System and method for tracking targets in a multipath environment

• US 4,449,127 A
• Filed: 03/10/1981
• Issued: 05/15/1984
• Est. Priority Date: 03/10/1981
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Paramount Global (f/k/a ViacomCBS Inc.))
• Original Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Paramount Global (f/k/a ViacomCBS Inc.))
• Inventors: Sanchez, Jose A.
• Primary Examiner(s): Tubbesing, T. H.
• Application Number:
  US06/242,514
• Time in Patent Office: 1,162 Days
• Field of Search: 343/7 A, 343/7.4, 343/5 NQ, 343/16 R, 343/16 M
• US Class Current: 342/80
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/4418 with means for eliminating radar-dependent errors in angle measurements, e.g. multipath effects
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/68 for angle tracking only
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 7/28 Details of pulse systems

Abstract

A method and apparatus is described for determining the presence of multipath conditions when tracking a target with a radar wherein the radar includes apparatus for transmitting signals and receiving target reflected signals along two boresight reference lines angularly displaced less than one beamwidth and means for processing the target reflected signals along both boresight reference lines to provide an elevation estimate of the target by target reflected signals along both boresight reference lines and to derive the quadrature component, if any, along both boresight reference line axes. A difference in target elevation derived from target reflected signals along both boresight reference lines or the presence of a quadrature component along one or both boresight reference lines is used to determine the presence of multipath conditions and to provide signals to select one of the elevation signals for tracking or to provide an estimate of target position. The selected elevation signal may be filtered and may have a correction factor added to it.

Claims

1. A method for determining the presence of multipath conditions when tracking a target with a radar comprising the steps of:

transmitting a first signal with an antenna having a first predetermined beamwidth and directed in a first direction towards said target;

receiving target reflected first signals with said antenna directed in said first direction;

generating a first elevation signal from said target reflected first signals;

transmitting a second signal with an antenna having a second predetermined beamwidth and directed in a second direction towards said target, said second direction being angularly offset in elevation from said first direction by a predetermined angle;

receiving target reflected second signals with said antenna directed in said second direction;

generating a second elevation signal from said target reflected second signals;

subtracting said first and second elevation signals to provide an elevation difference signal; and

generating a first signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said elevation difference signal exceeds a first predetermined value.

2. The method of claim 1 further including the steps of:

generating a first quadrature signal from said target reflected first signals; and

generating a second signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said first quadrature signal exceeds a second predetermined value.

3. The method of claim 2 further including the step of:

generating a second quadrature signal from said target reflected second signals; and

generating a third signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said second quadrature signal exceeds a third predetermined value.

4. The method of claim 3 further including the step of:

generating a fourth signal indicative of the severivity of the multipath condition in response to said first, second and third signals.

5. The method of claim 3 further including the steps of:

addressing a memory having a plurality of predetermined stored constants with said first, second and third signals combined to form an address signal; and

reading out a portion of said predetermined stored constants in response to said address signals to provide an indication of the severity of the multipath condition.

6. The method of claim 1 wherein said steps of transmitting said first and second signals includes transmitting with an antenna having first and second predetermined beamwidths of 50 milliradians.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein said steps of transmitting first and second signals includes transmitting with a monopulse antenna.

8. The method of claim 1 wherein said steps of receiving target reflected first and second signals includes the step of generating sum and difference signals.

9. The method of claim 8 wherein said step of generating a first elevation signal includes the step of generating in-phase and quadrature signals.

10. The method of claim 8 wherein said step of generating a second elevation signal includes the step of generating in-phase and quadrature signals.

11. The method of claim 1 wherein said step of transmitting a second signal in said second direction includes transmitting where said predetermined angle is substantially 60% of the angle of said second predetermined beamwidth.

12. Apparatus for determining the presence of multipath conditions when tracking a target with a radar comprising:

means for transmitting a first signal including an antenna having a first predetermined beamwidth and directed in a first direction towards said target;

means for receiving target reflected first signals with said antenna directed in said first direction;

means for generating a first elevation signal from said target reflected first signals;

means for transmitting a second signal including an antenna having a second predetermined beamwidth and directed in a second direction towards said target, said second direction being angularly offset in elevation from said first direction by a predetermined angle;

means for receiving target reflected second signals with said antenna directed in said second direction;

means for generating a second elevation signal from said target reflected second signals;

means for subtracting said first and second elevation signals to provide an elevation difference signal; and

means for generating a first signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said elevation difference signal exceeds a first predetermined value.

13. The apparatus of claim 12 further including:

means for generating a first quadrature signal from said target reflected first signals; and

means for generating a second signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said first quadrature signal exceeds a second predetermined value.

14. The apparatus of claim 13 further including:

means for generating a second quadrature signal from said target reflected second signals; and

means for generating a third signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said second quadrature signal exceeds a third predetermined value.

15. The apparatus of claim 14 further including:

means for generating a fourth signal indicative of the severity of the multipath condition in response to said first, second and third signals.

