Method and apparatus for merging change control delta structure files of a source module from a parent and a child development environment

• US 5,481,722 A
• Filed: 11/14/1994
• Issued: 01/02/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 08/19/1991
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Sun Microsystems Incorporated (Oracle Corporation)
• Original Assignee: Sun Microsystems Incorporated (Oracle Corporation)
• Inventors: Skinner, Glenn
• Primary Examiner(s): Kriess, Kevin A.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Richey, Michael T.
• Application Number:
  US08/338,883
• Time in Patent Office: 414 Days
• Field of Search: 395/650, 395/700
• US Class Current: 717/122
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 8/71 Version control security arrangements therefor G06F21/57; Configuration management

Abstract

A source module and its changes in a parent and a child development environment of an hierarchy of development environments are created as a first and a second delta structure in their respective environments. Various procedures and working tables/files are provided to merge the second delta structure into the first delta structure whenever the latest revision of the source module in the parent environment is reconciled to the latest edition of the source module in the child environment, and to merge the first delta structure into the second delta structure whenever the latest edition of the source module in the child environment is resynchronized to the latest revision of the source module in the parent environment. As a result, as the process is repeated by other parent and child environments of the hierarchy, change deltas are created and propagated among the environments without any loss in change history.

Claims

1. In a computer system comprising a parent and a child development environment, said parent and child environments having a first and a second delta hierarchy representing a source module and changes to said source module individually known to said parent and child environments respectively, a method for merging said first and second delta hierarchies together that preserves all delta relationships of said changes individually known to said parent and child environments without the need for computer assisted tracking, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) storing deltas in a first and a second list of deltas and storing descriptive entries corresponding to said deltas in a first and second table of descriptive entries of said first and second delta hierarchies;

(b) initializing a first and a second work list and a first and a second work table to equal said first and second list of deltas and first and said second table of descriptive entries of said first and second delta hierarchies respectively, said first and second lists of deltas being chronologically identified within a first and a second development environments in identical manners, and said first and second table of descriptive entries being time ordered and correspondingly describing said first and second lists of deltas respectively;

(c) initializing an output table, an output list, a first and a second two way associative array corresponding to said first and second work tables to empty, for sequentially receiving modified non-duplicate descriptive entries of said first and second work tables, modified non-duplicate deltas of said first and second lists of deltas, and cross reference entries cross referencing descriptive entries of said first and second work tables and said output table to each other;

(d) retrieving descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas from said first and second work tables and said first and second work lists, outputting a two way cross reference entry to the corresponding one of said first and second two way associative arrays for each descriptive entry which has been retrieved, as the descriptive entry and its corresponding delta are retrieved, cross referencing said descriptive entry which has been retrieved to the next descriptive entry of said output table, said step of retrieving being performed one descriptive entry and its corresponding delta at a time, in a predetermined least recent entry manner, until all descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas have been retrieved from said first and second work tables and said first and second work deltas;

(e) discarding each descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta, as its two way cross reference entry is output, if the descriptive entry which has been retrieved is a duplicate of a second descriptive entry which has been retrieved in the other work table;

(f) modifying each said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta not discarded, after its discard or not discard determination is made, outputting each of said descriptive entries which have been retrieved and modified and its corresponding modified delta into said output table and said output list respectively, as the modifications are made, said step of modifying being performed in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created in the merged hierarchy for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded, and the number of descriptive entries which have been retrieved having been output to the output table so far, and furthermore utilizing said cross reference entries.

2. The method as set forth in claim 1, wherein, said step (d) comprises the steps off

(d .1) retrieving the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if said first work table is empty;

(d .2) retrieving the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if said second work table is empty;

(d .3) retrieving the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are duplicates; and

(d .4) retrieving the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are not duplicates.

