Expert configurator

• US 5,260,866 A
• Filed: 09/17/1991
• Issued: 11/09/1993
• Est. Priority Date: 09/17/1991
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Andersen Consulting LLP (Accenture PLC)
• Original Assignee: Andersen Consulting LLP (Accenture PLC)
• Inventors: Frandsen, Michael L., Frandsen, Mary G., Penn, Greg T., Fiorellino, Mario S., Chaney, Russell, Lisinski, Mark S.
• Primary Examiner(s): Envall, Jr., Roy N.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Poinvil, Frantzy
• Application Number:
  US07/761,270
• Time in Patent Office: 784 Days
• Field of Search: 364/401, 364/406, 364/408, 364/469, 364/419
• US Class Current: 705/29
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/087 Inventory or stock management, e.g. order filling, procurement or balancing against orders
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/0875 Itemisation or classification of parts, supplies or services, e.g. bill of materials

Abstract

A multi-level system generates multiple custom work orders for the manufacture of an end item and lower-level configurable items comprising the end item. The system includes an order entry configuration for obtaining option values that define specifications for the end item and lower-level configurable items. An options storage within the system stores the option values and parameters for generating work order requirements for the end item and lower-level configurable items. The system further includes a manufacturing configuration which, after the order entry configuration processes the option values, generates the multiple custom work orders by interactively accessing the options storage.

Claims

1. A multi-level system for constructing a first custom work order for an end item and a plurality of second custom work orders for a plurality of configurable lower-level items necessary for manufacturing the end item, the system comprising:

a) order entry configuration means for enabling a customer desiring a particular product to specify features and options corresponding to the product, the product comprising the end item and the configurable lower-level items, the order entry configuration means comprising;

i) questioning means for presenting a plurality of sets of questions to a user, the sets of questions relating to the features and options of the product; and

ii) input means for inputting a plurality of sets of answers to the questions, the sets of answers specifying the features and options for the end item and the configurable lower-level items;

b) options storage means for storing the plurality of sets of answers, the options storage means comprising;

i) end item data structure means for storing the features and options needed to generate work order requirements to construct the end item; and

ii) lower-level item data structure means for storing the features and options needed to generate work order requirements to construct the configurable lower-level items; and

c) manufacturing configuration means for automatically generating the first custom work order to construct the end item and the plurality of second custom work orders to construct the configurable lower-level items, the manufacturing configuration means comprising;

i) means for accessing the end item data structure means and the lower-level item data structure means in order to retrieve the sets of answers; and

ii) means for translating the retrieved sets of answers into manufacturing requirements and for generating from the manufacturing requirements the first custom work order and the plurality of second custom work orders for construction of the product, including the end item and the configurable lower-level items, meeting the features and options specified by the customer, the first custom work order corresponding to construction of the end item and the plurality of second custom work orders corresponding to construction of the configurable lower-level items.

2. The system of claim 1 wherein:

a) the order entry configuration means comprises order entry rules for defining actions, and e conditions upon which the actions are dependent, to be executed by the order entry configuration means during a process of obtaining the sets of answers; and

b) the manufacturing configuration means comprises manufacturing rules for defining actions, and conditions upon which the actions are dependent, to be executed by the manufacturing configuration means during a process of generating the custom work orders.

3. The system of claim 2 wherein the order entry configuration means and the manufacturing configuration means further comprise forward chaining means for processing the order entry rules until the answers are complete and for processing the manufacturing rules until the custom work orders are complete, the forward chaining means comprising:

a) firing means for releasing the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules for execution;

b) compare means for comparing the condition of each of the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules with data available to the system; and

c) execution means for executing the action of each of the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules only if the condition of the corresponding rule is satisfied and the rule has been released by the firing means.

4. The system of claim 1, further comprising pricing configuration means for generating a custom price for the end item based upon the sets of answers.

5. The system of claim 4 wherein the pricing configuration means comprises pricing rules for defining actions, and conditions upon which the actions are dependent, to be executed by the pricing configuration means during a process of generating the custom price.

6. The system of claim 5 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises forward chaining means for processing the pricing rules until the custom price is generated, the forward chaining means comprising:

a) firing means for releasing the pricing rules for execution;

b) compare means for comparing the condition of each of the pricing rules with data available to the system; and

c) execution means for executing the action of each of the pricing rules only if the condition of the corresponding rule is satisfied and the rule has been released by the firing means.

7. The system of claim 3 wherein the input means comprises user-defined input means for inputting a plurality of sets of user-defined answers to the questions.

