Signal selection apparatus for redundant signal sources

• US 4,105,900 A
• Filed: 02/16/1977
• Issued: 08/08/1978
• Est. Priority Date: 02/16/1977
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: The Boeing Co.
• Original Assignee: The Boeing Co.
• Inventors: Martin, Donald L., Yanke, David B.
• Primary Examiner(s): Zazworsky, John
• Application Number:
  US05/769,395
• Time in Patent Office: 538 Days
• Field of Search: 307/204, 307/219, 307/243, 307/355, 307/357, 244/194, 318/564
• US Class Current: 327/526
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 9/03 with multiple-channel loop, i.e. redundant control systems
• CPC Class Codes: G05D 1/0077 using redundant signals or controls

Abstract

Apparatus for signal selection and signal consolidation of the redundant sensor signals in a triply redundant control system wherein one of the redundant sensors supplies precise information and the remaining two sensors supply less precise information is disclosed. Signal selection is based on the operational state of the three sensors, with the signal provided by the precision sensor being selected whenever the precision sensor is operational. If the precision sensor fails, each channel is supplied with a signal that is a weighted average of the signals supplied by the two less accurate sensors. In some arrangements of the invention whenever the precision sensor has not failed, but supplies a signal that deviates substantially from the signals being supplied by the two less accurate sensors, the signal supplied to each channel of the control system is a weighted average of all three sensor signals. In other arrangements of the invention, a weighted average of the signals supplied by the two less precise sensors is provided whenever the precision sensor fails and whenever the precision sensor has not failed, but supplies a signal that deviates substantially from the signals being supplied by the two less accurate sensors. To prevent abrupt variations in the signal supplied to the control system, the signal supplied by the signal selection apparatus smoothly transists from the signal being supplied at the time a particular failure condition occurs to the signal to be supplied following that failure.

Claims

1. Signal selection apparatus for supplying an output signal derived from a plurality of redundant signals supplied by a plurality of signal sources, each of said redundant signals representing substantially identical information with one of said signal sources being a precision signal source supplying more precise signal information than the remaining ones of said signal sources, said signal selection apparatus comprising:

signal selection means responsive to a signal source failure signal associated with each of said signal sources, each of said signal source failure signals indicating when the signal source associated therewith is operational and indicating when the signal source associated therewith operates in a failure state, said signal source selection means further responsive to said plurality of redundant signals, said signal source selection means including logic means for comparing said more precise signal supplied by said precision signal source with the signals supplied by the remaining signal sources, said logic means including means for supplying a first selection signal having a first predetermined value when the magnitude of said more precise signal exceeds the magnitude of each of the redundant signals supplied by said remaining signal sources by a first predetermined amount and having a second predetermined value when the magnitude of said more precise signal does not exceed the magnitude of each of said redundant signals supplied by said remaining signal sources by said first predetermined amount, said logic means further including means for supplying a second selection signal when said first selection signal is of said second predetermined value and said failure signal associated with said precision signal source indicates said precision signal source is operational; and

signal consolidation means responsive to said redundant signals and responsive to said first and second selection signals for supplying said output signal, said signal consolidation means including means for supplying said more precise signal as said output signal when said signal selection means supplies said second selection signal, said signal consolidation means including means responsive to said signal source failure signal associated with said precision signal source for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of said signals supplied by said remaining signal sources whenever said signal source failure signal associated with said precision signal source indicates said precision signal source is operating in said failure state, said signal consolidation means further including means responsive to said first selection signal for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of at least said signals supplied by said remaining signal sources whenever said first selection signal is said first predetermined value.

2. The signal selection apparatus of claim 1 wherein said signal consolidation means responsive to said signal source failure signal associated with said precision signal source and said signal consolidation means responsive to said first selection signal each supply said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of said signals supplied by said remaining signal sources, said mathematically weighted average being equal to the summation of the instantaneous signal value supplied by each of said remaining signal sources divided by the number of said remaining signal sources.

3. The signal selection apparatus of claim 1 wherein said signal consolidation means responsive to said first selection signal supplies said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of all of said redundant signals, said mathematically weighted average being equal to the summation of the instantaneous signal values supplied by each of said remaining signal sources multiplied by a first rational number (a - 1)/an added to a quantity equal to the instantaneous signal value supplied by said precision signal source multiplied by a second rational number 1/a where a is a selected integer and n is the number of signal sources included in said remaining signal sources.

