Method and apparatus for measuring and analyzing sound characteristics of record discs

• US 4,410,970 A
• Filed: 06/19/1981
• Issued: 10/18/1983
• Est. Priority Date: 06/19/1981
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Keysor-Century Corporation
• Original Assignee: Keysor-Century Corporation
• Inventors: Law, Kenneth S. K.
• Primary Examiner(s): Birmiel, Howard A.
• Application Number:
  US06/275,592
• Time in Patent Office: 851 Days
• Field of Search: 73/659, 369/58, 324/77 B, 324/77 D, 364/485
• US Class Current: 369/53.33
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 20/025 Error detection or correction
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 27/36 Monitoring, i.e. supervising the progress of recording or reproducing for digital recording G11B20/00 and s.gr.; for monitoring, testing or measuring of TV recorders of the type covered by H04N5/76 and subgroups, see H04N17/06
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 3/00 Recording by mechanical cutting, deforming or pressing, e.g. of grooves or pits; Reproducing by mechanical sensing; Record carriers therefor G11B11/00, G11B13/00 take precedence

Abstract

A method and apparatus for quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic-type record disc and using such measurements to analyze the sound characteristics and to thereby improve the sound recording. Selection of one or more sound samples to be taken from a phonographic-type record disc are made and electrical signals representative of these samples on the record disc are generated. These signals may be filtered in order to obtain individual frequency bands and decibel levels for each of the frequency bands is determined. Decibel levels for certain of or all frequencies or bands of frequencies for each sample may be averaged. In this way, it is possible to obtain signals representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for each discrete sample. The signals are used to present a profile of the decibel levels with respect to the frequency and for the selected time interval of each sample in order to thereby enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc. By using this method and the apparatus capable of carrying out this method, it is possible to determine the possible source and origin of any imperfections in the disc, and e.g., whether or not the imperfections were a result of the material used to create the phonographic-type record disc or whether or not the imperfections resulted from one or more steps in the fabrication of the record discs.

Claims

1. A method of quantitatively measuring only either of modulated sound or unmodulated sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one sample on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound from the selected sample of the phonographic type record disc,

(c) filtering said signal to obtain individual frequency bands,

(d) obtaining a statistical measure of the frequency for each frequency band as a function of decibel level,

(e) storing the statistical measure for at least certain of the frequency bands until such measure has been made for such certain frequency bands in the sample, and

(f) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the selected sample in order to enable evaluation of the modulated or the unmodulated sound characteristics of that record disc.

2. The method of claim 1 further characterized in that said

(a) establishing a threshold level, and

(b) initiating the selecting of a sample when the threshold level has been achieved and determined.

3. The method of claim 1 further characterized in that the statistical measure is an average of frequency as a function of decibel level, said method comprises at least temporarily storing the determined average of the decibel level for a certain frequency band until the average of decibel level for each frequency band in the sample has been determined.

4. The method of claim 3 further characterized in that the average of the decibel level for the frequency band in the sample is stored and the process is repeated with different phonographic type record discs in order to compare the decibel level versus frequency profiles for each record disc.

5. A method for quantitatively measuring and analyzing a sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc which was produced from a master, and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observation, said method comprising:

(a) generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of a phonographic type record disc,

(b) processing said electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel level as function of frequency for discrete increments of time,

(c) temporarily storing the individual signal components until the electrical signals thus generated have been processed,

(d) plotting the signal components representing decibel level as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time, and

(e) determining from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the second spectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the record disc used to produce said copy.

6. The method of claim 5 further characterized in that said electrical signals are proportional to the sounds generated from the copy of the record disc.

7. The method of claim 6 further characterized in that said method measures and analyzes unmodulated sound.

8. The method of claim 5 further characterized in that the electrical signals are generated for one-third octave bands.

9. A method of quantitatively measuring sounds from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurements to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one sample on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound of that sample from the phonographic type record disc,

(c) dividing the signal into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency ranges,

(d) determining an average decibel level for each frequency band,

(e) generating a first printed or displayed record member representative of the sound from the record disc and in which frequency is illustrated as a function of decibel level,

(f) repeating steps (a) through (e) for at least one additional sample from a different location on a record disc to thereby generate a second printed or displayed record member, and

(g) comparing the first printed or displayed record member against the second printed or displayed record member to thereby attempt to determine the possible source of imperfections in the sound recordings.

