Method and apparatus for radar measurement of ball in play

• US 5,138,322 A
• Filed: 08/20/1991
• Issued: 08/11/1992
• Est. Priority Date: 08/20/1991
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: GEC Marconi Limited (Gooding Consumer Electronics Ltd.)
• Original Assignee: Matrix Engineering Limited
• Inventors: Nuttall, Jerry A.
• Primary Examiner(s): Barron, Jr., Gilberto
• Application Number:
  US07/747,380
• Time in Patent Office: 357 Days
• Field of Search: 342/59, 342/126, 342/463, 342/465, 342/127, 342/129, 273/29 R
• US Class Current: 342/126
• CPC Class Codes: A63B 2071/0611 Automatic tennis linesmen, i.e. in-out detectors
• CPC Class Codes: A63B 2102/00 Application of clubs, bats, rackets or the like to the sporting activity ; particular sports involving the use of balls and clubs, bats, rackets, or the like
• CPC Class Codes: A63B 2225/54 Transponders, e.g. RFID
• CPC Class Codes: A63B 43/00 Balls with special arrangements
• CPC Class Codes: A63B 71/0605 Decision makers and devices using detection means facilitating arbitration
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/46 Indirect determination of position data
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/87 Combinations of radar systems, e.g. primary radar and secondary radar
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 2013/466 by Trilateration, i.e. two antennas or two sensors determine separately the distance to a target, whereby with the knowledge of the baseline length, i.e. the distance between the antennas or sensors, the position data of the target is determined

Abstract

A system for continuously and precisely measuring the positions of a generally symmetrical object, e.g., a tennis ball, in motion in a predefined three-dimensional region, e.g., a tennis court, which transmits multiple radar signals from first, second, and third, spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region. Multiple return signals are sensed and are compared with the transmitted signals to determine the phases of the return signals, to thereby obtain ambiguous ranges of the object. Ambiguities are removed by using the Chinese Remainder Theorem to obtain less-ambiguous ranges. Time-of-arrival range information is used in conjuction with the less-ambiguous ranges to provide unambiguous ranges over the range of interest. The unambiguous ranges are used to compute three-dimensional coordinates of the object that are accurate to within approximately 0.1 inches. A mathematical model defining boundaries of the three-dimensional region is completed by placing signal reflector devices on various boundary points of the three-dimensional region, and transmitting the radar signals when the object is not in the three-dimensional region. Coordinates of a projected trajectory are computed and compared with the actual coordinatres of the object, and certain characteristics are computed therefrom. Calibration of the system is maintained by placing signal reflector devices at various fixed locations within the region of interest and the return signals are processed to obtain an initial survey of the region and then to periodically resurvey the region.

Claims

1. A method of precisely measuring the positions of a generally symmetrical object in motion, in a predefined three-dimensional region, comprising the steps of:

(a) transmitting multiple radar signals from each of first, second, and third spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region, the object reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(b) sensing the return signals by means of receivers connected to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(c) comparing the return signals with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of first, second, and third ranges of the object relative to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(d) removing ambiguities of the first, second, and third ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain first, second, and third less-ambiguous ranges or unambiguous ranges of the object relative to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(e) if the ambiguities removed in step (d) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define first, second, and third unambiguous ranges of the object, using first, second, and third time of arrival range information and/or a priori information in conjunction with the first, second, and third less ambiguous ranges to obtain the first, second, and third unambiguous ranges of the object; and

(f) computing three-dimensional coordinates of the object using the first, second, and third unambiguous ranges and the coordinates of the first, second, and third antenna devices.

2. The method of claim 1 including transmitting multiple radar signals from one or more additional spaced antenna devices, and performing steps similar to steps (a)-(f) to obtain additional three-dimensional coordinates of the object, and averaging corresponding values of each of the three-dimensional coordinates to obtain more-robust three-dimensional coordinates of the object.

3. The method of claim 2 including eliminating three-dimensional coordinates the error of which exceeds a preselected value.