4. The signal selection apparatus of claim 1 wherein said signal consolidation means includes signal transition means for supplying said output signal during a predetermined time interval subsequent to the time at which said logic means initially supplies said first and second selection signals and for supplying said output signal during a predetermined interval of time subsequent to the time at which said signal source failure signal associated with said precision signal source indicates that said precision signal source is operating in said failure state, said signal transition means including means for supplying said output signal during said subsequent time interval as a signal that smoothly transits between that output signal supplied by said signal consolidation means at a time immediately prior to said logic means initiating said first and second signal selection signal and immediately prior to said signal source failure signal indicating operation of said precision signal source in said failure state to said output signal supplied by said signal consolidation means at the time said predetermined interval of time terminates.

5. Signal selection apparatus for supplying an output signal derived from a plurality of redundant input signals, each of said redundant input signals being supplied by a signal source with one of said signal sources supplying a more precise signal than the remaining ones of said signal sources, said signal selection apparatus comprising:

detection means responsive to said redundant signals for supplying signal source failure signals associated with each of said redundant signal sources, said signal source failure signals being representative of the operational state of each of said signal sources to indicate when each of said signal sources fails to provide a reliable signal and to indicate when each of said signal sources provides a reliable signal;

signal selection logic means responsive to said signal source failure signals and responsive to said redundant signals for supplying at least a first and second signal selection signal, said signal selection logic means including comparator means for comparing said more precise signal with each of the remaining redundant signals supplied by said remaining signal sources, said comparator means including means for supplying said first signal selection signal when the magnitude of said more precise signal exceeds the magnitude of each of said remaining redundant signals by at least a predetermined threshold value, said signal selection logic means further including means for supplying said second signal selection signal when said signal source failure signal associated with the signal source supplying said more precise signal indicates said more precise signal source supplies a reliable signal and said first selection signal is not supplied by said comparator means; and

signal consolidation means responsive to said redundant signals supplied by said signal sources and responsive to said first and second signal selection signals for supplying said output signal derived from said redundant input signals, said signal consolidation means including first signal means for supplying said more precise signal as said output signal whenever said signal selection logic means supplies said second signal selection signal, said signal consolidation means including second signal means for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of said remaining redundant signals supplied by said signal sources other than the more precise signal source during periods of time when the failure signal associated with said more precise signal source indicates that said more precise signal source is not reliable, said signal consolidation means further including third signal means for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of at least said remaining redundant signals whenever said signal selection means supplies said first signal selection signal to indicate said more precise signal exceeds each of said remaining signals by at least said first predetermined threshold value.

6. The signal selection apparatus of claim 5 wherein said third signal means of said signal consolidation means includes means for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of said remaining redundant signals supplied by said signal sources other than said more precise signal source.

7. The signal selection apparatus of claim 6 wherein said mathematically weighted average of said remaining redundant signals is numerically equal to the summation of the instantaneous signal values of each of said remaining redundant signals divided by the number of signal sources other than said more precise signal source.

8. The signal selection apparatus of claim 5 wherein said third signal means of said signal consolidation means includes means for supplying said output signal as a mathematically weighted average of all of said redundant signals.

9. The signal selection apparatus of claim 8 wherein said mathematically weighted average of all of said redundant signals is equal to the product of 1/a times the instantaneous signal value of said more precise signal added to a quantity equal to the product of (a - 1)/an times the summation of the instantaneous signal values of said remaining redundant signals where a is a predetermined integer and n is the number of signal sources other than said more precise signal source.

10. Signal selection apparatus for supplying an output signal derived from first, second and third redundant input signals wherein said first redundant input signal is a more precise signal than said second and third redundant signals in that the information conveyed by said redundant signals is more accurately represented by said more precise signal than said information is represented by the less precise second and third redundant input signals, said signal selection apparatus comprising:

signal selection logic responsive to first, second and third signal failure signals for supplying first, second and third signal selection signals, said first, second and third signal failure signals being respectively associated with said first, second and third redundant signals, each of said first, second and third signal failure signals having a first predetermined value when said associated redundant signal is supplied by a fully operational signal source, each of said first, second and third signal failure signals having a second predetermined value when said associated redundant signal is supplied by a non operational signal source, said signal selection logic including means for supplying a logic signal wherever the magnitude of said first redundant signal deviates from the magnitude of each of said second and third redundant signals by a first predetermined amount, said logic signal being a first predetermined value when said deviation between said magnitude of said first redundant signal and said magnitudes of said second and third redundant signals exceeds said first predetermined amount and being a second predetermined value when said deviation between said magnitude of said first redundant signal and said magnitudes of said second and third redundant signals is less than said first predetermined amount, said signal selection logic including means for supplying said first signal selection signal when said first failure signal is of said first predetermined value and either of said second and third failure signals is of said second predetermined value or said logic signal is of said second predetermined value, said signal selection logic means including means for supplying said second signal selection signal when said first, second and third failure signals are said first predetermined value and said logic signal is of said first predetermined value, said signal selection logic means further including means for supplying said third signal selection signal when said first failure signal is said second predetermined value; and

