Determining fix confidence scores in direction finding systems

• US 5,389,936 A
• Filed: 06/24/1993
• Issued: 02/14/1995
• Est. Priority Date: 06/01/1990
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Racal Radar Defence Systems Limited (Racal Defence Electronics Limited)
• Original Assignee: Thorn EMI Electronics Limited (Universal Music Group NV)
• Inventors: Alcock, Robert N.
• Primary Examiner(s): Issing, Gregory C.
• Application Number:
  US07/952,747
• Time in Patent Office: 600 Days
• Field of Search: 342/417, 342/432, 342/445, 342/450, 342/463, 342/465, 342/451, 364/449
• US Class Current: 342/465
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 5/04 Position of source determined by a plurality of spaced direction-finders

Abstract

A method of analysing clusters of bearings (A, B, C, D) taken of distant sources by an array of direction finding stations. Each bearing has an error +E and a triangulation process is used to fix the position of the sources. A combination of bearings is taken one each from the stations. Each bearing of the combination is taken in turn as a spoke (3) directed at a source. The triangulation process generates a bar (31, 32, 33) of intersection points along the spoke for each other bearing of the combination, each bar corresponding to the error +E of each bearing. The number of overlaps between pairs of bars along a spoke is totalled to give a spoke score. The spoke scores of all spokes of the combination is summed to form a fix confidence score for a source which may be associated with the combination, or cluster, of bearings. Methods are also provided for rejecting redundant fixes associated with subsets of bearings within a cluster.

Claims

1. A method of determining a fix confidence score for each source of radiation detected by direction finding stations in known separated locations in a direction finding system, which stations each produce a set of bearings of the sources each detects, each bearing having an error predetermined for the associated station, and a triangulation process being used to fix the position of the sources, characterised in that there are at least three direction finding stations, in that each fix confidence score is formed for a combination of bearings taken one each from the respective stations, in that one bearing of each of the combinations is taken in turn as a spoke directed at a source, in that the triangulation process generates a bar of intersection points along the spoke for each other bearing of the combination, each bar corresponding to the error of each other bearing, in that the number of overlaps between pairs of bars along the spoke is totalled to give a spoke score, and in that the spoke scores for all spokes of the combination are summed to form the fix confidence score for a source which may be associated with the combination.

2. Triangulation processing apparatus for use in a direction finding system, the apparatus being characterised by having at least three inputs for connection to respective means for deriving bearing information, which information is subject to error, fix confidence scoring means for forming a fix confidence score for a combination of items of bearing information taken one from each of the inputs, said fix confidence scoring means being configured to treat one item of bearing information of each of the combinations as a spoke directed at a source of radiation and to generate a bar of intersection points along the spoke for each other item of bearing information of the combination, each bar corresponding to the magnitude of the error of each other item of bearing information, the fix confidence scoring means being further configured to total the number of overlaps between pairs of bars along the spoke to give a spoke score and to combine the spoke scores for all the spokes of the combination to form a fix confidence score for a source of radiation which may be associated with the combination.

3. An apparatus as claimed in claim 2, characterised in that the fix confidence scoring means is adapted to produce a fix confidence score for each of all possible combinations of items of bearing information taken one from each of the inputs and to produce a list of fix confidence scores for all possible fixes.

4. An apparatus as claimed in claim 3, characterised in that the apparatus has at least four inputs and in that the fix confidence scoring means is so configured that in a given combination of items of bearing information when one item is ignored and the remaining items still produce a fix confidence score greater than zero, that fix confidence score is retained in the list, but the fix confidence scores for all subsequent complete combinations encountered which contain the remaining items of bearing information are suppressed in the list.

5. An apparatus as claimed in claim 3, characterised in that the apparatus has at least four inputs, and in that the fix confidence scoring means is so configured that if in a given combination of items of bearing information each of the spokes has a spoke score greater than zero, then the fix confidence scores for all the combinations of items of bearing information produced by replacing any one item of the given combination by another item of the same set as the one replaced are suppressed in the list.

6. An apparatus as claimed in claim 5, characterised in that the fix confidence scoring means is configured so that if in a given combination of items of bearing information when one item is ignored and the remaining items still produce a fix confidence score greater than zero, that fix confidence score is retained in the list, but the fix confidence scores for all subsequent complete combinations encountered which contain the remaining bearings are suppressed in the list.

7. An apparatus as claimed in claim 2, characterised in that the triangulation processing means is adapted to select a non-zero score level below which any apparent fix is rejected as being spurious.

8. An apparatus as claimed in claim 2, characterised in that the fix confidence scoring means comprises calculating means including means for assigning to each bearing an error predetermined for the associated station, combining means for forming combinations of bearings taken one from each of the stations, analysing means for implementing a triangulation process in which one bearing of each of the combinations is taken as a spoke and a bar is generated for the intersection by each of the other bearings of the combination with the spoke, each bar corresponding to the distance between the lower and upper limits of the error predetermined for the respective station, means for totalling the number of overlaps between pairs of bars along the spoke to give a spoke score, and means for combining the spoke scores for all spokes of the combination to form a fix confidence score.

9. A direction finding system comprising at least three direction finding stations disposed at locations the positions of which are known and a triangulation processing apparatus having inputs coupled in use to respective ones of the direction finding stations, characterised in that the triangulation processing apparatus includes fix confidence scoring means for forming a fix confidence score for a combination of items of bearing information taken one from each of the inputs, said fix confidence scoring means being configured to treat one item of bearing information of each of the combinations as a spoke directed at a source of radiation and to generate a bar of intersection points along the spoke for each other item of bearing information of the combination, each bar corresponding to the magnitude of the error of each other item of bearing information, the fix confidence scoring means being further configured to total the number of overlaps between pairs of bars along the spoke to give a spoke score and to combine the spoke scores for all the spokes of the combination to form a fix confidence score for a source of radiation which may be associated with the combination.