System and method for optimizing shed/restore operations for electrical loads

• US 4,324,987 A
• Filed: 09/26/1980
• Issued: 04/13/1982
• Est. Priority Date: 05/26/1978
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Cyborex Laboratories Incorporated
• Original Assignee: Cyborex Laboratories Incorporated
• Inventors: Sullivan, C. Gardner II, Hedges, Walter P.
• Primary Examiner(s): Hix, L. T.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Dwyer, James L.
• Application Number:
  US06/191,424
• Time in Patent Office: 564 Days
• Field of Search: 307/33, 307/34, 307/35, 307/38, 307/39, 307/41, 364/492, 364/493
• US Class Current: 307/35
• CPC Class Codes: H02J 2310/12 The local stationary network supplying a household or a building
• CPC Class Codes: H02J 3/14 by switching loads on to, or off from, network, e.g. progressively balanced loading
• CPC Class Codes: Y02B 70/3225 Demand response systems, e.g. load shedding, peak shaving
• CPC Class Codes: Y04S 20/222 Demand response systems, e.g. load shedding, peak shaving

Abstract

A system for controlling electrical load shedding and restoring operations includes a microprocessor system, a power measuring circuit, and a plurality of load switching relays controlled by the microprocessor system to electrically connect controlled loads of a residence to, and electrically disconnect the controlled loads from, a power line in accordance with priorities associated with the controlled loads. The system is operated to electrically disconnect or shed, in order of increasing priority, as many of the controlled loads as is necessary to cause the total power delivered to the residence to be less than a selected power limit, to compute power availability numbers which represent amounts of power which can be additionally consumed by the residence without exceeding the selected power limit, to restore, in order of decreasing priority, as many previously shed controlled loads as possible without exceeding the selected power limit, and to shed, in order of increasing priority, as many controlled loads presently electrically connected to the power line as is necessary to allow restoring of higher priority, previously shed controlled loads. The selected power limit is manually settable by means of a switch which is read by the microprocessor system.

Claims

1. A method for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total power delivered to the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of a control system, the control system including a plurality of load switching means for controllably connecting the controlled loads to and disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line the control system also including power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads, said method comprising operating a processor to effect the steps of:

(a) computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(b) comparing the selected power limit to the total power consumed by the electrical loads and, if the total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit, electrically disconnecting a sufficient number of the controlled loads, in order of increasing priority, to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit;

(c) computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded;

(d) comparing a stored power consumption number of a first highest-priority one of the controlled loads not presently electrically connected to the power line with said first power availability number and electrically connecting said first controlled load to the power line of said electrical connecting of said first controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(e) electrically disconnecting a second, lowest-priority one of the controlled loads presently electrically connected to the power line from the power line if said stored power consumption number of said first controlled load is greater than said first power available number and the priority of said second controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load.

2. The method of claim 1 further including the steps of:

(a) computing a second power availability number representing an amount of power, which can be additionally consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded, after step (d); and

(b) comparing a stored power consumption number of a third second-highest priority one of the controlled loads to said second power availability number and electrically connecting said third controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of said third controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded.

3. The method of claim 1 further including the step of electrically disconnecting a third second-lowest priority one of the controlled loads from the power line after step (e) if the priority of said third controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load and if electrically disconnecting only said second controlled load from the power line will not allow connecting of said first controlled load to the power line without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded.

4. The method of claim 2 wherein said method includes electrically connecting as many as possible of the controlled loads to the power line in order of decreasing priority after step (b) of claim 2 without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded.

5. The method of claim 3 wherein said method includes electrically disconnecting, in order of increasing priorities, as many of the controlled loads presently electrically connected to the power line and having priorities lower than the priority of said first controlled load as is necessary to allow connecting of said first controlled load to the power line without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded.

6. The method of claim 1 wherein said method includes determining if said second controlled load has been electrically disconnected from the power line before step (e), and performing step (e) for a third, second-lowest priority one of the controlled loads presently electrically connected to the power line if said second controlled load is presently electrically disconnected from the power line.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein the controlled loads presently electrically connected to or disconnected from the power lines in steps (d) and (e) do not include any electrical load which has been bypassed by removing that electrical load from control by the processor.

8. The method of claim 1 wherein step (a) includes computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically reconnected to the power line.

9. The method of claim 8 including providing a time delay after said reconnecting of a particular one of the controlled loads to the power line, said time delay being of sufficient duration to allow essentially complete stabilization of the power consumed by said particular one of the controlled loads before said computing and storing of a power consumption number for said particular one of the controlled loads.

10. The method of claim 1 wherein said method includes operating the processor to effect reading of a manual power limit switch to obtain the preselected power limit.