16. The apparatus of claim 14 further including:

a memory having a plurality of predetermined constants stored as a function of said first, second and third signals and

for providing a portion of said predetermined constants in response to said first, second and third signals to provide at least a fourth signal indicative of the severity of the multipath condition.

17. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said antenna has a first predetermined beamwidth of 50 milliradians.

18. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said antenna has a second predetermined beamwidth of 50 milliradians.

19. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said antenna is a monopulse antenna having at least a sum and difference channel.

20. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said antenna has a plurality of feeds to provide said first predetermined beamwidth at first times and said second predetermined beamwidth angularly offset by said predetermined angle at second times.

21. The apparatus of claim 20 wherein said antenna includes means for generating sum and difference signals from target reflected first and second signals.

22. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said means for generating a first elevation signal includes means for generating in-phase and quadrature signals.

23. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said means for generating a second elevation signal includes means for generating in-phase and quadrature signals.

24. The apparatus of claim 12 wherein said means for transmitting a second signal in said second direction includes means for transmitting at said predetermined angle which is substantially 60% of the angle of said second predetermined beamwidth.

25. A method for determining the presence of multipath conditions when tracking a target with a radar, comprising the steps of:

collecting radar echoes at two antenna positions spaced apart by a predetermined angle in elevation relative to one another;

processing said radar echoes at said two antenna positions to generate at least an in-phase angle error signal at said antenna positions;

converting said in-phase signals to target elevation measurements;

detecting the difference between said target elevation measurements; and

generating a first signal when said difference exceeds a first predetermined value to indicate a multipath condition.

26. The method of claim 25 wherein one of said antenna positions is called the first antenna position having its beam axis normally on a target and the other of said antenna positions is called the second antenna position having its beam axis normally off of the target, further comprising the steps of:

processing said radar echoes at said first antenna position to generate a quadrature angle error signal at said first antenna position; and

generating a second signal indicative of multipath conditions at times said quadrature angle error signal at said first antenna position exceeds a second predetermined value.

27. A system for target information processing in a multipath environment comprising:

antenna means positioned to detect radar echoes in two beams angularly spaced a predetermined distance;

a radar receiving channel for each of said antenna means;

means for processing the radar echoes to generate at least in-phase signals for each channel;

means for converting said in-phase signals to elevation measurements;

means for detecting the difference between said elevation measurements to provide a difference signal; and

means for selecting one of said radar receiving channels in accordance with said difference signal.

28. A method for determining multiscattering conditions while tracking with a monopulse radar comprising the steps of:

directing the boresight of an antenna at the target;

radiating pulses toward the target;

receiving target reflected pulses;

generating a first elevation error signal with respect to the position of said antenna boresight;

directing the boresight of said antenna at a predetermined angle above the target, said predetermined angle being small enough to enable illumination of the target by the main beam;

radiating pulses toward the target;

receiving target reflected pulses;

generating a second elevation error signal with respect to the position of said antenna boresight; and

comparing the difference between said first and second elevation signals to a predetermined value to

generate a signal indicative of a multipath condition when said difference exceeds said predetermined value.

29. A method of determining the position of a target comprising the steps of:

transmitting first and second radar signals that are offset angularly in elevation from each other by a predetermined angle;

generating a first elevation signal and a second elevation signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

subtracting one of said first and second elevation signals from the other to provide an elevation difference signal;

comparing said difference signal to a first predetermined value to

generate a first signal at times said elevation difference signal exceeds said first predetermined value;

generating a first quadrature signal and a second quadrature signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

comparing said first quadrature signal with a second predetermined value and said second quadrature signal with a third predetermined value to

generate a second signal at times said first quadrature signal exceeds said second predetermined value and a third signal at times said second quadrature signal exceeds said third predetermined value; and

selecting one of said first and second elevation signals as the position of said target in response to said first, second and third signals.

30. The method of claim 29 further including the step of filtering the signal to be selected.

31. The method of claim 29 further including the steps of:

generating at first times a table of target to image angle values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

selecting at second times a target to image angle value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

coupling said selected target to image angle value to an output terminal.

32. The method of claim 29 further including the steps of:

generating at first times a table of reflection coefficient values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

selecting at second times a reflection coefficient value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

coupling said selected reflection coefficient value to an output terminal.

33. The method of claim 29 further including the steps of:

generating at first times a table of phase angle values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

selecting at second times a phase angle value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

coupling said selected phase angle value to an output terminal.

35. The method of claim 29 or 34 further including the step of directing in elevation said first radar signals in response to said selected elevation signal and wherein said second radar signals are offset angularly in elevation above said first radar signals.

36. The method of claim 29 or 34 further including the steps of:

directing in elevation said first radar signals in response to said first elevation signal and wherein said second radar signals are offset angularly in elevation above said first radar signals.

37. The method of claims 34, 31, 32 or 33 wherein said step of generating a table includes storing a plurality of predetermined constants in a memory.

38. The method of claims 34, 31, 32 or 33 wherein said step of generating a table includes the steps of storing a plurality of predetermined constants in a memory and wherein said step of selecting includes the step of:

addressing said memory with said elevation difference signal, said first and second quadrature signals to

read out from said memory a portion of said predetermined constants.

