Best server selection in layered cellular radio system

• US 5,499,386 A
• Filed: 07/09/1993
• Issued: 03/12/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 07/09/1993
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson
• Original Assignee: Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson
• Inventors: Karlsson, Bror A.
• Primary Examiner(s): Pham, Chi H.
• Application Number:
  US08/090,734
• Time in Patent Office: 977 Days
• Field of Search: 455/33.1-33.4, 455/34.1, 455/34.2, 455/54.1, 455/54.2, 455/56.1, 455/67.1, 379/59, 379/60, 379/63
• US Class Current: 455/444
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 16/32 Hierarchical cell structures
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 36/04 Reselecting a cell layer in multi-layered cells
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 36/30 by measured or perceived connection quality data

Abstract

A multi-level layered cellular radio architecture serves mobile subscriber stations moving within the system. Best server selection is performed for the mobile stations by assigning within each cell a preference value to each other one of the cells with which is associated by proximity of service area. The strength of the radio signal received by the mobile from the serving cell as well as the radio channels of associated cells is measured. A decision as to the best serving cell for the mobile station is made based upon both the preference value of the associated cells and the signal strength of their respective radio channels.

Claims

1. A method of performing server selection for a mobile station operating within a cellular radio system comprised of multiple levels of cells having different service areas, said method comprising the steps of:

assigning to each cell according to cell level a category of preference for selection with respect to each other associated cell within the system having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area;

assigning to each associated cell a preselected signal strength threshold;

measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and each base station serving the associated cells;

comparing the measured signal strengths to the preselected thresholds for each of the associated cells; and

selecting for the mobile station as server a base station serving a candidate one of the associated cells based upon whether the measured signal strength to the candidate associated cell is greater than the preselected signal strength threshold assigned to said cell and whether the candidate associated cell has a higher category of preference than a currently serving cell.

2. A method of performing server selection as set forth in claim 1 in which the categories of preference assigned to each associated cell includes the categories of preferred, equal preference and non-preferred for selection.

3. A method of performing server selection as set forth in claim 2 in which an associated cell is assigned a preferred category of preference if its service area is substantially smaller than that of the currently serving cell, an equal category of preference if its service area is substantially the same size as that of the currently serving cell, and a non-preferred category of preference if its service area is substantially larger than that of the currently serving cell.

4. A method of performing server selection as set forth in claim 2 in which said multiple levels of cells include macrocells, microcells and picocells.

5. A method of performing best server selection for a mobile station operating within a cellular radio system comprised of multiple levels of cells each having a specific service area, said method comprising the steps of:

assigning to each cell a category of preference with respect to each of the other cells within the system having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, said categories of preference comprising a category of preferred, a category of equal preference or a category of non-preferred, said category assignment based upon the size of the cell'"'"'s service area relative to that of other cells;

measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and a first base station for a first cell currently selected as best server, and between the mobile station and a second base station for a second cell in the system;

identifying the assigned category of preference for the second cell;

selecting the second base station as the best server in response to satisfaction of any one of the following conditions, (a) the second cell having a category of preference of preferred and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than a preselected signal strength threshold, or (b) the second cell having a category of preference of equal preference and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than the measured signal strength with the first base station, or (c) the second cell having a category of preference of non-preferred and the measured signal strength with the first base station being less than a preselected signal strength threshold and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than that with the first base station.

6. A method of performing best server selection as set forth in claim 5 in which a cell is assigned a preferred category of preference with respect to another cell if its service area is substantially smaller than that of the other cell, an equal category of preference with respect to the other cell if its service area is substantially the same size as that of the other cell, and a non-preferred category of preference with respect to the other cell if its service area is substantially larger than that of the other cell.

8. A method of performing best server selection as set forth in claim 5 in which said multiple layers of cells include macrocells, microcells and picocells.

7. A method of performing best server selection as set forth in claim 7 further comprising the steps of:

measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and each of the base stations serving associated ones of the cells in the system having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area;

identifying the assigned category of preference for each of the associated cells;

selecting as the base station best serving the mobile station that particular base station for One Of the associated cells satisfying any one of the following conditions, (a) the particular base station being in a cell having a category of preference of preferred and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than a preselected signal strength threshold, or (b) the particular base station being in a cell having a category of preference of equal preference and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station, or (c) the particular base station being in a cell having a category of preference of non-preferred and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station and wherein the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station is less than a preselected signal strength threshold.

