-force-related, said cutting-efficiency related and resultant horsepower-related feedrate scaling factors; and

further comprising means coupling the smaller of said first and said second feedrate override signals to the N/C unit as a feedrate override signal.

20. An improved adaptive control system for use in combination with a numerically-controlled machine tool including an N/C unit capable of controlling the machine tool in a sequence of desired operational steps to provide a desired machining process in response to a set of N/C instructions contained in an N/C storage medium, the N/C unit further including input means responsive to an override signal to modify at least one selected operation of the machine tool;

an N/C storage medium containing a set of N/C instructions for a desired machining process which have been computed for a hypothetical machine tool having a predetermined operational capability, and further containing adaptive control system data including a reference value of at least one selected machining process variable which has been computed for operation of the hypothetical machine tool; and

data reading means supplying a set of N/C instructions to the N/C unit and the adaptive control system data to the improved adaptive control system, the improved adaptive control system comprising;

a. a machining process sensor coupled with the machine tool for providing an output signal representing the actual value of the selected machining process variable,

b. manual process control input means for providing a first signal representing an operator-selected reference value of the selected machining process variable,

c. storage means having said first signal coupled thereto for storing said operator-selected reference value,

d. control means comparing said reference value with said output signal from said machining process sensor to obtain an override signal,

e. means supplying said operator-selected reference value to said control means in place of said reference value, and

f. means coupling said override signal to the input means of the N/C unit to allow modification of the selected operation of the machine tool.

21. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 20, wherein the adaptive control system data contained in the N/C storage medium further includes a plurality of reference values for selected operational steps in the desired machining process, and sequence data relating each of said plurality of reference values to the specific operational steps for which said each reference value is to be used;

further comprising means supplying said plurality of reference values to said control means one at a time in response to the sequence data;

wherein said manual process control input means provides a plurality of said first signals representing a plurality of operator-selected reference values of the selected machining process variable and a plurality of second signals representing operator-selected sequence data relating each of said plurality of first signals to the specific operational steps in the machining process for which the operator-selected reference value represented by said each first signal is to be used, wherein said storage means is operative to store said plurality of operator-selected reference values and said operator-selected sequence data; and

wherein said supplying means comprises means comparing said sequence data included in the adaptive control system data with said operator-selected sequence data and supplying the corresponding operator-selected reference value to said control means in place of said reference value upon correspondence between the sequence data and said operator selected sequence data.

22. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 20, wherein the machine tool is a milling machine having at least one rotatable spindle for holding a cutter which engages a workpiece during a milling process;

wherein the selected operation of the machine tool which is modified in response to said override signal is feedrate of the cutter with respect to the workpiece;

wherein the selected machine process variable is milling force exerted on the machine'"'"'s spindle during the milling process; and

wherein said machining process sensor comprises a milling force sensor responsive to deflection of the cutter.

23. An improved adaptive control system as recited in claim 22, wherein the adaptive control system data contained in the N/C storage medium further includes a plurality of reference values for selected operational steps in the desired milling process, and sequence data relating each of said plurality of reference values to the sepcific operational steps in the milling process for which said each reference value is to be used;

further comprising means supplying said plurality of reference values to said control means one at a time in response to the sequence data;

wherein said manual process control input means further provides a plurality of said first signals representing a plurality of operator-selected reference values of milling force, a plurality of second signals representing a plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors, and a plurality of third signals representing operator-selected sequence data relating each of said plurality of first and second signals to the specific operational steps in the milling process for which the operator-selected reference values of milling force and operatorselected feedrate scaling factors are to be used;

wherein said storage means is operative to store said plurality of operator-selected reference values, said plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors, and said operator-selected sequence data;

further comprising multiplying means modifying said override signal by said plurality of operator-selected feedrate scaling factors one at a time in response to said operator-selected sequence data; and

wherein said supplying means comprises means comprising said sequence data included in the adaptive control system data with said operator-selected sequence data and supplying the corresponding operatorselected reference value to said control means in place of said reference value upon correspondence between the sequence data and said operatorselected sequence data.