11. The method of claim 1 performed at a rate determined by an AC frequency of the voltage on the power line.

19. The system of claim 8 wherein said power measuring means includes:

(a) an analog multiplier for multiplying a signal representing current flowing through the power line to the electrical loads by a signal representing voltage between a pair of conductors of said power lines to produce a power signal representing total power being delivered by the power line to the electrical loads;

(b) a digital to analog converter responsive to varying digital input numbers applied thereto by said microprocessor system for producing an analog signal for comparison with said power signal; and

(c) means for detecting equivalence between said analog signal and said power signal and sending a signal to said microprocessor system indicating said equivalence, the microprocessor system utilizing one of the digital input numbers to represent the power presently being delivered via the power line to the electrical loads, said one of the digital numbers being the one which causes said equivalence to occur.

12. A system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of said system, said system comprising in combination:

(a) a plurality of load switching means for controllably electrically connecting the controlled loads to and electrically disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line;

(b) power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads;

(c) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(d) first comparing means for comparing the selected power limit with the total power consumed by the electrical loads;

(e) first means for electrically disconnecting, in order of increasing priority, a sufficient number of the controlled loads to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit on the condition that total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit;

(f) computing means for computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded;

(g) second comparing means for comparing a stored power consumption number of a first highest-priority one of the controlled loads which is not presently electrically connected to the power line with said first power availability number;

(h) second means for electrically connecting said first controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of said first controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(i) third means for electrically disconnecting a second, lowest-priority one of the controlled loads which is presently electrically connected to the power line from the power line on the conditions that said stored power consumption number of said first controlled load is greater than said first power availability number and the priority of said second controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load.

13. The system of claim 12 further including manually operable power limit switch means settable by an operator for setting said selected power limit.

14. The system of claim 13 wherein said manually operable power limit switch means includes a rotary BCD encoded switch supported on a control panel contained in said system.

15. The system of claim 12 further including means operable by an operator to selectively bypass one of said electrical loads from control by said system.

16. The system of claim 12 further including timing means for causing a particular one of said electrical loads to remain electrically connected to the power line for at least a predetermined time each time said particular one of said electrical loads is electrically connected to the power line by one of said load switch means.

17. The system of claim 12 further including means for staggering the times of electrical reconnection of said controlled loads to the power line after the occurence of a power failure of power delivered to the establishment via the power line.

18. The system of claim 12 wherein said system includes a microprocessor system, said computing and storing means, said first and second comparing means, said computing means, and said first, second and third means being at least partially included in said microprocessor system.

20. The system of claim 12 wherein said second means includes means for electrically reconnecting, in order of decreasing priority, as many of the controlled loads which are not presently electrically connected to the power line back to the power line as is possible without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded.

21. The system of claim 12 wherein said third means includes means for electrically disconnecting, in order of decreasing priority, as many of the controlled loads having priorities lower than the priority of said first controlled load as is necessary to allow connecting of said first controlled load to the power line without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded.

22. A method for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total power delivered to the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of a control system and also can be electrically disconnected from the power line by means of the control system, the control system including a plurality of load switching means for controllably connecting the controlled loads to and disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line, the control system also including power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads, said method comprising operating a processor to effect the steps of:

(a) computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from or electrically connected to the power line;

(b) comparing the selected power limit to the total power consumed by the electrical loads and, if the total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit, electrically disconnecting a sufficient number of the controlled loads, to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit;

(c) computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded;

(d) comparing a stored power consumption number of a first highest-priority one of the controlled loads not presently electrically connected to the power line with said first power availability number and electrically connecting said first controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of said first controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(e) electrically disconnecting a second, lowest-priority one of the controlled load presently electrically connected to the power line from the power line if said stored power consumption number of said first controlled load is greater than said first power available number and the priority of said second controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load.

23. A method for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total power delivered to the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a controlled load which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line by means of a control system, the control system including a load switching means for controllably connecting the controlled load to and disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line, the control system also including power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads, said method comprising operating a processor to effect the steps of:

(a) computing and storing a power consumption number for the controlled load when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(b) comparing the selected power limit to the total power consumed by the electrical loads and, if the total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit, electrically disconnecting the controlled load to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit;

(c) computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical load without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(d) comparing a stored power consumption number of the controlled load, if the controlled load is not presently electrically connected to the power line, with said first power availability number and electrically connecting the controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of the controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded.

