Frequency agile sharing technology (FAST) for a personal communications service system

• US 5,410,737 A
• Filed: 04/27/1992
• Issued: 04/25/1995
• Est. Priority Date: 04/27/1992
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: American PCS Communications LLC (Deutsche Telekom AG)
• Original Assignee: American PCS LP (Deutsche Telekom AG)
• Inventors: Jones, J. Barclay
• Primary Examiner(s): Eisenzopf, Reinhard J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): SOBUTKA, PHILIP
• Application Number:
  US07/874,370
• Time in Patent Office: 1,093 Days
• Field of Search: 455/56.1, 455/33.1, 455/33.2, 455/33.4, 455/34.1, 455/50.1, 455/53.1, 455/54.1, 455/62, 455/63, 455/67.1, 455/67.3, 455/67.5, 379/59, 379/60
• US Class Current: 455/454
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 1/38 Transceivers, i.e. devices in which transmitter and receiver form a structural unit and in which at least one part is used for functions of transmitting and receiving
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 17/20 of receivers
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 17/24 with feedback of measurements to the transmitter
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 17/26 using historical data, averaging values or statistics
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 17/318 Received signal strength
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 17/373 Predicting channel quality or other radio frequency [RF] parameters
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 16/12 Fixed resource partitioning
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 16/14 Spectrum sharing arrangements between different networks
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 16/24 Cell structures
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 24/00 Supervisory, monitoring or testing arrangements
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 24/08 Testing, supervising or monitoring using real traffic
• CPC Class Codes: Y02D 30/70 in wireless communication networks

Abstract

A frequency agile sharing technology (FAST) system for controlling frequent usage in a communications system is disclosed. Specifically, a frequency agile sharing technology system of controlling frequency usage and eliminating interference for use with a Personal Communications Service (PCS) System is described. The frequency control system allows PCS systems to coexist in the same frequency band as Private Operational Fixed Microwave Service (POFS) systems without mutual interference. This system also controls frequency usage within a PCS system to eliminate interference from within the PCS system. This interference elimination system combines theoretical radio frequency interference analysis with measurements of actual frequency usage and allows for efficient and coordinated dynamic frequency allocation planning and management. To control frequency assignment and eliminate interference, the system employs several mechanisms including an intersystem interference analysis, an intrasystem interference analysis, a channel use verification (CUV) procedure, and a measured data analysis (MDA). These mechanisms are performed by a centralized controller, channel utilization controller (CUC), comprised of interference analysis/frequency planning computer programs with supporting data bases and data communication links. The system and method described allows for PCS frequency use around existing microwave users and can be readily adapted for use in any area and most efficiently make use of the available communications spectrum in that area. The system protects existing microwave users from interference while providing high quality PCS to subscribers utilizing small, low power and lightweight handsets in the same frequency band.

Claims

1. A personal communications system for providing a radio communication service in a dynamic communications environment in which communication transmissions from at least one other communications system occur, the personal communications system comprising:

at least one base station;

a plurality of subscriber units, at least some of which are mobile or portable;

a means for communicating between the base station and each of the subscriber units at radio frequencies; and

a centrally located processing means for controlling the frequency of transmissions used by the communicating means, linked electronically to each base station, the processing means comprising;

a means for calculating theoretical intersystem interference to determine which frequencies are used for the other communications transmissions and which frequencies are available for use by the base station and which frequencies are available for use by the plurality of subscriber units, wherein the theoretical calculation of intersystem interference predicts available frequencies to prevent unacceptable interference, the predictions based on calculations of interference caused by the base stations and the subscriber units on transmissions of the other communications systems and interference caused by the other communications systems on transmissions of the base .stations and the subscriber units;

a verification testing means for measuring signal strength of all frequencies being used by the other communication transmissions; and

a means for comparing the results of the theoretical intersystem interference test with the signal strengths determined by the verification test to determine frequencies available for use and accumulating the frequencies into an available channel list which is used to control the frequency of transmission of the base station whereby the system adapts to a changing RF environment and shares frequencies allocated to the other communications system within the same region through the provision of centralized control.

2. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the means for centrally controlling the transmission frequencies comprises means for assigning a first available frequency channel for communications from the base station to a subscriber unit and assigning a second available frequency channel for communications from the subscriber unit to the base station at a fixed frequency offset from the first frequency channel.

3. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the means for communicating further comprises means for multiplexing signals on a frequency channel.

4. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the frequency channels are in the 1850-1990 Mhz band.

5. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the frequency channels have bandwidths of less than 5 MHz.

6. The personal communications system as described in claim 1, further comprising:

a second base station;

means for switching transmissions between base stations; and

a communications link between the base stations and the means for switching transmissions.

7. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the means for communicating comprises means for assigning a first time slot for each transmission from the base station to a subscriber unit and assigning a second time slot for each transmission from subscriber units to the base station on the same frequency.

8. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 further comprising a means for partitioning a geographic area served by the personal communications system into a number of cells, each of which is served by at least one base station, whereby frequencies are reused in geographically separated cells.

9. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the base station comprises means for measuring the signal strength of communication transmissions.

10. The personal communications system of claim 1 wherein the plurality of subscriber units comprise means for using Code Division Multiple Access.

11. The personal communications system of claim 1 wherein each of the plurality of subscriber units comprises means for using Code Division Multiple Access in the range of 1.0 to 1.5 MHz.

12. The personal communications service of claim 1 wherein the subscriber units further comprise handsets of low power for communicating with the base station.

13. The personal communications service as described in claim 1 wherein the communications means comprises means for transferring voice signals between the base station and subscriber units.

14. The personal communications service as described in claim 1 wherein the communications means comprises means for transferring data signals between the base station and subscriber units.

15. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the means for centrally controlling the transmission frequencies comprises means for assigning a first available frequency channel for communications from the base station to a subscriber unit and assigning a second available frequency channel for communications from the subscriber unit to the base station at a variable frequency offset from the first frequency channel.

16. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the means for calculating theoretical intersystem interference comprises a means for selecting a set of grid points representative of possible positions of the subscriber units located around the base station whereby the means for calculating theoretical intersystem interference calculates predicted interference from other communication transmissions at the grid points surrounding the base station and predicted interference from the one or more subscriber units located at a grid point, and removes channels from the available channel list if the predicted interferences do not meet selected interference criteria.

17. The personal communications system as described in claim 16 wherein the means for selecting a set of grid points comprises a means for defining a set of critical grid points.

18. The personal communications system as described in claim 1 wherein the system comprises a plurality of base stations, each communicating to a plurality of subscribers and wherein the centrally located processing means further comprises a means for calculating theoretical intrasystem interference to determine which frequencies are currently being used by each base station and the plurality of subscriber units and which remaining frequencies are available for use by the personal communications system, wherein the available remaining frequencies are predicted based on calculations of interference caused by the base stations and the subscriber units on other base stations and subscriber units and the comparing means accumulates the frequencies available for use based on processing the results of the theoretical intersystem interference calculations, verification test signal strengths, and results of the theoretical intrasystem interference calculations into an available channel list which is used to control the frequency of transmission of each of the base stations.

19. The personal communications system as described in claim 18 wherein the means for centrally controlling the transmission frequencies further comprises an intrasystem verification testing means for measuring the signal strength of all frequencies being used by each of the base stations and plurality of subscriber units.

20. The personal communications system as described in claim 19 wherein the comparing means comprises means for accumulating the frequencies available for use based on the theoretical intersystem interference calculations, the verification test, the theoretical intrasystem interference calculations, and the intrasystem verification test into the available channel list which is used to control the frequency of transmission of each of the base stations.

21. The personal communications system as described in claim 18 wherein the means for calculating theoretical intrasystem interference comprises a means for selecting a set of grid points representative of possible positions of the subscriber units located around the base station whereby the means for calculating theoretical intrasystem interference calculates predicted interference from other base station transmissions at the grid points surrounding the base station and predicted interference from the one or more subscriber units located at the grid points, and removes channels from the available channel list if the predicted interferences do not meet selected interference criteria.

22. The personal communications system as described in claim 21 wherein the means for selecting a set of grid points comprises a means for defining a set of critical grid points.

