Method for liquid chromatography

• US 4,422,942 A
• Filed: 09/09/1981
• Issued: 12/27/1983
• Est. Priority Date: 09/09/1981
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Isco, Inc. (Teledyne Technologies Incorporated)
• Original Assignee: Isco, Inc. (Teledyne Technologies Incorporated)
• Inventors: Allington, Robert W.
• Primary Examiner(s): Adee, John
• Application Number:
  US06/300,567
• Time in Patent Office: 839 Days
• Field of Search: 210/635, 210/656, 210/659, 210/101, 210/198.2, 210/741, 210/137, 210/138
• US Class Current: 210/659
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2030/326 pumps
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 30/32 of pressure or speed G01N30/36 takes precedence

Abstract

To stabilize flow rate in a single-stroke, syringe-type high pressure pump to a constant value after turn-on, a control system increases the pump speed until equilibrium conditions are reached and then pumps at the preset rate. In one embodiment, the control system senses the maximum rate of change of pressure, detects a pressure when the rate of change is two-thirds of the maximum, increases the pump rate until the pressure is three times that at the value of the detected pressure and begins pumping at the preset constant flow rate.

In other embodiments: (1) a pumping system is operated at a flow rate ten times the preset flow rate and, when the time derivative of the pressure has dropped to nine tenths of its maximum, the pump motor speed is reduced to the preset flow rate; (2) the outflow of the column is measured under no load conditions at the desired flow rate and when a column is connected, the pumping speed is increased until the same outflow results before reducing the pumping rate; and (3) the system is operated in a constant pressure mode to a point at which the pressure is estimated to provide the desired flow rate, the flow rate measured, and if the flow rate is not the preset one, a new pressure measurement is set and the procedure repeated. In a constant pressure system, the speed of a recording chart is adjusted to the pumping speed to provide a chromatogram with abscissae of flow rate units.

Claims

1. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column for a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

estimating the equilibrium value of pressure from said measurements of said characteristic mode at said low value characteristic;

increasing the pumping rate of flow until said estimated equilibrium value of pressure is reached; and

the step of estimating including the steps of taking the time derivative of the pressure;

measuring the pressure at a predetermined fraction of the difference between the maximum time derivative of the pressure and zero; and

multiplying the pressure at that point by a factor which is the reciprocal of the predetermined fraction; and

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow.

2. A method according to claim 1 in which the step of measuring a characteristic of fluid includes the step of measuring the fluid outflow of the chromatograph.

3. A method according to claim 2 in which the step of increasing the rate of pumping flow includes the step of increasing the rate of flow until the outflow from the chromatograph means equals the predetermined rate of flow.

4. A method according to claim 2 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the steps of:

comparing the measured outflow with a preset outflow and generating a resulting signal; and

causing said resulting signal to control the rate of pumping until said measured outflow equals said preset outflow.

5. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of measuring, at a time of low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid including the step of measuring the pressure of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column at a low value of pressure;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of estimating the equilibrium value of pressure from said characteristic; and

increasing the pumping rate of flow until said estimated equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

the step of measuring a characteristic including the step of measuring the derivative with respect to time of the pressure of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column at a low value of pressure;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of taking the time derivative of the pressure;

measuring the pressure at a predetermined fraction of the difference between the maximum time derivative of the pressure and zero; and

multiplying the pressure at that point by a factor which is the reciprocal of the predetermined fraction; and

the step of reducing said rate of flow of pumping to said predetermined rate of flow including the steps of storing a value representing the instantaneous pressure when the pressure time derivative reaches said predetermined point;

comparing the stored value of instantaneous pressure with the instantaneous pressure as it changes; and

slowing the rate of flow when the ratio of the maximum pressure time derivative minus the instantaneous time derivative to the maximum pressure-time derivative multiplied by the instantaneous pressure value is larger than the stored pressure value.

