Apparatus and method for liquid chromatography

• US 4,775,481 A
• Filed: 08/10/1987
• Issued: 10/04/1988
• Est. Priority Date: 09/09/1981
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Isco, Inc. (Teledyne Technologies Incorporated)
• Original Assignee: Isco, Inc. (Teledyne Technologies Incorporated)
• Inventors: Allington, Robert W.
• Primary Examiner(s): Fisher, Richard V.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Jordan, Richard D.
• Application Number:
  US07/083,889
• Time in Patent Office: 421 Days
• Field of Search: 210/656, 210/659, 210/101, 210/137, 210/138, 210/148.2, 210/739, 210/741, 417/7, 417/42, 417/43, 417/44
• US Class Current: 210/656
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 2030/326 pumps
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 30/32 of pressure or speed G01N30/36 takes precedence

Abstract

To stabilize flow rate in a single-stroke, syringe-type high pressure pump at a constant value after turn-on, a control system increases the pump speed until equilibrium conditions are reached and then pumps at the present rate. In one embodiment, the system is operated in a constant pressure mode under the control of a feedback system to a point at which the pressure is estimated to provide the desired flow rate, with feedback being provided from a pressure measurement and from a flow rate measurement. The feedback from the flow measurement is increased logarithmically with the rate of pumping prior to being compared with the pressure error signal and the comparison between the previous error signal and the logarithmic flow rate signal is used to control the speed of pumping.

Claims

1. A method of rapidly bringing a chromatographic column through a transitory period from starting to equilibrium pressure comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into said column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring the pressure of the fluid;

measuring the rate of flow of the fluid;

determining the difference between the equilibrium pressure and the measured pressure to obtain a pressure error;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least a function of said pressure error and measured rate of flow until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow until said estimated equilibrium value of pressure is reached including the step of controlling the rate of flow with a feedback signal that causes the pumping speed to increase substantially proportionally to the change in the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure substantially independently of the rate of flow wherein the feedback signal is formed from the pressure error and a function that increases at a decreasing rate as the rate of flow increases.

2. A method according to claim 1 in which the step of controlling the rate of flow includes the step of subtracting a function that is substantially the logarithm of the pumping rate from the pressure error.

3. A method according to claim 2 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow comprises the steps of:

estimating the equilibrium pressure for a constant-flow-rate chromatographic run;

increasing the pump motor speed rapidly until said pressure is reached;

permitting the flow rate to stabilize at said set pressure;

repeating the process of estimating the pressure and increasing the speed of the pumping system to the estimated pressure until the flow rate is close to the constant flow rate; and

operating said chromatograph at the constant flow rate.

4. A method according to claim 3 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

comparing the pressure with the estimated pressure to derive a pressure error signal;

obtaining a flow rate signal corresponding substantially to the logarithm of the flow rate;

comparing the flow rate signal with the pressure error signal to obtain a difference signal; and

applying the difference signal to a feedback loop to control the pumping system speed until the set pressure equals the estimated pressure.

5. A method according to claim 4 including the step of operating the chromatograph at a constant flow rate after the equilibrium pressure is reached by applying a potential to the motor which is constant, whereby the motor drives the pump at a constant flow rate.

6. A method according to claim 5 in which the step of determining when the pressure is equal to the estimated pressure comprises the steps of:

determining when the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero;

determining when the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure is approximately zero; and

selecting the time when both the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero and the difference between the measured pressure and set pressure is approximately zero as the end of the transitory period.

7. A method according to claim 6 in which the step of determining when the pressure is equal to the estimated pressure includes the step of opening an analog gate when the transitory period is over and permitting a signal representing the speed of the pumping system to pass therethrough.

8. A method according to claim 7 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

9. A method according to claim 2 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

10. A method according to claim 3 including the step of operating the chromatograph at a constant flow rate after the equilibrium pressure is reached by applying a potential to the motor which is constant, whereby the motor drives the pump at a constant flow rate.

11. A method according to claim 3 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

12. A method according to claim 4 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

13. A method according to claim 5 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

14. A method according to claim 1 in which the step of increasing the rate of flow comprises the steps of:

estimating the equilibrium pressure for a constant-flow-rate chromatographic run;

increasing the pump motor speed rapidly until said pressure is reached;

permitting the flow rate to stabilize at said set pressure;

repeating the process of estimating the pressure and increasing the speed of the pumping system to the estimated pressure until the flow rate is close to the constant flow rate; and

operating said chromatograph at the constant flow rate.