23. The personal communications system as described in claims 1 or 18 wherein the available channel list is transmitted using the communications means from the base station to each of the subscriber units to control the frequency of transmission of each subscriber unit.

24. The personal communications service of claim 1 or 18 wherein the base station determines a channel pair for transmission between the base station and one of the subscriber units based on measured signal strengths of base station and subscriber unit receive channels in the available channel list, the base station comprising:

means for receiving the available channel list;

a first means for measuring the signal strength on each base station receive frequency channel in the available channel list at the base station;

a first means for ranking the base station receive frequency channel signal strengths by ascending signal strength;

means for transmitting the available channel list from the base station to the subscriber unit;

a second means for receiving the signal strength on each subscriber unit receive frequency channel in the available channel lists, wherein the signal strengths on each subscriber unit receive frequency channel are measured at the subscriber unit;

means for obtaining an initiation request message from the subscriber unit;

second means for ranking each of the subscriber unit receive frequency channel signal strengths by ascending signal strength;

means for combining the base station receive frequency channel rank with the subscriber unit receive frequency rank to obtain a composite rank for every channel;

means for selecting the channel pair with a lowest combined rank; and

means for notifying the subscriber unit of the selected channel pair for the call.

25. The personal communications system as described in claims 1 or 18 wherein the communications means comprises control channels and communications traffic channels.

26. The personal communications system as described in claim 25 wherein the available channel list is sent from the base station to each subscriber unit on a control channel.

27. A method of assigning variable radio frequencies, in a personal communications system, to a plurality of base stations and subscriber units including fixed, portable and mobile subscriber units without interfering with other radio frequency transmissions from at least one other communications system occurring at fixed frequencies and between fixed sites in essentially the same frequency spectrum, comprising:

creating technical databases comprising information pertaining to the characteristics of the personal communications system base station and subscriber unit transmissions, and to the other radio frequency transmissions;

predicting intersystem interference indicating which frequency transmissions could cause intersystem interference between the base station and subscriber units and the other communications systems utilizing a predetermined set of representative subscriber unit locations which represent possible positions of subscriber locations;

predicting intrasystem interference indicating which frequency transmissions could cause intrasystem interference between the base stations and subscriber units utilizing the set of representative subscriber unit locations;

measuring signal strength in selected frequency channels;

comparing the intersystem and intrasystem interference results with the measured signal strengths; and

creating an available channel list at a central controller for each base station listing available frequency channels for use by the base station and the associated subscriber units which will not interfere with the other base stations, other subscriber units transmitting to and from other base stations and transmissions to and from the other radio frequency communications systems, whereby the system can adapt to a changing RF environment and share frequencies allocated to the other communications system within the same region through the provision of centralized control.

28. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of predicting intersystem interference comprises the step of determining interference to the other radio frequency transmissions occurring at fixed frequencies from transmissions by the base station and subscriber units.

29. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of predicting intersystem interference comprises the step of determining interference to base station and subscriber unit transmissions from the other radio frequency transmissions occurring at fixed frequencies.

30. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of predicting intrasystem interference comprises the step of determining interference to base station transmissions received at each subscriber unit from transmissions from other base stations.

31. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of predicting intrasystem interference comprises the step of determining interference to subscriber unit transmissions received at the base station from other subscriber units.

32. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of measuring signal strength in selected frequency channels includes the step of measuring the signal strength of selected base station and subscriber unit transmissions.

33. The method of claim 27 wherein the method further comprises the steps of:

measuring the signal strength on each available receive channel on the available channel list at both the base station and any subscriber unit prior to a transmission by the subscriber unit; and

choosing a best available channel pair for transmissions.

34. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of predicting intrasystem interference comprises the step of determining interference to base station transmissions received at each subscriber unit located at a representative subscriber unit location from the transmissions from other subscriber units located at other representative subscriber unit locations.

35. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of measuring signal strength in selected frequency channels includes the step of measuring the signal strength of the other radio frequency transmissions occurring at fixed frequencies between fixed sites.

36. The method of claim 35 wherein the step of measuring signal strength is performed at the location of the base station.

37. The method of claim 32 wherein the step of measuring signal strength is performed at the location of the base station.

