Arrangement for monitoring the quality of electric welds

• US 5,291,423 A
• Filed: 06/21/1991
• Issued: 03/01/1994
• Est. Priority Date: 12/16/1988
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Elpatronic AG
• Original Assignee: Elpatronic AG
• Inventors: Roosli, Hans
• Primary Examiner(s): Black, Thomas G.
• Assistant Examiner(s): ZANELLI, MICHAEL J
• Application Number:
  US07/719,644
• Time in Patent Office: 984 Days
• Field of Search: 364/550, 364/551.01, 364/552, 364/507, 364/477, 364/554, 219/109, 219/110, 219/64, 219/117.1, 73/850, 324/693, 324/699, 324/716, 324/718, 33/522
• US Class Current: 702/82
• CPC Class Codes: B23K 11/063 Lap welding
• CPC Class Codes: B23K 11/252 using digital means
• CPC Class Codes: B23K 31/125 Weld quality monitoring

Abstract

What is described is an arrangement for monitoring the quality of electric welds on bodies (10) for the production of cans. Welding parameter values (F_i), which have been measured on a number of bodies (10) found to be good are statistically evaluated in an evaluation device (22). For this purpose, an average welding parameter profile is determined. Then a reject limiting-value band (F_g±) enveloping the average welding parameter profile is determined from the mean values and the product of the standard deviation of the welding parameter values (F_i) assumed to be normally distributed and at least one sensitivity factor. A permissible number of erroneous rejects per one million of welding spots is selected as a criterion for the sensitivity factor so that, for example with 100 welding spots on a body (10) of a medium-sized can, every ten thousandth body will be accidentally rejected on the average. For bodies (10) produced following on the "learning phase", a comparator (26) ascertains whether a welding parameter profile measured for these lies within the reject limiting-value band (F_g±). This quality control arrangement working on statistical methods is sensitive and precise since a fixed value is not simply selected for the width of the reject limiting-value band.

Claims

1. An apparatus for monitoring the quality of electric welds on can bodies, each can body having a weld seam formed by a plurality of welds extending continuously along the length of a can body each weld being associated with a welding parameter of a given value, said apparatus comprising:

means for receiving weld signal indicative of the value of the welding parameter as measured for each weld, with a set of said parameter values of each weld seam;

at least one means for determining from said weld signals an average welding parameter profile (F_m) computed from a group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets measured on a plurality of acceptable welded can bodies;

store means to store the average welding parameter profile;

a comparator to compare the average welding parameter profile with welding parameter profiles measured later on subsequently welded can bodies for determining a degree of agreement between the average welding parameter profile and each of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles; and

evaluation means for providing statistical evaluation of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles and determining a reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) from computed mean welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets and from the product of a standard deviation of said welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets assumed to be normally distributed and at least one weld quality sensitivity factor;

the comparator further generating output signals indicative of whether each welding parameter value of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles lie within the reject limiting-value band (F_g±

).

2. The apparatus according to claim 1, for an alternating-current seam welding device wherein each half-wave of the welding current produces a "welding spot", and wherein the evaluation device comprises a first calculating device which determines the average welding parameter profile (F_m) for the welding spots of the weld seam over a number of can bodies which have been found to be good, and a second calculating device which determines the reject limiting values for the reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) for each welding spot.

3. The apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the number of acceptable can bodies the first calculating device for determining the average welding parameter profile (F_m), is between 20 and 100.

4. The apparatus according to claim 2 wherein the welding profiles comprise a plurality of regions corresponding to respective portions of the weld seams with said limiting values of said reject limiting band being of a different magnitude in at least one of said regions.

5. The apparatus according to claim 4, characterized in that each of said regions comprises 10 to 20 welding spots.

6. The apparatus according to claim 2 further comprising an input device for the sensitivity factor which is connected to the second calculating device.

7. The apparatus according to claim 6, wherein the input device comprises an addressable search table which contains a number of weld quality sensitivity factors.

8. The apparatus according to claim 2 wherein the second calculating device calculates the reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) from the relationships

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">F.sub.gi+ = F.sub.mi + a.sub.1 σ

.sub.i

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">F.sub.gi- = F.sub.mi - z.sub.2 σ

.sub.i

with i = 1, 2, 3 . . . n and

F_gi = reject limiting value in the i^th spot of the weld seam,

F_mi = mean value of the welding parameter in the i^th spot of the weld seam,

z₁ = sensitivity factor or reciprocal quantity of the sensitivity for the upper reject limiting value,

z₂ = sensitivity factor or reciprocal quantity of the sensitivity for the lower reject limiting value,

σ

₁ = standard deviation of the with spot of the weld seam.

9. The apparatus according to claim 8 wherein z₁ ≠

z₂ so that the reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) envelops the average welding parameter profile (F_m) asymmetrically.

10. The apparatus according to claim 8 wherein z₁ = z₂ = z, so that the reject limiting value band (F_g±

) envelops the average welding parameter profile (F_m) symmetrically.