34. A method of determining the position of a target comprising the steps of:

transmitting first and second radar signals that are offset angularly in elevation from each other by a predetermined angle;

generating a first elevation signal and a second elevation signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

subtracting one of said first and second elevation signals from the other to provide an elevation difference signal;

comparing said difference signal to a first predetermined value to generate a first signal at times said elevation difference signal exceeds said first predetermined value;

generating a first quadrature signal and a second quadrature signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

comparing said first quadrature signal with a second predetermined value and said second quadrature signal with a third predetermined value to generate a second signal at times said first quadrature signal exceeds said second predetermined value and a third signal at times said second quadrature signal exceeds said third predetermined value;

generating at first times a table of elevation correction values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

selecting at second times an elevation correction value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal;

adding said selected elevation correction value to said second elevation signal to form a third elevation signal; and

selecting one of said first, second or third elevation signals as the position of said target in response to said first, second and third signals.

39. Apparatus for determining the position of a target comprising:

means for transmitting first and second radar signals that are offset angularly in elevation from each other by a predetermined angle;

means for generating a first elevation signal and a second elevation signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

means for subtracting one of said first and second elevation signals from the other to provide an elevation difference signal;

means for generating a first signal at times said elevation difference signal exceeds a first predetermined value;

means for generating a first quadrature signal and a second quadrature signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

means for generating a second signal at times said first quadrature signal exceeds a second predetermined value and a third signal at times said second quadrature signal exceeds a third predetermined value; and

means for selecting one of said first and second elevation signals as the position of said target in response to said first, second and third signals.

40. The apparatus of claim 39 wherein said means for transmitting includes an antenna having a beamwidth of 50 milliradians.

41. The apparatus of claim 39 wherein said means for transmitting includes an antenna having at least a sum and difference channel.

42. The apparatus of claim 39 wherein said means for transmitting includes an antenna having a plurality of feeds to provide a first radiant beam having a boresight reference axis and a first predetermined beamwidth at first times and a second radiant beam having a boresight reference axis and a second predetermined beamwidth angularly offset in elevation by said predetermined angle at second times.

43. The apparatus of claim 42 wherein said antenna includes means for generating sum and difference signals from target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals.

44. The apparatus of claim 39 wherein said means for generating a first elevation signal and a second elevation signal includes means for generating in-phase and quadrature signals.

45. The apparatus of claim 39 wherein said means for transmitting said second radar signal includes means for transmitting at said predetermined angle which is substantially 60% of the beamwidth of said second radar signal.

46. The apparatus of claim 39 further including means for filtering the signal to be selected.

47. The apparatus of claim 39 further including:

means for generating at first times a table of elevation correction values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

for selecting at second times an elevation correction value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal;

means for adding said selected elevation correction value to said second elevation signal to form a third elevation signal; and

means for selecting one of said first, second or third elevation signals as the position of said target in response to said first, second and third signals.

48. The apparatus of claim 39 further including:

means for generating a table of target to image angle values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

for selecting a target to image angle value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

means for coupling said selected target to image angle value to an output terminal.

49. The apparatus of claim 39 further including:

means for generating a table of reflection coefficient values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

for selecting a reflection coefficient value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

means for coupling said selected reflection coefficient value to an output terminal.

50. The apparatus of claim 39 further including:

means for generating a table of phase angle values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

for selecting a phase angle value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal; and

means for coupling said selected phase angle value to an output terminal.

52. The apparatus of claim 39 or 51 further including means for directing in elevation said first radar signals in response to said selected elevation signal and wherein said second radar signals are offset angularly in elevation above said first radar signals.

53. The apparatus of claims 51, 48, 49 or 50 wherein said means for generating a table includes means for storing a plurality of predetermined constants in a memory.

54. The apparatus of claims 51, 48, 49 or 50 wherein said means for generating a table includes means for storing a plurality of predetermined constants in a memory and wherein said means for selecting includes:

said memory coupled to receive said elevation difference signal, said first and second quadrature signals to address said memory to read

out from said memory a portion of said predetermined constants.

51. Apparatus for determining the position of a target comprising:

means for transmitting first and second radar signals that are offset angularly in elevation from each other by a predetermined angle;

means for generating a first elevation signal and a second elevation signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

means for subtracting one of said first and second elevation signals from the other to provide an elevation difference signal;

means for generating a first signal at times said elevation difference signal exceeds a first predetermined value;

means for generating a first quadrature signal and a second quadrature signal in response to target reflected signals of said first and second transmitted signals, respectively;

means for generating a second signal at times said first quadrature signal exceeds a second predetermined value and a third signal at times said second quadrature signal exceeds a third predetermined value;

means for generating at first times a table of elevation correction values in response to the values of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal and

for selecting at second times an elevation correction value from said table in response to the value of said elevation difference signal, first quadrature signal and said second quadrature signal;

means for adding said selected elevation correction value to said second elevation signal to form a third elevation signal; and

means for selecting one of said first, second or third elevation signals as the position of said target in response to said first, second and third signals.