4. The method of claim 1 including repetitively comparing three-dimensional coordinates of the object in motion in the three-dimensional region to model boundaries determined by a mathematical-boundary model and producing indications of the object'"'"'s position relative to such boundaries.

5. The method of claim 1 including computing projected trajectory coordinates of the object in motion, comparing actual coordinates of the object in motion with the corresponding projected coordinates, and computing preselected characteristics of the object from differences therebetween.

6. A method of precisely measuring the three-dimensional positions of a set of at least four spaced antenna devices and a set of spaced signal reflectors at various fixed positions relative to a three-dimensional region of interest, comprising the steps of:

(a) taking the position of one of the antenna devices or signal reflectors as the origin of the three dimensional coordinate system and taking the line between this origin and one other antenna device or corner reflector as one of a plurality of coordinate axes;

(b) transmitting multiple radar signals from each of the spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region containing the set of signal reflectors, each signal reflector reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(c) sensing the return signals of each signal reflector by means of receivers connected to each of the set of antenna devices, respectively;

(d) comparing the return signals from each of the signal reflectors with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of the range of each antenna device relative to each signal reflector;

(e) removing ambiguities of each of the set of ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain a less-ambiguous range or unambiguous range from each of the set of antenna devices to each of the set of signal reflectors;

(f) if the ambiguities removed in step (e) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define the above set of unambiguous ranges, using time-of-arrival range information from each antenna device to each signal reflector and/or a priori information in conjunction with the less-ambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector to obtain the unambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector;

(g) obtaining crude three dimensional coordinates of each of all antenna devices and all signal reflectors from a priori information, and computing, using the unambiguous ranges and the crude three-dimensional coordinates, more precise three-dimensional coordinates of each antenna device and each signal reflector;

(h) periodically repeating the sequence of steps (b)-(g) to update all the three dimensional positions as ambient conditions change.

7. A method for obtaining a mathematical-boundary-model of a three-dimensional region of interest, comprising the steps of:

(a) placing signal reflectors, either simultaneously or in sequence, on various boundary points of the region;

(b) transmitting multiple radar signals from each of a set of at least three spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region containing the signal reflectors, each signal reflector reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(c) sensing the return signals of each signal reflector by means of receivers connected to each of the set of antenna devices, respectively;

(d) comparing the return signals from each of the signal reflectors with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of the range of each antenna device relative to each signal reflector;

(e) removing ambiguities of each of the set of ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain a less-ambiguous range or unambiguous range from each of the set of antenna devices to each of the set of signal reflectors;

(f) if the ambiguities removed in step (e) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define the above set of unambiguous ranges, using time-of-arrival range information from each antenna device to each signal reflector and/or a priori information in conjunction with the less-ambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector to obtain the unambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector;

(g) computing, using the unambiguous ranges and the three-dimensional coordinates of the antenna devices, the three-dimensional coordinates of each of the signal reflectors and thereby the boundary points; and

(h) generating a mathematical-boundary-model using the boundary points obtained in step (g), for each combination of three antenna devices.

8. A system for precisely measuring the positions of a generally symmetrical object in motion, in a predefined three-dimensional region, comprising in combination:

(a) first, second, and third spaced antenna devices;

(b) means for transmitting multiple radar signals from each of first, second, and third spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region, the object reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(c) means for sensing the return signals by means of receivers connected to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(d) means for comparing the return signals with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of first, second, and third ranges of the object relative to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(e) means for removing ambiguities of the first, second, and third ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain first, second, and third less-ambiguous ranges or unambiguous ranges of the object relative to the first, second, and third antenna devices, respectively;

(f) means for computing first, second, and third unambiguous ranges of the object, using first, second, and third time-of-arrival range information and/or a priori information in conjunction with the first, second, and third less ambiguous ranges if the ambiguities removed in step (e) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define first, second, and third unambiguous ranges of the object; and

(g) means for computing three-dimensional coordinates of the object using the first, second, and third unambiguous ranges and the coordinates of the first, second, and third antenna devices.