11. The apparatus according to claim 1 wherein the weld quality sensitivity factor is between 3 to 5 and is preferably 4.54.

12. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the evaluation means further generates a running average of welding parameter values of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles with corresponding mean welding parameter values of said acceptable group of weld seam parameter value sets and wherein said comparator generates error signals is said running average exceeds said reject limiting-value band (F_g±

).

13. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein the values of said reject limiting value band (F_g±

) vary in dependence of the position of the weld along the weld seam,

14. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said evaluation means further generates a running average of welding parameter values of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles and wherein said comparator generates error signals if said running average exceeds said reject limiting-value band (F_g±

).

15. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising:

means for receiving first and second weld signals indicative of the value of corresponding first and second welding parameters as measured for each weld, with corresponding first and second sets of said welding parameter values for each weld seam;

said evaluation means further for determining, for each of said welding parameter sets, a reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) enveloping the average welding parameter profile (F_m) from computed mean welding parameter values for each weld in said acceptable group of weld seam parameter value sets and from the product of a standard deviation of welding parameter values for each weld in said acceptable group of weld seam parameter value sets and at least one weld quality sensitivity factor;

the comparator further comprising said first and second welding parameter value sets with each other and generating an error signal should either of said values of said first and second welding parameter signal sets exceed a cross correlation limiting value (F_k).

16. Apparatus for monitoring the quality of welds on can bodies, each body having a weld seam extending along the length of the can body and being composed of a plurality of individual welds, said apparatus comprising:

means for measuring a welding parameter value associated with the formation of each weld in a weld seam extending along the length of a can body and establishing a welding parameter profile composed of the measured values along the weld seam;

memory means for storing as welding parameter profiles the values of the welding parameter from a plurality of weld seams determined to be good weld seams;

means for statistically evaluating the stored values of the welding parameter profiles of the good weld seams and determining an average welding parameter profile (F_m);

means for also storing in the storing means the average welding parameter profile (F_m) as the first welding parameter profile;

means for statistically evaluating the stored values of the welding parameter profiles of the good welding seams and determining a reject limiting-value band (F_g±

) enveloping the average welding parameter profile (F_m) from the mean values of the stored welding parameter values used to determine the first welding parameter profile and from the product of a standard deviation of these welding parameter profiles assumed to be normally distributed and at least one sensitivity factor; and

comparator means for establishing that a second welding parameter profile measured along the weld seam of another can body by the means for measuring lies within the reject limiting-value band (F_g±

).

17. An apparatus for monitoring the quality of electric welds on can bodies, each can body having a weld seam formed by a plurality of welds extending continuously along the length of a can body, each weld being associated with a welding parameter of a given value, said apparatus comprising:

means for receiving weld signals indicative of the value of the welding parameter as measured for each weld, with a set of said parameter values for each weld seam;

at least one means for determining from said weld signals an average welding parameter profile (Fm) computed from a group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets measured on a plurality of acceptable welded can bodies;

store means to store the average welding parameter profile;

a comparator to compare the average welding parameter profile with welding parameter profiles measure later on subsequently welded can bodies for determining a degree of agreement between the average welding parameter profile and each of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles;

evaluation means for providing statistical evaluation of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles and determining a reject limiting-value band (Fg±

) enveloping the average welding parameter profile (F_m) from computed mean welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets and from the product of a standard deviation of said welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets assumed to be normally distributed and at least one weld quality sensitivity factor;

the comparator further generating output signals indicative of whether each welding parameter value of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles lies within the reject limiting-value band (Fg±

); and

signal processing means including a can body ejector connected with the comparator and responsive to the output signals for ejecting a can body if the measured welding parameter profile for the body does not lie within the reject limiting-value band (F_g ±

).

18. An apparatus for monitoring the quality of electric welds on can bodies, each can body having a weld seam formed by a plurality of welds extending continuously along the length of a can body each weld being associated with a welding parameter of a given value, said apparatus comprising:

means for receiving weld signals indicative of the value of the welding parameter as measured for each weld, with a set of said parameter values for each weld seam;

at least one means for determining from said weld signals an average welding parameter profile (Fm) computed from a group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets measured on a plurality of acceptable welded can bodies;

store means to store the average welding parameter profile;

a comparator to compare the average welding parameter profile with welding parameter profiles measured later on subsequently welded can bodies for determined a degree of agreement between the average welding parameter profile and each of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles;

evaluation means for providing statistical evaluation of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles and determining a reject limiting-value band (Fg±

) enveloping the average welding parameter profile (F_m) from computed mean welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets and from the product of a standard deviation of said welding parameter values for each weld in said group of acceptable weld seam parameter value sets assumed to be normally distributed and at least one weld quality sensitivity factor;

the comparator further generating output signals indicative of whether each welding parameter value of said subsequently welded can body welding parameter profiles lies within the reject limiting-value band (Fg±

); and

a controller responsive to the comparator output signals and generating signals to adjust said welding parameter value to bring said subsequently welded can body welding parameter values within the reject limiting-value band (Fg±

).