Hardware modeling system and method for simulating portions of electrical circuits

• US 4,744,084 A
• Filed: 07/08/1987
• Issued: 05/10/1988
• Est. Priority Date: 02/27/1986
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Mentor Graphics Corporation (Siemens AG)
• Original Assignee: Mentor Graphics Corporation (Siemens AG)
• Inventors: Stanbro, Michael E., Thomsen, Eric J., Beck, Ronald R.
• Primary Examiner(s): Smith, Jerry
• Assistant Examiner(s): Beausoliel, Robert W.
• Application Number:
  US07/070,598
• Time in Patent Office: 307 Days
• Field of Search: 371/15, 371/16, 371/17, 371/18, 371/20, 371/23, 364/578, 364/488, 364/489, 364/490, 364/491, 364/200 MS File, 364/900 MS File, 364/149, 364/150, 364/151, 324/73 R, 324/73 AT, 324/73 PC
• US Class Current: 714/33
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 30/33 Design verification, e.g. functional simulation or model checking

Abstract

A hardware modeling system 10 simulates portions of electrical circuits 16, 18 utilizing actual hardware components in the simulation. Access to these hardware modeling elements 16, 18 is provided on a shared basis to plural workstations 14. Simulation vectors for plural users may be stored discontiguously in a first memory 26 and a single user'"'"'s vectors are transferred to a second memory 28 for streaming to the elements 16, 18. An optional timing analyzer and memory circuit 34 periodically samples outputs from pins of the hardware modeling elements to provide timing information on the response of such elements. High impedance testing and bus contention detection is performed on the pins of the hardware modeling elements. Clocking signals applied to the hardware modeling elements are adjustable and may be set at extremely high frequencies. A special gating circuit 292 accesses each pin of the hardware modeling elements and incorporates one or more of the above features.

Claims

1. In a simulation system which includes plural workstations for independently and simultaneously simulating the response of electronic circuits to applied test data, a hardware modeling system for simulating the response of a plural pin circuit element by evaluating the behavior of an actual circuit element upon recognition by a workstation that the circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at the workstation corresponds to an actual circuit element in the hardware modeling system, the hardware modeling system comprising:

hardware modeling circuit means including input means for receiving input test data from the workstation, stimulus signal generation means coupled to the input means for converting the input test data into evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means coupled to the stimulus signal generation means for applying the evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and for converting the output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli, and output means coupled to the retrieval means for receiving the resultant test data; and

network interface means for coupling the plural workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means so as to provide concurrent access by each of the workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means, said network interface means comprising means for coupling the workstations to the input means and for transferring input test data from a workstation to the input means upon recognition that the plural pin circuit element being stimulated at the workstation corresponds to an actual circuit element in the hardware modeling system, the network interface means also comprising means coupling the output means to the workstations and for transfering resultant test data from the output means to the workstation following completion of a simulation, the network interface means thereby comprising means for interfacing the workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means so as to permit sharing of the hardware modeling circuit means among the workstations for concurrent circuit simulations by the workstations.

2. A simulation system according to claim 1 including plural hardware modeling circuit means, said network interface means comprising means for interfacing the workstations to such plural hardware modeling circuit means so as to permit sharing of the plural hardware modeling circuit means among the plural workstations.

3. A system according to claim 1 in which the hardware modeling circuit means includes plural integrated circuit interface means and input/output port means for coupling to actual circuit elements, the integrated circuit interface means and input/output port means including the stimulus signal generation means coupled to the input means for receiving input test data and for generating evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, the application means coupled to the stimulus signal generation means for applying evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit elements, and the retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit elements for receiving output signals from the actual circuit elements, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit elements in response to the evaluation stimuli.

4. The hardware modeling system of claim 1 in which the input means comprises:

a first semiconductor memory circuit capable of operating at a first rate for storing input test data for use in a plurality of simulations;

a second semiconductor memory circuit capable of operating at a second rate faster than the first rate for storing input test data for use in a single simulation;

means for transferring input test data for use in a single simulation from the first semiconductor memory circuit to the second semiconductor memory circuit; and

means for transferring input test data from the second semiconductor memory circuit to the stimulus signal generation means.

5. A hardware modeling system with a plurality of different plural pin hardware modeling elements used for performing simulations of the performance of electronic circuits in response to input test data, means for converting test data to evaluation stimuli and for applying the evaluation stimuli to selected input pins of the hardware modeling element, means for retrieving output signals from selected output pins of the hardware modeling element and for converting the output signals to resultant test data, timing analyzer circuit means for periodically sampling the resultant data from the output pins to provide a timing representation of the resultant data at the output pins over time, and means for selectively coupling the timing analyzer circuit means to the output pins to provide the timing representation.

