Distributed logic control system and method

• US 5,157,595 A
• Filed: 03/08/1991
• Issued: 10/20/1992
• Est. Priority Date: 07/19/1985
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: El-Mul Technologies Ltd. (PHOTONIS Technologies SAS)
• Original Assignee: El-Mul Technologies Ltd. (PHOTONIS Technologies SAS)
• Inventors: Lovrenich, Rodger T.
• Primary Examiner(s): Smith, Jerry
• Assistant Examiner(s): TRAMMELL, JAMES P
• Application Number:
  US07/667,249
• Time in Patent Office: 592 Days
• Field of Search: 364/136, 364/140, 364/141, 364/147, 364/183, 364/184, 364/474.19, 364/474.2, 364/474.11, 364/900 MS File, 371/29.1, 371/47.1, 371/48
• US Class Current: 700/7
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 19/058 Safety, monitoring
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 19/4063 Monitoring general control system G05B19/4062 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/1159 Image table, memory
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/1204 Multiprocessing, several plc's, distributed logic control
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/13066 Execute next step if state, control zone changes
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/13067 Use of variables, symbols in instructions, to indicate mechanisms, interfaces
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/13189 On error, look in table for alternative allowed next instruction
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/14044 Operating time test for over or under conditions
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/14055 Make log, journal, history file of state changes
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/14074 Signature analysis, recorded states, zones are compared to actual
• CPC Class Codes: G05B 2219/14091 Message generation, composer from variables and states, zones

Abstract

A system and method for controlling operation of a plurality of elements in an automated process, such as a production process, and indicating error conditions as they occur. Each unique set of input and output conditions of the various system elements defines a unique logic state or zone. Thus, there are defined a multiplicity of valid system logic states or zones, each having a unique input/output image. A predetermined sequence of zones, productive zones representing designed machine operations, is stored in a zone table. All zones not explicitly defined in the zone table are automatically treated as error zones. A zone engine automatically cycles to observe any change in input/output image. Any change in inputs from the various system elements automatically transfer action to the unique zone associated with such inputs, resulting in corresponding changes in control outputs to the system elements and/or display an error message as appropriate.

Claims

1. A machine control system which comprises, in combination, at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, means for sensing mechanism conditions, and control means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, characterized in that said control means comprises:

a present zone memory means for storing a present zone of a mechanism of said machine;

an input/output image memory means for storing a table of input/output images associated with said present zone of said mechanism;

an allowed next zones memory means for storing at least one allowed next zone associated with said present zone of said mechanism, at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones;

means for comparing a new input/output image to an input/output image of said plurality of allowed next zones, wherein if said next zone corresponding to said new input/output image does not correspond to one of said plurality of allowed next zones, an error in processing of said machine exists, and

a part processing inhibit table indicative of conditions wherein an operation on a workpiece at said mechanism should be inhibited because said workpiece is not properly prepared for said operation.

2. A machine control system which comprises, in combination, at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, means for sensing mechanism conditions, and control means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, characterized in that said control means comprises:

a present zone memory means for storing a present zone of a mechanism of said machine;

an input/output image memory means for storing a table of input/output images associated with said present zone of said mechanism;

an allowed next zones memory means for storing at least one allowed next zone associated with said present zone of said mechanism, at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones;

means for comparing a new input/output image to an input/output image of said plurality of allowed next zones, wherein if said next zone corresponding to said new input/output image does not correspond to one of said plurality of allowed next zones, an error in processing of said machine exists, and

an interference inhibit memory means for storing an interference inhibit table describing at least one zone of one mechanism which inhibits at least one zone of another mechanism.

3. The machine control system of claim 2 further comprising a means for identifying the current zone of the one mechanism, and using said interference table to determine the zones of the other mechanism which are inhibited.

