System and method for operating a steam turbine and an electric power generating plant

• US 4,258,424 A
• Filed: 09/07/1976
• Issued: 03/24/1981
• Est. Priority Date: 12/29/1972
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Company LLC (Brookfield Asset Management Incorporated)
• Original Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Company LLC (Brookfield Asset Management Incorporated)
• Inventors: Giras, Theodore C., Birnbaum, Manfred E.
• Primary Examiner(s): Wise, Edward J.
• Application Number:
  US05/720,725
• Time in Patent Office: 1,659 Days
• Field of Search: 235/151.21, 235/151.31, 235/151, 60/660, 60/105, 384/493, 384/494
• US Class Current: 700/290
• CPC Class Codes: F01D 17/04 responsive to load
• CPC Class Codes: F05D 2200/13 Product

Abstract

A programmed digital computer control system determines the turbine steam flow changes required to satisfy the speed and load demand made on the operation of a large electric power stream turbine for which substantially constant throttle pressure steam is generated. Load control is directed to plant electric power generation and it is based on feedforward valve positioning operation with feedback multiplication calibration for plant load and/or turbine speed error. Changes in the turbine operating level are limited by dynamic constraints applied by the computer.

Claims

1. A system for operating a steam turbine comprising nonlinear operating steam valve means for determining the flow of steam through at least one section of the turbine, means for determining a representation of the actual value of at least one variable turbine condition selected from the turbine speed condition and the turbine load condition, programmed digital computer means having a reference representation of said one turbine condition, said computer system further having means for generating at least one predetermined linearizing characterization to offset the nonlinear relationship of valve position to steam flow, said digital computer means having means for generating position control signals for said valve means in accordance with the reference representation and the linearizing characterization and the actual condition representation, and means for controlling said valve means in accordance with the determined position control signals.

2. A turbine operating system as set forth in claim 1, wherein the reference representation is an input load demand, the turbine is a large steam turbine for electric power generation and the steam valve means include throttle valve means and governor valve means, wherein the turbine speed and the turbine load are placed under end control by operation of the valve means, means are provided for generating signals corresponding to actual speed and the actual load and for coupling the signals to said computer, and wherein said computer further includes means for generating throttle and governor valve position demands as a function of representations of the actual speed and load and the input load demand and the linearizing characterization.

3. A turbine operating system as set forth in claim 1, wherein said computer means generates output signals corresponding to position demands which define said valve control actions, and wherein a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control includes individual position control loops responsive to the individual position signals to operate the throttle and governor valves.

4. A turbine operating system as set forth in claim 1, wherein the reference is a load reference and wherein said position control computer operating means includes means for determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward characterization a representation of steam valve position demand required to satisfy a derived representation based on the load reference and wherein said feedforward characterization includes said linearizing characterization.

5. A method for operating a steam turbine having steam valve means for determining the flow of steam through at least one section of the turbine, the steps of said method comprising sensing the turbine speed and the turbine load, storing in a digital computer means at least one linearizing characterization of valve position demand as a function of a variable based on turbine operating demand to linearize the relationship of steam flow to the variable, operating the digital computer means to determine control actions in accordance with the linearizing characterization and the sensed speed and load and at least a load reference from which the turbine operating demand is derived, and controlling the valve means in accordance with the determined control actions.

6. A control system for operating an electric power steam turbine having steam valve means for determining the flow of steam through at least one section of the turbine, said control system comprising means for determining a representation of an input load demand, means for determining a representation of the actual value of the load, means for determining in accordance with another predetermined characterization a correctively modified load demand representation dependent upon error between the actual and the input demand values of the load, means for determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward characterization a representation of steam valve position demand required to satisfy the correctively modified load demand representation, and means for controlling the valve means in accordance with the steam valve position demand representation.

7. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 6, wherein said modifying means provides multiplier calibration of the steam reference representation by a load error representation.

8. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 6, wherein said input load demand representing means includes means for determining an error representation of another predetermined operating variable, and means are provided for modifying the input load demand representation in accordance with the latter error representation.

9. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 8, wherein said valve controlling means includes at least one closed loop local electrohydraulic positioning control and said determining means include programmed digital computer means providing position setpoint control for said electrohydraulic positioning control.

10. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 8, wherein the modified load demand is multiplier calibrated by the first mentioned error representation, means are provided for further determining the steam valve position demand in accordance with a predetermined dynamic characterization, and the last-mentioned modifying means provides multiplier calibration of the input load demand representation by the error representation of the other operating variable.

11. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 8, wherein the last-mentioned modifying means provides multiplier calibration of the input demand representation by the error representation of the other operating variable.

12. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 8, wherein the other operating variable is the turbine speed, and means are provided for detecting a representation of turbine impulse pressure from which the actual load representation is determined.

13. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 6, wherein the steam flow determining means includes a plurality of steam valves, the steam valve feedforward position characterization includes a static characterization representing total steam valve position demand as a function of a representation of load demand, and said steam valve feedforward position demand characterization further includes a characterization representing individual steam valve position demands as a function of the total steam valve position demand.

14. A steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 6, wherein said steam valve controlling means includes at least one closed loop position control system characterized with a controllable gain, and means for controlling the position control loop gain in accordance with the steam valve position demand representation.

15. A system for operating a steam turbine comprising a steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 6 in combination with steam valve means for determining the flow of steam through at least one section of the turbine.

16. A steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 15, wherein there is provided means for further determining the steam valve position demand in accordance with a predetermined dynamic characterization which limits the maximum rate of change of the end controlled variable.

17. A steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 15, wherein said determining means includes programmed digital computer means having stored therein the steam valve feedforward characterization including a static characterization representing steam valve position demand as a function of a representation derived from load demand, and means are provided for operating said computer means to make determinations as defined.

18. A method for operating a steam turbine having steam valve means for determining the flow of steam through at least one section of the turbine, the steps of said method comprising determining a representation of an input load demand, determining a representation of the actual value of the load, determining in accordance with another predetermined characterization a correctively modified load demand representation dependent upon error between the actual and the input demand values of the load, determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward characterization a representation of a steam valve position demand required to satisfy the correctively modified load, and operating said steam valve means in accordance with the steam valve position demand representation.

19. A steam turbine operating method as set forth in claim 18, wherein the steps of said method include using programmed digital computer means in making the defined determinations, using the computer means to determine the steam valve position demand from a predetermined static characterization representing steam valve position demand as a function of a representation derived from the load demand, and using the computer means to determine the predetermined static characterization by operating the steam turbine after installation at various load levels of operation.

20. A steam turbine operating method as set forth in claim 18, wherein the steps of said method include determining the steam valve position demand in a first control loop for the load demand, making a corrective determination in another control loop on the basis of feedback error in a preselected operating variable, and applying the corrective determination as a multiplier calibrator of the first control loop at a predetermined calibration junction of the first and the other control loops.

21. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle valve arrangement and a predetermined governor valve arrangement, said system comprising means for determining representations of an input load demand and the actual value of turbine load, means for determining a representation dependent upon error between the actual and the input demand values of load, means for determining a representation of turbine speed error and for determining a correctively modified load demand representation in accordance with the speed error representation, means for determining a correctively modified load demand representation in accordance with the load error representation, means for determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward static and dynamic characterization a representation of steam valve position demand at least for each of the governor valves as required to satisfy the load and speed correctively modified load demand during a load control operating mode, and means for controlling at least the governor steam valves in accordance with the steam valve position demand representations.

22. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 21, wherein means are provided for determining in accordance with another differing predetermined static and dynamic characterization a representation of steam valve position demand at least for each of the throttle valves as required to satisfy turbine speed demand during a speed control mode of operation.

23. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 21, wherein the turbine speed error representation is multiplier calibrated against the load demand input representation.

24. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 23, wherein the load error representation is multiplier calibrated against the speed calibrated load demand input representation.

25. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 21, wherein means are provided for determining an electrical load error representation, means are provided for offsetting the electrical load error representation with the speed error representation, and means are provided for calibrating a representation of the load demand input representation by multiplication against the speed offset electrical load error representation.

26. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 21, wherein means are provided for transferring between the full arc throttle and the governor modes of operation when the control system is in one of the two modes of operation defined as the speed control mode and the load control mode.

27. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 21, wherein said determining means includes digital computer means, at least the governor valve feedforward position characterization includes a static characteristic representing steam valve position demand as a function of a representation derived from load demand, and said computer means includes means to make determinations as defined.

28. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 27, wherein said computer means includes means for generating a representation of a load reference as a function of a representation of load demand, said computer means includes means for generating the speed error representation and the load error representation and for correctively modifying the load reference with the error representations, and said computer means includes said valve position demand determining means to generate valve position demand representations as a function of the correctively modified load reference.

29. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 28, wherein means are provided for generating megawatt and impulse pressure signals and for coupling said signals to said computer means, and said computer means includes means for generating the load error representation in accordance with at least one of said signals.

30. A system for operating an electric power generating plant comprising a steam turbine, means including a steam generating system for supplying steam to said turbine, a generator driven by said turbine and adapted to generate a predetermined electrical load for network operation with other generators, said turbine including a plurality of turbine sections, a predetermined throttle valve arrangement, a predetermined governor valve arrangement, said throttle and governor valves disposed to control the flow of steam between said steam generating system and said turbine, means for determining a representation of turbine speed error and for determining a correctively modified electrical load demand representation in accordance with the speed error representation, means for determining a representation of the actual value of turbine load, means for determining a representation dependent upon error between the actual and the input demand values of load, means for determining a correctively modified electrical load demand representation in accordance with the load error representation, means for determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward static and dynamic characterization a representation of steam valve position demand at least for each of the governor valves as required to satisfy the load and speed correctively modified electrical load demand, and means for controlling said throttle and governor steam valves in accordance with the steam valve position demands.

31. An electric power plant system as set forth in claim 30, wherein said steam generating system includes a fossil fuel fired drum type boiler to supply steam to said turbine at substantially constant throttle pressure, and means are provided for determining an electrical load error representation, means are provided for offsetting the electrical load error representation with the speed error representation, and means are also provided for calibrating the load demand input representation by multiplication against the speed offset electrical load error representation.

32. An electrical power plant system as set forth in claim 30, wherein said determining and modifying means include digital computer means, and said digital computer means includes means to make the defined determinations.

33. An electric power plant system as set forth in claim 32, wherein means are provided for reheating steam after expansion in one turbine section and before admission to another turbine section, and means including said digital computer means for controlling the reheat steam flow.

34. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle valve arrangement and a predetermined governor valve arrangement, said system comprising means for correctively controlling in accordance with a predetermined characterization the position of at least each of the governor valves in response to a representation of total load demand input during a load control operating mode, means for determining a representation of turbine speed error and for correctively modifying the operation of said valve position controlling means in accordance with the speed error representation, and means for controlling in accordance with another differing predetermined characterization the position of at least each of the throttle valves as required to satisfy turbine speed demand during a speed control operating mode.

35. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 34, wherein means are provided for determining an electrical load error representation, means are provided for offsetting the electrical load error representation with the speed error representation, and means are provided for calibrating the load demand input representation by multiplication against the speed offset electrical load error representation.

36. A large electrical power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 34, wherein said determining and controlling means include digital computer means having stored therein the speed and load control characterizations.

37. A large electric power steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 34, wherein the predetermined throttle and governor valve characterizations each include a predetermined linearizing characterization to offset the nonlinear relationship of valve position to steam flow.

38. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which drives a generator to produce electric power through breaker means and which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle valve arrangement and a predetermined governor valve arrangement, said system comprising a digital computer having a representation of a speed reference for use during a speed control mode and a load control mode and a representation of a load reference for use during the load control mode, means for generating signals corresponding to the actual speed and load values and for coupling the signals to said computer, said computer including means for generating a representation of steam valve position demand as a function of representations of the actual and reference speed values during speed control and as a function of representations of the actual and reference speed and load values during load control, and a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control for controlling the valve means in accordance with the steam valve position demand signal.