6. A method according to claim 5 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the step of increasing the rate of flow at the time said pressure-time derivative reaches said preset value of pressure-time derivative.

7. A method according to claim 6 in which the step of reducing the rate of flow includes the step of reducing the rate of flow when said time derivative drops from a maximum value to a certain smaller value.

8. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of measuring a characteristic of fluid including the steps of counting drops from the column and deriving a signal in analog form representing the drops; and

applying a correction factor to that signal so as to cause it to represent the outflow from the column.

9. A method according to claim 8 in which the step of applying a correction factor includes the step of converting the signal to digital form and apply a digital correction factor.

10. A method according to claim 9 in which the step of increasing the rate of pumping flow includes the step of increasing the rate of flow until the outflow from the chromatograph means equals the predetermined rate of flow.

11. A method according to claim 10 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the steps of:

comparing the measured outflow with a preset outflow and generating a resulting signal; and

causing said resulting signal to control the rate of pumping until said measured outflow equals said preset outflow.

12. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of measuring a characteristic of fluid including the steps of counting drops from the column and deriving a signal in analog form representing the drops; and

applying a correction factor to that signal so as to cause it to represent the outflow from the column;

the step of applying a correction factor including the step of converting the signal to digital form and applying a digital correction factor;

the step of increasing the rate of pumping flow including the step of increasing the rate of flow until the outflow from the chromatograph means equals the predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of comparing the measured outflow with a preset outflow and generating a resulting signal; and

causing said resulting signal to control the rate of pumping until said measured outflow equals said preset outflow; and

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of applying a reference signal to the pumping system corresponding to the equilibrium rate while the chromatographic means is under no load;

generating a calibration factor signal by comparing the reference signal with the signal derived from the outflow measuring circuit when the chromatographic column has the desired outflow rate;

multiplying the calibration factor signal by the measured signal and comparing it to the desired signal during operation of the chromatographic column under load; and

discontinuing application of the reference signal to the motor control circuit and applying the factored measured signal when the calibrated measured signal differs from the desired signal.

13. A method according to claim 12 in which the step of determining the calibration factor includes the steps of:

applying the derived signal to one input of a subtractor and applying the reference signal to another input of the subtractor;

applying the output of the subtractor to the pumping system to establish the constant equilibrium flow rate from the chromatograph;

applying the output from the subtractor to a feedback loop when the chromatographic column is operated at no load to determine the value of an operator signal to be operated upon by the derived signal which equals the reference signal when the pump is operated at no load under the control of the reference signal; and

applying the operator signal operated upon the derived signal to the pumping system to change the speed of pumping until it reaches equilibrium value under operation with a back-pressure.

14. A method according to claim 13 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the step of controlling the rate of movement of a syringe pump.

15. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of measuring a characteristic of a fluid including the steps of measuring the pressure caused by a pump supplying fluid to the chromatographic system;

measuring a dynamic characteristic of the system which is inversely proportional to the pressure;

establishing a ratio between a point on the dynamic characteristic and its range from maximum to zero;

measuring the pressure at said point; and

calculating other points of pressure from proportionality between said dynamic characteristic and said pressure measurement.

16. A method according to claim 15 in which the step of measuring a dynamic characteristic includes the step of measuring the time rate of change of said pressure.

17. A method according to claim 16 in which the step of setting up a ratio includes the steps of:

measuring the instantaneous pressure at a point in time; and

calculating the equilibrium of pressure from a proportional relationship between the pressure at that point and the equilibrium pressure as related to the slope at the same point in time and the range between a maximum slope and a substantially zero slope.

18. A method according to claim 15 in which the step of setting up a ratio includes the steps of:

measuring the instantaneous pressure at a point in time; and

calculating the equilibrium of pressure from a proportional relationship between the pressure at that point and the equilibrium pressure as related to the slope at the same point in time and the range between a maximum slope and a substantially zero slope.

19. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of low value of pressure, a characteristic fo fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of increasing the rate of flow comprises the steps of estimating the equilibrium pressure for a constant flow-rate chromatographic run from said measurement of a characteristic;

increasing the pump motor speed rapidly until said pressure is reached;

permitting the flow rate to stabilize at said set pressure;

repeating the process of estimating the pressure and increasing the speed of the pumping system to the estimated pressure until the flow rate is close to the constant flow rate; and

operating said chromatograph at the constant flow rate.

20. A method according to claim 19 in which the step of increasing the speed of the pumping system includes the steps of:

comparing the pressure with the estimated pressure to derive a difference signal; and

applying the difference signal to a feedback loop to control the pumping system speed until the set pressure equals the estimated pressure.

21. A method according to claim 20 in which the step of operating the chromatograph at a constant flow rate includes the step of applying a potential to the motor which is constant, whereby the motor drives the pump at a constant flow rate.

22. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow comprising the steps of estimating the equilibrium pressure for a constant-flow-rate chromatographic run from said measurement of a characteristic;

increasing the pump motor speed rapidly until said pressure is reached;

permitting the flow rate to stabilize at said set pressure;

repeating the process of estimating the pressure and increasing the speed of the pumping system to the estimated pressure until the flow rate is close to the constant flow rate; and

operating said chromatograph at the constant flow rate;

the step of increasing the speed of the pumping system including the steps of comparing the pressure with the estimated pressure to derive a difference signal; and

applying the difference signal to a feedback loop to control the pumping system speed until the set pressure equals the estimated pressure;

the step of operating the chromatograph at a constant flow rate including the step of applying a potential to the motor which is constant, whereby the motor drives the pump at a constant flow rate; and

the step of determining when the pressure is equal to the estimated pressure comprises the steps of determining when the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero;

determining when the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure is approximately zero; and

selecting the time when both the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero and the difference between the measured pressure and set pressure is approximately zero as the end of the transitory period.

23. A method according to claim 22 in which the step of determining when the pressure is equal to the estimated pressure includes the step of opening an analog gate when the transitory period is over and permitting a signal representing the speed of the pumping system to pass therethrough.

24. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of measuring a characteristic of the fluid comprising the steps of deriving a signal representing the pressure of the pump;

taking the derivative of the signal representing the derivative of the pump;

establishing a set equilibrium pressure;

comparing the measured pressure with the equilibrium pressure; and

detecting when the slope of the pressure-time characteristic and the difference between measured and set pressure characteristic are both substantially zero, whereby the equilibrium time is detected.

25. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

deriving a signal representing the rate of flow of said fluid as it leaves the outlet of the chromatographic column;

detecting characteristics of an effluent in the chromatograph;

recording the characteristics of the effluent on a chart; and

varying the speed of the chart in direct proportion to the signal representing the rate of flow of fluid as it leaves the outlet.

26. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

estimating the equilibrium value of pressure from said characteristic;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of measuring a characteristic includes the step of measuring the derivative with respect to time of the pressure of fluid caused by the pumping system at a low value of pressure.

27. A method according to claim 26 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the steps of:

taking the time derivative of the pressure;

measuring the pressure at a predetermined fraction of the difference between the maximum time derivative of the pressure and zero; and

multiplying the pressure at that point by a factor which is the reciprocal of the ratio of the selected value from maximum to minimum divided by the entire range from maximum to minimum of the pressure derivative.

28. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of estimating the equilibrium value of pressure from said characteristic; and

increasing the pumping rate of flow until said estimated equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

the step of measuring a characteristic including the step of measuring the derivative with respect to time of the pressure of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column at a low value of pressure;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of taking the time derivative of the pressure;

measuring the pressure at a predetermined fraction of the difference between the maximum time derivative of the pressure and zero; and

multiplying the pressure at that point by a factor which is the reciprocal of the predetermined fraction, and

the step of reducing said rate of flow of pumping to said predetermined rate of flow including the steps of storing a value representing the instantaneous pressure when the pressure time derivative reaches said predetermined fraction;

comparing the stored value of instantaneous pressure with the instantaneous pressure as it changes; and

slowing the rate of flow when the ratio of the maximum pressure time derivative minus the time derivative at the predetermined fraction to the maximum pressure time derivative multiplied by the instantaneous pressure measured as it changes becomes substantially equal to the stored pressure value.