4. A method of monitoring the operating of a machine which comprises in combination at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, and means for sensing mechanism conditions, and control means including memory means, said control means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, said method comprising the steps of:

storing a machine program controlled of at least one mechanism program representing sequences of operation defined by predetermined images of input and output signals stored in a table,

monitoring the actual input/output signals, and

comparing the image of actual input/output signals with one of the stored means, characterized by;

a zone logic method in which each said input/output image is indicative of a zone of said mechanism and each zone having associated therewith a list of corresponding allowed next zones, with at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones,

moving between zones by determining to leave the present zone and by selecting the next zone from among the next allowed zones

accommodating interactions between mechanisms by having the current zone of one mechanism prevent the occupation of a predetermined zone of another mechanism, and

setting the outputs as prescribed by said selected allowed next zone.

7. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

said table containing at least one error zone,

indicating an error condition when, after determining to depart the present zone, no next zone can be selected, and

entering said error zone.

8. The method set forth in claim 7 further characterized by:

generating a plain language text error message.

9. The method set forth in claim 8 wherein the generating step is further characterized by:

storing a unique zone name for each zone of said mechanism,

storing a unique input/output name for each input/output,

providing at least one template containing fixed words and blank spaces, and

upon detecting an error, selecting zone and input/output names for insertion into the blanks of the appropriate template to generate the message using data stored upon detection of the error.

10. The method set forth claim 8 further characterized by:

saving the actual input/output image when leaving a zone, and

using said image for selecting a next zone and, if an error is detected, for generating the error message.

11. The method set forth in claim 7 further characterized by:

providing the error signal as an indication of the input/output conditions of said mechanism upon detection of an error.

13. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 characterized by:

determining departure from an existing zone by a change in actual input/output image for the mechanism.

14. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 characterized by:

determining departure from an existing zone by a mismatch of the actual input/output image and the current zone input/output image.

15. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 characterized by:

selecting the next zone from the list of allowed next zones by determining the input/output causing the departure and provided the actual input image matches that of said selected next zone.

16. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 characterized by:

selecting the next zone from the list of allowed next zones by comparing the actual input image with that of each allowed next zone in turn until a match is obtained.

17. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

monitoring the actual time in the present zone of the mechanism and comparing said time to a predetermined time associated with said particular zone.

18. The method set forth in claim 17 characterized by:

exiting the present zone when the actual time exceeds a predetermined maximum time.

19. The method set forth in claim 18 characterized by:

moving directly to the error zone and indicating an error.

20. The method set forth in claim 17 characterized by:

on leaving the zone, comparing the actual time in the zone to a predetermined minimum time, and, if less than the predetermined minimum, indicating an error.

21. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

recording an identifier of each zone that is departed and the actual time spent in that zone.

22. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

recording the occurrence of each error in a journal.

23. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

storing the condition of a part in a part process record, and

using said stored condition to inhibit at least one zone of said mechanism.

24. The method set forth in claims 4 or 5 further characterized by:

indicating an error condition when, after determining to depart the present zone, no next zone can be selected.

25. The method of claim 24 further comprising the steps of

storing a table containing a list of zone names, input/output names, input/output images for each zone and allowed zones for each said zone,

storing in a memory a plurality of error designations,

formulating an error message from said table and memory indicative of said error condition, and

generating the error message from the names of the last valid zone and the input/output names that caused the input/output image to not match the last valid zone or any of the allowed next zones.

5. A method of monitoring the operating of a machine which comprises in combination at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, and means for sensing mechanism conditions, and diagnostic means including memory means, said diagnostic means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, said method comprising the steps of:

storing a machine program comprised of at least one mechanism program representing sequences of operation defined by predetermined images of input and output signals stored in a table,

monitoring the actual input/output signals, and

comparing the image of actual input/output signals with one of the stored images, characterized by;

a zone logic method in which each said input/output image is indicative of a zone of said mechanism and each zone having associated therewith a list of corresponding allowed next zones, with at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones,

moving between zones by determining to leave the present zone and by selecting the next zone from among the next allowed zones, and

using said zone logic method to monitor the input/output conditions of said mechanism without setting outputs, which outputs are set by a control method other than said zone logic method.