,

signal consolidation means responsive to said first, second and third redundant signals and responsive to said first, second and third signal selection signals for supplying said output signal, said signal consolidation means including first signal combining means for combining said second and third redundant signals to supply a first weighted signal mathematically equal to the sum of one-half the instantaneous value of said second redundant signal and one-half the instantaneous signal value of said third redundant signal, said signal consolidation means including second signal combining means for combining said first redundant signal and said first weighted signal to supply a second weighted signal mathematically equal to the sum of one-half the instantaneous value of said first redundant signal and one-half the instantaneous value of said first weighted signal, said signal consolidation means including first, second and third signal paths individually and respectively associated with said first, second and third signal selection signals, said first signal path including means for supplying said first redundant signal as said output signal when said associated first signal selection signal is supplied by said signal selection logic, said second signal path including means for supplying said second weighted signal as said output signal when said associated second signal selection signal is supplied by said signal selection logic, said third signal path including means for supplying said first weighted signal as said output signal when said associated third signal selection signal is supplied by said signal selection logic.

11. The signal selection apparatus of claim 10 wherein said first, second and third signal paths of said signal consolidation means respectively include first, second and third controlled gain means, each of said first, second and third controlled gain means having an input terminal and an output terminal, the input terminals of said first, second and third controlled gain means respectively connected for receiving said first redundant signal, said second weighted signal and said first weighted signal, said output terminal of said first, second and third controlled gain means being coupled to one another for supplying said output signal of said signal selection apparatus, said first, second and third controlled gain means being respectively associated with said first, second and third signal selection signals to exhibit a gain factor of substantially unity when the associated one of said first, second and third signal selection signals is supplied by said signal selection logic, said first, second and third controlled gain means exhibiting a gain factor of substantially zero when a signal selection signal other than said associated signal selection signal is suplied by said signal selection logic.

12. The signal selection apparatus of claim 11 wherein each of said first, second and third signal paths further includes a first summing means having an additive input terminal, a subtractive input terminal, and an output terminal, the output terminals of said first summing means of said first, second and third signal paths being respectively connected to the input terminals of said first, second and third controlled gain means, the additive input terminals of said first summing means of said first, second and third signal paths being respectively connected for receiving said first redundant signal, said second weighted signal and said first weighted signal, each of said first, second and third signal paths further including a second summing means having an additive input terminal, a first subtractive input terminal and an output terminal, said first subtractive input terminal of each of said second summing means of said first, second and third signal paths being connected to receive said output signal of said signal selection apparatus, said additive input terminal of said second summing means of each of said first, second and third signal paths being connected to the output terminal of that one of said first summing means located within the same one of said first, second and third signal paths, each of said first, second and third signal paths further including integrating means having an input terminal and an output terminal, said input terminal of said integrating means of said first, second and third signal paths being connected to said output terminal of that one of said second summing means located within the same one of said first, second and third signal paths, said output terminal of each of said integrating means of said first, second and third signal paths being connected to said subtractive input terminal of that one of said first summing means located within the same one of said first, second and third signal paths.

13. The signal selection apparatus of claim 12 wherein each of said second summing means of each of said first, second and third signal paths further includes a second subtractive input terminal, said first signal path further including first feedback means connected between said output terminal of said first signal path integrating means and said second subtractive terminal of that one of said second summing means located in said first signal path, said second signal path further including second feedback means connected between said output terminal of said second signal path integrating means and said second subtractive input terminal of that one of said second summing means located in said second signal path, said third signal path further including third feedback means connected between said output terminal of said third signal path integrating means and said second subtractive input terminal of said second summing means located in said third signal path, each of said first, second and third feedback means respectively responsive to said first, second and third signal selection signals to exhibit a predetermined gain factor when that one of said first, second and third signal selection signals associated with the signal path including said first, second and third feedback means is supplied by said signal selection logic, each of said first, second and third feedback means exhibiting a gain factor of substantially zero when a first, second and third signal selection signal that is not associated with said one of said signal paths including said first, second and third feedback means is supplied by said signal selection logic.

