Automatic threshold control for multi-level signals

• US 5,521,941 A
• Filed: 11/29/1990
• Issued: 05/28/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 11/29/1990
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Motorola Solutions, Inc.
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: Miller, Matthew R., Wiatrowski, David G., Kurby, Christopher N.
• Primary Examiner(s): Safourek, Benedict V.
• Application Number:
  US07/620,601
• Time in Patent Office: 2,007 Days
• Field of Search: 375/17, 375/76, 375/94, 375/99, 375/287, 375/317, 375/318, 375/319, 307/358, 307/359, 328/146, 328/147, 328/149, 328/164, 358/464, 327/307, 327/72, 327/73
• US Class Current: 375/287
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 25/062 Setting decision thresholds using feedforward techniques only
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 25/066 Multilevel decisions, not including self-organising maps

Abstract

Symbol recovery for multi-level digital signals has traditionally been difficult because of the nature of the eye pattern output by the discriminator (103), and especially its response to a noisy or impeded signal environment. This method and apparatus for recovery thresholds adjusts (411 and 417) to the current state of the discriminator (103) output of the received signal, based on an attenuated (301) version of that signal. Using a fast adjust mode and slow adjust mode, the threshold generating circuitry (331 and 361) adapts to the signal based on data from the received signal fed into lock detectors (329 and 359) which determine the mode to use.

Claims

1. An apparatus for automatic threshold control for recovery of a received multi-level digital signal composed of symbols and having an amplitude, comprising:

means for amplifying the received multi-level digital signal in a predetermined fashion, producing an amplified signal;

means for providing at least a first threshold based on the amplitude of the received multi-level digital signal;

means, coupled to said means for providing, for comparing said amplified signal to said first threshold to generate signal information;

means, coupled to said comparing means, for computing signal statistics from said generated signal information and adjusting at least said first threshold in accordance therewith; and

means, receiving as inputs the received multi-level digital signal and said adjusted first threshold, for recovering at least one symbol using said received multi-level signal and said at least said adjusted first threshold.

2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said means for adjusting further comprises means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received.

3. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said means for adjusting further comprises means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received.

5. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said amplified signal is an attenuated signal that has a peak value that is substantially equal to a threshold for the received multi-level digital signal.

6. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of the number of times said first threshold is increased during a measurement period and a second count of the number of times said first threshold is decreased during said measurement period.

7. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of comparison that result from said amplified signal falling above said first threshold during a measurement period and a second count of comparisons that result from said amplified signal falling below said first threshold during said measurement period.

8. The apparatus of claim 7, wherein said means for computing and adjusting further comprises:

first means for comparing said first count to an above value, wherein said above value represents how many symbols are expected to fall above said first threshold during said measurement period;

second means for comparing said second count to a below value, wherein said below value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold during said measurement period;

means, operatively coupled to said first means for comparing, for adjusting said first threshold to a value above said first threshold when said first count is greater than said above value; and

means, operatively coupled to said second means for comparing, for adjusting said first threshold to a value below said first threshold when said second count is greater than said below value.

9. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein said means for computing and adjusting further comprises:

means, operatively coupled to said means for comparing, for increasing said first threshold when said symbol falls above said first threshold;

means, operatively coupled to said means for comparing, for increasing a symbol count when said symbol falls below said first threshold; and

means, operatively coupled to said means for increasing said symbol count, for decreasing said first threshold when said symbol count reaches a predetermined value.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein said predetermined value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold when said first threshold is correctly adjusted.

4. The apparatus of claim I wherein said means for adjusting further comprises:

means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received;

means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received; and

means for determining when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received and when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after said plurality of symbols is received.

11. A method for automatic threshold control for recovery of a received multi-level digital signal composed of symbols and having an amplitude, comprising the steps of:

amplifying the received multi-level digital signal in a predetermined fashion, producing an amplified signal;

providing at least a first threshold based on the amplitude of the received multi-level signal;

comparing said amplified signal to said first threshold to generate signal information;

computing, responsive to said step of comparing, signal statistics from said generated signal information and adjusting at least said first threshold in accordance therewith; and

recovering at least one symbol using said received multi-level signal and at least said adjusted first threshold.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of adjusting further comprises the step of deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received.

13. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of adjusting further comprises the step of deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received.

14. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of adjusting further comprises the steps of:

determining when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received and when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after said plurality of symbols is received;

deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received when it is determined that it is time to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received; and

deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received when it is determined that it is time to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received.

15. The method of claim 11 wherein said amplified signal is an attenuated signal that has peak value that is substantially equal to a threshold for the received multi-level distal signal.

16. The method of claim 11 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of the number of times said first threshold is increased during a measurement period and a second count of the number of times said first threshold is decreased during said measurement period.

17. The method of claim 11 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of comparison that result from said amplified signal falling above said first threshold during a measurement period and a second count of comparisons that result from said amplified signal falling below said first threshold during said measurement period.

18. The method of claim 17, wherein said step of computing and adjusting further comprises the steps of:

comparing said first count to an above value, wherein said above value represents how many symbols are expected to fall above said first threshold during said measurement period;

comparing said second count to a below value, wherein said below value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold during said measurement period;

adjusting said first threshold to a value above said first threshold when said first count is greater than said above value; and

adjusting said first threshold to a value below said first threshold when said second count is greater than said below value.

19. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of computing and adjusting further comprises the steps of:

increasing said first threshold when said symbol falls above said first threshold;

increasing a symbol count when said symbol falls below said first threshold; and

decreasing said first threshold when said symbol count reaches a predetermined value.

20. The method of claim 19, wherein said predetermined value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold when said first threshold is correctly adjusted.

21. A receiver with apparatus for automatic threshold control for recovery of a received multi-level digital signal composed of symbols and having an amplitude, comprising:

means for receiving a multi-level digital signal composed of symbols;

means for amplifying said received multi-level digital signal in a predetermined fashion, producing an amplified signal;

means for providing at least a first threshold based on the amplitude of the received multi-level signal;

means, coupled to said means for providing, for comparing said amplified signal to said first threshold to generate signal information;

means, coupled to said comparing means, for computing signal statistics from said generated signal information and adjusting at least said first threshold in accordance therewith; and

means, receiving as inputs said received multi-level digital signal and said adjusted first threshold, for recovering at least one symbol using said received multi-level signal and said at least said adjusted first threshold.

22. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said means for adjusting further comprises means for deciding whether said first threshold need adjusting after every symbol is received.

23. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said means for adjusting further comprises means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received.

24. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said means for adjusting further comprises:

means for deciding whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received;

means for deciding whether said threshold needs adjusting after a plurality of symbols is received; and

means for determining when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after every symbol is received and when to decide whether said first threshold needs adjusting after said plurality of symbols is received.

25. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said amplified signal is an attenuated signal that has a peak value that is substantially equal to a threshold for the received multi-level digital signal.

26. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of the number of times said first threshold is increased during a measurement period and a second count of the number of times said first threshold is decreased during said measurement period.

27. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said signal statistics comprise a first count of comparisons that result from said amplified signal falling above said first threshold during a measurement period and a second count of comparisons that result from said amplified signal falling below said first threshold during said measurement period.

28. The apparatus of claim 27, wherein said means for computing and adjusting further comprises:

first means for comparing said first count to an above value, wherein said above value represents how many symbols are expected to fall above said first threshold during said measurement period;

second means for comparing said second count to a below value, wherein said below value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold during said measurement period;

means, operatively coupled to said first means for comparing, for adjusting said first threshold to a value above said first threshold when said first count is greater than said above value; and

means, operatively coupled to said second means for comparing, for adjusting said first threshold to a value below said first threshold when said second count is greater than said below value.

29. The apparatus of claim 21, wherein said means for computing and adjusting further comprises:

means, operatively coupled to said means for comparing, for increasing said first threshold when said symbol falls above said first threshold;

means, operatively coupled to said means for comparing, for increasing a symbol count when said symbol falls below said first threshold; and

means, operatively coupled to said means for increasing said symbol count, for decreasing said first threshold when said symbol count reaches a predetermined value.

30. The method of claim 29, wherein said predetermined value represents how many symbols are expected to fall below said first threshold when said first threshold is correctly adjusted.