10. The method of claim 9 further characterized in that said method comprises:

(a) establishing a threshold level to initiate a measurement, and

(b) initiating a measurement when the threshold level has been achieved and determined.

11. The method of claim 9 further characterized in that said additional sample is from a different location on the same record disc.

12. The method of claim 9 further characterized in that said additional sample is from a different location on a different record disc.

13. The method of claim 9 further characterized in that the method comprises filtering the selected samples into one-third octave bands for each of the selected samples.

14. The method of claim 9 further characterized in that the measurement of a sample is made over a predetermined time interval and the frequency is illustrated as a function of decibel level with respect to a given time period.

15. A method of quantitatively measuring unmodulated sound from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc to thereby determine record disc quality, said method comprising:

(a) generating electrical signals representative of unmodulated sound from a phonographic type record disc where imperfections on the disc giving rise to the unmodulated sound are not readily discernable by visual observation,

(b) processing said electrical signals and generating a first signal function representing unmodulated surface noise from said record disc, if any, and generating a second signal function representing ticks and pops, if any, from said record disc, and generating a third signal function representing a combination of surface noise and ticks and pops,

(c) plotting the first signal function to obtain a plot of the surface noise without ticks and pops,

(d) plotting the second signal function to obtain a plot of ticks and pops,

(e) plotting the third signal function to obtain a plot of combined surface noise and ticks and pops, and

(f) determining from the plotted signal functions the level and location of ticks and pops in the copy of the record disc and the possible source of said ticks and pops.

16. The method of claim 15 further characterized in that the method comprises also determining the location of the ticks and pops relative to a pre-established time frame from said plotted signal functions.

17. The method of claim 16 further characterized in that in the step of processing the electrical signals, the second signal function is subtracted from the third signal function to obtain the first signal function.

18. The method of claim 16 further characterized in that in the step of processing the electrical signals, the first signal function and the second signal function are represented by signal components which represent decibel levels as a function of frequency.

19. The method of claim 18 further characterized in that the third signal function is also represented by signal components which represent decibel levels as a function of frequency.

20. The method of claim 19 further characterized in that the signal functions represent decibel level as a function of frequency for discrete increments of time.

21. The method of claim 20 further characterized in that in the steps of plotting the signal functions, the signal components are plotted with decibel level as a function of frequency for each discrete increment of time.

22. The method of claim 21 further characterized in that the method comprises determining from the plotted signal functions the existence of unwanted noise in the unmodulated sound of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from a master of the record disc which was used to produce said copy.

23. A method of quantitatively measuring unmodulated sound from a sound producing copy of a phonographic record disc, said method comprising:

(a) generating a signal from the unmodulated sound portion of the record disc representing a total spectrum of noise, including surface noise and ticks and pops, if any,

(b) determining from the signal representing the total spectrum of noise, decibel levels at certain frequencies substantially above the surface noise and thereby determining the existence of ticks and pops in the total spectrum of noise, and

(c) locating the ticks and pops in the total spectrum as a function of time in the predetermined time interval.

24. The method of claim 23 further characterized in that said method comprises generating a plot of the total spectrum of noise and a plot of the background noise and a plot of the ticks and pops for quantitatively evaluating the ticks and pops.

25. The method of claim 24 further characterized in that the plots are comprised of decibel levels as a function of frequency.

26. The method of claim 24 further characterized in that the plots are comprised of decibel levels as a function of frequency and function of time.

27. The method of claim 23 further characterized in that said method comprises measuring sound in the cross-over regions.