14. A triply redundant signal selection system comprising:

first, second and third redundant signal sources for supplying first, second and third redundant signals, and first redundant signal source being a precision signal source for supplying a more precise signal than the signals supplied by said second and third signal sources;

failure detection means for defining an operational state and a failure state for each of said first, second and third signal sources, said failure detection means including first comparator means responsive to said first, second and third redundant signals for comparing said first, second and third redundant signals one with another, said first comparison means including means for supplying a first failure signal having a first predetermined value when said first redundant signal is greater than each of said second and third redundant signals by a predetermined amount and having a second predetermined value when said first redundant signal does not exceed said second and third redundant signals by said predetermined amount, said first comparator means including means for supplying a second failure signal having a first predetermined value when said second redundant signal is greater than each of said first and third redundant signals by a predetermined amount and having a second predetermined value when said second redundant signal does not exceed said first and third redundant signals by said predetermined amount, said first comparator means further including means for supplying a third failure signal having a first predetermined value when said third redundant signal is greater than each of said first and second redundant signals by a predetermined amount and having a second predetermined value when said third redundant signal does not exceed said first and second redundant signals by said predetermined amount;

signal selection logic means responsive to said first, second and third redundant signals and responsive to said first, second and third failure signals for supplying signal selection signals, said signal selection logic including second comparator means responsive to said first, second and third redundant signals for detecting when said first redundant signal deviates from both said second and third redundant signals by at least a predetermined signal deviation, said second comparator means including means for supplying a suspect state signal having a first predetermined value when said deviation of said first redundant signal from said second and third redundant signals exceeds said predetermined signal deviation and having a second predetermined value when said deviation of said first redundant signal from said second and third redundant signals does not exceed said predetermined signal deviation, said signal selection logic means including means for supplying a first selection signal when said first failure signal is said second predetermined value concurrently with one of said second and third failure signals being said first predetermined value and for supplying a first selection signal when said first failure signal is said second predetermined value concurrently with said suspect state signal being said second predetermined value; and

signal consolidation means responsive to said first, second and third redundant signals and said selection signals supplied by said signal selection logic for supplying an output signal derived from said first, second and third redundant signals, said signal consolidation means including first signal control means responsive to said first signal selection signal for supplying said first redundant signal as said output signal whenever said first signal selection signal is supplied by said signal selection logic means, said signal consolidation means including second signal control means responsive to said first signal selection signal for supplying a first mathematically weighted signal including equal signal contribution from at least said second and third redundant signals whenever said first signal selection signal is not supplied.

15. The triply redundant signal selection system of claim 14 wherein said signal selection logic further includes means for supplying a second signal selection signal when said suspect signal is said first predetermined value concurrent with each of said first, second and third failure signals being said second predetermined value, said signal selection logic further including means for supplying a third signal selection signal when said first failure signal is said first predetermined value;

and, wherein said second signal control means of said signal consolidation means is responsive to said third signal selection signal to supply said first mathematically weighted signal as a signal equal to the sum of one-half of each of said second and third redundant signals whenever said third signal selection signal is supplied by said signal selection logic, said signal consolidator means further including third signal control means for supplying a second mathematically weighted signal as said output signal when said signal selection logic supplies said second signal selection signal, said second mathematically weighted signal being equal to the sum of one-half said first mathematically weighted signal and one-half of said first redundant signal.

16. The signal selection system of claim 15 wherein said signal consolidator means further includes transient control means responsive to said first, second and third signal selection signals to control said output signal during a predetermined time interval immediately subsequent to said signal selection logic means supplying said first, second and third signal selection signals, said transient control means including means for establishing the value of said output signal at the time at which said first, second and third signal selection signals are supplied equal to a first output value, said first output value being substantially equal to the value of said output signal supplied immediately prior to the time at which said first, second and third signal selection signals are supplied by said signal selection logic means, said transient control means further including means for supplying said output signal at predetermined values intermediate to and mathematically related to said first output value and the value of said output signal being supplied by said first, second and third signal control means of said signal consolidation means, said transient control means being configured and arranged to supply an output signal during said predetermined time interval that smoothly transists between said first output value and the value of said output signal being supplied by said first, second and third signal control means at the time said predetermined time interval ends.