6. A hardware modeling system according to claim 5 including:

user memory means for storing input test data for one or more simulations;

operating memory means for storing input test data for only one simulation;

means for applying input test data from the operating memory means to said means for converting test data during a simulation; and

means for transferring input test data for a single simulation from the user memory means to the operatin memory means following the application of input test data for a prior simulation from the operating memory means to the means for converting test data.

7. In a hardware modeling system in which evaluation stimuli corresponding to data signals and clocking signals are applied to pins of a plurality of different plural pin hardware modeling elements used in circuit simulations so as to produce output signals from output pins of the hardware modeling elements and thereby simulation results;

gating circuit means with plural circuit pin connections, each such pin connection for connection to a single associated pin of a hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as input data pin connections;

means for transferring test stimuli to the input data pin connections and thereby to the associated pins of the hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as clock pin connections;

means for transferring clocking signals to the clock pin connections and thereby to the associated pins of the hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as output data connections; and

means for receiving output data from the output data connections and thereby from the associated pins of the hardware modeling element.

8. A gating circuit according to claim 7 including means for selectively applying a variable logic 0, logic 1 or high impedance to any of the pin connections and thereby to the associated pins.

9. A gating circuit according to claim 7 including means for selectively applying a pull-up or a pull-down load to any of the pin connections and thereby to the associated pins.

10. A hardware modeling system according to claim 7 which includes means for selectively applying clock signals to any of the pins of the actual circuit element, and also includes means for adjusting the phase, duty cycle and frequency of the applied clock signals.

11. A hardware modeling system in which evaluation stimuli corresponding to data signals and clocking signals are applied to pins of a plural pin hardware modeling element corresponding to a component in a circuit being simulated so as to produce output signals from output pins of the hardware modeling element for use in the circuit stimulation, the system including;

gating circuit means with plural circuit pin connections, each such pin connection for connection to a single associated pin of a hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as input data pin connections;

means for transferring test stimuli to the input data pin connections and thereby to the associated pins of the hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as clock pin connections;

means for transferring clocking signals to the clock pin connections and thereby to the associated pins of the hardware modeling element;

means for selecting any of the pin connections as output data connections;

means for receiving output data from the output data connections and thereby from the associated pins of the hardware modeling element;

the system further including bus contention detection means for indicating when any of such pin connections are driven by a signal from a hardware modeling element to one state while the same pin connection is driven by a signal from the gating circuit to an opposite state, and for disabling at least one of the drive signals applied to the pin connection under such conditions.

12. An apparatus according to claim 11 including timing analyzer means selectively coupled to the output pin connections for performing timing analysis on output signals received from the associated pins.

13. An apparatus according to claim 11 including clocking means for applying clocking signals to the clocking pin connections, such clocking means including means for varying the frequency, duty cycle and phase of clocking signals applied to each such clocking pin connection.

14. A hardware modeling system for simulating the response of at least one plural pin circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at a workstation by evaluating the behavior of an actual plural pin circuit element in response to test data from the workstation, comprising:

memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation;

circuit interface means for coupling to the actual circuit element, the circuit interface means being coupled to the memory means for receiving the input test data from the memory means, the interface means comprising stimulus signal generation means for generating evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means for applying evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and converting the received output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli;

the memory means comprising means coupled to the resultant test data retriveval means for receiving and storing the resultant test data;

control circuit means coupled to the memory means and to the circuit interface means for controlling the transfer of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, for controlling the application of the evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element by the application means, for controlling the receiving of output signals and conversion of output signals to resultant test data by the resultant test data retrieval means, and for controlling the transfer of resultant test data to the memory means and the return of the resultant test data from the memory means to the workstation; and

the memory means including first memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation for plural circuit simulations, second memory means for receiving input test data from the first memory means for a single simulation, the control circuit means comprising means for controlling the transfer of input test data for a simulation from the second memory means to the circuit interface means and for controlling the transfer of input test data for a single simulation from the first memory means to the second memory means following the transfer from the second memory means to the circuit interface means.

15. A hardware modeling system according to claim 14 which the control circuit means comprises means for controlling the transfer of resultant test data from the resultant test data retrieval means to the first memory means.

16. The hardware modeling system of claim 14 in which the first and second memory means comprise semiconductor memory circuits.

17. The hardware modeling system of claim 16 in which the second semiconductor memory circuit can be accessed more quickly than the first.

18. A system according to claim 14 in which the first memory means operates at a first rate and the second memory means operates at a second rate greater than the first rate.