28. An apparatus for quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc to enable improvement of sound recording from such quantitative measurements, said apparatus comprising:

(a) signal generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a phonographic type record disc,

(b) means operatively connected to the signal generating means for filtering and dividing the electrical signals into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency, and averaging the decibel levels for each of the frequency bands with respect to a selected frequency intermediate the end frequencies of each such band to thereby obtain an average of the decibel level for each of the frequencies in each of the individual frequency bands,

(c) temporary storage means operatively connected to the means for averaging, for storing the determined average for a frequency band until the average for each band in the sample has been determined, and

(d) means for generating a presentation representative of the sound from the record disc and in which decibel level versus frequency is one of the parameters presented to thereby enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc.

29. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that threshold level means is operatively connected to said signal generating means and initiates selection of a sample and generation of a signal when a preselected threshold has been achieved.

30. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that said filter means is adapted to select sample increments from a one-third octave band.

31. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that additional storage means is provided for storing the determined average for a frequency band until the average for each band in a sample has been determined.

32. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that said apparatus measures modulated sound.

33. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that said apparatus measures unmodulated sound.

34. The apparatus of claim 28 further characterized in that means are provided for selecting a plurality of individual samples which are evaluated from a selected phonograph-type record disc in which a spectrum containing ticks and pops is identified.

35. Apparatus for quantitatively measuring and analyzing only either of a modulated sound spectrum or an unmodulated sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observaton, said apparatus comprising:

(a) generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of a phonographic type record disc,

(b) signal processing means for processing said electrical signals,

(c) means for receiving the processed electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for discrete increments of time, and

(d) presentation means for plotting the signal components representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time to thereby determine from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the modulated or unmodulated sound spectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the record disc used to produce said copy.

36. The apparatus of claim 35 further characterized in that said electrical signals are proportional to the sounds generated from the copy of the record disc.

37. The apparatus of claim 36 further characterized in that the electrical signals are generated for one-third octave bands.

38. The apparatus of claim 36 further characterized in that said apparatus measures and analyzes unmodulated sound.

39. A method of quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting a plurality of sampling locations on at least one phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement, and where all of said sampling locations constitute one sample in combination,

(b) generating electrical signals representative of sound from the selected samples locations,

(c) filtering said signals to obtain individual frequency bands, and decibel levels for each of the frequency bands,

(d) making a statistical measure of the decibel levels for channels comprising increments of the frequency band over a selected time period for each of the sampling locations, and

(e) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the statistical measure across the channel in the selected sampling locations in order to enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc.

40. The method of claim 39 further characterized in that said method comprises:

(a) establishing a threshold level, and

(b) initiating the selecting of a sample when the threshold level has been achieved and determined.

41. The method of claim 39 further characterized in that said method comprises at least temporarily storing the determined average of the decibel level for a certain frequency band until the average of decibel level for each frequency band in the sample has been determined.

42. A method of quantitatively measuring modulated sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one sample of modulated sound on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound from the selected sample of the phonographic type record disc,

(c) filtering said signal to obtain individual frequency bands,

(d) determining an average of the decibel level for each of the frequency bands in the sample,

(e) temporarily storing the determined average of the decibel level for each frequency band until the averge of all frequency bands in the sample has been determined, and

(f) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the selected sample in order to enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc.

43. A method of quantitatively measuring unmodulated sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitive measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one sample of unmodulated sound on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound from the selected sample of the phonographic type record disc,

(c) filtering said signal to obtain individual frequency bands,

(d) determining an average of the decibel level for each of the frequency bands in the sample,

(e) temporarily storing the determined average of the decibel level for each frequency band until the average of all frequency bands in the sample has been determined, and

(f) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the selected sample in order to enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc.

44. A method of quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting a plurality of individual sample portions in at least one sample on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of meausrement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound from the selected sample of the phonographic type record disc,

(c) filtering said signal to obtain individual frequency bands,

(d) determining an average of the decibel level for each of the frequency bands in the sample,

(e) temporarily storing the determined average of the decibel level for each frequency band until the average of all frequency bands in the sample has been determined, and

(f) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the selected sample in order to enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc and thereby identifying a spectrum containing ticks and pops from such sample portions.