38. The method of claim 37 wherein the method further comprises the step of comparing calculated interference with the measured signal strength to verify theoretical interference predictions between base stations and the other radio frequency transmissions occurring at fixed frequencies between fixed sites.

39. The method of claim 27 wherein the step of measuring signal strength in selected frequency channels includes the step of transporting a mobile sensing unit to make measurements at locations different than the location of the base station.

40. The method of claim 39 wherein the method further comprises the step of comparing calculated interference with the measured signal strength to verify theoretical interference predictions between subscriber units and the other radio frequency transmissions occurring at fixed frequencies and between fixed sites.

41. A personal communications system for providing a high capacity portable radio communication service in a frequency spectrum with frequency channels where other radio frequency transmissions from at least one other communications system occur, comprising:

a plurality of subscriber units each having means for transmitting and receiving communications signals;

a plurality of base stations, each base station comprising at least one base transmitter and base receiver; and

a means for centrally controlling the frequency channels used by the subscriber units and the base stations, comprising;

means for calculating theoretical performance characteristics of the other radio frequency transmissions and the transmissions from the base stations and the subscriber units, comprising means for predicting interference by the other radio frequency transmissions on transmissions to and from the base stations and representative subscriber units and interference by the base stations and representative subscriber units on the other radio frequency transmissions;

means for storing the theoretical performance characteristics of the other radio frequency transmissions and the transmissions from the base stations and the subscriber units;

means for collecting actual performance characteristics of the other radio frequency transmissions and the transmissions from the base stations and the subscriber units;

means for storing the collected actual performance characteristics of the other radio frequency transmissions and the transmissions from the base stations and the subscriber units; and

processing means for determining possible intersystem and intrasystem interference based on the stored theoretical and the stored actual performance characteristics to determine which of the frequency channels are available frequency channels for use by the subscriber units and the base stations whereby the system adapts to a changing RF environment and shares frequencies allocated to the other communications system within the same region through the provision of centralized control.

42. The personal communications system as described in claim 41 further comprising a mobile communications unit for sensing actual performance characteristics and sending the actual performance characteristics to the controlling means.

43. The personal communications system as described in claim 42 wherein the mobile communications unit comprises:

an omnidirectional antenna; and

means for receiving attached to the omnidirectional antenna.

44. The personal communications system as described in claim 42 wherein the mobile communications unit comprises:

a highly directional antenna; and

means for receiving attached to the highly directional antenna.

45. A method for determining available frequency channels for use in an adaptable centrally controlled personal communications system having a plurality of base stations and subscriber units, each of the frequency channels being in a changing RF environment where the frequency spectrum is also used by other fixed site stations, the steps comprising:

entering information about the other fixed site stations;

entering information about the personal communications system base stations;

selecting intersystem interference test thresholds;

predicting interference at base stations and other fixed site stations by determining theoretical signal strengths based on entered information;

generating an available frequency channel list based on predicted interference results wherein cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies are excluded from the list if predicted signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds;

choosing a set of grid points representative of subscriber units located around each base station location;

predicting interference at subscriber unit grid points based on other fixed site theoretical signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if other fixed site theoretical signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at other fixed site stations based on theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds;

selecting intrasystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at subscriber unit grid points based on theoretical undesired base station signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical undesired base stations signal strengths exceed predetermined intrasystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at desired base station based on theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths exceed predetermined intrasystem interference thresholds; and

storing the completed available frequency channel list in data storage at a central controller.

46. The method for determining available frequency channels as described in claim 45, further comprising:

selecting channel use verification thresholds;

measuring actual signal strengths in each personal communications system and other fixed site frequency channel;

comparing the measured actual signal strengths against theoretical predicted interference determined in the intrasystem and intersystem test to determine if measured actual signal strengths are at a predetermined threshold above or below the theoretical predicted interference;

updating the available frequency channel list by excluding frequency channels when measured actual signal strengths exceed threshold;

storing the updated available frequency channel list in data storage at a central controller; and

downloading the frequency channel list from the central controller to the plurality of base stations.

47. The method of claim 46 wherein the step of updating the available frequency list includes the step of adding frequency channels where measured actual signal strengths are below threshold.

