Procedure for qualifying synthetic base gear lubricant

• US 5,157,963 A
• Filed: 05/22/1990
• Issued: 10/27/1992
• Est. Priority Date: 05/22/1990
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Eaton Corp. (Wisconsin) (Eaton Corporation PLC.)
• Original Assignee: Eaton Corp. (Wisconsin) (Eaton Corporation PLC.)
• Inventors: Newkirk, James E., Muyskens, Dale E.
• Primary Examiner(s): MYRACLE, JERRY
• Application Number:
  US07/526,823
• Time in Patent Office: 889 Days
• Field of Search: 73/10, 73/61.2, 73/64, 73/64.1
• US Class Current: 73/53.05
• CPC Class Codes: F16H 57/041 Coatings or solid lubricants, e.g. antiseize layers or pastes
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/30 for lubricating properties

Abstract

A procedure for qualifying a proposed synthetic lubricant includes: (1) compatibility testing the proposed lubricant with previously approved synthetic lubricants; (2) stability testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation by testing the lubricant in a heated gear box; (3) corrosion testing the proposed lubricant by a copper strip tarnish test; (4) field testing the proposed lubricant to evaluate the ability of the lubricant to withstand extended drain intervals while still performing its function; and analyzing all of the results of those tests. In another embodiment, the lubricant furthermore undergoes a seal life test to evaluate the appearance of various covers and seals for degradation due to long term exposure to the lubricant.

Claims

1. A procedure for qualifying a proposed synthetic gear lubricant to be used in transmissions having a rear bearing cover and a rear bearing cover seal, comprising:

testing the lubricant for compatibility with previously approved synthetic lubricants;

testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box;

testing the lubricant for corrosion resistance by a copper strip tarnish test; and

field testing the proposed gear lubricant to evaluate the ability of the lubricant to withstand extended drain intervals while still performing as functioned.

2. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing for compatibility includes heating the proposed synthetic lubricant with an approved lubricant in weight percentage ratios of 90/10, 75/25, 50/50, 25/75, and 10/90, respectively.

3. The procedure of claim 2, wherein said heating is accomplished with each weight percentage ratio at 0°

F., 70°

F., and 150°

F.

4. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing the lubricant for compatibility is accomplished by blending the proposed lubricant with the previously approved synthetic lubricants for about 430 days in order to evaluate for haze or separation.

5. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing for thermal oxidation stability by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box is accomplished by using a heated test gear box which contains two spur gear and a test bearing while operating at a predetermined load with at least one copper catalyst strip blank inside the test gear box during the test.

6. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished by maintaining the heated test gear box at about 325°

F.

7. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished in a heated test gear box while bubbling air at the rate of about 0.3 gallons per hour through the lubricant.

8. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box for about 300 hours of continuous operation and thereafter analyzing the test results by checking general appearance and cleanliness, and amounts of color of carbonaceous deposits.

9. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said thermal oxidation stability testing is accomplished by analyzing the increase of the viscosity of the proposed lubricant used in the heated test gear box.

10. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said thermal oxidation stability testing is accomplished by evaluating the total acidity of the lubricant after the test.

11. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said testing the lubricant for corrosion resistance is accomplished by heating the copper strip blank immersed in the test lubricant to an elevated temperature of about 250°

F.

12. The procedure of claim 11, wherein said heating is carried out for about 3 hours to effect the test.

13. The procedure of claim 1, wherein said field testing to evaluate the ability to withstand extended drain intervals is accomplished by doing the test on at least about 100 new, substantially identical vehicles each run in on-highway service for at least 275,000 miles without changing the lubricant, before inspecting the transmission parts.

14. The procedure of claim 1, further comprising testing for seal life by testing vehicles which have each been run in on-highway service for at least 300,000 miles without changing the lubricant.

15. The procedure of claim 14, wherein testing for seal life is accomplished by testing at least about 50 new, substantially identical vehicles which have been run in on-highway service for at least 300,000 miles without changing the lubricant and evaluating the appearance of the rear bearing covers and seals for general appearance, evidence of wearing or degradation of the seal or any mating surfaces, and for the amount and color of carbonaceous deposits existing as varnish and sludge on the rear bearing cover seal.