3. The method as set forth in claim 2, wherein said step (f) further comprises the step of creating a new branch for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been removed and not discarded in said step (f) if said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded was retrieved from said second work table, and said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded has a predecessor descriptive entry in said second work table cross referencing a descriptive entry in said output table, which cross references a descriptive entry in said first work table, and if said cross referenced descriptive entry in said first work table is a predecessor descriptive entry to another descriptive entry in said first work table, which is on the same branch said descriptive entry which has been removed and not discarded is on.

4. The method as set forth in claim 3, wherein, said step (f) comprises the steps off

((f) .1) replacing an existing change identifier in said descriptive entry not discarded with a new change identifier, said existing and new change identifiers indicating revision/edition levels of said source module in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said new change identifier being generated in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created for the corresponding delta of said descriptive entry in the merged hierarchy;

((f) .2) replacing a first existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry not discarded with a first new unique delta serial number, said first existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said first new unique delta serial number being generated in accordance to the number of descriptive entries having been output to said output table so far;

((f) .3) replacing a second existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry not discarded with a second new unique delta serial number, said second existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta'"'"'s predecessor delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said second new unique delta serial number being retrieved from the corresponding one of said first and second two way cross reference arrays, said second new unique delta serial number being equal to the first new unique delta number of the cross referenced descriptive entry of said output table, whose first existing delta serial number of the cross referencing descriptive entry of said first and second work tables equals said second existing delta serial number.

5. The method as set forth in claim 4 further comprises the steps of:

merging said second delta hierarchy into said first delta hierarchy to reconcile the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment to the latest edition of said source module in said child environment; and

replacing said first delta hierarchy in said parent environment with said output table.

6. The method as set forth in claim 5, further comprising the steps of:

merging said first delta hierarchy into said second delta hierarchy to resynchronize the latest edition of said source module in said child environment of the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment; and

replacing said second delta hierarchy in said child environment with said output table instead.

7. The method as set forth in claim 6 further comprises the step of automatically triggering said performance of said steps (a) through (f) to merge said first delta hierarchy into said second delta hierarchy to resynchronize the latest edition of said source module in said child environment of the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment in response to an attempt to perform said steps (a) through (f) to merge said second delta hierarchy into said first delta hierarchy to reconcile the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment to the latest edition of said source module in said child environment, and said second delta hierarchy was originally created using said first delta hierarchy, which has subsequently changed.

8. In a computer system comprising a parent and a child development environment, said parent and child environments having a first and a second delta hierarchy representing a source module and changes to said source module individually known to said parent and child environments respectively, an apparatus for merging said first and second delta hierarchies together that preserves all delta relationships of said changes individually known to said parent and child environments without the need for computer assisted tracking, said apparatus comprising:

(a) storage means for storing deltas in a first and a second list of deltas and storing descriptive entries corresponding to said deltas in a first and second table of descriptive entries of said first and second delta hierarchies;

(b) first initialization means coupled to said parent and child environments for initializing a first and a second work list and a first and a second work table to equal a first and a second list of deltas and a first and a second table of descriptive entries of said first and second delta hierarchies respectively, said first and second lists of deltas being chronologically identified within a first and second development environments in identical manners, and said first and second table of descriptive entries being time ordered and correspondingly describing said first and second lists of deltas respectively;

(c) second initialization means for initializing an output table, an output list, a first and a second two way associative array corresponding to said first and second work tables to empty, for sequentially receiving modified non-duplicate descriptive entries of said first and second work tables, modified non-duplicate deltas of said first and second lists of deltas, and cross reference entries cross referencing descriptive entries of said first and second work tables and said output table to each other;

(d) retrieval means coupled to said first initialization means for retrieving descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas from said first and second work tables and said first and second work lists, and first output means coupled to said removal means and said second initialization means for outputting a two way cross reference entry to the corresponding one of said first and second two way associative arrays for each descriptive entry which has been retrieved, as the descriptive entry and its corresponding delta are retrieved, cross referencing said descriptive entry which has been retrieved to the next descriptive entry of said output table, said step of retrieving being performed one descriptive entry and its corresponding delta at a time, in a predetermined least recent entry manner, until all descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas have been retrieved from said first and second work tables and said first and second work deltas;