39. A turbine control system as set forth in claim 38, wherein said computer further includes means for generating at least one throttle valve position demand and a plurality of governor valve position demands and corresponding output signals as a function of representations of the actual speed and load and the reference speed and load values, and wherein the closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control includes corresponding throttle and governor valve position control loops responsive to the respective position signals to operate the throttle and governor valves.

40. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which drives a generator to produce electric power through breaker means and which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle valve arrangement and a predetermined governor valve arrangement, said system comprising digital computer means having a representation of a speed reference for use during a speed control mode and a load control mode and a representation of a load reference for use during the load control mode, means for generating signals corresponding to the actual speed and load values and for coupling the signals to said computer means, said computer means including means for generating a representation of steam valve position demand as a function of representations of the actual and reference speed values during speed control and as a function of representations of the actual and reference speed and load values during load control, said computer means further including means for transferring between load and speed control modes according to whether the breaker means is closed or open, and means for controlling the individual throttle and governor valves in accordance with the position demand representation.

41. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 40, wherein said computer means includes means for generating at least an output corresponding to the steam valve position demand, and a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control having individual position control loops for operating the respective throttle and governor valves in accordance with the computer output.

42. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 41, wherein said computer means includes means for generating an output which includes at least one throttle valve position signal and at least a plurality of individual governor valve position signals for application to said electrohydraulic positioning control.

43. A large electric power steam turbine control sysem as set forth in claim 40, wherein the actual load signal is a signal representative of turbine impulse pressure.

44. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 40, wherein at least two actual load signals are generated in correspondence to actual turbine impulse pressure and actual generated megawatts and wherein said computer position demand generating means responds to the impulse pressure and the megawatt load values.

45. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 40, wherein said position demand generating means includes means for determining in accordance with a predetermined feedforward characterization a representation of steam valve position demand required to satisfy a derived representation based on the load reference during load control, and means for modifying the load reference representation in accordance with the difference between the actual and the reference speed values and in accordance with the load value to generate the derived reference representation.

46. A steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 45, wherein said digital computer means includes means for modifying the linearizing characterization to improve its operating accuracy.

47. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 40, wherein said function of said position demand generating means includes a predetermined linearizing characterization to offset the nonlinear relationship of valve position to steam flow.

48. A large electric power steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 40, wherein said valve position demand generating means is provided with a governor valve position characterization and a different throttle valve position characterization respectively for use in the load control and speed control modes.

49. A large electric power steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 48, wherein said digital computer means further includes means for generating changes in the throttle and governor valve position demand representations during valve mode changes in the speed and load control modes of operation.

50. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle and governor valve arrangement, said system comprising means for generating a signal representative of actual turbine speed, means for generating a signal representative of actual turbine load, means for generating a representation of steam valve position demand as a function of representations of the actual turbine speed and load and reference speed and load values, means for periodically coupling said signals to said position demand generating means and for periodically operating said position demand generating means to generate the position demand representation continuously, and means for positioning the throttle and governor valves in accordance with the position demand representation.

51. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 50, wherein the turbine drives a generator to produce power through a breaker means, and wherein a digital computer includes said position demand generating means and the speed reference is provided for comparison to a computer stored representation of the actual speed during a speed control mode and a load control mode and the load reference is provided for comparison to a computer stored representation of the actual load during the load control mode, and said computer includes means for transferring between the load and speed control modes according to whether the breaker means is closed or open.

52. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 50, wherein digital computer means includes said position demand generating means, said computer means including means for generating continuous output signals corresponding to the position demand representation, and said valve positioning means including a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control for controlling the valves.

53. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 52, wherein the position demand generating means generates the valve position demand in accordance with a throttle valve characterization in response to the actual and reference turbine speed values at least during speed control and in accordance with a different governor valve characterization in response to the actual and reference speed and load values at least during load control.