45. The method of claim 44 further characterized in that the method comprises determining an average of the ticks and pops and determining an average of the surface noise.

46. The method of claim 45 further characterized in that the method comprises presenting a decibel level versus frequency profile for ticks and pops of all sample portions from a disc and presenting a decibel level versus frequency profile for surface noise of all sample portions from a disc.

47. A method for quantitatively measuring and analyzing a sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observation, said method comprising:

(a) generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of a phonographic type record disc,

(b) processing said electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel level as a function of frequency for discrete increments of time,

(c) plotting the signal components representing decibel level as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time to produce three dimensional plots in which frequency is represented by one of the axes, decibel level by another of the axes and increments of time by a third of the axes, and

(d) determining from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the sound spectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the record disc used to produce said copy.

48. A method for quantitatively measuring and analyzing an unmodulated sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observation, said method comprising:

(a) generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of a phonographic type record disc,

(b) processing said electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel level as a function of frequency for discrete increment of time,

(c) plotting the signal components representing decibel level as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time to thereby generate

(1) a first plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for a total sound spectrum,

(2) a second plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for surface noise only, and

(3) a third plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for ticks and pops,

(d) determining from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the sound spectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the record disc used to produce said copy.

49. The method of claim 48 further characterized in that each of said plots are three dimensional with frequency shown as a function of decibel level for each of the meansured time increments.

50. The method of claim 49 further characterized in that the unmodulated sound is sampled and evaluated from cross-over regions.

51. The method of claim 48 further characterized in that electrical signals representative of the ticks and pops are generated relative to electrical signals representative of other surface noise from the record disc.

52. A method of quantitatively measuring sounds from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitive measurements to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one sample on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound of that sample from the phonographic type record disc,

(c) dividing the signal into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency ranges,

(d) determining an average decibel level for each frequency band,

(e) generating a printed record member representative of the sound of ticks and pops from the record disc and in which frequency is illustrated as a function of decibel level, and

(f) repeating steps (a) through (e) for at least one additional sample and presenting the sound of ticks and pops relative to the sound of at least one additional sample to thereby determine the possible source of imperfections in the sound recordings.

53. The method of claim 52 further characterized in that only unmodulated sound is sampled and quantitatively evaluated.

54. The method of claim 53 further characterized in that the unmodulated sound is sampled and evaluated from cross-over regions.

55. An apparatus for quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc to enable improvement of sound recording from such quantitative measurements, said apparatus comprising:

(a) means for selecting a plurality of individual samples which are to be evaluated from a selected phonograph-type record disc in which a sprectrum containing ticks and pops is identified,

(b) signal generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a phonographic type record disc,

(c) filter means operatively connected to the signal generating means and dividing the electrical signals into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency, and averaging the decibel levels for each of the frequency bands,

(d) temporary storage means operatively connected to the means for averaging, for storing the determined average for a frequency band for each band in the sample,

(e) additional storage means for storing the determined average for a frequency band for each frequency band in the sample until the average for each band in the sample has been determined, and retaining at least certain of the determined averages, and

(f) means for generating a presentation representative of the sound from the record disc and in which decibel level versus frequency is one of the parameters presented to thereby enable evaluation of the sound charcteristics of that record disc.

56. The apparatus of claim 55 further characterized in that the means for generating a presentation presents a decibel level versus frequency profile for ticks and pop and presents an average of the surface noise.

57. The apparatus of claim 56 further characterized in that the means for generating a presentation presents a decibel level versus frequency profile for ticks and pops of all samples of a disc and presents a decibel level versus frequency profile for surface noise of all samples from a disc.

58. Apparatus for quantitatively measuring and analyzing a sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observation, said method comprising:

(a) generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of phonographic type record disc,

(b) signal processing means for processing said electrical signals,

(c) means for receiving the processed electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for discrete increments of time, and

(d) presentation means for plotting the signal components representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time to present three dimensional plots of the signal components in which frequency is represented by one of the axes, decibel level by another of the axes and increments of time by a third of the axes, to thereby determine from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the sound spectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the record disc used to produce said copy.

