Verification of computer software

• US 4,819,233 A
• Filed: 04/08/1987
• Issued: 04/04/1989
• Est. Priority Date: 04/08/1987
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Paramount Global (f/k/a ViacomCBS Inc.))
• Original Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Paramount Global (f/k/a ViacomCBS Inc.))
• Inventors: Wolf, Daniel J., Casteel, Eric P., Delucia, R. Ralph
• Primary Examiner(s): ATKINSON, CHARLES
• Application Number:
  US07/035,802
• Time in Patent Office: 727 Days
• Field of Search: 371/16, 371/19, 364/200
• US Class Current: 717/129
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/3688 for test execution, e.g. scheduling of test suites

Abstract

A computer program is verified, unit by unit, by automatically instrumentating the code and generating a test driver program which executes all branches of an instrumented code unit. The code is instrumented by operating processors to standardize the code format and to insert executable tracer statements into each block of reformatted code between control statements. A pseudocode having only control statements and tables identifying valid linkages between blocks of code are generated by another processor for use by a verifier in selecting values of input variables and expected outputs for test cases which execute each block of code in the selected unit. Another processor generates the test driver program from the test cases and a software test specification identifying the test cases and expected results. The test driver program and instrumented code unit are compiled and linked to repeatively execute the instrumented code unit to implement all the test cases. Results of the test cases are printed out indicating the sequence of block linkages generated by each test case, the expected output values and the actual output values.

Claims

1. A method of verifying a computer source code having a series of program statements, including control statements which provide for branching to alternative statements of the code, said method comprising:

instrumenting the source code to generate when the code is executed an indication for each block of code that the statements of that block have been executed, a block of code being the program statements between control statements;

selecting test cases, with each test case comprising input values for variables in the source code, said test cases being selected such that each block of code is executed;

generating a test driver routine to implement the test cases;

compiling and linking the test driver routine with the instrumented source code;

executing the compiled/linked code to implement the test cases, and

generating an output with said indication of each block of code which has been executed by the test cases.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein said step of generating said test cases includes determining expected output values for each test case, and wherein the step of generating an output includes generating a representation of the expected output values and actual output values generated by executing the compiled/linked code.

3. The method of claim 1 wherein said step of instrumenting said source code comprises operating a processor to insert into each block of code an executable instruction to write to an output file an identifier for that block when the statements of that block are executed, and wherein the step of generating an output includes generating from said output file a list of block identifiers in the sequence in which said blocks were executed.

4. The method of claim 3 wherein said step of inserting executable write instructions into each block of code includes inserting at the beginning of the block such a statement to write to said output file an identifier assigned to the block, and inserting at the end of the block such a statement to sequentially write to the output file the identifier of the block to which control reverts.

5. The method of claim 4 wherein the step of instrumenting the code comprises operating a processor to insert into each block of code non-executable comments identifying the beginning and the end of the block and wherein said steps of inserting the write instructions comprises inserting the instruction which writes the block identifier immediately after the non-executable comment identifying the beginning of the block, and inserting the instruction which writes the block identifier to which control reverts immediately prior to the comment identifying the end of the block.

6. The method of claim 5 including generating from said control statements and said block comments a block data file indicating the path by which each block is entered and identifying those blocks which loop back, and wherein said step of inserting write statements into the code utilizes said block data file to determine the block to which control reverts when the statements in the block have been executed.

7. The method of claim 4 wherein said instrumentation step includes generating a block linkage table, identifying the possible branchings from one block of code to another.

8. The method of claim 3 including the steps of generating a pseudocode by operating a processor to generate from the source code a separate listing with only control statements and with comments between the control statements containing the same block identifiers as used by the executable instructions for corresponding blocks of code in the instrumented code, said pseudocode being used to select said test cases to assure that every block of code is executed.

9. The method of claim 3 including the step prior to instrumenting the source code of standardizing the format of the source code to a set of prescribed formatting standards to generate a reformatted source code, and then instrumenting said reformatted source code.

10. The method of claim 3 wherein said source code contains an instruction that calls for an external program, and wherein said instrumentation step includes inserting prior to said call instruction an instruction to write to an output file an indication that the external program is to be called, and inserting after said call instruction, an instruction to write to the output file an indication that the source code being verified has been reentered.

11. The method of claim 10 wherein said instrument in step includes the steps of inserting into said source code before and after said call instruction, instructions to write to the output file the values of at least selected ones of the source code variables, and wherein said step of generating an output includes generating from the output file representations of the values of said selected variables before and after the call.

12. A method of verifying a computer program source code having a series of program statements including control statements by which the program can branch to alternative statements, said method comprising:

size the format of

operating a processor to standard the source code to a set of prescribed formatting standards to generate a reformatted source code;

selecting a target unit of the reformatted source code for verification;

instrumenting said target unit of code by operating a processor to divide said target unit into blocks of code, a block of code being the non-control statements between control statements, and to insert into said blocks of code executable instructions to write to an output file an identifier for each block of code when it is executed;

selecting test cases for said target unit of code with each test case comprising input values for variables in the target unit and expected output values, said test cases being selected such that each block of code in the test unit is executed;

operating a processor to generate a test driver routine to implement said test cases;

operating a processor to compile and link the test driver routine with the instrumented target unit of code;

executing the compiled/linked test driver routine and instrumented target unit of code; and

generating an output presenting actual output values and expected output values for each test case, and a sequential listing from said output file of the block identifiers of the blocks of said target unit code in the sequence in which they were executed.

