Power tool compensator for torque overshoot

• US 5,315,501 A
• Filed: 04/03/1992
• Issued: 05/24/1994
• Est. Priority Date: 04/03/1992
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Stanley Works Limited (Stanley Black & Decker, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Stanley Works Limited (Stanley Black & Decker, Inc.)
• Inventors: Whitehouse, Hugh L.
• Primary Examiner(s): Smith, Jerry
• Assistant Examiner(s): GORDON, PAUL P
• Application Number:
  US07/863,054
• Time in Patent Office: 781 Days
• Field of Search: 364/152, 364/153, 364/508, 73/862.21, 73/862.23, 81/467, 81/470, 173/176, 173/181, 173/182
• US Class Current: 700/32
• CPC Class Codes: B23P 19/066 by electrical means
• CPC Class Codes: B25B 23/14 Arrangement of torque limiters or torque indicators in wrenches or screwdrivers couplings for transmitting rotation or clutches F16D; devices for measuring torque per se G01L
• CPC Class Codes: G05D 17/02 characterised by the use of electric means

Abstract

A system and method for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool wherein the tool is shut off at an adjusted set point value of torque which is below the target value of torque by the amount of torque overshoot. While the tool is operated to perform a fastening job, the relationship between the torque rate in the fastening job to overshoot in the tool is determined, the torque rate in the job is monitored while the tool is setting the job, and the torque set point is adjusted while the tool is setting the job to compensate for the torque overshoot determined from the foregoing relationship. The relationship between torque rate in the fastening job and overshoot in the tool follows the expression Y=K/X where Y is the overshoot, X is the deceleration time required to tighten the fastener and K is a constant determined by using the measured deceleration time and torque overshoot during a previous high torque rate job in the foregoing expression, the deceleration time being measured between the same selected fractional values of the target torque. During a subsequent fastening job, the deceleration time is measured between the same selected fractional values of target torque, the overshoot is calculated from the foregoing mathematical expression using the previous value of K, and the torque set point is adjusted to compensate for the calculated value of overshoot. The foregoing is performed job-to-job developing a running average of the constant K. While the use of torque-time rates is preferred for simplicity and economy, the use of torque-angle rates also is contemplated.

Claims

1. A method for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool wherein the tool is to be shut off at a target torque and is actually shut off at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) operating the tool to perform a high torque rate fastening job;

(b) measuring time duration between selected fractions of the target torque which occur during a portion of the fastening job when the torque rate is linear to provide a fastener deceleration time value;

(c) measuring the torque overshoot in the job;

(d) calculating a value of K from an expression K=XY where Y is torque overshoot and X is deceleration time required to tighten the fastener;

(e) operating the tool to perform a next fastening job;

(f) measuring the time duration between the same selected fractions of target torque as in the first measuring step to obtain a deceleration time for said next fastening job;

(g) determining the torque overshoot for said next fastening job from the expression Y=K/X using the value of K previously determined and a value of X measured during said next fastening job; and

(h) adjusting the torque set point to compensate for the calculated value of overshoot.

2. The method of claim 1, further including determining the value of K from job-to-job to perform an on-going averaging of K.

3. A method according to claim 1, wherein said tool is fluid operated.

4. A method according to claim 1, wherein said tool is electrically operated.

5. A method for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool wherein the tool is to be shut off at a target torque and is actually shut off at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) operating the tool to perform a first fastening job;

(b) measuring time duration between selected fractions of the target torque which occur during a portion of the fastening job when the torque rate is linear to provide a fastener deceleration time value;

(c) determining the torque overshoot by subtracting the measured torque at the end of the fastening job from the target torque;

(d) calculating a value of K from an expression K=XY where Y is torque overshoot and X is deceleration time required to tighten the fastener;

(e) operating the tool to perform a second fastening job;

(f) measuring the time duration between the same selected fractions of target torque as in the first measuring step to obtain a deceleration time for said second fastening job;

(g) determining torque overshoot for said second fastening job from an expression Y=K/X using the value of K determined during said first fastening job and the deceleration time obtained during said second fastening job;

(h) determining a new torque set point according to a relationship

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">S=[(Target)/(Target+Y)](Target)

where S is the new set point, Target is the target torque and Y is the torque overshoot determined for the second fastening job; and

(i) establishing a running average of the constant K.

6. A method according to claim 5, wherein said step of establishing a running average of the constant K comprises:

(a) calculating actual overshoot on a previous fastening job;

(b) calculating the next value of the constant K; and

(c) subtracting the next value of K from the previous value of K and adding a fraction of the difference to the previous value of K to obtain a new value of K.

7. A method according to claim 6 further including:

(a) operating the tool to perform a third fastening job;

(b) measuring the time duration between the same selected fractions of target torque to obtain a deceleration time for said third fastening job;

(c) determining the torque overshoot for said third fastening job from the expression Y=K/X using said new value of K and the deceleration time obtained during said third fastening job; and

(d) determining a new torque set point according to the relationship

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">S=[(Target)/(Target)+Y](Target)

where S is the new set point, Target is the target torque and Y is the torque overshoot determined for the third fastening job.

8. A method according to claim 7 further including obtaining a new value of the constant K by:

(a) calculating actual overshoot on a previous fastening job;

(b) calculating the next value of the constant K; and

(c) subtracting the next value of K from the previous value of K and adding a fraction of the difference to the previous value of K to obtain a new value of K.

9. A method according to claim 8, wherein said step of obtaining a new value of the constant K comprises:

(a) calculating the actual overshoot on a previous fastening job Y_a according to the relationship

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">Y.sub.a =(M/S)(Target)-Target

where M is the measured torque at the end of the fastening job, S is the set point torque and Target is the target torque;

(b) calculating the next value of the constant K according to the relationship K₁ =Y_a X where K₁ is the next value of K, Y_a is the calculated actual overshoot on a previous fastening job and X is the measured deceleration time on the previous fastening job; and

(c) subtracting the next value of K from the previous value of K and adding about 15% of the difference to the previous value of K to obtain a new value of K.