59. Apparatus for quantitatively measuring and analyzing a sound spectrum from a sound producing copy of a phonographic type record disc and where a means on the disc to produce discrete portions of the sound in the spectrum are not readily discernable by visual observation, said apparatus comprising:

(a) generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a copy of phonographic type record disc,

(b) signal processing means for processing said electrical signals,

(c) means for receiving the processed electrical signals and generating a plurality of individual signal components with each representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for discrete increments of time, and

(d) presentation means for plotting the signal components representing decibel levels as a function of frequency for each such discrete increment of time, said presentation means being adapted to;

(1) generate a first plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for a total sound spectrum,

(2) generate a second plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for surface noise only, and

(3) generate a third plot illustrating at least decibel level as a function of frequency for ticks and pops, to thereby determine from the plotted signal components the existence of unwanted noise in the sound sprectrum of said copy of the record disc and thereby determining from the copy of the record disc if said unwanted noise occurred in or was derived from the master of the second disc used to produce said copy.

60. The apparatus of claim 59 further characterized in that each of said plots are three dimensional with frequency shown as a function of decibel level for each of the measured time increments.

61. A method of quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurement to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting a plurality of sampling locations on at least one single selected phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement, and where all of said sampling locations constitute one sample in combination,

(b) generating electrical signals representative of sound from the selected samples locations,

(c) filtering said signals to obtain individual frequency bands and decibel levels for each of the frequency bands,

(d) making a statistical measure of the decibel levels for channels of the frequency band for each of the sampling

(e) presenting a profile of the decibel level with respect to frequency for the statistical measure across the channel in the selected sampling locations in order to enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc and indentify a spectrum containing ticks and pops from the sample.

62. The method of claim 61 further characterized in that the method comprises determining an average of the ticks and pops and determining an average of the surface noise.

63. The method of claim 62 further characterized in that the method comprises presenting a decibel level versus frequency profile for ticks and pops of all sampling locations from a disc and presenting a decibel level versus frequency profile for surface noise of all sampling locations from a disc.

64. A method of quantitatively measuring sounds from a phonographic type record disc and using such quantitative measurements to improve sound recording, said method comprising:

(a) selecting at least one first sample on a phonographic type record disc for purposes of measurement,

(b) generating an electrical signal representative of sound of that first sample from the phonographic type record disc,

(c) dividing the signal into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency ranges,

(d) determining an average decibel level for each frequency band,

(e) repeating steps (a) through (d) for at least one additional sample at a different location to thereby determine the possible source of imperfections in the sound recordings,

(f) averaging the averages of the decibel level for each frequency band in the first sample and in the second sample to obtain an overall average of frequency with respect to decibel level, and

(g) generating a printed or displayed record member representative of the sound from the record disc and in which frequency of said first and additional samples is illustrated as a function of decibel level.

65. The method of quantitatively measuring sounds of claim 64 further characterized in that said method comprises generating printed or displayed record members for the first and additional samples and comparing the first printed or displayed record member against the additional printed or displayed record member to thereby attempt to determine the possible source of imperfections in the sound recordings.

66. An apparatus for quantitatively measuring sound from a phonographic type record disc to enable improvement of sound recording from such quantitative measurements, said apparatus comprising:

(a) signal generating means for generating electrical signals representative of sound from a phonographic type record disc,

(b) filter means operatively connected to the signal generating means and dividing the electrical signals into individual frequency bands of predetermined frequency, and averaging the decibel levels for each of the frequency bands,

(c) temporary storage means operatively connected to the means for averaging, for storing the determined average for a frequency band until the average for each band in the sample has been determined,

(d) processing means operable in conjunction with said filter means and temporary storage means for making a further averaging of the bands or portions thereof in the sample, and

(e) means for generating a presentation representative of the sound from the record disc and in which decibel level versus frequency is one of the parameters presented to thereby enable evaluation of the sound characteristics of that record disc.