29. A method according to claim 28 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow includes the step of increasing the rate of flow at the time said pressure-time derivative reaches said preset value of pressure-time derivative.

30. A method according to claim 29 in which the step of reducing the rate of flow includes the step of reducing the rate of flow when said time derivative drops from a maximum value to a relatively small value.

31. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of taking the time derivative of the pressure;

measuring the pressure at a predetermined fraction of the difference between the maximum time derivative of the pressure and zero; and

multiplying the pressure at that point by a factor which is the reciprocal of the predetermined fraction.

32. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of increasing the rate of pumping flow including the step of increasing the rate of flow until the outflow from the chromatograph means equals the predetermined rate of flow.

33. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of comparing the measured outflow with a preset outflow and generating a resulting signal; and

causing said resulting signal to control the rate of pumping until said measured outflow equals said preset outflow.

34. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow; and

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of applying a reference signal to the pumping system corresponding to the equilibrium rate while the chromatographic means is under no load;

generating a calibration factor signal by comparing the reference signal with the signal derived from the outflow measuring circuit when the chromatographic column has the desired outflow rate;

multiplying the calibration factor signal by the measured signal and comparing it to the desired signal during operation of the chromatographic column under load; and

discontinuing application of the reference signal to the motor control circuit and applying the factored measured signal when the calibrated measured signal differs from the desired signal.

35. A method according to claim 34 in which the step of measuring the outflow from the chromatograph includes the steps of:

counting drops from the column and deriving a signal in analog form representing the drops; and

applying a correction factor to that signal so as to cause it to represent the outflow from the column.

36. A method according to claim 35 in which the step of applying a correction factor includes the step of converting the signal to digital form and apply a digital correction factor.

37. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring, at a time of a low value of pressure, a characteristic of fluid being transferred from the pumping system to the chromatographic column related to the pressure of the fluid;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least said measured characteristic until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of measuring a characteristic of fluid including the step of measuring the fluid outflow of the chromatograph;

the step of increasing the rate of flow including the steps of applying a reference signal to the pumping system corresponding to the equilibrium rate while the chromatographic means is under no load;

generating a calibration factor signal by comparing the reference signal with the signal derived from the outflow measuring circuit when the chromatographic column has the desired outflow rate;

multiplying the calibration factor signal by the measured signal and comparing it to the desired signal during operation of the chromatographic column under load; and

discontinuing application of the reference signal to the motor control circuit and applying the factored measured signal when the calibrated measured signal differs from the desired signal.

38. A method according to claim 37 in which the step of measuring the outflow from the chromatograph includes the steps of:

counting drops from the column and deriving a signal in analog form representing the drops; and

applying a correction factor to that signal so as to cause it to represent the outflow from the column.

39. A method according to claim 38 in which the step of applying a correction factor includes the step of converting the signal to digital form and apply a digital correction factor.

40. A method of operating a chromatograph comprising the steps of:

applying fluid from a pumping system into a chromatographic column system;

detecting chromatographic peaks in the effluent as the fluid passes through the chromatographic column system;

recording said chromatographic peaks;

measuring the rate of flow of said fluid from said chromatographic column system and generating a signal related thereto; and

controlling the rate of recording said peaks in response to said signal so that the rate of recording is directly proportional to the rate of flow of fluid between the pumping system and the chromatographic column system.

41. A method according to claim 40 in which the step of controlling the rate of recording includes the step of changing the speed of a recorder as the chromatographic peaks are recorded thereon so as to maintain the speed proportional to the rate of flow of the fluid.