16. A procedure for qualifying a proposed synthetic gear lubricant to be used in transmissions having a rear bearing cover and a rear bearing cover seal, comprising:

testing the lubricant for compatibility with previously approved synthetic lubricants;

testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box;

testing the lubricant for corrosion resistance by a copper strip tarnish test;

field testing the proposed gear lubricant to evaluate the ability of the lubricant to withstand extended drain intervals while still performing as functioned; and

testing for seal life by testing at least about 50 new, substantially identical vehicles which have each been run in on-highway service for at least 300,000 miles without changing the lubricant and evaluating the appearance of the rear bearing covers and seals for general appearance, evidence of wearing or degradation of the seal or any mating surfaces, and for the amount and color of carbonaceous deposits existing as varnish and sludge on the rear bearing cover seal.

17. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing for compatibility includes heating the proposed synthetic lubricant with an approved lubricant in varying combinations having weight percentage ratios of 90/10, 75/25, 50/50, 25/75, and 10/90.

18. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said heating is accomplished with each weight percentage ratio at 0°

F., 70°

F., and 150°

F.

19. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant for compatibility is accomplished by blending the proposed lubricant with the previously approved synthetic lubricants for about 30 days in order to evaluate for haze or separation.

20. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing for thermal oxidation stability by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box is accomplished by using a heated test gear box which contains two spur gears and a test bearing while operating at a predetermined load with at least one copper catalyst strip blank inside the test gear box during the test.

21. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished by maintaining the heated gear box at about 325°

F.

22. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished in a heated gear box while bubbling air at a rate of about 0.3 gallons per hour through the lubricant.

23. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant for thermal oxidation stability is accomplished by testing the lubricant in a heated gear box for about 300 hours of continuous operation and thereafter analyzing the test results by checking general appearance and cleanliness, and amounts of color of carbonaceous deposits.

24. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said thermal oxidation stability testing is accomplished by analyzing the increase of the viscosity of the proposed lubricant used in the heated test gear box.

25. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said thermal oxidation stability testing is accomplished by evaluating the total acidity of the lubricant after the test.

26. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant for corrosion resistance is accomplished by heating the copper strip blank immersed in the test lubricant to an elevated temperature of about 250°

F.

27. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box is accomplished by heating for about 3 hours to effect the test.

28. The procedure of claim 16, wherein said field testing to evaluate the ability to withstand extended drain intervals is accomplished by doing the test on at least about 100 new, substantially identical vehicles each run in on-highway service for at least 275,000 miles without changing the lubricant, before inspecting the transmission parts.

29. A procedure for qualifying a proposed synthetic gear lubricant to be used in a transmission having an internal case, a shift bar housing, internal case rear seals, rear bearing covers and rear bearing cover seals, comprising:

(a) compatibility testing the proposed lubricant by heating the proposed synthetic lubricant with an approved lubricant in weight percentage ratios of 90/10, 75/25, 50/50, 25/75, and 10/90, respectively, at 0°

F., 70°

F., and 150°

F., respectively, for about 30 days to evaluate for haze or separation;

(b) stability testing the proposed lubricant for thermal oxidation by testing the lubricant in a heated test gear box containing two spur gears and a test bearing while operating at a predetermined load with at least one copper catalyst strip inside the test gear box, maintaining the test gear box at about 325°

F. while bubbling air at the rate of about 0.3 gallons per hour through the lubricant for about 300 hours of continuous operation, and thereafter analyzing the test results by checking general appearance and cleanliness, assessing resultant carbonaceous deposits of sludge and varnish including on the gears for color, analyzing the increase of the viscosity of the lubricant, and evaluating the total acid number in the lubricant after the test;

(c) corrosion testing the proposed lubricant by a copper strip tarnish test including placing a copper strip blank into a test bomb containing the lubricant to be tested, heating the test bomb to elevate the temperature to about 250°

C. for about three hours with a showing of slightly tarnished light orange surface on the copper strip blank after the test;

(d) field testing the proposed lubricant to evaluate the ability of the lubricant to withstand extended drain intervals while still performing its function, said field testing being done in at least about 100 new, substantially identical vehicles in on-highway service for at least 275,000 miles each, without changing the lubricant, by inspecting the transmission after on-highway service, including the internal transmission case, the shift bar housing, the internal case rear seals, and other transmission parts for wear and to evaluate the appearance for cleanliness as well as an evaluation of the amount and color of carbonaceous deposits existing as varnish and sludge within the transmission; and

(e) seal like testing by evaluating the appearance of the rear bearing covers and seals in at least about 50 new, substantially identical vehicles which have each been run in on-highway service for at least 300,000 miles without changing the proposed synthetic gear lubricant for general appearance, evidence of wearing or degradation of the seals or any mating surfaces, and the amount and color of carbonaceous deposits existing as varnish and sludge on the rear bearing cover seal.