10. A method according to claim 5, wherein said step of establishing a running average of the constant K comprises:

(a) calculating actual overshoot on a previous fastening job Y_a according to the relationship

space="preserve" listing-type="equation">Y.sub.a =(M/S)(Target)-Target

where M is the measured torque at the end of the fastening job, S is the set point torque and Target is the target torque;

(b) calculating the next value of the constant K according to the relationship K₁ =Y_a X where K₁ is the next value of K, Y_a is the calculated actual overshoot on a previous fastening job and X is the measured deceleration time on the previous fastening job; and

(c) substracting the next value of K from the previous value of K and adding about 15% of the difference to the previous value of K to obtain a new value of K.

11. A method according to claim 5 wherein said steps of measuring the time duration between selected fractions of target torque during the first fastening job and the second fastening job each includes determining if the measured time duration is greater than a predetermined value and, if so, preventing compensation for overshoot.

12. A method according to claim 5, wherein said tool is fluid operated.

13. A method according to claim 5, wherein said tool is electrically operated.

14. A method for compensating for torque overshoot in a power tool wherein the tool is to be shut off at a target torque and is actually shut of at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) operating the tool to perform a high torque rate fastening job;

(b) measuring torque angle between selected fractions of the target torque which occur during a portion of the fastening job when the torque rate is linear to provide a fastener deceleration angle value;

(c) measuring the torque overshoot on the job;

(d) calculating a value of K from an expression K=XY where Y is torque overshoot and X is a deceleration angle required to tighten the fastener;

(e) operating the tool to perform a next fastening job;

(f) measuring the torque angle between the same selected fractions of target torque as in the first measuring step to obtain a deceleration angle for said next fastening job;

(g) determining the torque overshoot for said next fastening job from the expression Y=K/X using the value of K previously determined and a value of X measured during said next fastening job; and

(h) adjusting the torque set point to compensate for the calculated valve of overshoot.

15. The method of claim 14, further including determining the value of K from job-to-job to perform an on-going averaging of K.

16. A system for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool including control means to normally shut off the tool at a target torque and to actually shut off the tool at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said system comprising:

(a) torque measuring means operatively associated with said tool for providing an output indicative of the torque of said tool;

(b) processor means having an input operatively connected to said torque measuring means and having an output operatively connected to said control means; and

(c) said processor means including means for computing deceleration time between selected fractional values of the target torque, means for computing the torque overshoot, means operatively connected to said means for computing deceleration time and to said means for computing overshoot for computing a constant K in a relationship K=XY where Y is computer overshoot and X is computer deceleration time, the constant K being determined by using values of overshoot and deceleration time during a previous high torque-rate application of said tool, and means connected to said means for computing K and to said means for computing deceleration time for computing overshoot according to the relationship Y=K/X so that the output of said means for computing overshoot is used for adjusting the torque set point via said control means to compensate for the computed value of torque overshoot.

17. A system according to claim 16, wherein said tool is fluid operated.

18. A method for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool wherein the tool is to be shut off at a target torque and is actually shut off at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) operating the tool to perform a fastening job;

(b) determining a relationship between torque rate in the fastening job to overshoot in the tool while the tool is performing the job;

(c) monitoring the torque rate in the job while the tool is setting the job;

(d) measuring deceleration time and torque overshoot during the job, said deceleration time being measured between selected fractional values of the target torque;

(e) adjusting the torque set point while the tool is setting the job to compensate for overshoot related to the torque rate according to said relationship between torque rate and overshoot;

(f) said relationship between torque rate in the fastening job to overshoot in the tool following the mathematical expression Y=K/X where Y is overshoot, X is deceleration time required to tighten the fastener and K is a constant which is determined by using the measured deceleration time and torque overshoot during a previous fastening job in said expression; and

(g) during a subsequent fastening job, measuring deceleration time between the same selected fractional values of target torque of a previous high torque-rate job, calculating overshoot from the foregoing mathematical expression using the previously determined value of K, and adjusting the torque set point to compensate for the calculated value of overshoot.

19. The method of claim 18, further including determining the value of K from job-to-job to perform an on-going averaging of K.

20. The method according to claim 19, wherein said tool is fluid operated.

21. The method according to claim 18, wherein said tool is electrically operated.

23. The method of claim 20, further including determining the value of K from job-to-job to perform an on-going averaging of K.

22. A method for compensating for torque overshoot in a rotary power tool wherein the tool is to be shut off at a target torque and is actually shut off at a torque set point equal to or less than the target torque depending upon the amount of torque overshoot, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) operating the tool to perform a fastening job;

(b) determining a relationship between torque rate in the fastening job to overshoot in the tool while the tool is performing the job;

(c) monitoring the torque rate in the job while the tool is setting the job;

(d) measuring deceleration angle and torque overshoot during the job, said deceleration angle being measured between selected fractional values of the target torque;

(e) adjusting the torque set pint while the tool is setting the job to compensate for overshoot related to the torque rate according to said relationship between torque rate and overshoot;

(f) said relationship between torque rate in the fastening job to overshoot in the tool following the mathematical expression Y=K/X where Y is overshoot, X is deceleration angle required to tighten the fastener and K is a constant which is determined by using the measured deceleration angle and torque overshoot during a previous fastening job in said expression; and

(g) during a subsequent fastening job, measuring deceleration angle between the same selected fractional values of target torque of a previous high torque-rate job, calculating overshoot from the foregoing mathematical expression using the previously determined value of K, and adjusting the torque set point to compensate for the calculated value of overshoot.