13. The method of claim 12 wherein said instrumenting step includes operating a processor to insert non-executable comments with a unique block identifier at the beginning and the end of each block of code in the target unit, generating from the control statements and said block comments a block data table identifying the block by which each block is entered, the nesting level of the block, and any loop backs in a block and wherein the step of inserting executable write instructions into each block includes using said comments and block data table to insert . at the beginning of each block an instruction to write the block identifier and to insert at the end of each block an instruction to write the block identifier of the block to which the target unit reverts.

14. The method of claim 13 wherein the step of generating an output includes generating a comparison of the block identifiers written to the output file during execution of a block of code and the block identifiers in the block data table.

15. The method of claim 13 wherein said instrumenting step includes generating a block linkage file identifying all possible transitions between blocks of code in the target unit.

16. The method of claim 13 wherein the target unit of code includes a call instruction calling an external routine, and wherein said instrumenting step includes:

inserting an executable instruction before the call instruction to write to the output file an indication of the call and inserting after the call instruction an executable instruction to write to the output file an indication that the program has returned to the target unit of code at the correct location.

17. The method of claim 16 wherein said instrumenting step includes inserting into the target unit before and after said call instruction, instructions to write to the output file the values of at least selected ones of the target code variables, and wherein said step of generating an output includes generating from the output file representations of the values of said selected variables before and after the call.

18. The method of claim 13 including generating a pseudocode for use in selecting said test cases by operating a processor to generate a separate file containing only the control statements of the target unit with non-executable comments inserted in place of the non control statements, said comments identifying said blocks with the same identifiers as the comments inserted in the target code by said instrumenting step.

19. The method of claim 12 wherein the step of selecting test case includes operating a processor to generate a variable file for the test cases listing input and output variables for each test case along with the input value for each input variable and the expected value for each output variable, and said method further including when a program revision calls for a change in a designated variable, searching said variable file to identify the test cases which utilize said designated variable.

20. The method of claim 12 wherein said step of operating a processor to generate a test driver routine includes generating a software test specification listing the values of variables used by the test driver to implement the test cases and the expected values of output parameters.

21. A method of verifying software for microprocessors in control and protection systems for a nuclear power plant wherein said software comprises source code having a series of program statements, including . control statements by which the program can branch to alternative statements, said method comprising:

loading said source code into a general purpose digital computer;

operating said digital computer to standardize the format of the source code in accordance with a set of prescribed formatting standards to generate a reformatted source code;

selecting a target unit of the reformatted of the source code for verification;

operating said digital computer to instrument said target unit of code by dividing said target unit into blocks of code, a block of code being the non-control statements between control statements, and to insert into the beginning of each block of code an instruction to write to an output file a unique identifier for that block of code when it is executed, and to insert at the end of each block of code an instruction to write to the output file the unique identifier of the block of code to which the target unit reverts;

selecting test cases for said target unit of code with each test case comprising input values for variables in the target unit and expected output values, said test cases being selected such that each block of code in the test unit is executed;

operating said digital computer to generate a test driver routine to implement said test cases;

operating the digital computer to compile and link the test driver routine with the instrumented target unit of code;

operating the digital computer to execute the compiled/linked test driver routine and instrumented target unit of code; and

operating the digital computer to generate an output presenting actual output values and expected output values for each test case, and a sequential listing from said output file of the block identifiers of the blocks of said target unit code in the sequence in which they were executed.

22. The method of claim 21 wherein the target unit of code includes a call instruction calling an external routine, and wherein said digital computer is operated to insert an executable instruction before the call instruction to write an indication of the call to the output file and inserting after the call instruction an indication that the program has returned to the target unit of code at the correct location.

23. A system for verifying computer program source code having a series of statements, including control statements by which the program can branch to alternative statements, said system comprising:

means for instrumenting the source code by dividing the code into blocks of code, a block of code being the non-control statements between control statements, and to insert into said blocks of code executable instructions to write to an output file an identifier for each block of code when it is executed;

means for generating a variable file containing the input value of selected input variables of the source code and expected output values for output variables of the source code for selected test cases, said test cases being selected such that each block of code is executed;

means for generating a test driver routine utilizing the values in the variable file to implement the test cases;

means for compiling and linking the test driver routine with the instrumented source code;

means for executing the compiled/linked test driver routine and the instrumented source code to generate actual output values and to write to the output file an identifier for each block of each executed; and

means for generating an output presenting said actual output values generated by said executing means and the expected output values contained in said variable file for each test case, and a sequential listing from said output file of the block identifiers of the blocks of said source code in the sequence in which they were executed.

24. The system of claim 23 including:

means to reformat the source code to a set of prescribed formatting standards to generate a reformatted source code; and

means for selecting a target unit of the reformatted source code for instrumentation by said instrumenting means.