Robust data broadcast over a distributed network with malicious failures

• US 5,175,765 A
• Filed: 05/09/1989
• Issued: 12/29/1992
• Est. Priority Date: 05/09/1989
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Digital Equipment Corporation (HP Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Digital Equipment Corporation (HP Inc.)
• Inventors: Perlman, Radia
• Primary Examiner(s): Gregory, Bernarr E.
• Application Number:
  US07/349,448
• Time in Patent Office: 1,330 Days
• Field of Search: 380/2, 380/23, 380/25, 380/30, 380/33, 380/48, 380/49, 370/60, 370/61, 370/92, 370/93, 370/94.1, 370/94.3, 370/99, 364/242.94, 364/284.4, 364/940.64
• US Class Current: 380/30
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 2209/601 Broadcast encryption
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 9/3226 using a predetermined code, e.g. password, passphrase or PIN network architectures or network communication protocols for supporting authentication of entities using passwords in a packet data network H04L63/083
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 9/3247 involving digital signatures
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 9/40 Network security protocols
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 3/665 Circuit arrangements therefor

Abstract

A public-key encryption system is used to reliably transmit packets over a network subject to malicious failures. Each node on the network is associated with a public and private key. A transmission over the network identifies its originating node and also includes a digital-signature code word generated by encoding predetermined portions of the transmission using the private key of the originating node. When a transmission is received, the receiving node verifies that the transmission was originated by the identified originating node by manipulating the packet contents using the public key associated with the originating node. The packet is accepted only if the digital-signature code word in the packet corresponds to contents of the packet and the public key of the originating node.

Claims

1. A method for transmitting data over a network of nodes interconnected by communication links comprising the steps of:

A. forming a data packet at an originating node, said packet containing

1. an identifier identifying the originating node and

2. a count of the packets formed by the originating node;

B. transmitting the packet over at least one of the communication links to a neighboring node;

C. at each neighboring node that receives determining whether the packet is valid and is the newest valid packet formed by the originating node and received by the neighboring node by comparing the count with a stored count corresponding to a previously received from the same originating node, said previously received packet being the newest valid packet previously received by the node;

D.

1. for each received packet determined to be the newest valid packet at a given node

i. storing at least the packet count in a memory location at the given node which is associated with the originating node; and

ii. queuing the packet for transmission over a communication link to at least one of the neighbors of the node, and

iii. transmitting the packet when an appropriate communication link is available;

2. if the packet is a duplicate of an earlier received packet, discarding the packet; and

E. repeating steps C and D until the packet is transmitted to every node.

2. The transmittal method of claim 1, wherein said method further includes:

A. in the step of queuing a packet for transmission, setting one or more flags which are associated with the packet and also correspond to the communication links over which the packet is to be transmitted;

B. in step D.1.iii., when a given communication link becomes available

1. searching the memory locations associated with the network originating nodes for a set flag corresponding to the available communication link,

2. transmitting the packet corresponding to the set flag, and

3. if the communication link continues to be available repeating steps 1 and 2.

3. The transmittal method of claim 2, wherein said step of determining whether a packet is the newest valid packet associated with the originating node includes:

A. if the count in the received packet is larger than the stored count, determining the received packet is the newest;

B. if the count in the received packet is smaller than the stored count, determining the received packet is older; and

C. if the count in the received packet is equal to the stored count, designating the received packet as either the newest packet or an older packet.

4. The transmittal method of claim 3, wherein said method further includes:

A. in the packet forming step

6. The transmittal method of claim 4, wherein said step of determining if the received packet is the newest valid packet associated with the packet originating node includes, for a received packet containing a count equal to the stored count, comparing the digital-signature code word in the received packet with the digital-signature code word in the stored packet and determining that the received packet is a duplicate of the stored packet if the code words are the same.

8. The transmittal method of claim 2, wherein said step of storing the packet count determined to be the newest valid packet associated with the originating node includes storing the entire packet in the memory location.

10. The transmittal method of claim 1, wherein step B. includes transmitting the packet over every attached communication link to every neighboring node of the originating node;

and

step D. includes transmitting the packet to each of the neighboring nodes, except the node from which the packet was received.

