Diagnostic vehicle alignment system

• US 5,442,549 A
• Filed: 06/08/1993
• Issued: 08/15/1995
• Est. Priority Date: 06/08/1993
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Hunter Engineering Company
• Original Assignee: Hunter Engineering Company
• Inventors: Larson, Timothy A.
• Primary Examiner(s): Teska, Kevin J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): NGUYEN, TAN QUANG
• Application Number:
  US08/073,185
• Time in Patent Office: 798 Days
• Field of Search: 364/424.01, 364/424.03, 364/424.04, 364/551.01, 364/559, 364/188, 364/562, 33/203.18, 33/286, 33/288, 356/155, 395/54, 395/60, 395/77, 395/161, 395/162, 371/16.1, 371/21.2, 371/24, 371/27, 371/11.3
• US Class Current: 701/35
• CPC Class Codes: G01R 31/31912 Tester/user interface
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/2257 using expert systems

Abstract

A diagnostic vehicle alignment system includes an electronic controller for guiding a user through a series of diagnostic steps to determine probable causes for particular vehicle symptoms. Vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments determine the alignment of at least one wheel of the vehicle. An input device is manually operable by a user for providing symptom identification and answers to diagnostic questions. A digital memory stores a set of possible causes for each selectable symptom and also stores diagnostic questions and an identification of diagnostic procedures. The stored diagnostic questions and procedures are preselected to eliminate possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration. A display is provided for displaying diagnostic questions and procedures to the user. The electronic controller is responsive to the selection of a particular symptom to cause the display to display diagnostic questions associated with that symptom to the user as well as the display of instructions to the user to perform diagnostic procedures, and the user uses the input device to interactively supply answers to the diagnostic questions and diagnostic procedure results to the electronic controller. The electronic controller is responsive to user provided input and to information from the vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments to eliminate at least one possible cause of a symptom from consideration and identify any remaining possible causes of the symptom.

Claims

1. A vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system comprising:

an electronic controller for guiding a user through a series of diagnostic steps to determine likely causes for at least one predetermined vehicle symptom;

vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments for determining wheel alignment data for at least one wheel of said vehicle;

an input device manually operable by a user for providing input from the user to the electronic controller, said input ,device being operable by the user to identify at least one particular symptom which the user desires to diagnose;

a digital memory for storing a a plurality of likely causes for each of a predetermined number of selectable symptoms;

a display operatively connected to the electronic controller for displaying diagnostic questions to the user, said electronic controller being responsive to the selection of a particular symptom to cause the display to display at least one diagnostic question associated with that symptom to the user, said input device being operable by the user to supply an answer to the diagnostic question to the electronic controller, said electronic controller being responsive to user provided input in response to at least one diagnostic question, to the likely causes stored in the digital memory, and to data from the vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments to eliminate at least one likely cause of a symptom from consideration and identify any remaining likely causes of the symptom.

2. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein identifying information for a plurality of predetermined diagnostic procedures is stored therein, said electronic controller including means to cause the display of identifying information to the user to perform one of the a diagnostic procedure procedures, the particular identified diagnostic procedure being selected by the electronic controller to assist in the elimination of at least one likely cause of the selected symptom.

3. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 2 wherein the identified diagnostic procedure is selected by the electronic controller to maximize the elimination of possible causes of the selected symptom.

4. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 2 wherein each diagnostic procedure has at least one possible result, the electronic controller being responsive to the result of the selected diagnostic procedure to eliminate possible causes of the symptom from consideration.

5. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller is programmed such that said controller causes the display of the least possible number of diagnostic questions to the user consistent with the particular answers to the diagnostic questions supplied by the user.

6. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller is under programmed control such that in response to answers to at least one diagnostic question the controller causes the display of an additional diagnostic question preselected to maximize the elimination of probable causes of the selected symptom from consideration.

7. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to a predetermined user input from the input device to cause the display of a diagnosis report for use by the user.

8. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 7 wherein the diagnosis report includes a list of all known facts concerning the diagnosis.

9. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 7 wherein the diagnosis report includes a list of possible causes of the selected symptom, said possible causes excluding those possible causes inconsistent with user supplied answers to diagnostic questions.

10. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 9 wherein the list of possible causes is displayed in order of probability of being the actual cause.

11. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 7 wherein the diagnosis report is automatically displayed when the electronic controller reaches a diagnosis of the selected symptom.

12. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller includes a diagnostic mode and at least a second mode other than the diagnostic mode, and wherein the digital memory includes means for storing answers to diagnostic questions supplied by the user while the electronic controller is in the diagnostic mode for use during the second mode of the electronic controller.

13. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 12 wherein the electronic controller includes means for accessing the stored answers to diagnostic questions upon a return to the diagnostic mode.

14. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 12 wherein the vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments acquire said alignment data in the second mode, said electronic controller being responsive to the alignment to include said measured alignment data in diagnosing the selected symptom.

15. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 14 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to exiting from the diagnostic mode to utilize new measurements of measured alignment information upon reentry into the diagnostic mode.

16. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 14 wherein the electronic controller is under programmed control to acquire measured alignment information directly and automatically from the measuring instruments.

17. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 16 wherein during use of measured alignment information from the vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments, the electronic controller causes the display to inform the user of the use of said measured alignment information.

18. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 14 wherein the electronic controller causes the measured alignment information values used in the diagnosis to be displayed to the user.

19. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 14 wherein the input device includes manually operable means for modifying the measured alignment data values used in the diagnosis.

20. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the digital memory includes means for storing database information concerning vehicle alignment specifications, models and makes, said electronic controller being responsive to said stored database information to select particular diagnostic questions to display to the user and to eliminate possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration based upon the stored database information.

21. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller includes a diagnostic mode and at least an inspection mode, said electronic controller being responsive to entry into the diagnostic mode to use information acquired in the inspection mode in eliminating possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration.

22. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller has associated with at least one symptom a definition of that symptom, the electronic controller being responsive to the selection of that symptom to cause the display of the definition of the selected symptom.

23. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein at least one of the selectable symptoms has a visual representation thereof associated therewith, the electronic:

controller being responsive to the selection of a selectable symptom having a visual representation associated therewith to cause the display of said visual representation on the display.

24. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 23 wherein at least one of the visual representations includes a plurality of said representations from which the user can select, the input device being usable by the user to select from the plurality of visual representations the one visual representation most closely approximating the symptom of the vehicle under test.

25. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 further including a printer under control of the electronic controller, the electronic controller being responsive to a request from the user via the input device to cause the printer to print a checklist of items to be examined on the vehicle corresponding to the selected symptom.

26. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein at least one of the diagnostic questions has associated therewith at least one visual image, said electronic controller causing the display of those visual images corresponding to a displayed diagnostic question, further includes means for highlighting at least some portion of said visual image.

27. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 26 wherein at least one of the visual images is a digitized photograph.

28. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the input device includes means for requesting a restart of a diagnosis, the electronic controller being responsive to the request for a restart of a diagnosis to eliminate from consideration answers to diagnostic questions already supplied before the restart request and to cause the display of at least one of the previously asked diagnostic questions.

29. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to the elimination of all stored possible causes for a selected symptom to cause the display of the cause as unknown to the user.

30. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 further including means for storing measured alignment information for the vehicle under test, the electronic controller being responsive to the values of the stored measured alignment information and to the answers to diagnostic questions to generate a diagnosis of the selected symptom.

31. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 1 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to the subsequent selection of a second symptom by the user to eliminate from consideration the answers to diagnostic questions for the first selected symptom, whereby if any diagnostic question for the second symptom is identical to an answered diagnostic question for the first symptom, the electronic controller will cause the re-display of said diagnostic question to obtain a new answer thereto from the user.

32. A method of diagnosing predetermined vehicle symptoms, said method comprising:

prestoring in a digital memory a knowledge base of information with respect to diagnosing vehicle symptoms, said knowledge base electronically utilizable to diagnose likely causes of vehicle symptoms;

measuring alignment angles of the wheels of a vehicle using vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments;

selecting at least one of said predetermined vehicle symptoms to be diagnosed;

visually displaying to a user at least one of a plurality of predetermined diagnostic questions to be answered by the user;

electronically utilizing the answers supplied by the user and the wheel alignment measurements from the measuring instruments to eliminate from consideration at least one likely cause of a selected symptom to be diagnosed and identify any remaining likely causes of the symptom.

33. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 further including the step of visually instructing the user to perform a diagnostic procedure, the particular identified diagnostic procedure being selected to assist in the elimination of possible causes of the selected symptom.

34. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 33 wherein the visually identified diagnostic procedure is selected to maximize the elimination of possible causes of the selected symptom.

35. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 wherein a minimum number of diagnostic questions are displayed to the user consistent with the particular answers to the diagnostic questions supplied by the user.

36. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 wherein, in response to a particular set of answers to a series of diagnostic questions, an additional diagnostic question preselected to maximize the elimination of probable causes of the selected symptom from consideration is displayed.

37. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 including displaying a list of possible causes of the selected symptom in order of probability of being the actual cause.

38. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 wherein during acquisition of measured alignment information from the vehicle wheel alignment measuring instruments, the user is visually informed of the acquisition of said measured alignment information.

39. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 38 including manually modifying the measured alignment information values used in the diagnosis.

40. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 including prestoring database information concerning vehicle alignment specifications, models and makes, and selecting particular diagnostic questions to display to the user and to eliminate possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration based upon the stored database information.

41. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 wherein at least one of the selectable symptoms has a visual representation thereof associated therewith, further including, in response to the selection of a selectable symptom having a visual representation associated therewith, the step of displaying said visual representation.

42. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 41 wherein at least one of the visual representations includes a plurality of said representations from which the user can select, further including the step of manually selecting from the plurality of displayed visual representations the one visual representation most closely approximating the symptom of the vehicle under test.

43. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 32 further including storing measured alignment information for the vehicle under test, and, in response to the values of the stored measured alignment information and to the answers to diagnostic questions, generating a diagnosis of the selected symptom.

44. A vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system comprising:

an electronic controller for guiding a user through a series of diagnostic steps to determine likely causes for at least one predetermined vehicle symptom;

an input device manually operable by a user for providing at least one of a plurality of predetermined inputs from the user to the electronic controller, said input device being operable by the user to identify at least one symptom which the user desires to diagnose;

a digital memory for storing a set of at least one likely cause for each selectable symptom;

a display operatively connected to the electronic controller for displaying diagnostic questions and instructions to perform diagnostic procedures to the user; and

means for storing identification of at least one diagnostic procedure, said electronic controller including means to cause the display of an instruction to the user to perform a diagnostic procedure;

said electronic controller being responsive to the selection of a predetermined symptom to cause the display to display at least one diagnostic question associated with that symptom to the user, said input device being operable by the user to supply an answer to the diagnostic question to the electronic controller;

said electronic controller being responsive to user provided input in response to at least one diagnostic question and to the result of the identified diagnostic procedure to eliminate at least one likely cause of the selected symptom from consideration and identify any remaining likely causes of the symptom.

45. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the identified diagnostic procedure is selected by the electronic controller to maximize the elimination of possible causes of the selected symptom.

46. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to a particular user input to cause the display of a diagnosis report for use by the user, said diagnosis report including a list of possible causes of the selected symptom, said possible causes excluding those inconsistent with user supplied answers to diagnostic questions and with the result of the user performed diagnostic procedure.

47. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the digital memory includes means for storing database information concerning vehicle alignment specifications, models and makes, said electronic controller being responsive to said stored database information to select particular diagnostic questions and diagnostic procedures to display to the user and to eliminate possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration based upon the stored database information.

48. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the electronic controller includes a diagnostic mode and at least an inspection mode, said electronic controller being responsive to entry into the diagnostic mode to use information acquired in the inspection mode in eliminating possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration.

49. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 further including a printer under control of the electronic controller, the electronic controller being responsive to a request from the user via the input device to cause the printer to print a checklist of items to be examined on the vehicle corresponding to the selected symptom.

50. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the input device includes means for requesting a restart of a diagnosis, the electronic controller being responsive to the request for a restart of a diagnosis to eliminate from consideration answers to diagnostic questions and results of diagnostic procedures already supplied before the restart request and to cause the display of at least some of the previously asked diagnostic questions.

51. The vehicle wheel alignment diagnostic system as set forth in claim 44 wherein the electronic controller is responsive to the subsequent selection of a second symptom by the user to eliminate from consideration the results of diagnostic procedures for the first selected symptom, whereby if any diagnostic procedure for the second symptom is identical to a diagnostic procedure for the first symptom, the electronic controller will cause the re-display of instructions to perform the diagnostic procedure to obtain a new result therefor from the user.

52. A method of diagnosing predetermined vehicle symptoms, said method comprising:

prestoring in a digital memory a knowledge base of information with respect to diagnosing said predetermined vehicle symptoms, said knowledge base being electronically utilizable to diagnose likely causes of vehicle symptoms;

selecting at least one of said predetermined vehicle symptoms to be diagnosed;

visually displaying to a user a series of diagnostic questions to be answered by the user and instructions to perform at least one diagnostic procedure;

electronically utilizing the answers and the result of the diagnostic procedure supplied by the user to eliminate from consideration at least one likely cause of the selected symptom to be diagnosed and identify remaining likely causes of the symptom.

53. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 52 wherein the visually identified diagnostic procedure is selected to maximize the elimination of possible causes of the selected symptom.

54. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 52 wherein a minimum number of diagnostic questions and diagnostic procedure instructions are displayed to the user consistent with the particular answers to the diagnostic questions and particular results of the diagnostic procedures supplied by the user.

55. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 52 including prestoring database information concerning vehicle alignment specifications, models and makes, and selecting a particular diagnostic procedure to perform to eliminate possible causes of the selected symptom from consideration based upon the stored database information.

56. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 52 wherein at least one of the selectable symptoms has a visual representation thereof associated therewith, further including, in response to the selection of a selectable symptom having a visual representation associated therewith, the step of displaying said visual representation.

57. The method of diagnosing vehicle symptoms as set forth in claim 56 wherein at least some of the visual representations include a plurality of said representations from which the user can select, further including the step of manually selecting from the plurality of displayed visual representations the one visual representation most closely approximating the symptom of the vehicle under test.