Instrumentation and monitoring systems employing differential temperature sensors

• US 4,901,061 A
• Filed: 05/20/1988
• Issued: 02/13/1990
• Est. Priority Date: 06/05/1987
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Siemens Power Generation, Inc.
• Original Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Company LLC (Brookfield Asset Management Incorporated)
• Inventors: Twerdochlib, Michael
• Primary Examiner(s): Orsino, Joseph A.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Jackson, Jill D.
• Application Number:
  US07/196,707
• Time in Patent Office: 634 Days
• Field of Search: 340/501, 340/514-516, 340/584, 340/587, 340/604, 340/622, 340/618, 340/620, 73/295, 374/4, 374/5, 374/10, 374/11, 374/163, 374/164, 376/247, 376/259, 364/550, 364/557, 364/579, 364/580, 364/184, 364/185, 364/186, 136/232, 136/242
• US Class Current: 340/604
• CPC Class Codes: G01K 1/08 Protective devices, e.g. casings
• CPC Class Codes: G01K 3/14 in respect of space

Abstract

Instrumentation and monitoring systems utilize, as differential temperature sensors, heated, split-well thermowells of duplex design, mounted to the sidewall of a pressure vessel and communicating through a penetration in the sidewall with the fluid state within the vessel. Each probe has at least one parallel axial bore therein, a related, selected pair of probes receiving respective heater and temperature sensing elements in the associated bores and together functioning as a differential temperature sensor producing distinguishable, differential temperature outputs representative of the presence of steam versus water. The systems monitor the differential temperature outputs of plural such sensors to produce alarm indications and perform verification and error checking of the sensor output indications. Duplex sensor embodiments permit toggling between different, selected such pairs of probes for on-line testing and verification of monitored conditions represented by the sensor output indications and of the operability of the elements and supporting circuits, under automatic and manual controls, and with on-line substitution of complementary elements in the event of element failure.

Claims

1. An instrumentation system for monitoring fluid conditions within the interior of a pressure vessel, comprising:

at least one duplex differential temperature sensor comprising at least one pair of two substantially identical probes in communication with the fluid condition within the interior of the pressure vessel and two complementary sets of heater and temperature sensing elements, each such set being associated with a given pair of probes, the heater element being in one of the probes of the associated pair of probes and both probes of the pair having respective temperature sensing elements of the complementary set therein, and selectively operable, when energized, to heat the one probe, the one probe thus being a heated probe and the other probe being a reference probe, and to sense the temperatures of the heated and reference probes of the given pair and produce corresponding, sensed temperature outputs having a temperature differential therebetween, the temperature differential being of respectively higher and lower values in response to exposure of the pair of heated and reference probes of the sensor to steam and water conditions within the pressure vessel interior;

means for selectively energizing the heater element of a given one of the complementary sets of heater and temperature sensing element of a given sensor;

means for determining the temperature differential between the sensed temperature outputs of a given one of the complementary sets and producing a corresponding, sensed temperature differential output; and

control means, operative during a normal monitoring mode, for selecting one of the two complementary sets of the at least one sensor as an operative set and for maintaining the other of the two complementary sets thereof in a standby condition, the control means controlling the selective energizing means to energize the selected set and controlling the temperature differential determining means to determine the differential between the sensed temperature outputs of the selected set and produce a corresponding, sensed temperature differential output.

2. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising:

means for determining the inoperability of any of the temperature sensing and heater elements of the complementary sets of any of the at least one given sensor and producing a corresponding inoperable element output; and

the control means responding to the inoperable element output of the inoperable element determining means in the normal monitoring mode and corresponding to the selected, operative set of the given sensor, for selecting the other of the complementary sets theretofore maintained in standby condition as the operative set and controlling the selective energizing means to energize, and the temperature differential determining means to determine the difference between the sensed temperature outputs of, the thus selected, other set.

3. A system as recited in claim 2, further comprising:

sensor display means, responsive to the inoperable element output, for producing a display indication of the inoperable element.

4. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising:

means for defining a reference temperature differential value intermediate the relatively higher and lower values of the sensed temperature differential outputs of the determining means produced in response to the sensed temperature outputs of the given set and respectively corresponding to exposure of the associated pair of probes of the sensor to steam and water conditions within the pressure vessel interior; and

means for comparing the value of the sensed temperature differential output of the determining means, produced in response to the sensed temperature outputs of the selected, operative set, with the reference temperature differential value and producing an alarm output when the sensed temperature differential output is less than the reference temperature differential value.