(e) discard means coupled to said first output means for discarding each descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta, as its two way cross reference entry is output, if the descriptive entry which has been retrieved is a duplicate of a second descriptive entry which has been retrieved in the other work table;

(f) modification means coupled to said discard means for modifying each said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta not discarded, after its discard or not discard determination is made, outputting each of said descriptive entries which have been retrieved and modified and its corresponding modified delta into said output table and said output list respectively, as the modifications are made, said step of modifying being performed in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created in the merged hierarchy for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded, and the number of descriptive entries which have been retrieved having been output to the output table so far, and furthermore utilizing said cross reference entries.

9. The apparatus as set forth in claim 8, wherein, said retrieval means retrieves

(d. 1) the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if said first work table is empty;

(d.

     2) the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if said second work table is empty;

(d.

     3) the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are duplicates; and

(d.

     4) the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are not duplicates.

10. The apparatus as set forth in claim 9, wherein, said modification means further comprises means for determining that a new branch is to be created for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been retrieved not discarded if said descriptive entry which has been retrieved not discarded was removed from said second work table, and said descriptive entry which has been retrieved not discarded has a predecessor descriptive entry in said second work table cross referencing a descriptive entry in said output table, which cross references a descriptive entry in said rust work table, furthermore, said cross referenced descriptive entry in said first work table is a predecessor descriptive entry to another descriptive entry in said first work table, which is on the same branch said descriptive entry not discarded is on.

11. The apparatus as set forth in claim 10, wherein, said modification means replaces:

(h.

     1) an existing change identifier in said descriptive entry not discarded with a new change identifier, said existing and new change identifiers indicating revision/edition levels of said source module in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said new change identifier being generated in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created for the corresponding delta of said descriptive entry not discarded in the merged hierarchy;

(h.

     2) a first existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry with a first new unique delta serial number, said first existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said first new unique delta serial number being generated in accordance to the number of descriptive entries having been output to said output table so far;

(h.

     3) a second existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry with a second new unique delta serial number, said second existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta'"'"'s predecessor delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said second new unique delta serial number being retrieved from the corresponding one of said first and second two way cross reference arrays, said second new unique delta serial number being equal to the first new unique delta number of the cross referenced descriptive entry of said output table, whose first existing delta serial number of the cross referencing descriptive entry of said first and second work tables equals said second existing delta serial number.

12. The apparatus as set forth in claim 11, further comprising:

merging means for merging said second delta hierarchy into said first delta hierarchy to reconcile the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment to the latest edition of said source module in said child environment; and

replacement means coupled to said parent environment and said second output means for replacing said first delta hierarchy in said parent environment with said output table.

13. The apparatus as set forth in claim 12 further comprising:

merging means for merging said first delta hierarchy into said second delta hierarchy to resynchronize the latest edition of said source module in said child environment of the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment, and

said replacement means being further coupled to said child environment replaces said second hierarchy in said child environment with said output table instead, said usage of said apparatus to merge said first delta hierarchy into said second delta hierarchy to resynchronize the latest edition of said source module in said child environment of the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment is automatically triggered in response to an attempt to use said apparatus to merge said second delta hierarchy into said first delta hierarchy to reconcile the latest revision of said source module in said parent environment to the latest edition of said source module in said child environment, and said second delta hierarchy was originally created using said first delta hierarchy, which has subsequently changed.

14. A computer system comprising:

(a) a parent development environment having a first execution means for executing means, and a first delta hierarchy representing a source module and changes to said source module known to said parent environment;

(b) a child development environment having a second execution means for executing means, and a second delta hierarchy representing said source module and changes to said source module known to said child environment;

(c) merging means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for merging said first and second delta hierarchies together that preserves all delta relationships of said changes individually known to said parent and child environments, said merging means including

(c.