19. A hardware modeling system according to claim 14 in which the control cirucit means includes device clock means for generating device clock signals for clocking the actual circuit elements, the control circuit means also including means for selectively positioning the rising and falling edges of the device clock signals relative to the evaluation stimuli and thus relative to the input test data.

20. A system according to claim 14 in which the second memory means has a full pattern depth available to each circuit element during a simulation using the circuit element.

22. A hardware modeling system according to claim 16 including timing analyzer and memory circuit means coupled to the resultant test data retrieval means for selectively receiving resultant test data, the control circuit means comprising means for periodically transferring resultant test data to the timing analyzer and memory circuit means to provide a representation of such resultant test data over time.

23. A hardware modeling system according to claim 22 in which the control circuit means includes means for applying timing analysis clocking signals to the timing analyzer and memory circuit means to transfer resultant test data in response to the timing analysis clocking signals.

21. A hardware modeling system for simulating the response of at least one plural pin circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at a workstation by evaluating the behavior of an actual plural pin circuit element in response to test data from the workstation, comprising:

memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation;

circuit interface means for coupling to the actual circuit element, the circuit interface means being coupled to the memory means for receiving the input test data from the memory means, the interface means comprising stimulus signal generation means for generating evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means for applying evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and converting the received output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli;

the memory means comprising means coupled to the resultant test data retrieval means for receiving and storing the resultant test data;

control circuit means coupled to the memory means and to the circuit interface means for controlling the transfer of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, for controlling the application of the evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element by the application means, for controlling the receiving of output signals and conversion of output signals to resultant test data by the resultant test data retrieval means, and for controlling the transfer of resultant test data to the memory means and the return of the resultant test data from the memory means to the workstation;

the memory means including first memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation for plural circuit simulations, second memory means for receiving input test data from the first memory means for a single simulation, the control circuit means comprising means for controlling the transfer of input test data for a simulation from the second memory means to the circuit interface means and for controlling the transfer of input test data for a single simulation from the first memory means to the second memory means following the transfer from the second memory means to the circuit interface means; and

the memory means including third supplemental disk memory means which acts as a virtual memory means, the hardware modeling system including means for swapping inputting test data from the first to third memory means and from the third to first memory means.

24. A hardware modeling system according to claim 21 including high impedance testing means for determining whether a pin of the actual circuit element is at a high impedance state, the high impedance testing means comprising means for applying a logic high signal and a logic low signal to the pin and evaluating whether the pin is pulled to the logic high and logic low states in response to the applied signals.

25. A system according to claim 21 in which the first memory means operates at a first rate and the second memory means operates at a second rate greater than the first rate.

26. A hardware modeling system for simulating the response of at least one plural pin circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at a workstation by evaluating the behavior of an actual plural pin circuit element in response to test data from the workstation, comprising:

memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation;

circuit interface means for coupling to the actual circuit element, the circuit interface means being coupled to the memory means for receiving the input test data from the memory means, the interface means comprising stimulus signal generation means for generating evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means for applying evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and converting the received output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli;

the memory means comprising means coupled to the resultant test data retrieval means for receiving and storing the resultant test data;

control circuit means coupled to the memory means and to the circuit interface means for controlling the transfer of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, for controlling the application of the evaluation stimuli by the actual circuit element by the application means, for controlling the receiving of output signals and conversion of output signals to resultant test data by the resultant test data retrieval means, and for controlling the transfer of resultant test data to the memory means and the return of the resultant test data from the memory means to the workstation;

the control circuit means including first clock means for clocking a first set of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, second clock means for clocking a second set of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, master clock means for generating master clock signals for clocking the stimulus signal generation means following the transfers of the first and second sets of input test data, thereby controlling the generation of evaluation stimuli to correspond to both of the first and second sets of input test data, and device clock means for generating device clock signals for clocking the actual circuit elements.

27. The hardware modeling system according to claim 26 in which the control circuit means includes means for selectively positioning the rising and falling edges of the device clock signals relative to the master clock signals.

28. A hardware modeling system for simulating the response of at least one plural pin circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at a workstation by evaluating the behavior of an actual plural pin circuit element in response to test data from the workstation, comprising:

memory means for receiving and storing input test data from the workstation;

circuit interface means for coupling to the actual circuit element, the circuit interface means being coupled to the memory means for receiving the input test data from the memory means, the interface means comprising stimulus signal generation means for generating evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means for applying evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and converting the received output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli;

the memory means comprising means coupled to the resultant test data retreval means for receiving and storing the resultant test data;

control circuit means coupled to the memory means and to the circuit interface means for controlling the transfer of input test data from the memory means to the circuit interface means, for controlling the application of the evaluation stimuli by the actual circuit element by the application means, for controlling the receiving of output signals and conversion of output signals to resultant test data by the resultant test data retrieval means, and for controlling the transfer of resultant test data to the memory means and the return of the resultant test data from the memory means to the workstation;

the system further including bus contention means for detcting bus contentions, a bus contention occurring upon the application of a drive signal by the application means to a pin of the actual circuit element simultaneously with the generation of an output drive signal at such pin by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli.