9. The system of claim 8 including one or more additional spaced antenna devices, means for transmitting multiple radar signals from the one or more additional spaced antenna devices, and means for computing additional three-dimensional coordinates of the object, and averaging corresponding values of each of the three-dimensional coordinates to obtain more-robust three-dimensional coordinates of the object.

10. The system of claim 9 including means for eliminating three-dimensional coordinates the error of which exceeds a preselected value.

11. The system of claim 8 including means for obtaining a mathematical-boundary-model, means for repetitively comparing three-dimensional coordinates of the object in motion in the three-dimensional region to court model boundaries determined by the mathematical-boundary-model and producing indications of the object'"'"'s position relative to such boundaries.

12. The system of claim 8 including means for computing projected trajectory coordinates of the object in motion, means for comparing actual coordinates of the object in motion with the corresponding projected coordinates, and means for computing preselected characteristics of the object from differences therebetween.

13. A system for precisely measuring the three-dimensional positions of a set of at least four spaced antenna devices and a set of spaced signal reflectors at various fixed positions relative to a three-dimensional region of interest, comprising in combination:

(a) a set of at least four antenna devices and a set of signal reflectors;

(b) means for taking a position of one of the antenna devices or signal reflectors as the origin of the three-dimensional coordinate system and taking a line between this origin and one other antenna device or corner reflector as one of the coordinate axes;

(c) means for transmitting multiple radar signals from each of the set of spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region containing the set of signal reflectors, means for each signal reflector reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(d) means for sensing the return signals of each signal reflector by means of receivers connected to each of the set of antenna devices, respectively;

(e) means for comparing the return signals from each of the signal reflectors with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of the range of each antenna device relative to each signal reflector;

(f) means for removing ambiguities of each of the set of ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain a less-ambiguous range or unambiguous range from each of the set of antenna devices to each of the set of signal reflectors;

(g) means for using time-of-arrival range information from each antenna device to each signal reflector and/or a priori information in conjunction with the less-ambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector to obtain the unambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector, if the ambiguities removed by the means of step (f) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define the above set of unambiguous ranges;

(h) means for obtaining the crude three dimensional coordinates of each of the antenna devices and all signal reflectors from a priori information, and means for computing, using the unambiguous ranges and the crude three-dimensional coordinates, more precise three-dimensional coordinates of each antenna device and each signal reflector.

14. A system for obtaining a mathematical-boundary-model of the region of interest, comprising in combination:

(a) a set of at least three antenna devices and at least one signal reflector;

(b) means for placing signal reflectors, either simultaneously or in sequence, on various boundary points of the three-dimensional region;

(c) means for transmitting multiple radar signals from each of a set of at least three spaced antenna devices, respectively, into the three-dimensional region containing the signal reflectors, means for each signal reflector reflecting multiple return signals corresponding to the multiple radar signals, respectively;

(d) means for sensing the return signals of each signal reflector by means of receivers connected to each of the set of antenna devices, respectively;

(e) means for comparing the return signals from each of the signal reflectors with the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to determine phases of the return signals relative to phases of the corresponding transmitted multiple radar signals, respectively, to obtain ambiguous representations of the range of each antenna device relative to each signal reflector;

(f) means for removing ambiguities of each of the set of ranges using modular arithmetic to obtain a less-ambiguous range or unambiguous range from each of the set of antenna devices to each of the set of signal reflectors;

(g) means for using time-of-arrival range information from each antenna device to each signal reflector and/or a priori information in conjunction with the less-ambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector to obtain the unambiguous range from each antenna device to each signal reflector, if the ambiguities removed by means of step (f) do not result in an unambiguous region sufficiently large to define the above set of unambiguous ranges;

(h) means for computing, using the unambiguous ranges and the three-dimensional coordinates of the antenna devices, the three-dimensional coordinates of each of the signal reflectors and thereby the boundary points for each combination of three antenna devices; and

(i) means for generating a mathematical-boundary-model using the boundary points.