15. A method according to claim 1 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

16. A method according to claim 1 in which the step of determining when the pressure is equal to the estimated pressure comprises the steps of:

determining when the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero;

determining when the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure is approximately zero; and

selecting the time when both the slope of the pressure-time curve is approximately zero and the difference between the measured pressure and set pressure is approximately zero at the end of the transitory period.

17. Apparatus for rapidly bringing a chromatographic means to equilibrium pressure comprising:

pumping system means;

feedback signal means for controlling said pumping system means;

means for setting a pressure for fluid from the pumping system;

means for measuring the pressure of said fluid, being transferred from the pumping system means to the chromatographic means;

means for measuring the rate of flow of fluid from the pumping system means and generating a flow rate signal;

means for finding the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure and generating a pressure error signal therefrom; and

said feedback signal means including means for controlling the flow rate with a feedback signal formed from the pressure error signal and a function that increases at a decreasing rate as the pumping speed increases to cause the pumping speed to increase substantially proportionally to the pressure error signal substantially independently of the rate of flow.

18. Apparatus according to claim 17 further including:

means for setting the pumping speed means for pumping fluid into said chromatographic means at a predetermined rate of flow;

means for increasing the rate of flow of fluid from the pumping system means under the control of at least said pressure error signal until the set pressure is reached;

means for reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system means to said predetermined rate of flow after said set pressure is reached;

said feedback signal means for controlling the flow rate including means for increasing the speed of the pump in a constant pressure mode;

a first comparator;

first means for deriving a signal representing the speed of the pump;

means for deriving a first signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure;

means for obtaining a signal representing a nonlinear decreasing function of the pump speed and a second comparator;

said means for obtaining a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure having outputs electrically connected to different ones of the inputs of said first comparator;

the output of said first comparator being electrically connected to one input of said second comparator and the means for measuring the rate of flow and generating a flow rate signal being connected to the other input of said second comparator; and

the output of said second comparator being electrically connected to means for controlling the speed of the motor, whereby the feedback signal raises the speed of the motor until said set pressure and measured pressure are equal in said constant pressure mode.

19. Apparatus according to claim 18 in which the means for obtaining the nonlinear decreasing function is a means for obtaining the logarithm of the pump speed.

20. Apparatus according to claim 19 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure and generating a pressure error signal representing the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the pressure of said pump;

said second input of said comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to a sample-and-hold circuit.

21. Apparatus according to claim 20 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said second comparator.

22. Apparatus according to claim 21 including:

means for determining when equilibrium has been reached;

the means for determining when equilibrium has been reached including means for detecting a substantially zero slope in the pressure-time characteristic, means for determining when the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure is approximately zero and gate means for applying an output signal when the slope of the pressure-time curve and the difference between the measured pressure and set pressure are each approximately zero.

23. Apparatus according to claim 22 in which the means for determining when equilibrium has been reached includes:

gating means for applying a first output signal upon receiving a zero difference signal from said zero difference signal means and a zero slope signal from said zero slope detector and a second signal at other times, said first signal being electrically connected to a switch;

said switch providing a first signal upon receiving the signal from said gating means;

means electrically connected to said switching means for providing a signal thereto when the pressure in said pump moves from a value substantially zero to greater value;

the output from said switch means being connected to an analog gate; and

means for applying a signal to the input of said analog gate representing the speed of the pump motor, whereby said speed of said output motor is provided to the output of said analog gate when said transitory period is over.

24. Apparatus according to claim 23 further including a means for indicating the constant flow rate at a set equilibrium constant pressure when the chromatograph is operating in the constant pressure mode.

25. Apparatus according to claim 17 in which the means for controlling is a means for providing an increasing nonlinear function of said pressure error signal.

26. Apparatus according to claim 25 in which the means for providing an increasing nonlinear function is a means for providing a nonlinear function which is related to a product of said pressure error signal and flow rate signal.

27. Apparatus according to claim 17 in which the means for controlling includes means for generating a signal substantially proportional to the logarithm of the rate of flow.

28. Apparatus according to claim 27 in which the means for controlling includes a means for subtracting the signal substantially proportional to the logarithm of the rate of flow from the pressure error signal.

29. Apparatus according to claim 28 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the measured pressure of said pump;

said second input of said comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to a sample-and-hold circuit.

30. Apparatus according to claim 29 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-to-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said first comparator.

31. Apparatus according to claim 27 in which the means for generating a signal includes an automatic gain control circuit.

32. Apparatus according to claim 31 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the measured pressure of said pump;

said second input of said comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to a sample-and-hold circuit.

