Channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communication system

• US 4,977,612 A
• Filed: 10/10/1989
• Issued: 12/11/1990
• Est. Priority Date: 10/10/1989
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: Wilson, Timothy J.
• Primary Examiner(s): Eisenzopf, Reinhard J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): KUNTZ, CURTIS A
• Application Number:
  US07/419,369
• Time in Patent Office: 427 Days
• Field of Search: 455/33, 455/34, 455/54, 455/56, 455/67, 455/179, 455/166, 455/161, 455/186, 340/825.5, 340/825.04, 340/825.51, 379/59, 379/60, 379/63, 371/32, 371/33
• US Class Current: 455/166.1
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 24/00 Supervisory, monitoring or testing arrangements
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 36/06 Reselecting a communication resource in the serving access point
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 36/30 by measured or perceived connection quality data

Abstract

A method and apparatus are disclosed for improved channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system whereby a minimum level of signal/service quality may be maintained at all times without unduly impacting channel loading considerations. Specialized idle messages are utilized in the outbound channel of the radio system which are required in any event but include added information for the monitoring remote terminals to determine channel quality and take appropriate action by selecting a new channel to operate on if channel quality falls below a preset threshold level.

Claims

1. In a multi-frequency radio data communication system operating on inbound and outbound channels with multiple transmitting sites interconnected to a central network control processor NCP and having multiple portable terminals, a method of channel selection for portable terminal usage which assures a set level of signal/service quality without unduly affecting outbound capacity, including the steps of:

a. having each portable terminal randomizing the list of frequencies available in the system;

b. each terminal upon initial operation selecting a channel from said random list, and if traffic is found, evaluating the quality level thereof and if acceptable attempting to register thereon by sending a channel registration message and receiving back an acknowledgement, if successful;

c. each portable terminal continuing to monitor the outbound channel and when signal/service quality falls below a threshold level, selecting a new channel from its random list and attempting to register thereon in the manner set forth in step (b); and

d. said portable terminals in response to a failure to successfully send an inbound message due to message errors, as well as receiving no acknowledgement response to a transmitter channel registration message, treating the same as an indication of poor signal/service quality and repeating step (c).

2. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 1 wherein the step of evaluating channel quality includes setting an internal timer, waiting for an idle message to occur on the outbound channel and upon receipt thereof, determining whether a particular entry exists in an included Channel Quality Table and, if so, retrieving such entry and updating the same with current information.

3. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 2 wherein if no prior entry has been logged in the terminal Channel Quality Table for the channel being monitored, then creating such an entry with information extracted from the received idle message.

4. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 2 wherein the updating of the prior entry in the Channel Quality Table includes noting the sum of the counted bit errors in the received idle message and incrementing upwardly by one the number of received idle messages.

5. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 2, then evaluating the information already within the Channel Quality Table such that, for each entry, calculation is made as to the average bit errors and on that basis determining whether such channel is deemed to have acceptable service quality or alternatively, of inferior service quality.

6. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 5 wherein calculating the average bit errors includes taking the total of bit error count and dividing by the number of idle messages that have been received and wherein if any of the calculated bit error figure is less than a set check through level, the channel is deemed to have acceptable service quality.

7. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 6 wherein if all of the calculated average bit error exceeds the set check thru level, the service quality is deemed inferior and the terminal returns to the step of selecting the next channel candidate on the randomized frequency list and repeats the channel evaluation process.

8. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 1 wherein the step of registering on the selected channel includes the step of sending a registration message on the inbound channel and wherein such registration is deemed completed if an acknowledgement is received by the terminal in response to its transmitted registration message.

9. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 2 wherein the evaluation phase of the channel monitoring effected by the remote terminal includes the step of periodically evaluating the Channel Quality Table by first removing any stale entries in the Channel Quality Table older than a selectable but set time period, and then noting whether any of the still remaining entries exist with a bit error rate less than the set monitor throughput level.

10. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 9 wherein the channel is deemed to have acceptable service quality if any of this recorded bit error rates are less than the set monitor thru put level and then returning to the initial step in the evaluation process.

11. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 9 wherein the channel is deemed to have unacceptable and inferior service quality if all of the recorded bit error rate exceeds the set monitor throughput level whereupon the terminal issues a poor channel quality indication and returns to the step of selecting a new channel.

12. A method of channel selection in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 2 wherein the updating of the channel quality phase of the channel monitoring process by the remote terminals includes waiting for an idle message to occur on the outbound channel and upon receipt thereof noting whether a Channel Quality Table entry exists for the general communication controller originating the idle message whereupon the entry is retrieved and updated by smoothing the bit error count through low pass filtering and updating the time stamp associated therewith.

13. A remote radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system having multiple transmitting sites interconnected to a central NCP, which remote terminal may select an operating channel among multiple channels available while maintaining a set level of signal/service quality at all times, comprising in combination:

means for randomizing a list of channels available on the system and maintaining the same within the terminal;

means, upon turn-on of the remote terminal, for selecting a channel from said randomized list and evaluating the signal/service quality thereof;

means, upon said evaluation being above a set threshold level, for sending a registration message on said selected and evaluated channel and, if an acknowledgement is received in response thereto, beginning normal operation thereon; and

means for periodically and continually monitoring the channel so selected and registered upon, and initiating a new channel selection as upon turn-on whenever the signal/service quality falls below said set threshold level.

14. A remote radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio communications system in accordance with claim 13 wherein said means for evaluating channel quality includes means for setting an evaluation interval timer within which to wait for receipt of idle messages and, upon receipt thereof, updating an associated Channel Quality Table with information extracted from said received idle message.

15. A remote data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 14 wherein means are further included for evaluating the information already within the Channel Quality Table upon expiration of the evaluation internal timer.

16. A radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 14 wherein means are included such that if no acknowledgement is received by the terminal after transmitting said registration message, said means for selecting a channel from said randomized list is again activated.

17. A radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 14 wherein said means for periodically monitoring a selected channel includes means for evaluating the channel being monitored by removing any stale entries in said Channel Quality Table older than a set time period and then noting whether any remaining said table entries still remain with a bit error rate less than a set monitor throughput level.

18. A remote radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 17 wherein said means of updating the channel quality after evaluating as referenced in claim 17, includes means for waiting and receiving an idle message, noting whether a Channel Quality Table entry exists for the source of such message, and retrieving and updating such entry if it exists.

19. A remote radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 14 wherein the idle messages monitored by the remote terminals include information regarding the location and identity of the source transmitting any such message.

20. A remote radio data terminal for operating in a multi-frequency radio data communications system in accordance with claim 19 wherein such idle messages further include information regarding the location identity of the central controller if more than one such controller is present in the system.