12. The transmission verifying method of claim 10, wherein said sending step includes:

A. storing in each node node-identifier and associated public code information for a predetermined number of nodes;

B. sending from said predetermined number of nodes to the network nodes a packet containing a list of node-identifying and associated public code information relating to the other nodes on the network;

C. at each receiving node determining whether said node-identification and public code information originated from one of said predetermined number of nodes by

1. retrieving the stored public code associated with the listed originating node,

2. manipulating the contents of the packet, including the digital-signature code word, and the public key using the retrieved public code word,

3. analyzing the results of the manipulation to determine if the digital-signature code word corresponds to the transmission,

4. determining that the listed originating node originated the transmission if the digital-signature code word corresponds to the transmission, or that the transmission was not originated by the listed originating node if they do not correspond,

5. storing the packet node identification and public code information if the transmission is determined to be valid, and

6. allocating memory locations for each identified node.

15. The verification method of claim 10, wherein said transmission further includes a count representing the number of transmissions originated by the originating node.

17. The verification method of claim 15 wherein if the count in the recently received transmission is equal to the count in the previously received transmission, the transmission with the numerically greater digital-signature code word is designated as the newer transmission.

18. The verification method of claim 15 wherein if the count in the recently received transmission is equal to the count in the previously received transmission, the transmission with the numerically lesser digital-signature code word is designated as the newer transmission.

20. The method of claim 18, further comprising including in the packets a public code associated with the packet originating node, said public code being related to the code used to generate the digital-signature code word.

5. encoding a predetermined portion of the contents of the packet using a private code associated with the originating node to form a digital-signature code word, said private code being unavailable to the other nodes on the network,including the digital-signature code word in the packet;

and

B. in the step of determining if the received packet is the newest valid packet associated with the originating node

1. manipulating the packet contents and the packet digital-signature code word and a public code associated with the originating node to generate an output value; and

2. analyzing the output value to determine both if the packet was originated by the listed originating node and if the packet contents were unaltered during transmission;

7. The transmittal method of claim 5, wherein said method includes the step of sending an acknowledgment to the transmitting node if the packet received by the neighbor is determined by the neighbor to be the newest valid packet associated with the originating node.

9. The transmittal method of claim 7, wherein said transmittal method includes, if the given node is storing a packet associated with the same originating node as the received packet which has a larger count than the received packet, sending a copy of the stored packet to the neighboring node from which the received packet was received.

11. A method of determining if transmissions over a network of nodes interconnected by communication links are reliable comprising the steps of:

A. sending to every node on the network one or more packets containing a list of nodke-identifier information and associated public code information, said list containing information from which to identify the nodes on the network;

B. when a node receives a transmmission over the network, said transmission containing an identifier identifying the node originating the transmission and a digital-signature code word generated by encoding predetermined portions of the transmission, verifying that the transmission was originated by the identified originating node by;

1. manipulating the packet contents, including the public code associated with the originating node, to generate a second digital-signature code word,

2. analyzing the second digital-signature code word to determine if it corresponds to the digital signature code word in the transmission, and

3. determining that the listed originating node originated the transmission if the second digital-signature code word corresponds to the digital-signature code word in the transmission, or that the transmission was not originated by the listed originating node if the digital-signature code words do not correspond.

13. The verifying method of claim 11, wherein said sending step further includes, if contradictory lists are received from one or more of said predetermined number of nodes, storing all the information which is verified, and allocating a memory location for each node identified on either list.

14. The verification method of claim 11, wherein said determining step further includes, if contradictory information is received from said predetermined number of nodes, trying each code associated with the packet originating node until the packet contents are verified or until all the associated codes are tried.

16. The verification method of claim 14, wherein said verification step includes:

A. comparing the count in the received transmission with the count in a transmission received previously which was originated by the same originating node;

B.

1. if the count in the recently received transmission is larger than the count in the previously received transmission, determining that the received transmission is newer;

2. if the count in the recently received transmission is smaller than the count in the previously received transmission, determining that the recently received transmission is older.

19. A method of transmitting data in a packet over a network of nodes interconnected by communication links, comprising:

including said transmitted data in a data section of the packet;

including in the packet an identifier identifying the node which originated the packet;

including in the packet a count of the number of packets formed by the originating node;

generating a digital-signature code word by manipulating a public code associated with the originating node and a predetermined portion of the contents of the packet, and

including said digital-signature code word in the packet in addition to said transmitted data.