8. The system of claim 3 wherein the input means comprises rule-determined input means for inputting a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

9. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises screen generation means for generating a graphical interface for presenting a user with the sets of questions and for allowing the user to enter the sets of answers.

10. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises validation means for determining whether the sets of answers produce valid combinations for the end item.

11. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises configured component rule means for identifying custom lower-level items required to construct the end item and for establishing links between the sets of answers so that the linked sets of answers comprise complete specifications for the end item.

12. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means further comprises:

a) component requirement means for determining the components required for the custom work orders; and

b) labor requirement means for determining the labor required for the custom work orders.

13. The system of claim 11 wherein the lower level item data structure means comprises means for storing the parameters of each of the lower level items as unique data sets so that each parameter is stored in only one of the data sets.

14. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises global variable means for accessing the end item data structure means and the lower level item data structure means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

15. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means further comprises global variable means for accessing the end item data structure means and the lower level item data structure means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

16. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises global variable means for accessing the end item data structure means and the lower level item data structure means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

17. The system of claim 1 wherein the manufacturing configuration means comprises multi-plant means for determining and specifying, for each of the custom work orders, which plant among a plurality of plants will be assigned to receive at least one of the custom work orders to construct an item corresponding to the custom work order.

18. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises secondary variable means for accessing only one particular data structure within the options storage means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

19. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means further comprises secondary variable means for accessing only one particular data structure within the options storage means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

20. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises secondary variable means for accessing only one particular data structure within the options storage means and for temporarily storing a value for subsequent use by the system.

21. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises condition rule means for suspending the releasing by the firing means of one or more order entry rules while a user-determined condition is not satisfied.

22. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means further comprises condition rule means for suspending the releasing by the firing means of one or more manufacturing rules while a user-determined condition is not satisfied.

23. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises condition rule means for suspending the releasing by the firing means of one or more pricing rules while a user-determined condition is not satisfied.

24. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises price detail means for generating a price value for selected elements of the end item.

25. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means further comprises comment rule means for associating a user-defined comment with at least one of the custom work orders.

26. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means and the manufacturing configuration means further comprise rule syntax means for processing a first variable and a second variable according to an operation defined by an operand within each of the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules.

27. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means and the manufacturing configuration means further comprise rule syntax means for processing a variable within each of the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules.

28. The system of claim 27 wherein the rule syntax means comprises variable means for processing at least one of the variables selected from the following group of variables:

option variable, user-defined constant, secondary variable, global variable, validation table variable, matrix variable, program variable, internal database variable, or multiple options table.

29. The system of claim 28 wherein:

a) the order entry configuration means further comprises matrix variable means for generating a result value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

30. The system of claim 28 wherein:

a) the manufacturing configuration means further comprise matrix variable means for generating a result value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

31. The system of claim 26 wherein the rule syntax means comprises variable means for processing at least one of the variables selected from the following group of variables:

option variable, user-defined constant, secondary variable, global variable, validation table variable, matrix variable, program variable, internal database variable, or multiple options table.

32. The system of claim 26 wherein the rule syntax means comprises operand means for processing the first variable and the second variable according to at least one of the operations selected from the following group of operations:

less than, less than or equal, addition, subtraction, division, multiplication, greater than, greater than or equal to, equal to, round down, round up, concatenate between one and four characters, element of multiple option table, element of validation table, logical AND, logical OR, logical IF, substring after, or substring before.

33. The system of claim 31 wherein:

a) the order entry configuration means further comprises matrix variable means for generating a result value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

34. The system of claim 31 wherein:

a) the manufacturing configuration means further comprises matrix variable means for generating a result value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

35. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises rule syntax means for processing a first variable and a second variable and an operand within each of the pricing rules.

36. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises rule syntax means for processing a variable within each of the pricing rules.

37. The system of claim 36 wherein the rule syntax means comprises variable means for processing at least one of the variables selected from the following group of variables:

option variable, user-defined constant, secondary variable, global variable, validation table variable, matrix variable, program variable, internal database variable, or multiple options table.

38. The system of claim 37 wherein:

a) the pricing configuration means further comprises matrix variable means for generating a result value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

39. The system of claim 35 wherein the rule syntax means comprises variable means for processing at least one of the variables selected from the following group of variables:

option variable, user-defined constant, secondary variable, global variable, validation table variable, matrix variable, program variable, internal database variable, or multiple options table.

40. The system of claim 35 wherein the rule syntax means comprises operand means for processing the first and second variables according to at least one of the operations selected from the following group of operations:

less than, less than or equal, addition, subtraction, division, multiplication, greater than, greater than or equal, equal to, round down, round up, concatenate between one and four characters, element of multiple option table, element of validation table, logical AND, logical OR, logical IF, substring after, or substring before.