29. A hardware modeling system according to claim 28 in which the bus contention means includes means for changing the drive signal which is applied to such pin by the application means to a high-impedance signal upon detection of a bus contention at such pin to thereby minimize the risk of damage from the bus contention.

30. An electronic circuit simulation method in which actual plural pin hardware circuit elements are used in the simulation comprising:

storing test data for plural simulations in a first memory;

transferring test data for a single simulation from the first memory to a second memory;

applying test data for the single simulation from the second memory to an actual hardware circuit element to provide resultant test data from the circuit element; and

transferring test data for successive single simulations from the first memory to the second memory following the application of test data for a prior single simulation to an actual hardware modeling element.

31. A method according to claim 30, including the step of sampling output signals from output pins of an actual circuit element as test data is applied to the actual circuit element during a simulation, thereby providing a representation of the output signals at the sampled output pins during the simulation.

32. A method according to claim 30 comprising the steps of transferring test data at a first rate from the first memory to the second memory and applying the test data at a second rate higher than the first rate from the second memory to the actual hardware circuit element.

33. In a simulation system which includes plural workstations for simulating the response of electronic circuits to applied test data, a hardware modeling system for simulating the response of at least one plural pin circuit element by evaluating the behavior of an actual circuit element upon recognition by a workstation that the circuit element in an electronic circuit being simulated at the workstation corresponds to an actual circuit element in the hardware modeling system, the hardware modeling system comprising:

hardware modeling circuit means including input means for receiving input test data from the workstations, stimulus signal generation means coupled to the input means for converting the input test data into evaluation stimuli corresponding to the input test data, application means coupled to the stimulus signal generation means for applying the evaluation stimuli to the actual circuit element, resultant test data retrieval means coupled to the actual circuit element for receiving output signals from the actual circuit element and for converting the output signals to resultant test data, the output signals being generated by the actual circuit element in response to the applied evaluation stimuli, and output means coupled to the retrieval means for receiving the resultant test data;

network interface means for coupling the plural workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means so as to provide access by each of the workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means, said network interface means comprising means for coupling the workstations to the input means and for transferring input test data from a workstation to the input means upon recognition that the plural pin circuit element being stimulated at the workstation corresponds to an actual circuit element in the hardware modeling system, the network interface means also comprising means coupling the output means to the workstations and for transferring resultant test data from the output means to the workstation following completion of a simulation, the network interface means thereby comprising means for interfacing the workstations to the hardware modeling circuit means so as to permit sharing of the hardware modeling circuit means among the workstations; and

the hardware modeling circuit means including;

user memory means for storing input test data for one or more simulations;

operating memory means for storing input test data for only one simulation;

means for applying input test data from the operating memory means to said means for converting test data during a simulation; and

means for transferring input test data for a single simulation from the user memory means to the operating memory means following the application of input test data for a prior simulation from the operating memory means to the means for converting test data.

34. A system according to claim 33 in which the means for transferring input test data from the user memory means to the operating memory means comprises means for transferring such input test data at a first rate, and in which the means for applying input test data from the operating memory means comprises means for applying such test data at a second rate which is greater than the first rate.

35. A system according to claim 34 in which the operating memory means has a full pattern depth available to each circuit element during a simulation using the circuit element.

36. A system according to claim 33 including third supplemental disk memory means which acts as a virtual memory means, the hardware modeling circuit means including means for swapping input test data from the first to third memory means and from the third to first memory means as the first memory means fills with input test data.

37. A simulation system comprising:

plural workstations each capable of independently performing circuit evaluations of various circuit in which the evaluations involve at least in part a software simulation of the circuit being evaluated by each workstation;

hardware modeling circuit means coupled to the plural workstations and including at least one actual circuit element, the hardware modeling circuit means comprising means for providing shared access by the plural workstations to the actual circuit element, the hardware modeling circuit means comprsing means permitting the plural workstations to perform concurrent circuit evaluations using the actual hardware element in the evaluation when such element appears in the circuits being evaluated by the plural workstations.

38. A simulation system according to claim 37 in which the hardware modelling circuit means has plural actual circuit elements.