6. The method set forth in claim 5 further characterized by:

accommodating interactions between mechanisms and outputs by having the current zone of one mechanism determine the actuation of a predetermined output.

12. The method set forth in claim 6 further characterized by:

displaying an error message indicative of an error condition.

26. A system for monitoring the operating of a machine which comprises in combination at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, means for sensing mechanism conditions, and control means including memory means, said control means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, said means comprising:

a stored machine program comprised of at least one mechanism program representing sequences of operation defined by predetermined images of input and output signals stored in a table,

means for monitoring the actual input/output signals, and

means for comparing the image of actual input/output signals with one of the stored images, characterized by;

zone logic means in which each said input/output image is indicative of a zone of said mechanism and each zone having associated therewith a list of corresponding allowed next zones, with at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones,

means for moving between zones by determining to leave the present zone and by selecting the next zone from among the next allowed zones

means for accommodating interactions between mechanisms by having the current zone of one mechanism prevent the occupation of a predetermined zone of another mechanism, and

means for setting the outputs as prescribed by said selected allowed next zone.

28. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

said table containing at least one error zone,

means for indicating an error condition when, after determining to depart the present zone, no next zone can be selected, and

means for entering said error zone.

29. The system set forth in claim 28 further characterized by:

means for generating a plain language text error message.

30. The system set forth in claim 29 wherein the means for generating is further characterized by:

means for storing a unique zone name for each zone of said mechanism,

means for storing a unique input/output name for each input/output,

means for providing at least one template containing fixed words and blank spaces, and

means for selecting zone and input/output names for insertion into the blanks of the appropriate template to generate the message using data stored upon detection of the error.

31. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 characterized by:

means for determining departure from an existing zone by a change in actual input/output image for the mechanism.

32. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 characterized by:

means for determining departure from an existing zone by a mismatch of the actual input/output image and the current zone input/output image.

33. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 characterized by:

means for selecting the next zone from the list of allowed next zones by determining the input/output causing the departure and provided the actual input image matches that of said selected next zone.

34. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 characterized by:

means for selecting the next zone from the list of allowed next zones by comparing the actual input image with that of each allowed next zone in turn until a match is obtained.

35. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

means for monitoring the actual time in the present zone of the mechanism and comparing said time to a predetermined time associated with said particular zone.

36. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

means for recording an identifier of each zone that is departed and the actual time spent in that zone.

37. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

means for recording the occurrence of each error in a journal.

38. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

means for storing the condition of a part in a part process record, and

using said stored condition to inhibit at least one zone of said mechanism.

39. The system set forth in claims 26 or 27 further characterized by:

means for indicating an error condition when, after determining to depart the present zone, no next zone can be selected.

40. The apparatus of claim 39 further characterized by:

means having a table containing a list of zone names, input/output names, input/output images for each zone and allowed zones for each said zone,

a memory containing a plurality of error designations,

means for formulating an error message from said table and memory indicative of said error condition, and

means for generating the error message from the names of the last valid zone and the input/output names that caused the input/output image to not match the last valid zone or any of the allowed next zones.

27. A system for monitoring the operating of a machine which comprises in combination at least one mechanism including means for actuating said mechanism, means for sensing mechanism conditions, and diagnostic means including memory means, said diagnostic means responsive to a predefined input from said condition-sensing means for providing a predefined output to said actuating means, said means comprising:

a stored machine program comprised of at least one mechanism program representing sequences of operation defined by predetermined images of input and output signals stored in a table,

means for monitoring the actual input/output signals, and

means for comparing the image of actual input/output signals with one of the stored images, characterized by;

zone logic means in which each said input/output image is indicative of a zone of said mechanism and each zone having associated therewith a list of corresponding allowed next zones, with at least one of said zones having a plurality of allowed next zones,

means for moving between zones by determining to leave the present zone and by selecting the next zone from among the next allowed zones, and

means for using said zone logic means to monitor the input/output conditions of said mechanism without setting outputs, which outputs are set by a control method other than said zone logic method.