9. A system for performing server selection for a mobile station operating within a cellular radio system comprised of multiple levels of cells having different service areas, each cell assigned according to cell level a category of preference for selection with respect to each other associated cell within the system having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, and for assigning to each associated cell a preselected signal strength threshold, said system comprising;

means for measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and each base station serving the associated cells;

means connected to the means for measuring for comparing the measured signal strengths to the preselected signal strength thresholds for the associated cells; and

means connected to the means for comparing for selecting for the mobile station as server a base station serving a candidate one of the associated cells based upon whether the measured signal strength to the candidate associated cell is greater than the preselected signal strength threshold for said cell and whether the candidate associated cell has a higher category of preference than a currently serving cell.

10. A system for performing server selection as set forth in claim 9 in which the categories of preference assigned to each associated cell includes the categories of preferred, equal preference and non-preferred for selection.

11. A system for performing server selection as set forth in claim 10 in which an associated cell is assigned a preferred category of preference if its service area is substantially smaller than that of the currently serving cell, an equal category of preference if its service area is substantially the same size as that of the currently serving cell, and a non-preferred category of preference if its service area is substantially larger than that of the currently serving cell.

12. A system for performing server selection as set forth in claim 10 in which said multiple levels of cells include macrocells, microcells and picocells.

13. A system for performing best server selection for a mobile station operating within a cellular radio system comprised of multiple levels of cells each having a different service area, each cell assigned a category of preference with respect to each of the other cells within the system having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, said categories of preference comprising a category of preferred, a category of equal preference or a category of non-preferred, said category assignment based upon the size of its service area relative to that of other cells, said system comprising;

means for measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and a first base station for a first cell currently selected as best server, and between the mobile station and a second base station for a second cell in the system;

means connected to the means for measuring for identifying the assigned category of preference for the second cell;

means connected to the means for identifying for selecting the second base station as the best server in response to satisfaction of any one of the following conditions, (a) the second cell having a category of preference of preferred and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than a preselected signal strength threshold, or (b) the second cell having a category of preference of equal preference and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than the measured signal strength with the first base station, or (c) the second cell having a category of preference of non-preferred and the measured signal strength with the first base station being less than a preselected signal strength threshold and the measured signal strength with the second base station being greater than that with the first base station.

14. A system for performing best server selection as set forth in claim 13 in which a cell is assigned:

a preferred category of preference with respect to another cell if its service area is substantially smaller than that of the other cell, an equal category of preference with respect to the other cell if its service area is substantially the same as that of the other cell, and a non-preferred category of preference with respect to the other cell if its service area is substantially larger than that of the other cell.

15. A system for performing best server selection as set forth in claim 13 further comprising:

means for measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and each of the base stations serving associated ones of the cells in the system that are either coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping with the first cell;

means for identifying the assigned category of preference for each of the associated cells; and

means for selecting as the base station best serving the mobile station that particular base station for one of the associated cells satisfying any one of the following condition, (a) the particular base station being in a cell having a category of preference of preferred and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than a preselected signal strength threshold, or (b) the particular base station being in a cell having a category of preference of equal preference and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station, or (c) the particular base station being in a cell having a category or preference of non-preferred and having a measured signal strength with the mobile station greater than the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station and wherein the measured signal strength between the mobile station and the first base station is less than a preselected signal strength threshold.

16. A system for performing best server selection as set forth in claim 13 in which said multiple levels of cells include macrocells, microcells and picocells.

17. A cellular communications system including a plurality of cells arranged in multiple layers, comprising:

a base station for each of the plurality of cells, each base station assigned a category of preference for server selection with respect to each neighboring cell in the plurality of cells having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, each base station further assigned a signal strength threshold for mobile station communications within the cell; and

a plurality of mobile stations moving through the plurality of cells and communicating with the plurality of base stations, each mobile station comprising;

means for measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile station and each of the base stations within communications range; and

processing means connected to the means for measuring for making a server selection determination for the mobile station based on a comparison of the measured signal strength of communications with each candidate base station to the assigned signal strength threshold for those candidate base stations in conjunction with a comparison of the category of preference assigned to each candidate base station.