5. A system as recited in claim 4, wherein:

the control means is operative in a verification mode, in response to the alarm output of the comparing means, for selecting the other, complementary set of elements theretofore in standby condition and for controlling the energizing means to energize, and the determined means to determine the difference between the sensed temperature outputs of, the other, thus selected complementary set and produce a corresponding, sensed temperature differential output.

6. A system as recited in claim 5, further comprising:

means for comparing the respective, sensed temperature differential outputs of the determining means produced for the given sensor in the monitoring mode and in the verification mode as a result of the alarm output for the given sensor, to verify the alarm condition.

7. A system as recited in claim 6, further comprising:

means responsive to the alarm output for producing an alarm indication display.

8. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein:

means for determining the inoperability of any of the temperature sensing and heater elements of the complementary sets of a given sensor and producing corresponding inoperable element outputs; and

the control means is selectively operable, during on-line testing in a normal monitoring mode, for selecting the other, complementary set theretofore in standby condition as the operative set and for controlling the selective energizing means to energize, and the temperature differential determining means correspondingly to determine the difference between the sensed temperature outputs of, the thus, alternatively selected, other complementary set.

9. A system as recited in claim 8, further comprising:

plural differential temperature sensors and respectively associated energizing means and temperature differential determining means, the control means comprising system control means and plural sensor control means respectively associated with the plural sensors and the system control means controlling the plural sensor control means to perform on-line testing of the respectively associated sensors.

10. A system as recited in claim 9, further comprising:

means for comparing the temperature differential outputs respectively produced during the normal monitoring mode and during on-line testing, by each of the plural temperature differential test the operability of the respectively corresponding sensors.

11. A system as recited in claim 10, further comprising;

system display means for displaying the respective temperature differential outputs, during the normal monitoring mode and during on-line testing, of each of the plural temperature differential determining means in association with the identification of the respective sensor, for each of the plurality of sensors.

12. A system as recited in claim 11, wherein:

the system display means displays the temperature differential output for only a single, selected set of a single sensor; and

in each of the monitoring mode and on-line testing, the system control means selects, in individual succession, the plural sensor control means and correspondingly the respectively associated plural temperature differential sensors and plural determining means, and supplies the respective differential temperature outputs therefrom, corresponding to the selected set of each sensor in the monitoring mode and the complementary set of each sensor in on-line testing, to the system display means for display in corresponding, individual succession and in conjunction with the identification of the selected sensor.

13. A system as recited in claim 11, wherein the system display means further comprises:

plural alarm indication display means respectively corresponding to the plural sensors, each such corresponding alarm indication sensor display means providing an indication of an alarm condition in association with the respective sensor.

14. A system as recited in claim 13, further comprising:

means associated with each sensor for determining inoperability of any of the temperature sensing and heating elements of the complementary sets thereof and producing corresponding inoperable element outputs;

each of the plural sensor control means being operable in response to an inoperable element output of the corresponding inoperability determining means as to a selected, operative set, for producing an inoperative set output, and in response to receiving an inoperable element output of the inoperability determining means for both of the complementary sets, for producing a failed sensor output;

the system control means supplies the failed set and failed sensor outputs of the plural sensor control means in conjunction with the identification of the corresponding sensor to the system display means; and

the system display means further comprises means for separately displaying failed set and failed sensor indications in conjunction with the identification of the corresponding sensor in response to receipt of failed set and failed sensor outputs, respectively.

15. A system as recited in claim 9, further comprising:

operator control means for selectively controlling the system control means to perform selective on-line testing of the plurality of sensors

16. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein:

each of the probes of the at least one pair has disposed therein a heater element positioned centrally therein and two temperature sensing elements positioned symmetrically with respect to the heater element, the heater element and one of the temperature sensing elements of one probe and one of the two temperature sensing elements of the other probe of the pair of probes being associated as a first complementary set and the heater element of the other probe of the pair and the remaining temperature sensing element of the one probe of the pair being associated as the second complementary set.

17. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein:

each complementary set comprises a pair of integrated heater/temperature sensing elements;

each probe of the pair of probes of a sensor has a pair of integrated heater/temperature sensing elements disposed therein, each such integrated element having a resistance value substantially linearly dependent on temperature and operable as a temperature sensing element for producing a sensed temperature output, and being selectively operable, when energized, to function as a heater element for heating the associated probe, each such integrated heater/temperature sensing element of one of the at least one pair of probes being associated with an integrated heater/temperature sensing element of the other, related probe of the pair thereby to define first and second complementary sets of integrated heater/temperature sensing elements for the pair of probes of the sensor;

the control means, in a normal monitoring mode and for a given sensor, selects the first complementary set of integrated heater/temperature sensing elements for operation, the second set thereof remaining in standby condition, and controls the energizing means to energize one of the integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the selected set.

18. A system as recited in claim 17, further comprising:

means for determining the inoperability of any of the integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the complementary sets of a given sensor and producing corresponding inoperable element outputs; and

the control means is responsive to an inoperable element output of the inoperability determining means, during a normal monitoring mode and for the selected set of integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the given sensor, for selecting the other such set thereof theretofore in standby condition, and for controlling the energizing means to energize one of the integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the thus selected, other set.

19. A system as recited in claim 17, wherein the energizing means comprises:

a bridge circuit having first and second legs, each connected between first and second junctions and therefore in parallel relationship with the other;

first and second constant current sources connected in series with respective first and second heater/temperature sensing elements of a complementary set thereof in the respective first and second legs, the series connections in the respective first and second legs defining third and fourth junctions;

the first constant current source supplying current to the first element in the first leg, of a first level sufficient to energize same as a heater element;

the second constant current source connected in the second leg supplying the second element with a second level of current, lower by a predetermined proportionality factor relatively to the first level of current such that the second heater/temperature sensing element is heated only insignificantly by the current flow therethrough of the second level;

a differential amplifier having first and second inputs and an output;

means for connecting the third and fourth junctions of the bridge network to the first and second inputs of the differential amplifier and for normalizing the respective voltage outputs at the third and fourth junctions in accordance with the first and second levels of current flow through the respective first and second heater/temperature sensing elements, effectively by the inverse of the proportionality factor; and

the differential amplifier producing a sensed temperature differential output representative of the difference between the respective sensed temperature outputs of the integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the complementary set.

20. A system as recited in claim 17, wherein the energizing means comprises:

means for supplying the first and second integrated heater/temperature sensing elements of the given complementary set with respective, high and low level constant currents differing by a known proportionality factor to produce corresponding high and low level voltage outputs therefrom as the respective sensed temperature outputs thereof, the high level current producing sufficient heating of the first integrated heater/temperature sensing element to enable it to function as a heater and its corresponding probe to function as a heated probe and the low level current producing insignificant heating of the second integrated heater/temperature sensing element and its associated probe for functioning as a reference probe.

21. A system as recited in claim 20, wherein the temperature differential determining means further comprises:

means for altering the relative levels of the respective voltage outputs of the first and second integrated heater/temperature sensing elements by the inverse of the known proportionality factor, in determining the difference between the sensed temperature outputs and producing the corresponding sensed temperature differential output.

22. A system as recited in claim 21, wherein the inoperable element determining means comprises:

means providing a continuous reference range of voltage values corresponding to the range of sensed temperature output voltage values of an operative, integrated heater/temperature sensing element; and

means for comparing the sensed temperature output voltage of each integrated heater/temperature sensing element with the continuous reference range of voltage values and producing the an inoperable element output when the sensed temperature output voltage is not within the continuous reference range.

23. An instrumentation system for monitoring fluid conditions within the interior of a pressure vessel, comprising:

at least one duplex differential temperature sensor having a pair of first and second substantially identical probes integrally interconnected at first ends thereof and extending in parallel axial relationship and spaced by a bilateral plane and adapted to be mounted to the sidewall of a pressure vessel with the probes in communication through a penetration in the sidewall with the fluid state within the interior of the pressure vessel, each said probe incorporating a heater element and a pair of associated temperature sensing elements, the heater element and a selected temperature sensing element of said first probe and a selected temperature sensing element of said second probe comprising a first differential temperature sensor component and the heater element of the said second probe and a selected temperature sensing element thereof and a selected temperature sensing element of said first probe comprising a second differential temperature sensor component;