33. Apparatus according to claim 32 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said first comparator.

34. Apparatus comprising:

pumping system means;

feedback signal means for controlling said pumping system means;

means for setting a pressure for fluid from the pumping system;

means for measuring the pressure of said fluid being transferred from the pumping system means to a chromatographic means;

means for measuring the rate of flow of fluid from the pumping system means and generating a flow rate signal;

means for finding the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure and generating a pressure error signal therefrom; and

said feedback signal means including means for controlling the flow rate with a feedback signal formed from the pressure error signal and a function that increases at a decreasing rate as the pumping speed increases to cause the pumping speed to increase substantially proportionally to the pressure error signal substantially independently of the rate of flow.

35. Apparatus according to claim 34 further including:

said feedback signal means for controlling the flow rate including means for increasing the speed of the pump in a constant pressure mode;

a first comparator;

first means for deriving a signal representing the speed of the pump;

means for deriving a first signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure;

means for obtaining a signal representing a nonlinear decreasing function of the pump speed and a second comparator;

said means for obtaining a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure having outputs electrically connected to different ones of the inputs of said first comparator;

the output of said first comparator being electrically connected to one input of said second comparator and the means for measuring the rate of flow and generating a flow rate signal being connected to the other input of said second comparator; and

the output of said second comparator being electrically connected to means for controlling the speed of the motor, whereby the feedback signal raises the speed of the motor until said set pressure and measured pressure are equal in said constant pressure mode.

36. Apparatus according to claim 35 in which the means for obtaining the nonlinear decreasing function is a means for obtaining the logarithm of the pump speed.

37. Apparatus according to claim 36 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure and generating a pressure error signal representing the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the pressure of said pump;

said second input of sid comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to the sample-and-hold circuit.

38. Apparatus according to claim 37 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said second comparator.

39. Apparatus according to claim 34 in which the means for controlling is a means for providing an increasing nonlinear function of said pressure error signal.

40. Apparatus according to claim 39 in which the means for providing an increasing nonlinear function is a means for providing a nonlinear function which is related to a product of said pressure error signal and flow rate signal.

41. Apparatus according to claim 34 in which the means for controlling includes means for generating a signal substantially proportional to the logarithm of the rate of flow.

42. Apparatus according to claim 41 in which the means for controlling includes a means for subtracting the signal substantially proportional to the logarithm of the rate of flow from the pressure error signal.

43. Apparatus according to claim 42 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the measured pressure of said pump;

said second input of said comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to the sample-and-hold circuit.

44. Apparatus according to claim 43 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-to-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said second comparator.

45. Apparatus according to claim 41 in which the means for generating a signal includes an automatic gain control circuit.

46. Apparatus according to claim 45 in which the means for finding the difference between the set pressure and measured pressure includes:

a pressure comparator having first and second inputs;

the first input of said comparator being electrically connected to said means for measuring the measured pressure of said pump;

said second input of said comparator being electrically connected to the means for developing a signal representing the setting of said pressure;

a sample-and-hold circuit; and

the output of said comparator being electrically connected to the sample-and-hold circuit.

47. Apparatus according to claim 46 including means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode;

said means for changing from a constant pressure mode to a constant flow mode including means for applying a strobe potential to said sample-and-hold circuit in said constant pressure mode, whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a signal representing the difference between the measured pressure and the set pressure to said first comparator and for applying a second potential to said .pa sample-and-hold circuit whereby said sample-and-hold circuit applies a constant potential to said first comparator.

48. A method comprising the steps of:

setting a pumping speed for pumping fluid from a pumping system into a chromatographic column at a predetermined rate of flow;

measuring the pressure of the fluid;

measuring the rate of flow of the fluid;

determining the difference between the equilibrium pressure and the measured pressure to obtain a pressure error;

increasing the rate of flow from the pumping system under the control of at least a function of said pressure error and measured rate of flow until the equilibrium value of pressure is reached;

reducing said rate of flow from the pumping system to said predetermined rate of flow;

the step of increasing the rate of flow until said equilibrium value of pressure is reached including the step of controlling the rate of flow with a feedback a feedback signal that causes the pumping speed to increase substantially proportionally to the change in the difference between the set pressure and the measured pressure substantially independently of the rate of flow wherein the feedback signal is formed from the pressure error and a function that increases at a decreasing rate as the rate of flow increases.

49. A method according to claim 48 in which the step of controlling the rate of flow includes the step of subtracting a function that is substantially the logarithm of the pumping rate from the pressure error.

50. A method according to claim 49 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.

51. A method according to claim 48 in which the step of controlling the flow rate includes the steps of:

applying a signal proportional to the flow rate to an automatic gain control amplifier having an adjustable log element in it; and

applying an output signal of the automatic gain control circuit that is approximately proportional to a constant multiplied by the log of the flow rate signal.