41. The system of claim 39 wherein:

a) the pricing configuration means further comprises value based upon one or more of the following keys;

the answers, the secondary variable, the global variable, or the internal database variable; and

b) the matrix variable means comprises means for receiving the keys and for generating a unique result value corresponding to each combination of values of the keys.

42. The system of claim 2, further comprising knowledge acquisition means for gathering data for the order entry rules and the manufacturing rules.

43. The system of claim 5, further comprising knowledge acquisition means for generating the pricing rules.

44. The system of claim 3 wherein the order entry configuration means further comprises explanation means for outputting results of the order entry rules executed by the execution means during the process of obtaining the sets of answers and for outputting results of the manufacturing rules executed by the execution means during the process of generating the custom work orders, the explanation means comprising means for listing rules that were fires, for specifying a firing sequence of the rules that were fired, and for listing results of the rules that were fired.

45. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means further comprises explanation means for outputting results of the pricing rules executed by the execution means during the process of generating the custom price, the explanation means comprising means for listing rules that were fired, for specifying a firing sequence of the that rules were fired, and for listing results of the rules that were fired.

46. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means comprises finalized price means for calculating a finalized price for the end item and for inputting the finalized price into a data storage.

47. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means comprises cost roll-up means for adding a cost of each lower-level item into a cumulative total cost during the process of generating the custom work orders and for adding a cost of assembling the end item and assembling the lower-level items into the total cost.

48. The system of claim 1 wherein the manufacturing configuration means comprises matrix maintenance means for defining a matrix variable having user-defined input keys and a unique user-defined result value for each combination of the input keys, the matrix maintenance means comprising means for inputting the user-defined keys and the user-defined result values.

49. The system of claim 1 wherein the order entry means comprises matrix maintenance means for defining a matrix variable having user-defined input keys and a unique user-defined result value for each combination of the input keys, the matrix maintenance means comprising means for inputting the user-defined keys and the user-defined result values.

50. The system of claim 4 wherein the pricing configuration means comprises matrix maintenance means for defining a matrix variable having user-defined input keys and a unique user-defined result value for each combination of the input keys, the matrix maintenance means comprising means for inputting the user-defined keys and the user-defined result values.

51. The system of claim 3 wherein the input means comprises rule-determined input means for modifying a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

52. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means comprises rule-determined input means for inputting a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

53. The system of claim 3 wherein the manufacturing configuration means comprises rule-determined input means for modifying a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

54. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means comprises rule-determined input means for inputting a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

55. The system of claim 6 wherein the pricing configuration means comprises rule-determined input means for modifying a plurality of sets of rule-determined answers to the questions.

56. The system of claim 1, further comprising inventory management means for identifying parts that have been configured by the system, for which a work order has been completed, and which have been received into an inventory.

57. The system of claim 56 wherein the inventory management means comprises configuration code means for assigning a unique configuration code to each of the parts.

58. A process for dynamically constructing a plurality of custom work orders for an end item and for a plurality of lower-level configurable items necessary for manufacturing the end item, the process comprising:

a) processing a first set of option values for the end item and the lower-level items comprising the end item;

b) executing a recursive process of gathering a second set of option values for each lower-level configurable item identified while processing the first and second sets of option values until processing of the second sets of option values for all the lower-level configurable items is complete, the recursive processing comprising the steps of;

1) suspending processing of a parent set of option values for a parent configurable item when a lower-level configurable item is identified;

2) transferring control to a processing of a lower-level set of option values for the identified lower-level configurable item;

3) processing the lower-level set of option values for the identified lower-level configurable item; and

4) returning to the processing of the parent set of option values for the parent configurable item; and

c) generating a plurality of custom work orders for the end item and the lower-level configurable items based upon data available to the process which includes the sets of option values.

59. The process of claim 58 wherein steps (a) and (b) each comprise the substep of processing order entry rules, comprising the steps of:

1) firing the order entry rules for execution;

2) comparing a condition of each of the order entry rules with data available to the process; and

3) executing an action of each of the order entry rules only if the condition of the corresponding rule is satisfied and the rule has been released by the firing step (1).

60. The process of claim 58 wherein step (c) comprises the substep of processing manufacturing rules, comprising the steps of:

1) firing the manufacturing rules for execution;

2) comparing a condition of each of the manufacturing rules with data available to the process; and

3) executing an action of each of the manufacturing rules only if the condition of the corresponding rule is satisfied and the rule has been released by the firing step (1).