Fail-safe circuit for a control system

• US 4,739,469 A
• Filed: 04/18/1985
• Issued: 04/19/1988
• Est. Priority Date: 04/19/1984
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Nissan Motor Co., Ltd.
• Original Assignee: Nissan Motor Co., Ltd.
• Inventors: Oshiage, Katsunori, Yamamoto, Akito, Abo, Toshimi
• Primary Examiner(s): Harkcom, Gary V.
• Application Number:
  US06/724,596
• Time in Patent Office: 1,097 Days
• Field of Search: 364/184, 364/187, 364/431.04, 364/431.11, 371/7-9, 371/11, 371/61-62, 123/417, 123/479
• US Class Current: 700/82
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 9/03 with multiple-channel loop, i.e. redundant control systems
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/0796 Safety measures, i.e. ensuring safe condition in the event of error, e.g. for controlling element
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/2028 eliminating a faulty processor or activating a spare
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/2038 with a single idle spare processing component

Abstract

A highly reliable, fail-safe circuit for a control system wherein a controlled device will always receive a control signal derived from a main control circuit when the main control circuit operates normally even if a back-up control circuit backing up at least one function of the main control circuit which is a minimum requirement for an operation of the controlled device fails or wherein a controlled device will receive a control signal derived from the back-up control circuit when the main control circuit fails. Replacement of the control signal from the main control circuit with a back-up control signal from the back-up circuit is carried out only when the back-up circuit outputs a particular signal at or near a predetermined frequency or alternatively when the back-up circuit outputs a plurality of parallel logical signals in a predetermined combination.

Claims

1. A fail-safe circuit for a control system, comprising:

(a) a main control circuit which produces and sends a first control signal to a controlled device for controlling the controlled device;

(b) a back-up control circuit which operatively produces and sends a second control signal to the controlled device in place of the first control signal when the main control circuit fails, the back-up control circuit having first means for recognizing a malfunction of said main control circuit and proper operation of the back-up control circuit and second means for generating a unique switching signal when said first means recognizes the malfunction of said main control circuit and proper operation of the back-up control circuit;

(c) a switching circuit for switching between the first and second control signals to transmit either of the first and second control signals to the controlled device depending on a presence or absence of the unique signal generated from said second means; and

(d) a switching control circuit for controlling the switching circuit to enable transmission of the second control signal produced from the back-up control circuit to the controlled device when the unique switching signal is received from the back-up control circuit and for enabling transmission of the first control signal produced from the main control circuit when the unique switching signal is not received from the back-up control circuit, thereby preventing an erroneous switching of the switching circuit when the main control circuit is operating properly and the back-up control circuit generates a faulty switching signal.

2. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 1, wherein the unique switching signal from said back-up control circuit is a signal having a predetermined frequency and is outputted to the switching control circuit when the first means recognizes the malfunction of the main control circuit and proper operation of the back-up control circuit and wherein the switching control circuit enables the switching circuit to transmit the second control signal to the controlled device when the unique signal derived from the second means is received, wherein the unique signal falls within a given range including the predetermined frequency.

3. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 2, wherein said switching control circuit comprises:

a band-pass filter which receives the unique signal from said second means and transmits the components of the unique switching signal falling within a predetermined frequency band; and

a retriggerable monostable multivibrator connected to said band-pass filter which outputs a third control signal when components of said unique signal fall within a given range of the predetermined frequency.

4. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 1, wherein the unique switching signal derived from said second means of the back-up control circuit comprises a plurality of parallel logical signals in a predetermined combination of logical levels and said switching control circuit enables the switching circuit to transmit the second control signal to the controlled device only when the unique signal has the predetermined combination of logic levels.

5. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 4, further including means for resetting said main control circuit whenever said main control circuit malfunctions, wherein said first means of the back-up control circuit recognizes malfunction of said main control circuit on the basis of the number of times said main control circuit is reset.

6. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 4, wherein said switching circuit transmits the first control signal fromsaid main control circuit to the controlled device in the absence of a third control signal derived from said switching control circuit which is produced when the unique signal is received.

7. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 1, wherein said first means recognizes malfunction of said main control circuit on the basis of a period of a status signal generated periodically during the process of generating the first control signal by said main control circuit.

8. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 7, wherein said main control circuit comprises:

a control section having a microprocessor;

a register for receiving and storing temporarily a predetermined value from said control section during execution of a series of control procedures by said control section;

a timer for counting fixed-frequency clock pulses;

a comparator for comparing the predetermined value stored in said register with the number of clock pulses counted by said timer and outputting an interrupt signal to said timer for resetting said timer and to said control section for changing the level of said status signal, whereby the status signal has a predetermined period when said main control circuit is operating normally.

9. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 8, wherein said back-up control circuit comprises:

a control section having the same structure as said main control circuit;

a timer for counting clock pulses; and

a capture register which temporarily stores the counted value of said timer in response to the rising edge of said status signal from said main control circuit, said control section of said back-up control circuit reading and comparing the values of said capture register at successive rising edges of said status signal so as to obtain the period of said status signal.

10. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 9, wherein said control section constitutes said first of said back-up control circuit means and said first means recognizes malfunction of said main control circuit when the period of said status signal is not substantially equal to a predetermined period and the interval of time over which the period of the status signal is not substantially equal to the predetermined period exceeds a predetermined interval of time.

11. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 10, wherein said second means outputs a plurality of parallel logical signals in a predetermined combination of logic levels when said first means recognizes malfunction of said main control circuit and said switching control circuit outputs the third control signal to said switching circuit only in response to the predetermined combination of logical levels.

12. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 11, wherein said switching control circuit comprises a logic circuit having a plurality of input terminals, each receiving a corresponding one of the plurality of parallel logical signals from said second means, and one output terminal from which the third control signal is outputted to said switching circuit only when the combination of logic levels of the parallel logical signals satisfied a predetermined logical condition.

13. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 12, wherein the second means outputs three parallel signals at low, high and low logic levels respectively, and said logic circuit comprises two inverters receiving the two low-level signals and a NAND gate circuit receiving the two inverted signals and the remaining high-level signal, whereby the NAND gate circuit outputs the third control signal at a low logic level to said switching control circuit to enable said switching control circuit to transmit the second control signal to the controlled device.

14. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 14, wherein said switching circuit transmits the first control signal when a third control signal, derived from the switching control circuit produced when the unique signal is received, is at a grounded voltage level and further comprising a pull-down resistor connected between a line connecting said switching circuit and switching control circuit and ground.

15. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 15, wherein said switching control circuit transmits the first control signal when the third control signal is at a higher of two voltage levels and further comprising a pull-up resistor connected between a line connecting said switching circuit and switching control circuit and a positive power supply.

16. The fail-safe circuit according to claim 16, wherein the second control signal satisfies minimum requirements of control of the controlled device.