heater controller means for selectively supplying electrical power to said respective heater elements of said first and second probes of said sensor, the selected heater element heating the corresponding probe and raising the temperature thereof, in the absence of a fluid in the line contacting and dissipating heat from the probe, and thereby producing a difference between the temperatures sensed by the selected temperature sensing elements associated with the respective, heated and unheated probes of the sensor, said heater controller means further comprising means for determining operability of each of the heater elements of the sensor and producing an inoperative heater element output upon determining the inoperability of a heater element;

temperature sensing element controller means for selecting the temperature sensing elements of the first and second probes and for monitoring the sensed temperature outputs of the selected temperature sensing elements, for providing a differential temperature output indicative of the difference between the respective, sensed temperature outputs of the selected temperature sensing elements of the first and second probes, and for determining the operability of the selected temperature sensing elements of the first and second probes; and

system control means for controlling said heater and temperature sensing element controller means to select the heater and sensing elements of each sensor corresponding to the first sensor component thereof in a normal monitoring mode of the instrumentation system, for defining a normal differential temperature output condition, for detecting an alarm condition in the normal monitoring mode when the differential temperature output of the selected, first sensor component differs from the normal differential temperature condition, and for producing an alarm output in response to detecting an alarm condition;

display means responsive to an alarm output of said system control means for producing an alarm display identified with the corresponding sensor; and

said system control means being responsive to an inoperative heater element output from said heater controller for the selected heater of said first probe, corresponding to the first sensor component, for automatically causing said heater controller to select the heater element of the second probe and supply electrical power thereto and thereby to switch from the first to the second sensor component of the given sensor.

24. A system as recited in claim 23, wherein:

said system control means, in response to detecting an alarm condition and for verifying same, directs said heater controller to select the second heater element and thereby switch to the second sensor component, for comparing the differential temperature output indication produced by the temperature sensing element controller for the second sensor component with that for the first sensor component for verification of the detected alarm condition, as a qualifying condition for producing the alarm indication for the corresponding sensor.

25. A system as recited in claim 24, comprising plural said sensors, and wherein said system control means, in an automatic test mode, performs on-line testing of each sensor, in sequence, for said plurality of sensors.

26. A system as recited in claim 25, wherein:

said system control means, for performing the automatic mode of on-line testing of each sensor, determines and stores the respective differential temperature outputs of the first sensor components of the plurality of sensors in a normal operating mode, causes said heater controller means and said temperature sensing controller means to switch to the respective, second sensor components of the plural sensors for selectively supplying electrical power to the heater elements of the respective second probes of the plurality of sensors for a sufficient period of time to establish thermal stability of the second sensor components, determines the corresponding differential temperature outputs thereof and compares same with the respective differential outputs of the first sensor components of the respective sensors, and detects a sensor failure condition when the respective differential temperature outputs of the first and second sensor components of a given sensor, under test, do not have the same numerical value and opposite sign.

27. A system as recited in claim 26, further comprising:

means for selectively displaying the numerical value and sign of the sensed temperature differential output of each sensor;

means for displaying an indication of a failed sensor;

means for displaying an indication of a failed heater element; and

means for initiating a selective test mode, in lieu of the automatic test mode, for on-line testing of selected, said sensors.

28. A system as recited in claim 26, further comprising:

plural alarm display means respectively corresponding to said plural sensors, for indicating an alarm condition sensed by the corresponding sensor; and

for selectively testing a given sensor in the selective test mode of the system, said system control means causes said heater controller means and said temperature sensing element controller means to switch to the second sensor component of the given sensor, thereby to enable selective display of the value and sign of the differential temperature output of the second sensor component produced thereby in the selective test mode for comparison with the corresponding display of the output of the first sensor component produced in the normal monitoring mode of the system.

29. A system as recited in claim 23, wherein:

said temperature sensing element controller means selects the same temperature sensing elements, conditioned on continued operability thereof, for both the first and second sensor components of each said sensor.

30. A system as recited in claim 29, wherein:

said temperature sensing element controller means selects the complementary temperature sensing elements of the sensor for each of said first and second sensor components of a given sensor upon the detection of a failure of either of the first selected temperature sensing elements.