54. A steam turbine control system for a large steam turbine having a predetermined throttle and governor valve arrangement, said system comprising means for generating a signal representative of actual turbine speed, means for generating a signal representative of generated megawatt electrical load, means for generating a representation of steam valve position demand as a function of representations of the actual turbine speed and megawatt load and reference speed and megawatt load values, means for coupling said signals to said position demand generating means, said position demand generating means having means for comparing representations of the actual speed and a reference speed and representations of the actual megawatt load and a reference load to provide speed and megawatt error representations, said position demand generating means having means for generating a corrective load demand representation in a load control path in accordance with the speed and megawatt error representations, said megawatt error representation being multiplied against the load control path in the generation of the corrective load demand representation and the valve position demand representation being generated in accordance with the corrective load demand representation, and means for positioning the throttle and governor valves in accordance with the position demand representation.

55. A large electric power system turbine control system as set forth in claim 54, wherein digital computer means includes said position demand generating means and wherein means are provided for generating a signal representative of actual turbine impulse pressure and said position demand generating means further having means for comparing the megawatt and speed corrective load reference and a representation of the actual impulse pressure to provide an impulse pressure error representation and for generating the corrective load demand representation in accordance with the impulse pressure error representation.

56. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 54, wherein said position demand generating means further includes means for determining the valve position demand representation in accordance with a predetermined feedforward characterization which defines the valve position required to satisfy a representation based on the corrective load demand.

57. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 54, wherein the turbine drives a generator to produce electric power through breaker means, a digital computer system includes said position demand generating means to generate a representation of steam valve position demand as a function of the actual and reference speed values during speed control and as a function of the actual and reference speed and load values during load control, and wherein said computer further includes means for transferring between load and speed control modes according to whether the breaker means is closed or open.

58. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 54, wherein digital computer means includes said position demand generating means and said computer means includes means for generating at least one output signal corresponding to the steam valve position demand, and wherein said valve positioning means is a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control.

59. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 54, wherein said valve position demand generating means is provided with a governor valve position characterization and a different throttle valve position characterization for use in the speed control and load control functions.

60. A steam turbine control system for a large electric power steam turbine which is provided with a plurality of turbine sections and a predetermined throttle and governor valve arrangement, said system comprising means for generating a signal representative of actual turbine speed, means for generating a signal representative of actual turbine load, digital computer means, means for coupling said signals to said computer means, said digital computer means including means for comparing representations of the actual speed and a reference speed and representations of the actual load and a reference load to provide speed and load error representations, said digital means further including means for generating a corrective load demand representation in a load control path in accordance with the load and speed error representations and for generating a corrective speed demand representation in a speed control path in accordance with the speed error representation, said digital computer means including means for generating representations of at least throttle valve position demands in accordance with the corrective speed demand representation on speed control and at least governor valve position demands in accordance with the corrective load demand representation on load control, said digital computer means further including means for generating changes in the throttle and governor valve position demand representations during valve mode changes in the speed and load control modes of operation, and means for positioning the throttle and governor valves in accordance with the position demand representations.

61. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 60, wherein the valve position demand representations are generated during a change from throttle valve to governor valve operation in the speed control mode.

62. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 61, wherein said position demand generating means further operates in accordance with a predetermined linearizing characterization of offset the nonlinear relationship of valve position to steam flow.

63. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 60, wherein the actual load signal is a megawatt signal and the reference load value is a megawatt value and the load error is a megawatt error multiplied against the load control path.

64. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 60, wherein said computer further includes means for transferring between load and speed control modes according to whether the breaker means is closed or open.

65. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 64, wherein said computer includes means for generating at least one output signal corresponding to the steam valve position demand, and wherein said valve positioning means is a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control.

66. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 60, wherein said computer means includes means for generating at least one output signal corresponding to the steam valve position demand, and wherein said valve positioning means is a closed loop electrohydraulic positioning control.

67. A large electric power steam turbine control system as set forth in claim 60, wherein said position demand generating means further operates in accordance with a predetermined linearizing characterization to offset the nonlinear relationship of valve position to steam flow.

68. A large electric power steam turbine operating system as set forth in claim 60, wherein said valve position demand generating means further operates in accordance with a throttle valve characterization and a second different governor valve characterization during speed and load control.