18. The cellular communications system as in claim 17 wherein the base station further includes means for broadcasting in a communication to the mobile stations the assigned category of preference for server selection and assigned signal strength threshold for communications to the base station.

19. The cellular communications system as in claim 17 wherein the processing means for making the server selection determination operates to select a server when the mobile station is both camping-on to a base station in an idle operating mode and handing-off between base stations in a call processing mode.

20. The cellular communications system as in claim 17 wherein the processing means of the mobile station further includes means for determining a server selection change from a currently serving base station to the candidate base station if the measured signal strength exceeds the assigned signal strength threshold for the candidate base station and further if the candidate base station has a higher category of preference than the currently serving base station.

21. The cellular communications system as in claim 20 wherein the determination by the processing means of the server selection change is further based on a comparison of the measured signal strength of communications with the candidate base station to the measured signal strength of communications with the currently serving base station.

22. The cellular communications system as in claim 21 wherein the processing means of the mobile station further includes means for determining the server selection change from the currently serving base station to the candidate base station if the measured signal strength for the candidate base station exceeds the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station and further if the candidate base station has at least an equal category of preference to the currently serving base station.

23. The cellular communications system as in claim 21 wherein the processing means of the mobile station further includes means for determining the server selection change from the currently serving base station to the candidate base station, even if the candidate base station has a lower category of preference than the currently serving base station, if the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station is below the assigned signal strength threshold for the currently serving base station, and further if the measured signal strength for the candidate base station exceeds the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station.

24. In a cellular communications system including a plurality of cells arranged in multiple layers, wherein each cell includes a base station, and further including a plurality of mobile stations moving through the plurality of cells and communicating with the plurality of base stations, wherein each base station is assigned a category of preference for server selection with respect to each neighboring cell in the plurality of cells having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, and each base station is assigned a signal strength threshold for mobile station communications within the cell, a method for determining mobile station server selection of a base station, comprising the steps of:

measuring the signal strength of communications between each mobile station and each of the base stations within communications range thereof;

comparing the measured signal strength of communications with each candidate base station to the assigned signal strength threshold for that candidate base station;

comparing the category of preference for each candidate base station to the category of preference for the base stations currently serving each of the mobile stations; and

responsive to the foregoing comparisons making the mobile station server selection determination for each mobile station.

25. The method as in claim 24 wherein the step of making is performed to select a server when the mobile station is both camping-on to a base station in an idle operating mode and handing-off to a base station in a call processing mode.

26. The method as in claim 24 wherein the step of making includes the step of selecting as a server a candidate base station having a measured signal strength with the mobile station that exceeds its signal strength threshold, and also having a category of preference that is higher than the category of preference for the currently serving base station.

27. The method as in claim 26 further including the step of comparing the measured signal strength of communications with the candidate base station to the measured signal strength of communications with the currently serving base station.

28. The method as in claim 27 wherein the step of making includes the step of selecting as a server the candidate base station having a measured signal strength with the mobile station that exceeds the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station, and also having a category of preference that is at least equal to the category of preference for the currently serving base station.

29. The method as in claim 27 wherein the step of making includes the step of selecting as a server the candidate base station having a measured signal strength with the mobile station that exceeds the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station, even if the category of preference for that candidate base station is lower than the category of preference for the currently serving base station, and also provided that the measured signal strength for the currently serving base station is below its signal strength threshold.

30. A cellular communications system including a plurality of cells, comprising:

a base station for each of the plurality of cells, wherein each base station is assigned a category of preference for server selection with respect to each neighboring cell in the plurality of cells having either a coextensive, adjacent, contiguous, or overlapping service area, and wherein each base station is further assigned a signal strength threshold for mobile station communications within the cell;

a plurality of mobile stations moving through the plurality of cells and communicating with the plurality of base stations;

means for measuring the signal strength of communications between the mobile stations and base stations;

processing means connected to the means for measuring, said processing means executing a predetermined procedure for selecting a base station to serve each of the mobile stations, the selected base station having both the highest assigned category of preference and a measured signal strength of mobile station communications that exceeds the assigned base station signal strength threshold, said predetermined procedure followed for each mobile station in selecting the base station both for camping-on to a server during an idle operating mode and for handing-off between servers during a call processing mode.