Method and apparatus for monitoring and controlling resistance spot welding

• US 4,694,135 A
• Filed: 07/09/1986
• Issued: 09/15/1987
• Est. Priority Date: 07/09/1986
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: General Motors Corporation (General Motors Company)
• Original Assignee: General Motors Corporation (General Motors Company)
• Inventors: Sidlosky, David M., Lee, Anthony, Cleveland, Dixon, Murty, Balarama V., Nagel, Gregory L.
• Primary Examiner(s): Shaw, Clifford C.
• Application Number:
  US06/883,934
• Time in Patent Office: 433 Days
• Field of Search: 219/108, 219/109, 219/110, 219/117.1
• US Class Current: 219/110
• CPC Class Codes: B23K 11/115 by means of two electrodes placed opposite one another on both sides of the welded parts
• CPC Class Codes: B23K 11/256 the measured parameter being the inter-electrode electrical resistance

Abstract

A method and apparatus are disclosed for analyzing the dynamic resistance of a resistance spot welding process to determine the time of an expulsion event and use that time as the weld completion time for controlling weld termination via a weld feedback signal, controlling automatic current stepping, and identifying maintenance needs. A preconditioning pulse is used to stabilize the weld process and aid in obtaining interpretable resistance information. After an initial blanking period the resistance curve is analyzed by calculating first and second derivative values and applying several algorithms that make possible the computer recognition of characteristic resistance curve shapes resulting from weld expulsion under good geometry, bad geometry and edge weld conditions.

Claims

1. A method of monitoring resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

stabilizing the weld process by preconditioning the workpiece interfaces immediately after electrode contact with the workpiece and before steady state electrode pressure is attained to establish consistent interface resistance levels,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters, and

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event.

2. A method of monitoring resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

stabilizing the weld process by preconditioning the workpiece interfaces immediately after electrode contact with the workpiece and before steady state electrode pressure is attained to establish consistent interface resistance levels,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

setting a blanking period at the beginning of the weld process when abberations in the parameters frequently occur,

after the blanking period, calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters, and

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event.

3. A method of monitoring resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

stabilizing the weld process by applying a preheat current pulse to the workpiece immediately after initial contact of electrodes with the workpiece and before steady state electrode pressure is attained and then inhibiting weld current for a cooling period to establish consistent interface resistance levels,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters, and

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event.

4. A method of monitoring resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from first and second derivative resistance curves characteristic shapes and values which are indicators of the start of expulsion, the middle of expulsion, and the end of expulsion, and

(b) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators.

5. A method as defined in claim 4 wherein the process is subject to a period of mechanical instability during an early portion of the weld cycle, comprising beginning the step of analyzing the calculated values after the instability period.

6. A method of monitoring resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process at a time later than the beginning of nugget formation to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value below a negative threshold which is an indicator of the start of expulsion,

(b) detecting from the first derivative resistance curve a value below another negative threshold which is an indicator of the middle of expulsion,

(c) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value above a positive threshold which is an indicator of the end of expulsion, and

(d) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators.

7. A method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

applying welding current to a workpiece,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event, and

terminating the welding current upon detection of expulsion.

8. A method as defined in claim 7 wherein the welding current is initiated by applying a preheat current pulse immediately after electrode contact to heat the interfaces and then inhibiting current for a cooling period to allow heat dissipation from the interfaces so that the interface resistance is stabilized prior to continuation of the weld current schedule.

9. A method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

applying weld current to a workpiece,

stabilizing the weld process by applying a preheat current pulse to the workpiece immediately after initial contact of electrodes with the workpiece and then inhibiting weld current for a cooling period to establish consistent interface resistance levels,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event, and

terminating weld current upon detection of an expulsion event.

10. A method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

applying weld current to a workpiece,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from the first and second derivative resistance curves characteristic shapes and values which are indicators of the start of expulsion, the middle of expulsion, and the end of expulsion, and

(b) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators, and

terminating weld current upon determination of an expulsion event.

11. A method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

applying welding current to a workpiece,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process at a time later than the beginning of nugget formation to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value below a negative threshold which is an indicator of the start of expulsion,

(b) detecting from the first derivative resistance curve a value below another negative threshold which is an indicator of the middle of expulsion,

(c) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value above a positive threshold which is an indicator of the end of expulsion, and

(d) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators, and

terminating weld current upon determining an expulsion event.

12. A method as defined in claim 11 wherein the welding current is initiated by applying a preheat current pulse immediately after electrode contact to heat the interfaces and then providing a cooling period to allow heat dissipation from the interfaces so that the interface resistance is stabilized prior to continuation of the weld current schedule.

13. A method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

applying welding current to a workpiece,

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the expulsion time,

averaging the expulsion time over a plurality of consecutive welds to obtain a trend of expulsion time, and

changing the heat setting when the average time varies from a setpoint, thereby compensating for changes in electrode geometry.

14. In a resistance welding system having an adjustable heat setting to accommodate changing weld current changes due to electrode wear, the method of controlling resistance spot welding comprising the steps of;

measuring electrical welding parameters,

calculating first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters,

analyzing the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the expulsion time,

setting a standard expulsion time,

averaging the deviation of expulsion time from the standard expulsion time over a plurality of consecutive welds to obtain a trend of expulsion time, and

changing the heat setting in accordance with the average expulsion time deviation thereby compensating for changes in electrode geometry.

15. A controller for a resistance spot welding system having electrode means for applying weld current and pressure to a workpiece including;

means for supplying weld current according to a weld schedule, and

control means coupled to the current supply means programmed to;

(a) measure electrical welding parameters,

(b) calculate first and second derivative resistance values from the measured parameters,

(c) analyze the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event, and

(d) signal the current supply means to terminate the welding current upon detection of expulsion.

16. A controller as defined in claim 15 including means for detecting electrode contact with the workpiece, and means for applying a preheat current pulse immediately after electrode contact to heat the interfaces and then providing a cooling period to allow heat dissipation from the interfaces so that the interface resistance is stabilized prior to continuation of the weld current schedule.

17. A controller for a resistance spot welding system having electrode means for applying weld current and pressure to a workpiece including;

means for supplying weld current according to a weld schedule, and

control means coupled to the current supply means programmed to;

measure electrical welding parameters,

calculate dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyze the calculated values during the welding process to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from first and second derivative resistance curves characteristic shapes and values which are indicators of the start of expulsion, the middle of expulsion, and the end of expulsion, and

(b) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators, and

signal the current supply means to terminate weld current upon determination of an expulsion event.

18. A controller for a resistance spot welding system having electrode means for applying weld current and pressure to a workpiece including;

means for supplying weld current according to a weld schedule, and

control means coupled to the current supply means programmed to;

measure electrical welding parameters,

calculate dynamic resistance values and first and second derivative resistance curves from the measured parameters,

analyze the calculated values during the welding process at a time later than the beginning of nugget formation to detect an expulsion event and the time of the event by

(a) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value below a negative threshold which is an indicator of the start of expulsion,

(b) detecting from the first derivative resistance curve a value below another negative threshold which is an indicator of the middle of expulsion,

(c) detecting from the second derivative resistance curve a value above a positive threshold which is an indicator of the end of expulsion, and

(d) determining an expulsion event upon the occurrence of a middle of expulsion indicator and at least one of the start and the end of expulsion indicators, and

generate a signal to terminate weld current upon determining an expulsion event.