31. A method of adjusting a threshold for use in recovering a symbol from a received multi-level signal comprising the steps of:

a) setting an upper threshold to a first value;

b) setting a symbol count to a second value;

c) receiving a plurality of symbols and attenuating the plurality of symbols yielding a plurality of attenuated symbols;

d) when a first symbol from the plurality of attenuated symbols is above the upper threshold, increasing the upper threshold;

e) when a second symbol from the plurality of attenuated symbols is below the upper threshold, increasing the symbol count;

f) when the symbol count reaches a third value, decreasing the upper threshold and setting the symbol count to a fourth value; and

g) recovering at least one symbol using the plurality of symbols and the upper threshold.

32. The method of claim 31, further comprising the steps of:

g) when X symbols are counted, where X is an integer, compare the first value with the upper threshold;

h) when the first value is different from the upper threshold, setting the first value to the current value of the upper threshold, and continue with step c);

i) when the first value is the same as the upper threshold, considering the upper threshold to be in a lock condition.

33. The method of claim 32, wherein X is 128.

34. The method of claim 32, when the upper threshold is considered to be in the lock condition, further comprising the steps of:

j) setting a minimum count to a fifth value;

k) setting a maximum count to a sixth value;

l) during a sample interval of X symbols, counting how many of the X symbols are above the upper threshold, yielding a first count;

m) when the first count is greater than the maximum count, increasing the upper threshold;

n) when the first count is less than the minimum count, decreasing the upper threshold;

o) repeating steps j) through n).

35. The method of claim 34, further comprising the steps of:

p) count Y consecutive repetitions of steps j) through n), where Y is an integer;

q) when the upper threshold is increased on each of the Y repetitions, considering an unlock condition to be detected, and continuing the process with step c);

r) when the upper threshold is decreased on each of the Y repetitions, considering an unlock condition to be detected, and continuing the process with step c)

s) when neither the condition of step q) nor the condition of step r) is met, repeating from step p).

36. The method of claim 35, wherein the fifth value is 13;

wherein the sixth value is 19; and

wherein Y is 8.

37. The method of claim 31, wherein the first value is the midpoint of possible values for the upper threshold;

wherein the second value is 0;

wherein the third value is 7; and

wherein the fourth value is 0.

38. A method of adjusting a threshold for use in recovering a symbol from a received multi-level signal comprising the steps of:

a) setting a lower threshold to a first value;

b) setting a symbol count to a second value;

c) receiving a plurality of symbols and attenuating the plurality of symbols, yielding a plurality of attenuated symbols;

d) when a first symbol from the plurality of attenuated symbols is below the lower threshold, decreasing the lower threshold;

e) when a second symbol from the plurality of attenuated symbols is above the lower threshold, increasing the symbol count;

f) when the symbol count reaches a third value, increasing the lower threshold and setting the symbol count to a fourth value; and

g) recovering at least one symbol using the plurality of symbols and the lower threshold.

39. The method of claim 38, further comprising the steps of:

g) when X symbols are counted, where X is an integer, compare the first value with the lower threshold;

h) when the first value is different from the lower threshold, setting the first value to the current value of the lower threshold;

i) when the first value is the same as the lower threshold, considering the lower threshold to be in a lock condition.

40. The method of claim 39, wherein X=128.

41. The method of claim 39, when the lower threshold is considered to be in the lock condition, further comprising the steps of:

j) setting a minimum count to a fifth value;

k) setting a maximum count to a sixth value;

l) during a sample interval of X symbols, counting how many of the X symbols are below the lower threshold, yielding a first count;

m) when the first count is greater than the maximum count, decreasing the lower threshold;

n) when the first count is less than the minimum count, increasing the lower threshold;

o) repeating steps j) through n).

42. The method of claim 41, further comprising the steps of:

p) count Y consecutive repetitions of steps j) through n), where Y is an integer;

q) when the lower threshold is increased on each of the Y repetitions, considering an unlock condition to be detected, and continuing the process with step c);

r) when the lower threshold is decreased on each of the Y repetitions, considering an unlock condition to be detected, and continuing the process with step c)

s) when neither the condition of step q) nor the condition of step r) is met, repeating from step p).

43. The method of claim 42, wherein the fifth value is 13;

wherein the sixth value is 19; and

wherein Y is 8.

44. The method of claim 38, wherein the first value is the midpoint of possible values for the lower threshold;

wherein the second value=0;

wherein the third value=7; and

wherein the fourth value=0.