48. A centralized control system in a personal communications system, the personal communications system containing a plurality of subscriber units, communications links, a central controller, and a base station for controlling the frequency usage and allocating frequency channel assignments based on theoretical and actual interference analysis in a shared frequency spectrum environment where personal communications system transmissions share frequencies used in common with private operational fixed site station transmissions from at least one other communications system within the same region, the centralized control system comprising:

a first means for storing private operational fixed site station information;

a means for selecting a set of grid points, the grid points representing possible positions of subscriber units located around a base station location;

a second means for storing personal communications system base station and subscriber unit information;

means for determining, connected to the first and second storage means, frequency channels which meet acceptable interference criteria and are thereby available for the base station to establish communications links to subscriber units, comprising;

means for simulating propagation performance of transmissions from the base station, the plurality of subscriber units and the private operational fixed site station;

a means for calculating intersystem interference to determine, from the selected grid points, the information stored in the first and second storage means and the simulated propagation performance, available frequency channels for the base station and subscriber unit transmissions which do not unreasonably interfere with and do not receive unreasonable interference from the private operational fixed site station transmissions, wherein the intersystem interference calculating means utilizes the selecting means to calculate predicted interference to and from the subscriber units;

a means for calculating intrasystem interference to determine, from the selected grid points, the information stored in the first and second storage means and the simulated propagation performance, available frequency channels for the base station and subscriber unit transmissions which do not unreasonably interfere with and do not receive unreasonable interference from other base station and subscriber unit transmissions, whereby the intrasystem interference calculating means utilizes the selecting means to calculate predicted interference to and from the subscriber units; and

a means for accumulating the available frequencies into an available frequency channel list whereby the personnel communications system adapts to a changing RF environment and shares frequencies allocated to the other communications system within the same region through the provision of centralized control.

49. A mobile communications unit in a personal communications system having a plurality of base stations, subscriber units and a central controller, for measuring signal strengths in a communications environment in which other communications transmissions from at least one other communications system share a common frequency spectrum, the mobile communications unit comprising:

input means for capturing satellite based position information at various grid point locations located around the base station location;

means, connected to the input means, for storing the position information;

a means for receiving communications transmissions from base stations, subscriber units and other communications transmissions;

a means for measuring, connected to the receiving means, the signal strengths of communications transmissions from base stations, subscriber units and other communications systems at the various grid point locations;

means for storing the signal strengths of communications transmissions; and

means for transmitting the stored position information and stored signal strengths of the communications transmissions to a central controller for verifying theoretical interference performance predictions with the measured signal strengths whereby the personnel communications system adapts to a changing RF environment and shares frequencies allocated to the other communications system within the same region through the provision of centralized control.

50. A method for determining available frequency channels for use in a personal communications system having a plurality of base stations and subscriber units, each of the frequency channels being in a frequency spectrum used by other fixed site stations, the steps comprising:

entering information about the other fixed site stations;

entering information about the personal communications system base stations;

selecting intersystem interference test thresholds;

predicting interference at base stations and other fixed site stations by determining theoretical signal strengths based on entered information;

generating an available frequency channel list based on predicted interference results wherein cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies are excluded from the list if predicted signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds;

choosing a set of grid points representative of subscriber units located around each base station location;

predicting interference at subscriber unit grid points based on other fixed site theoretical signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if other fixed site theoretical signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at other fixed site stations based on theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths; and

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths exceed predetermined intersystem interference thresholds.

51. A method for determining available frequency channels for use in a personal communications system having a plurality of base stations, a central controller and subscriber units, each of the frequency channels being in a frequency spectrum used by other fixed site stations, the steps comprising:

entering information about the personal communications system base stations;

selecting intrasystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at subscriber unit grid points based on theoretical undesired base station signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical undesired base stations signal strengths exceed predetermined intrasystem interference thresholds;

predicting interference at desired base station based on theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths;

excluding cochannel and adjacent channel frequencies from the available frequency channel list if theoretical subscriber unit signal strengths exceed predetermined intrasystem interference thresholds; and

storing the completed available frequency channel list in data storage at a central controller.