24. A method for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total power delivered to the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of a control system, the control system including a plurality of load switching means for controllably connecting the controlled loads to and disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line, the control system also including power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads, said method comprising operating a processor to effect the steps of:

(a) computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(b) comparing the selected power limit to the total power consumed by the electrical loads and, if the total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit, electrically disconnecting a sufficient number of the controlled loads, in order of increasing priority, to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit;

(c) computing a power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(d) comparing stored power consumption numbers of the controlled loads not presently electrically connected to the power line with said power availability number and electrically connecting the highest priority controlled load having a power consumption number less than or equal to said power availability number to the power line.

25. A method for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total power delivered to the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of a control system, the control system including a plurality of load switching means for controllably connecting the controlled loads to and disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line, the control system also including power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads, said method comprising operating a processor to effect the steps of:

(a) computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line; and

(b) using said power consumption numbers for selecting from those controlled loads which have been electrically disconnected from the power line a controlled load which may be reconnected to the power line without causing said selected power limit to be exceeded.

26. A system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of said system and which can be also electrically connected to the power line, said system comprising in combination:

(a) a plurality of load switching means for controllably electrically connecting the controlled loads to and electrically disconnecting the controlled loads from the power line;

(b) power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads;

(c) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(d) first comparing means for comparing the selected power limit with the total power consumed by the electrical loads;

(e) first means for electrically disconnecting a sufficient number of the controlled loads to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit on the condition that total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit;

(f) computing means for computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded;

(g) second comparing means for comparing a stored power consumption number of a first highest-priority one of the controlled loads which is not presently electrically connected to the power line with said first power availability number;

(h) second means for electrically connecting said first controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of said first controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(i) third means for electrically disconnecting a second, lowest-priority one of the controlled loads which is presently electrically connected to the power line from the power line on the conditions that said stored power consumption number of said first controlled load is greater than said first power availability number and the priority of said second controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load.

27. A system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a controlled load which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line by means of said system, said system comprising in combination:

(a) load switching means for controllably electrically connecting the controlled load to and electrically disconnecting the controlled load from the power line;

(b) power measuring means for measuring power delivered from the power line to the electrical loads;

(c) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for the controlled load when the controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line;

(d) first comparing means for comparing the selected power limit with the total power consumed by the electrical loads;

(e) first means for electrically disconnecting the controlled load to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit on the condition that total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit;

(f) computing means for computing a power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded;

(g) second comparing means for comparing a stored power consumption number of the controlled load with said first power availability number if the controlled load is not presently electrically connected to the power line; and

(h) second means for electrically reconnecting the controlled load to the power line if said electrical reconnecting of the controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded.

28. A system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of said system, said system comprising in combination:

(a) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line or when that controlled load is electrically connected to the power line;

(b) first means for electrically disconnecting, in order of increasing priority, a sufficient number of the controlled loads to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit on the condition that total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit;

(c) computing means for computing a first power availability number representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded and comparing a stored power consumption number of a first highest-priority one of the controlled loads which is not presently electrically connected to the power line with said first power availability number;

(d) second means for electrically connecting said first controlled load to the power line if said electrical connecting of said first controlled load will not cause the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(e) third means for electrically disconnecting a second, lowest-priority one of the controlled loads which is presently electrically connected to the power line from the power line on the conditions that said stored power consumption number of said first controlled load is greater than said first power availability number and the priority of said second controlled load is lower than the priority of said first controlled load.

29. In a system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of said system, the improvement comprising:

(a) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line or when that controlled load is electrically connected to the power line; and

(b) means for utilizing said power consumption numbers to select from those controlled loads which have been electrically disconnected from the power line a controlled load which may be reconnected to the power line without causing said selected power line to be exceeded.

30. A system for controlling delivery of electrical energy from a power line to an establishment having a plurality of electrical loads in order to maintain the total energy consumption of the electrical loads below a selected power limit, the electrical loads including a plurality of controlled loads which can be electrically connected to and disconnected from the power line in accordance with priorities of the controlled loads by means of said system, said system comprising in combination:

(a) computing and storing means for computing and storing a power consumption number for any one of the controlled loads when that controlled load is electrically disconnected from the power line or when that controlled load is electrically connected to the power line;

(b) first means for electrically disconnecting, in order of increasing priority, a sufficient number of the controlled loads to reduce the total power consumed by the electrical loads to a level which is lower than the selected power limit on the condition that total power consumed by the electrical loads exceeds the selected power limit;

(c) computing means for computing power availability numbers representing an amount of power which additionally can be consumed by the electrical loads without causing the selected power limit to be exceeded; and

(d) means for comparing stored power consumption numbers of the controlled loads which are not presently electrically connected to the power line with said power availability number and electrically connecting the highest priority controlled load having a power consumption number less than or equal to said power availability number to the power line.