     1) first initialization means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for initializing a first and a second work list and a first and a second work table to equal a first and a second list of deltas and a first and a second table of descriptive entries of said first and second delta hierarchies respectively, said first and second lists of deltas being chronologically identified within a first and second development environments in identical manners, and said first and second table of descriptive entries being time ordered and correspondingly describing said first and second lists of deltas respectively;

(c.

     2) second initialization means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for initializing an output table, an output list, a first and a second two way associative array corresponding to said first and second work tables to empty, for sequentially receiving modified non-duplicate descriptive entries of said first and second work tables, modified non-duplicate deltas of said first and second lists of deltas, and cross reference entries cross referencing descriptive entries of said first and second work tables and said output table to each other;

(c.

     3) retrieval means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for retrieving descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas from said first and second work tables and said first and second work lists, outputting a two way cross reference entry to the corresponding one of said first and second two way associative arrays for each descriptive entry which has been retrieved, as the descriptive entry and its corresponding delta are retrieved, cross referencing said descriptive entry which has been retrieved to the next descriptive entry of said output table, said step of retrieving being performed one descriptive entry and its corresponding delta at a time, in a predetermined least recent entry manner, until all descriptive entries and their corresponding deltas have been retrieved from said first and second work tables and said first and second work deltas;

(c.

     4) discard means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for discarding each descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta, as its two way cross reference entry is output, if the descriptive entry which has been retrieved is a duplicate of a second descriptive entry which has been retrieved in the other work table;

(c.

     5) modification means to be executed by either said first or second execution means for modifying each said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and its corresponding delta not discarded, after its discard or not discard determination is made, outputting each of said descriptive entries which have been retrieved and modified and its corresponding modified delta into said output table and said output list respectively, as the modifications are made, said step of modifying being performed in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created in the merged hierarchy for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded, and the number of descriptive entries which have been retrieved having been output to the output table so far, and furthermore utilizing said cross reference entries and

a processor coupled to said memory, said processor for running merging means.

15. The computer system as set forth in claim 14, wherein, said retrieval means retrieve

(c.3.1) the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if said first work table is empty;

(c.3.2) the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if said second work table is empty;

(c.3.3) the least recent descriptive entry of said second work table and its corresponding delta from said second work table and said second work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are duplicates; and

(c.3.4) the least recent descriptive entry of said first work table and its corresponding delta from said first work table and said first work list if both of said first and second work tables are non-empty and the least recent descriptive entries of said first and second work tables are not duplicates.

16. The computer system as set forth in claim 15, wherein, said modification means further comprises means for determining that a new branch is to be created for the corresponding delta of the descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded if said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded was removed from said second work table, and said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded has a predecessor descriptive entry in said second work table cross referencing a descriptive entry in said output table, which cross references a descriptive entry in said first work table, furthermore, said cross referenced descriptive entry in said first work table is a predecessor descriptive entry to another descriptive entry in said first work table, which is on the same branch said descriptive entry which has been retrieved and not discarded is on.

17. The computer system as set forth in claim 16, wherein, said modification means replaces:

(c. 5.1) an existing change identifier in said descriptive entry not discarded with a new change identifier, said existing and new change identifiers indicating revision/edition levels of said source module in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said new change identifier being generated in accordance to whether a new branch is to be created for the corresponding delta of said descriptive entry not discarded in the merged hierarchy;

(c. 5.2) a first existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry not discarded with a first new unique delta serial number, said first existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said first new unique delta serial number being generated in accordance to the number of descriptive entries having been output to said output table so far;

(c. 5.3) a second existing delta serial number in said descriptive entry with a second new unique delta serial number, said second existing and new delta serial numbers identifying the corresponding delta'"'"'predecessor delta in the pre-merge and merged hierarchies respectively, said second new unique delta serial number being retrieved from the corresponding one of said first and second two way cross reference arrays, said second new unique delta serial number being equal to the first new unique delta number of the cross referenced descriptive entry of said output table, whose first existing delta serial number of the cross referencing descriptive entry of said first and second work tables equals said second existing delta serial number.